Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest, would you judge us for having another child?

508 replies

Callingmrssnow · 28/11/2022 13:02

We have two DS, 8 & 10, one of whom has autism. We have always talked about having another child but the timing has never been right until now. Also, time is not on our side as I have just turned 39.

DS 2 has autism and is non verbal. I feel like people will judge us for having another child, family included. They will judge us because it will cause our lives to change and think that we are taking time away from our child who already has high needs.

I know all this. However, my DH and I dream of another but I can't help but think people will think we are past it and being selfish.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Frazzledstudentmom · 07/12/2022 23:48

No judgement at all from me... but as a mum of 4, I'd day stick to the same number of children as you have hands! 3 is the hardest number. 4 is about level on difficulty.
People will always have their own opinions, but that doesn't mean they have a right to force them on you. Only you and your partner can decide what is best for your family.

Susandorothy22 · 30/11/2022 18:46

It is really up to you and your DH.
It is not really anyone else’s concern.
If you feel confident that you could manage another child (possibly on the spectrum or not),
it is up to you!

Purplemagnolias · 30/11/2022 16:09

I’d judge cause I would think 2 kids is more than enough

I tend to agree.

I guess selfishly many people want children but as a society we really should consider our planet!

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 14:53

@WhiteFire I wouldn’t say we have good services around us and ds1 suffered greatly due to a failure of local services (so bad the LA did a case review on him). But nevertheless the CCG & LA had to act because the risks were so high. The impact of both failures and actions were felt largely by ds1 and parents rather than siblings (but again they had each other). The actions they took were bloody awful but did protect the younger siblings.

DixonD · 30/11/2022 14:44

Aiaichipsnpie · 28/11/2022 13:41

I’ve a friend whose eldest child has sever special needs and will require care her whole life. Her issues only became apparent after her second child was born. People judged them when they had a third but their thought was that they wished for DS2 to have another sibling so that they would support each other as adults with a special needs sister whose care arrangements they will one day be responsible for. She didn’t want one child to have to carry that responsibility alone.

That’s one of worst reasons I’ve ever heard. What if the third child also had severe needs and the poor NT child had to support BOTH?

Neither child should be forced to be support a disabled sibling as adults. It’s down to the parents to make provision which does not include your other children “stepping up”.

DixonD · 30/11/2022 14:36

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/11/2022 13:08

I wouldn't judge you. Not my place.

Have you considered that dc3 may also be autistic?

This.

This is why I would not have another. If a third has autism, it could be more severe than the other one. You would regret it and I wouldn’t be able to live with knowing I’d made my entire family’s life much harder. Hypothetical of course, but enough to put me off.

WhiteFire · 30/11/2022 14:34

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:37

@BloodAndFire And with respect you do not know my family or how we interact or the conversations we have had.

DS1 was not violent - he was/is aggressive when distressed. And that did not happen until he was older. There was no intent (hence not violence) and they have a very good understanding of distress and communication disorders. They have had some training around distress & stress training and they can attend that again any time they want. It’s the same training my son’s support workers get. Ds1 never physically hurt them as we were able to protect them.

anyway this thread was about 1 vs 2 siblings and in all the above 2 was a help imo.

This goes back to the point I made pages ago, if you have good services around you, it is very different to when you don't. Services will not touch us, mainstream school and no EHCP and no support for the siblings.

The only real support we get is through his consultant, which we only see as he has another genetic condition. We (and her) have fought for years to see a dietician, he is only seen now because he was dropping down the growth charts, and he is only monitored due to the other condition.

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 13:39

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:40

But your oldest was 15 when the second one came along. Which means you planned a pregnancy while these violent incidents were still routine. How did you know they would stop? How did you know the baby would be safe?

And my son was around my nephews daily ( babies at the time ) so I could predict very well how he would behave .
I should had he was never prone to tantrums the smacking I mention would be ( example ) ipad battery would die , he would get upset come running across me and smack me and go back to his bedroom , come back apologise and go back on his merry way, not that violence is not bad but in case you are imagining he was screaming or volatile for a period of time , he was not . Same with throwing remotes , it was like a release of anger , he would o be upset with something throw a remote on the floor , remote would break and he would calm down . At a stage I had his psychologist saying to try and let him throw the recycling glass in the recycling bin as it might be good for him to let go of his frustration . .He still likes doing it now , albeit only because he likes the noise :-)

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 13:35

Buttonjugs · 30/11/2022 12:51

My ASD son has never been violent. When he was little he used to have meltdowns but a child psychologist taught me how to deal with him (think Supernanny) and it took some work but it was so effective he grew up to be thoughtful and gentle. He has enormous empathy, and literally wouldn’t hurt a fly.

