Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many parents are subsidised by their parents at Christmas?

279 replies

EveryoneIsIll · 28/11/2022 13:13

As I get older, it seems a lot of friends are getting financial help with everything from school trips to clubs or tutors, through to holidays and days out (in some cases so the grandparents can have time with their grandkids but sometimes not). Christmas also - whether that’s buying the turkey, the big ticket gifts or whatever.

It’s not my experience so it can leave me wondering if this is most people’s experiences, only it’s just not spoken about?

OP posts:
RoachPussy · 28/11/2022 21:19

needthemenopause · 28/11/2022 19:42

I think it’s a bit sad that those who can afford to support their children have the attitude of “I paid my own way, so they will have to as well”. It’s their money to do what they wish with and I wouldn’t suggest otherwise.
However, I just don’t understand why, if you can afford it, would you not try to break that cycle of struggle that is passed on to each generation. Having support financially or through giving some of your time doesn’t suddenly make the recipient slovenly or profligate.

My parents can afford to help me and my brothers but we don’t want their money, we want them to enjoy their retirement, travel, eat out, treat themselves, they both worked hard and if they spend it all good luck to them. If we inherit anything we each have to donate a pre arranged sum each to charity.

needthemenopause · 28/11/2022 19:42

I think it’s a bit sad that those who can afford to support their children have the attitude of “I paid my own way, so they will have to as well”. It’s their money to do what they wish with and I wouldn’t suggest otherwise.
However, I just don’t understand why, if you can afford it, would you not try to break that cycle of struggle that is passed on to each generation. Having support financially or through giving some of your time doesn’t suddenly make the recipient slovenly or profligate.

SirMingeALot · 28/11/2022 19:28

Ilovemybed2022 · 28/11/2022 16:37

Why do people need to be transparent about it? It’s not your business where other people get their money from and how they can afford things.

but I do agree, some of us are very fortunate to get family help. Whether it is interest free loans, big financial gifts and free childcare. I know my mum and in laws completely spoil my son. I’m actually embarrassed at the amount of stuff he has

I'd distinguish being transparent from being actively misleading. It would be weird as fuck if a mate you chat to at school pick up was like full disclosure, my PILs gave us 15k for our deposit in 2014 and they're paying for the cottage when we all go away at Easter. But people giving themselves airs over things they've been given or wouldn't have without assistance is twat behaviour.

Hungoverandashamed · 28/11/2022 19:24

My mum is really generous. She will always buy great presents, checking in advance what I want - for example she bought a children's wardrobe one year for our LO.

She often takes us all out to a nice restaurant. She is treating us to a really nice place Christmas week after the panto in the city centre - I paid for all those tickets which were pretty pricey but there are three of us and only one of her so she's definitely getting the raw deal.

She doesn't provide regular free childcare and I wouldn't dream of asking but she will do an overnight every few months to give us a chance for a break.

She's hosting Christmas dinner this year, I will take a few dishes along but it wouldn't be the done thing to offer money to pay for the food. I host in mine every second year. I'm so relieved to be getting spoiled this year as work and life has been full on and I'm really looking forward to simply arriving as guests.

For her birthday last year, me and the other siblings took her on an upmarket mini break no expense spared and had all her siblings out too for dinner. So we try to express our gratitude but we don't match the financial contributions.

I think (certainly hope) she knows how much we appreciate her.

DaphneduM · 28/11/2022 19:22

We have a small family - just our daughter, son-in-law and little grandson. We help out where we can. We're not hugely wealthy having both worked in the public sector, but I inherited from my parents and we have always been careful with money and saved quite a bit.

I paid for her wedding, gave them a substantial deposit for a house, paid off their car loans and we now do two days a week childcare. Really glad to have a great relationship with our toddler grandson - we've had him today and it's been a blast - he's so funny and cute.

We moved to be nearer to them about three years ago and ended up with some spare cash from the move, so in due course will help them move up the ladder as I want to see that money invested back in property.

I buy our grandson things like his shoes and other bits and pieces. The other grandparents are also generous in differing ways - one has started a financial investment for him.

My daughter and son-in-law both work very hard and we're happy to help. I prefer to see them benefit now rather than after we're gone. We prefer a fairly simple life ourselves so have more than enough for our own needs.

