Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest, would you judge us for having another child?

508 replies

Callingmrssnow · 28/11/2022 13:02

We have two DS, 8 & 10, one of whom has autism. We have always talked about having another child but the timing has never been right until now. Also, time is not on our side as I have just turned 39.

DS 2 has autism and is non verbal. I feel like people will judge us for having another child, family included. They will judge us because it will cause our lives to change and think that we are taking time away from our child who already has high needs.

I know all this. However, my DH and I dream of another but I can't help but think people will think we are past it and being selfish.

OP posts:
kateandme · 30/11/2022 12:09

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 07:40

I did - and I have referred to those times on this thread as well. If you trawl through my posts on here rather than elsewhere you will see I said they were so awful that having two made zero difference to the situation - other than helped them as they had each other.

Unless you are saying that anyone with an autistic kid should never have another child ever again in case the worse happens?

I’ve also said that despite the traumatic times both younger kids are now happy, well adjusted young adults who talk with a dark sense of humour about those times but have no lingering trauma. I’m sorry they just don’t - we talk about it openly and they are off happily getting on with their lives.

I know this is hard to understand - but sometimes going through the worst brings families together. It’s not something I would wish on my worst enemy but now, 6 or 7 years later life is good for all three siblings (even ds1 who continues to have struggles). This isn’t fantasy - it’s just one possible outcome - and it’s up to OP whether she wants to take the risk any third child brings (many more risks than autism for anyone with each child).

Totally get this. A family that comes through certain situations are a family to fucking behold.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:07

@Wiluli your cognitive dissonance is amazing.

You say My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands

but then also smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15

smacking is absolutely violence. Throwing things is also violence.

The way you minimise it tell me you are seriously downplaying the degree to which your younger ones were also affected. And remember, witnessing violence and living without a sense of security is also traumatic. You don't necessarily have to be on the receiving end of it.

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:04

Oh my quote in the above post didn’t come out. It was about me not understanding how traumatising it can be (which I do, obviously).

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:00

Of course I understand it can be. I also know siblings who have experienced less trauma with their sibling who have ongoing issues. My kids don’t. Sorry I can’t magic up issues for them. There are no hidden issues. My point is that it isn’t a given as many in here seem to think, not that it isn’t possible.

Probably helps that my son’s needs were so great services had to act.

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:33

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 11:24

Re read the post and you will what the post was actually what she was asking (is it the right word to describe a NT child as “normal”)

Ha sorry my bad , no it’s not the right way you are very right .

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:33

Everyone seems to assume autistic people are very violent . My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands , 99% during the teen years ( hormones are hard with every teen and even harder as a non verbal autistic one ) , mostly towards me in the form of smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15 , thankfully not awfully hard and he would realise his actions and apologise within 30 second ) Mostly my DC would get upset and throw remotes , literally I went through dozens of sky remotes . But was a stage , now a much more mellow personality . I think my situation is a bit differently as my child was a teen when my middle child was born and my youngest is almost 1 year old so I already knew at least partly how he would react .
Thankfully DC adores his sisters and has he got older he understands and accepts much better changes around him . Others probably think my life is super hard ( work kids partner home , always on the go ) but I love the craziness of it all . If I was a bit younger I would even go for a 4th .

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 11:24

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:18

Why don’t you think it’s normal ? So many children are born of over 40 s mums

Re read the post and you will what the post was actually what she was asking (is it the right word to describe a NT child as “normal”)

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 11:21

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:18

Why don’t you think it’s normal ? So many children are born of over 40 s mums

She's saying that "normal" is definitely not the right word to describe a child without a disability.

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:18

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 06:55

It’s not

Why don’t you think it’s normal ? So many children are born of over 40 s mums

BloodAndFire · 30/11/2022 10:47

@Sindonym ·

I know some on this thread will find it difficult to understand but even with the very difficult period we had they do not have lasting trauma. We have always been open about it all and as a family have a very dark sense of humour about it all. Ds2 FaceTimed me recently to tell me he had been trying to explain his childhood to his girlfriend and we ended up snorting with laughter.

my close friend and his sister are able to be very funny about their childhood with their mother in and out of psychiatric hospitals, and her eventual suicide.

they have a dark sense of humour about it and are very funny.

they are also deeply, hugely traumatised by it. It's worrying that you don't seem to understand the impact these childhood experiences have, or that being able to joke and laugh about it is in no way incompatible with being traumatised and damaged.

RavenclawsPrincess · 30/11/2022 10:01

I'm sorry but growing up with a sibling who is so out of control and so dangerous that you have to lock yourself away from them or you can't live in the same house as them cannot not be traumatic. It just cannot.

This.

This literally happened to my sister. I still carry guilt because I had left and gone to uni at the point where my brother started to get more and more difficult to handle. She was subjected to violence pretty much every day. It took years for them to admit there was a problem or get any help. My mum had to stop work to care for him, which had a financial impact. My sister has CPTSD and the sibling abuse has had a major impact on her mental health.

As I said in my previous comment, we are also all autistic, but with very varying levels of support need. As an autistic person I feel my reaction to people making blanket statements such as “ASD is always hard work” or similar. But adding to a family where you already have a child with support needs requires serious thought and planning and you do need to think about the what ifs, including if another child has even higher support needs than those you already have, and how that might impact your family. Because the reality is, living with a sibling that cannot control their temper, whether it is their fault or not, WILL be difficult or even traumatic for the other children in that household. Saying “he can’t help it” does not do anything to make that any better either.