Most asd adults and young adults are not violent , some go through stages as young children due to frustration and some have incidents during their teen years . But most are not violent adults . Yes I know a few who are violent and some extremely violent but far from being the majority .

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 13:33

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:40

But your oldest was 15 when the second one came along. Which means you planned a pregnancy while these violent incidents were still routine. How did you know they would stop? How did you know the baby would be safe?

And ? I knew my child better than anyone else . He was never violent until that stage , he had a great psychologist at this stage great support and we all knew for a fact it was a phase and hormones . And I was 100% right , he is mellow , wonderful and very patient with me his siblings and the rest of the family . What sort of world do you live in that makes you think a disabled child or adult deserve less or those around gain nothing from them ? You had your own experience which I gather was very bad and I’m truly sorry you feel so much resentment but for sure you realise that’s not the norm ?

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 13:30

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 30/11/2022 13:15

I completely agree with you. I think having children is utterly selfish at the best of times but I really wonder about people who look around the world today and think ah I know, I will satisfy my own selfish desires and make another person to have to suffer it.

Have you noticed the name of this website?

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 30/11/2022 13:15

Buttonjugs · 30/11/2022 12:45

Is it just me that thinks why would anyone want children when the future is so uncertain? Climate change, political unrest etc. I worry what the world will be like in 50 years time, if we will halt climate change and if so, how? I have grandchildren age 9 and 11 and worry about their futures all the time. Sorry to be so dark but it’s the reality.

I completely agree with you. I think having children is utterly selfish at the best of times but I really wonder about people who look around the world today and think ah I know, I will satisfy my own selfish desires and make another person to have to suffer it.

Buttonjugs · 30/11/2022 12:51

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 11:33

Everyone seems to assume autistic people are very violent . My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands , 99% during the teen years ( hormones are hard with every teen and even harder as a non verbal autistic one ) , mostly towards me in the form of smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15 , thankfully not awfully hard and he would realise his actions and apologise within 30 second ) Mostly my DC would get upset and throw remotes , literally I went through dozens of sky remotes . But was a stage , now a much more mellow personality . I think my situation is a bit differently as my child was a teen when my middle child was born and my youngest is almost 1 year old so I already knew at least partly how he would react .
Thankfully DC adores his sisters and has he got older he understands and accepts much better changes around him . Others probably think my life is super hard ( work kids partner home , always on the go ) but I love the craziness of it all . If I was a bit younger I would even go for a 4th .

My ASD son has never been violent. When he was little he used to have meltdowns but a child psychologist taught me how to deal with him (think Supernanny) and it took some work but it was so effective he grew up to be thoughtful and gentle. He has enormous empathy, and literally wouldn’t hurt a fly.

Sunnytwobridges · 30/11/2022 12:46

groundhoglet · 28/11/2022 13:26

I would but only because I think it'd be better for the planet if people stuck to two or fewer children. But I know that in practice the desire for a child is not a rational one.

This. I wouldn’t judge because one if your kids have autism. I’d judge cause I would think 2 kids is more than enough considering I think there are too many people on the earth already.

Buttonjugs · 30/11/2022 12:45

Is it just me that thinks why would anyone want children when the future is so uncertain? Climate change, political unrest etc. I worry what the world will be like in 50 years time, if we will halt climate change and if so, how? I have grandchildren age 9 and 11 and worry about their futures all the time. Sorry to be so dark but it’s the reality.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:40

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 12:31

You only read what you wanted , o said I was in a different position as I only had my youngest when my oldest was a teen , so no siblings

But your oldest was 15 when the second one came along. Which means you planned a pregnancy while these violent incidents were still routine. How did you know they would stop? How did you know the baby would be safe?

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 12:40

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:37

Living in a house where it is routine for an older sibling to hit your mother and to throw and destroy things is traumatic and makes for a very shitty childhood (whether or not there are special needs involved), no matter how you spin it.

The fact you insist your younger kids have not been affected by this is simply preposterous.

And if this view makes me an asshole, so be it...