Dixiechickonhols · 28/11/2022 19:21

mam0918 · 28/11/2022 19:17

Your missing the point its about accepting generousity at the expense of others.

It is a decision for grandparents though? They know their financial situation. How is it at their expense if they freely gift it. It often gives them pleasure as they see grandchildren enjoying activities or all family can enjoy a holiday together.
Totally different to demanding money from a parent who is on breadline.

mam0918 · 28/11/2022 19:17

Dixiechickonhols · 28/11/2022 19:11

You’ve missed of the first part seek to obtain which changes whole meaning.
In most of these examples the adults and grandchildren aren’t asking for money or demanding it rather the grandparents are gifting money freely. Voluntarily sharing their wealth.

Your missing the point its about accepting generousity at the expense of others.

Dixiechickonhols · 28/11/2022 19:11

mam0918 · 28/11/2022 19:05

'scrounge - to obtain something at the expense or through the generosity of others.'

Thats the dictionary definition, it is litrally the exact word for it, if you are gaining things at the expense of your parents which they offer through generousity you are scrounging.

You’ve missed of the first part seek to obtain which changes whole meaning.
In most of these examples the adults and grandchildren aren’t asking for money or demanding it rather the grandparents are gifting money freely. Voluntarily sharing their wealth.

Seymour5 · 28/11/2022 19:10

We’re baby boomers, helped our DC a little when they were starting out, but our finances aren’t great in retirement. However, we buy decent presents for the DGC, either outright or a contribution to something bigger, and provided childcare for one when they lived close enough. Babysitting when they were younger too.

We are fortunate that our DC are in good financial circumstances, in fact they have offered help if we need it, but we’re still eating and heating. One DC hosts at Christmas, they have the space. We contribute alcohol, and nice bits and pieces of food.

mam0918 · 28/11/2022 19:05

nokidshere · 28/11/2022 18:55

It's sad that people see being given a helping hand, being supported or treated as scrounging.

And at the same time we see tons of threads moaning about how much money the older generation have and that they think it's easy for the younger generation.

I grew up in poverty, I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I'm not wealthy but if I have it - be that time, money or treats, then I'm more than happy to share it.

My boys don't need anything from me, nor do they expect anything. They both work and have their own money. But if I invite them to join us for dinner I foot the bill. If I have spare money I'll ask them if there's anything they need, and I sometimes buy things for no other reason than I know they would get enjoyment from the item.

If they were in trouble financially I would want them to ask, or accept if I offer, because I'm their mum and I can. If I couldn't help financially I would help in whatever way I could. I would never view them as scroungers or as being dependent, they are my sons. As far as I am concerned as long as my bills are paid and I have food in the fridge what's left is to benefit us all as a family.

'scrounge - to obtain something at the expense or through the generosity of others.'

Thats the dictionary definition, it is litrally the exact word for it, if you are gaining things at the expense of your parents which they offer through generousity you are scrounging.

TheSausageKingofChicago · 28/11/2022 19:05

My mum takes the view that I’m her child and if she can help where I’m struggling then she will. When she was at my age and stage of parenting they had two decent wages coming in and life was cheaper. I only have one wage, and life is expensive. But if her grandchildren can have the opportunities she was able to give her own children, why wouldn’t she help them and me? She’s comfortable and has a nice life, so if for example, she can pay for a school trip I couldn’t stretch to, then she will. She sees it as an extension of her parenting really.
I never ask, but she does offer from time to time. Eg she knows it’s hard for me with two SEN kids, working full time and solo parenting, so she pays for me to have a cleaner once a fortnight. It’s no big expense to her, but it’s an absolute life saver for me.
Id do the same for my own daughter. I love my mum ❤️

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 28/11/2022 19:03

Im sorry, what! 20k - 40k a year? Wowee. Does he still work hard or is his foot out the door/planning early retirement?

Dh? Not a chance, he regularly does 60 hour plus weeks when he's obsessed with a project (which is most of the time).

His siblings are the same. Can't see any of them retiring early. Suspect they'll be like FiL who still does consultancy work at 80.

NeedAChangeAsIAmSoooOuting · 28/11/2022 19:00

My more well off friends do as their parents are well off. One friends husbands got a really high paying job yet her parents paid for their new boiler and carpets.