At the end of the day as well, when you have a child, you are fulfilling your own desires - we have to own that. My dad wanted a son, which is part of why us two daughters resent the decision they made to have a third. Both of us have made it very clear we will not take care of my brother when they are gone, so parents also should not go into it with the idea that they can rely on their NT or lower support need children as a caretaking strategy either.

Legallypinkish · 30/11/2022 09:49

whiteroseredrose · 28/11/2022 16:03

That is awful! Why should the siblings automatically have responsibility? Not live their own lives to the full?

A lovely colleague met a gorgeous Australian dentist. She knew he would want to go back eventually and agonised about marrying him because her parents 'expected' her to take care of her sibling with Downs Syndrome.

I'm glad to say that she married and emigrated in the end.

Totally agree. There’s no way I want my younger children taking care of their brother full time once We are gone. They’ve missed out on so much already. Of course they’ll look out for him, maybe manage his money, advocate on his behalf if they want and make sure he’s safe and happy but definitely not full time caring. My 16 year old has already said she wants to be a joint deputy when she’s 18. But they need to live their lives and he needs to be around his peers and have a full life too. All my kids have already said that they don’t want children of their own (that may change I know) because of the genetic risk.

berksandbeyond · 30/11/2022 09:42

Why do you want another? If your second child didn't have autism would you have stopped at 2?

wildchild554 · 30/11/2022 09:30

I wouldn't judge at all and you sound like you have thought about it thoroughly, there will be people that judge no matter what and they probably already do about other things even if you are not aware of it, but your best off not worrying about that and just getting on with your lives and don't let the worry of being judged hold you back. Do what's right for your family and don't worry about what others think. Good luck OP :)

Thisisworsethananticpated · 30/11/2022 08:46

Having a sibling with SEN isn’t easy

my DC has really matured and adapted
and there are moments ….

but it impacts him 1000%

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 08:37

It doesn’t make sense to describe the times with your disabled child as “so awful”. To say how his siblings had to lock themselves in a room to protect themselves from their disabled sibling.

But in the same breath say having a disabled child had zero impact

😐

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 08:36

I said they were so awful that having two made zero difference to the situation - other than helped them as they had each other.

reread your own words @Sindonym

and then say whether you agree with your original statement that having a disabled child had Zero impact

sue20 · 30/11/2022 08:22

Yes I judge but on the basis of knowing nothing about you. I judge because I’m considering the situation as a Mumsnet exercise. I think none of my business. Then my thoughts are mainly for the other children. That’s your judgement. I would say as long as you have the resources and independence then go for it. 39 not that old IMO.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 07:52

both younger kids are now happy, well adjusted young adults who talk with a dark sense of humour about those times but have no lingering trauma. I’m sorry they just don’t -

but you don't know that @Sindonym
That's for a trained mental health expert to assess. They might not be conscious of the trauma or the effects it's has on them. Or they want to spare you the guilt trip so they won't be 100% honest and open about how they really feel about their childhood.

I'm sorry but growing up with a sibling who is so out of control and so dangerous that you have to lock yourself away from them or you can't live in the same house as them cannot not be traumatic. It just cannot.

UnicornsDoExist · 30/11/2022 07:51

Both of my kids have sn. I wouldn’t judge you because it’s none of my business . who cares what other people think, it’s your choice

Purplemagnolias · 30/11/2022 07:47

don’t over think it either, I doubt anyone would ever have a child if we did that!

A financially stable and healthy young couple in their late 20s choosing to have a (first) child is VERY different to an almost 40 year old mother of two older children already, one with additional needs.

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 07:40

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 06:53

But on another thread you say how incredibly hard it has been and how your two other children regularly had to kick themselves in a room away from their sibling to protect themselves

I did - and I have referred to those times on this thread as well. If you trawl through my posts on here rather than elsewhere you will see I said they were so awful that having two made zero difference to the situation - other than helped them as they had each other.

Unless you are saying that anyone with an autistic kid should never have another child ever again in case the worse happens?

I’ve also said that despite the traumatic times both younger kids are now happy, well adjusted young adults who talk with a dark sense of humour about those times but have no lingering trauma. I’m sorry they just don’t - we talk about it openly and they are off happily getting on with their lives.

I know this is hard to understand - but sometimes going through the worst brings families together. It’s not something I would wish on my worst enemy but now, 6 or 7 years later life is good for all three siblings (even ds1 who continues to have struggles). This isn’t fantasy - it’s just one possible outcome - and it’s up to OP whether she wants to take the risk any third child brings (many more risks than autism for anyone with each child).

sorrynotathome · 30/11/2022 07:34

As autism is linked to age of parents, I would think your chances of having another child with special needs is quite high.

itsjustnotok · 30/11/2022 07:30

@beachcitygirl seriously? I just don’t understand this idea. You decide to have children and then think yeah have another so there’s people to take care of them….intentionally. It’s one thing it happening by chance but knowingly doing it just doesn’t sit right.

liarliarshortsonfire · 30/11/2022 07:05

I'd never judge, my SIL did exactly what you are considering and her family are all happy and stable (her second has additional needs). The one thing I would consider is if you can support, both financially and mentally another autistic child.