Do you know how to read ? I clearly say it’s a different experience as my children were only born when he was a teen . So they cannot possibly be affected as they were not here yet

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:37

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 12:27

Don’t be an asshole , I know plenty of NT kids with a much worse temper than my child ever had during their teen years and nowhere did I say it was the whole year I said between those ages .
Your ableism is showing !
And off course they count but they were by no means awful or impossível to deal with as some ( like you ) like to make others believe . They were also not traumatic in any way to me or anyone else.

Living in a house where it is routine for an older sibling to hit your mother and to throw and destroy things is traumatic and makes for a very shitty childhood (whether or not there are special needs involved), no matter how you spin it.

The fact you insist your younger kids have not been affected by this is simply preposterous.

And if this view makes me an asshole, so be it...

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:37

@BloodAndFire And with respect you do not know my family or how we interact or the conversations we have had.

DS1 was not violent - he was/is aggressive when distressed. And that did not happen until he was older. There was no intent (hence not violence) and they have a very good understanding of distress and communication disorders. They have had some training around distress & stress training and they can attend that again any time they want. It’s the same training my son’s support workers get. Ds1 never physically hurt them as we were able to protect them.

anyway this thread was about 1 vs 2 siblings and in all the above 2 was a help imo.

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 12:31

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:07

@Wiluli your cognitive dissonance is amazing.

You say My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands

but then also smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15

smacking is absolutely violence. Throwing things is also violence.

The way you minimise it tell me you are seriously downplaying the degree to which your younger ones were also affected. And remember, witnessing violence and living without a sense of security is also traumatic. You don't necessarily have to be on the receiving end of it.

You only read what you wanted , o said I was in a different position as I only had my youngest when my oldest was a teen , so no siblings

BloodAndFire · 30/11/2022 12:28

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:00

Of course I understand it can be. I also know siblings who have experienced less trauma with their sibling who have ongoing issues. My kids don’t. Sorry I can’t magic up issues for them. There are no hidden issues. My point is that it isn’t a given as many in here seem to think, not that it isn’t possible.

Probably helps that my son’s needs were so great services had to act.

My parents don't know the half of what I've been through or how I feel about lots of stuff that happened in my childhood or how it affects me today.

You are really not in a position to say that your other children weren't and aren't traumatised by what they went through.

I understand that you all have a laugh about it. I do this with some of my worst experiences too. It's quite common. You don't know how they feel or how it affects them. They are doubtless as a result of those experiences both 1. Good at hiding trauma and 2. Want to protect you from knowing what it was really like for them.

You say you can't "magic up trauma". Really, you can't "magic it away" either. Children, particularly those who grow up in violent frightening homes around bigger people they can't control, are very very good at masking.

Wiluli · 30/11/2022 12:27

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:14

Oh but those instances don't count because they didn't smack her "too hard" 🙄

Unless it leaves you black and blue, it's not violence in @Wiluli's world.

So misleading...

Don’t be an asshole , I know plenty of NT kids with a much worse temper than my child ever had during their teen years and nowhere did I say it was the whole year I said between those ages .
Your ableism is showing !
And off course they count but they were by no means awful or impossível to deal with as some ( like you ) like to make others believe . They were also not traumatic in any way to me or anyone else.

Sindonym · 30/11/2022 12:22

Thank you @kateandme that’s a lovely thing to say.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 12:14

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 12:12

@Wiluli
Everyone seems to assume autistic people are very violent . My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands , 99% during the teen years ( hormones are hard with every teen and even harder as a non verbal autistic one ) , mostly towards me in the form of smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15 , thankfully not awfully hard and he would realise his actions and apologise within 30 second )

so is it less than a handful of times
or
2x a week at points in teenage years?

Oh but those instances don't count because they didn't smack her "too hard" 🙄

Unless it leaves you black and blue, it's not violence in @Wiluli's world.

So misleading...

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 12:12

@Wiluli
Everyone seems to assume autistic people are very violent . My child now 19 violent actions can be counted by the fingers of my hands , 99% during the teen years ( hormones are hard with every teen and even harder as a non verbal autistic one ) , mostly towards me in the form of smacking me in the back due to frustration ( use to happen twice a week if that at age 14 to 15 , thankfully not awfully hard and he would realise his actions and apologise within 30 second )

so is it less than a handful of times
or
2x a week at points in teenage years?