JosephFrancis · 28/11/2022 18:59

cptartapp · 28/11/2022 13:25

Nope.
PIL are very well off yet their contribution to Xmas lunch last year was two £1 cheesecakes from Morrisons. For ten.

Mine just turned up empty handed and expected to be plied with their choice of booze and food all day long. 🙄

JosephFrancis · 28/11/2022 18:56

My parents have never contributed a penny and I doubt it has ever entered their heads to. My husband's parents haven't either. And I doubt theirs did or theirs before them.

nokidshere · 28/11/2022 18:55

It's sad that people see being given a helping hand, being supported or treated as scrounging.

And at the same time we see tons of threads moaning about how much money the older generation have and that they think it's easy for the younger generation.

I grew up in poverty, I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I'm not wealthy but if I have it - be that time, money or treats, then I'm more than happy to share it.

My boys don't need anything from me, nor do they expect anything. They both work and have their own money. But if I invite them to join us for dinner I foot the bill. If I have spare money I'll ask them if there's anything they need, and I sometimes buy things for no other reason than I know they would get enjoyment from the item.

If they were in trouble financially I would want them to ask, or accept if I offer, because I'm their mum and I can. If I couldn't help financially I would help in whatever way I could. I would never view them as scroungers or as being dependent, they are my sons. As far as I am concerned as long as my bills are paid and I have food in the fridge what's left is to benefit us all as a family.

funtycucker · 28/11/2022 18:41

yoyy · 28/11/2022 17:53

Not everyone has help from parents to buy property. We saved every single penny of our deposit ourselves

Why would you reply to my post with this? All I said was I don't know anyone, why you would infer that to mean I know everyone or no one can buy without help?😆

@AliceMcK

As well as cash gift we lived at home for cheap rent, also had childcare help. I count that all as help.

I think you've taken my comment in the completely wrong context. It wasn't aimed as a dig at you

yoyy · 28/11/2022 18:37

I'll take whatever I'm given, if that makes me a scrounger then 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mentalpiece · 28/11/2022 18:35

Neither me or my husband have asked for, or been offered anything financial from our parents since we left school and began working.
Our children have never asked us for anything financial, nor do we offer.
We all stand on our own two feet.

EveryoneIsIll · 28/11/2022 18:29

@mam0918 Your mam sounds lovely. Interesting use of the word ‘scrounging’. I think some people here have said they would feel same way. Someone else said there’s no ‘shame’ in taking money.

i guess this poses question of how far should we encourage kids to stand on own two feet in today’s world.

OP posts:
mam0918 · 28/11/2022 18:26

My mam a shopoholic and likes to throw money around when it comes to gifts for the kids especially as shes the only family that buys the kids gifts so she likes to go big... but its not subsidising me in anyway though as they are gifts from HER that are ontop of what we do.

I still buy all of the xmas stuff myself, if she only bought a box of maltesers for the kids nothing would change in how we do xmas.

I pay for my holidays myself, I saved my house deposit myself (although mam offered to help) and she did INSIST on paying for my first car which was £500 (I paid the rest of the costs and insurance was 5x the cost of the car lol) it was a pride thing for her to say she bought my first car.

I don't like accepting money from my mam as I don't like scrounging.

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 18:25

My parents will spend up to £50 on a present for DS now he is a teen, half that when he was younger. They are young grandparents in a much better financial situation than when they were young parents themselves. One of my siblings and I are both single parents and not well off. They don't subsidise us in any other way.

EveryoneIsIll · 28/11/2022 18:24

@Dinosauratemydaffodils Im sorry, what! 20k - 40k a year? Wowee. Does he still work hard or is his foot out the door/planning early retirement?

OP posts:
EveryoneIsIll · 28/11/2022 18:22

@stuntbubbles I notice grandparents play a significant part of modern lives today. Everywhere we go, grandparents are there. Like ice skating recently for example. We don’t have that and I notice it even more every Xmas. Especially when people talk about plans and so on. I think it’s good to talk about this. Guess it means I’m a ‘have-not’ according to some posts perhaps?

OP posts:
EveryoneIsIll · 28/11/2022 18:19

@yoyy I wondered about this.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread