Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest, would you judge us for having another child?

508 replies

Callingmrssnow · 28/11/2022 13:02

We have two DS, 8 & 10, one of whom has autism. We have always talked about having another child but the timing has never been right until now. Also, time is not on our side as I have just turned 39.

DS 2 has autism and is non verbal. I feel like people will judge us for having another child, family included. They will judge us because it will cause our lives to change and think that we are taking time away from our child who already has high needs.

I know all this. However, my DH and I dream of another but I can't help but think people will think we are past it and being selfish.

OP posts:
Baconand · 29/11/2022 14:09

BabyFour2023 · 29/11/2022 13:41

Really? Don’t all your children enjoy the beach or theme parks or zoos? How bizarre. I grew up with a 10 year gap between me (eldest) and my youngest sibling with 2 in between. We had plenty of days out.

Right. Yes I can see that a 3 year old and 14 year old will love the same theme park. So much they can go on together. What a lovely weekly activity they can enjoy. I would’ve loved hanging out with a preschooler that gets up at 6am as a teen. Not irritating at all.

I don’t do zoos. We are 4hrs from a beach. They aren’t regular days out for everyone.

Fortunately I had the sense to stick at one DD though. So we can focus on whatever she would enjoy best.

BabyFour2023 · 29/11/2022 13:41

Baconand · 29/11/2022 11:14

I wouldn’t judge, but privately I’d wonder what the impact would be on the 10 year old. Not sure they will benefit from a significantly younger sibling that will need a lot of attention as they hit the teenage years. Days out etc will never appeal to all. It doesn’t sound like it is the best idea for everyone.
But it’s your circus, I do think people shouldn’t worry what others think.

Really? Don’t all your children enjoy the beach or theme parks or zoos? How bizarre. I grew up with a 10 year gap between me (eldest) and my youngest sibling with 2 in between. We had plenty of days out.

Wiluli · 29/11/2022 13:36

Purplemagnolias · 28/11/2022 19:21

What will a third child bring you that the other two haven't?

This!!

Do you have more than one child ? If so I’m assuming your fist was a disappointment since you had a second ?

Wiluli · 29/11/2022 13:32

The sheer ableism on this post is shocking !!

CuteAsDuck · 29/11/2022 11:36

I wouldn't judge you at all.

It is worth considering carefully how life might change for everyone in your household but you are obviously doing that already!

Baconand · 29/11/2022 11:14

I wouldn’t judge, but privately I’d wonder what the impact would be on the 10 year old. Not sure they will benefit from a significantly younger sibling that will need a lot of attention as they hit the teenage years. Days out etc will never appeal to all. It doesn’t sound like it is the best idea for everyone.
But it’s your circus, I do think people shouldn’t worry what others think.

Feef83 · 29/11/2022 11:13

Algor1thm · 29/11/2022 11:12

Second this. No professional would say that. Also every county has hundreds if not thousands of severely disabled children with a very low level of communication. There's literally no way of judging who is the most severely disabled or autistic child in a county. Ridiculous.

Added to which, no one within the county would deal with every child with a disability so who the heck would even be able to know that?

Algor1thm · 29/11/2022 11:12

Feef83 · 29/11/2022 10:47

Your niece has been described as the “most severely effected in the county” by whom?

Second this. No professional would say that. Also every county has hundreds if not thousands of severely disabled children with a very low level of communication. There's literally no way of judging who is the most severely disabled or autistic child in a county. Ridiculous.

Feef83 · 29/11/2022 11:09

Sindonym · 29/11/2022 07:03

OP - all this talk of terribly hard work autistic children. My son (who is sweet & loving & funny) is recognised as one of the most challenging to services in his cohort. He lived at home until 17 and his then social worker told me she would wake in the night in dread at what might happen. Since leaving home we had 16 good months, followed by a year & a half of utter hell, and now nearly years of rebuilding his life with a wonderful provider. As I said earlier I am very involved in his support & that is partly because he is hard work for services (as well as being the delightful, funny, loving young man I described above).

Yes it put enormous strain on the family - particularly us. Having a third child didn’t make the blindest bit of difference other than give the younger two someone to share the experience with. There was absolutely nothing negative about having a third.

Having only ds1 & no other kids would not have helped. He stayed at home with us as long as he could whether or not he had siblings. He moved out when his care needs became 2:1. We couldn’t have done that even without siblings as dh needed to work. So did I really, although we could live without my input if necessary.

Having 2 or 3 kids in all the above made zero difference to the situation. And the other two are happy, well adjusted adults. We remain a close family - probably closer to the younger two than we might otherwise have been at their ages because of what we all went through (think this thread shows you can’t really understand it from the outside, which leads to a stronger bond between those who do).

@Sindonym

i thought I recognised your user name

. It has been difficult for his siblings but they have always been understanding of his difficulties, although their feelings can be complicated (fear, worry for him, worry for us, worry for them, love, loyalty etc). .

We did have to split ourselves a lot so one of us with ds1 and the other with the other 2. There were times when the younger two had to lock themselves away to be safe.

this sure as heck doesn’t sound like it had zero impact

Feef83 · 29/11/2022 10:51

Sindonym · 29/11/2022 07:03

OP - all this talk of terribly hard work autistic children. My son (who is sweet & loving & funny) is recognised as one of the most challenging to services in his cohort. He lived at home until 17 and his then social worker told me she would wake in the night in dread at what might happen. Since leaving home we had 16 good months, followed by a year & a half of utter hell, and now nearly years of rebuilding his life with a wonderful provider. As I said earlier I am very involved in his support & that is partly because he is hard work for services (as well as being the delightful, funny, loving young man I described above).

Yes it put enormous strain on the family - particularly us. Having a third child didn’t make the blindest bit of difference other than give the younger two someone to share the experience with. There was absolutely nothing negative about having a third.

Having only ds1 & no other kids would not have helped. He stayed at home with us as long as he could whether or not he had siblings. He moved out when his care needs became 2:1. We couldn’t have done that even without siblings as dh needed to work. So did I really, although we could live without my input if necessary.

Having 2 or 3 kids in all the above made zero difference to the situation. And the other two are happy, well adjusted adults. We remain a close family - probably closer to the younger two than we might otherwise have been at their ages because of what we all went through (think this thread shows you can’t really understand it from the outside, which leads to a stronger bond between those who do).

Having 2 or 3 kids in all the above made zero difference to the situation

hand on heart. Can you honestly say or made zero difference ?

Feef83 · 29/11/2022 10:47

HedgehogB · 29/11/2022 10:06

Totally agree with you. Same situation exactly with my sis and her three, middle child is non verbal autistic and equally described as most severely affected in the county . The other two love her to bits and are a great support to each other

Your niece has been described as the “most severely effected in the county” by whom?

Emotionalsupportviper · 29/11/2022 10:39

Feef83 · 28/11/2022 19:02

at 8… automatism and non verbal.

I am very sorry to say that unlikely to ever be the case that he’s loving living in sheltered accommodation .

and I think if you think back to your experience with you brother, it would have been different if he had been autistic and non verb.

sadly it is highly unlikely the OP’s NT child will be describing his brother as a “wonderful uncle” at 20

Sadly I have to agree.

I was a Salt and children who are non-verbal at this age are not going to suddenly develop normal communication skills. I wish I could be optimistic, but it won't happen. (Though I would love to be proved wrong)

WhiteFire · 29/11/2022 10:35

I have no doubt that my two girls love their brother, it doesn't mean that they also find the situation difficult.

FlamingJingleBells · 29/11/2022 10:28

FlamingJingleBells · 29/11/2022 07:49

Have you got an action plan if the third is diagnosed with autism which is very likely. Then would you go for a fourth baby, where do you draw the line? I'd actually go for some generic counselling first before making a decision. Think very carefully because you will be making a decision that will impact a child(ren) not necessarily for the better.

Genetic counselling not generic counselling.

HedgehogB · 29/11/2022 10:06

Totally agree with you. Same situation exactly with my sis and her three, middle child is non verbal autistic and equally described as most severely affected in the county . The other two love her to bits and are a great support to each other

WhiteFire · 29/11/2022 09:43

Raven Thank you for sharing your experience. I feel stretched beyond my capacity so I can empathise there.

RavenclawsPrincess · 29/11/2022 08:29

I want to give an POV here from an autistic adult.

On the one hand, part of me wants to say your family, your business, an autistic child is not a curse, you already know how to care for an autistic child, etc. I don’t necessarily empathise with the dread around autism, because I come from a family where we are all autistic. But also, we are all different, partly due to nature and partly other factors. I’m the oldest of three. Me, then my sister (5 years younger) than my brother (8 years younger than me, 3 years younger than my sister). My brother was the only one diagnosed in childhood with autism and has high support needs. He had terrible meltdowns and was violent, which became problematic in his teens. I mostly missed that stage because I had moved out, but my sister got a lot of it. My sister has a lot of trauma from what she went through, she has CPTSD, has had a lot of therapy and never held down a job, and I have no doubt it was hardest on her and the trauma she experienced is what has made the difference, as otherwise we are fairly similar. My autism was missed until adulthood because I was female and “no trouble” - I was the classic quiet, daydreamy, nerdy kid, so of course, autism does not automatically equal difficult. But having my brother, when my parents were already older, completely changed our family dynamics and honestly not for the better. I think before my brother arrived you’d have said we were just an eccentric family (both my parents, I suspect, are also autistic) but after that, the whole family had to be arranged around his needs, and me and my sister had to fit in with that.

I guess I’m sharing here because even in an entirely autistic family, there can be vast differences and there is more likelihood as far as I know of a child possibly having higher support needs if the parents are older. Of course also different families deal differently with a child with higher support needs too. Mine did their best, but they were very out of their comfort zone with a high needs autistic child - it stretched them way beyond their capacity. You might be far more comfortable with the idea OP, and may be well resourced if you do have an autistic child with more needs than there are in your current family setup. Only you will know.

RandomMusings7 · 29/11/2022 07:55

There was absolutely nothing negative about having a third.

...for yourself. You can't speak for your children though. And they might not be entirely honest with you if asked

FlamingJingleBells · 29/11/2022 07:49

Have you got an action plan if the third is diagnosed with autism which is very likely. Then would you go for a fourth baby, where do you draw the line? I'd actually go for some generic counselling first before making a decision. Think very carefully because you will be making a decision that will impact a child(ren) not necessarily for the better.

WhiteFire · 29/11/2022 07:35

There was absolutely nothing negative about having a third.

For me there was / is. Please stop downplaying my experience. I have acknowledged that others may feel different to me for a myriad of reasons and it would be good for that to be extended the other way.

Problemorno · 29/11/2022 07:15

Nope. Your life, your business.

Softplayhooray · 29/11/2022 07:07

OP I wonder if this is really about your family. Are they very judgemental and unpleasant? Because I don't think anyone here would think to judge you, nor would it cross their mind that they would have any business standing in judgement. But sounds like your family feel they do. If that's the case ignore them and go for it.

Sindonym · 29/11/2022 07:04

So again. If you want a third & feel you can cope with another child go for it,

Sindonym · 29/11/2022 07:03

OP - all this talk of terribly hard work autistic children. My son (who is sweet & loving & funny) is recognised as one of the most challenging to services in his cohort. He lived at home until 17 and his then social worker told me she would wake in the night in dread at what might happen. Since leaving home we had 16 good months, followed by a year & a half of utter hell, and now nearly years of rebuilding his life with a wonderful provider. As I said earlier I am very involved in his support & that is partly because he is hard work for services (as well as being the delightful, funny, loving young man I described above).

Yes it put enormous strain on the family - particularly us. Having a third child didn’t make the blindest bit of difference other than give the younger two someone to share the experience with. There was absolutely nothing negative about having a third.

Having only ds1 & no other kids would not have helped. He stayed at home with us as long as he could whether or not he had siblings. He moved out when his care needs became 2:1. We couldn’t have done that even without siblings as dh needed to work. So did I really, although we could live without my input if necessary.

Having 2 or 3 kids in all the above made zero difference to the situation. And the other two are happy, well adjusted adults. We remain a close family - probably closer to the younger two than we might otherwise have been at their ages because of what we all went through (think this thread shows you can’t really understand it from the outside, which leads to a stronger bond between those who do).

bubblesball · 29/11/2022 00:36

I'd judge privately, but I wouldn't show it if I knew you and you'd never know. Outwardly I would smile and congratulate you. I'm a parent of an autistic child (now an adult) and didn't have another child until DS1 was old enough to go into supported living on his own. He needed my full attention until then, especially throughout the teenage years when he was physically bigger than I was, and I needed to stop work to get him a decent EHCP and deliver daily therapies at home and accompany him to weekly appointments and therapies. He wouldn't have had the provisions and the support he had throughout his childhood (and still has now) if I'd had my hands full with a younger sibling.