Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm a tenant, landlords company broke my hoover

63 replies

ditherwood · 28/11/2022 09:34

Sorry, this is long, I'm waffling as really upset by this. My landlord had all my windows replaced in my flat last week. Obviously I had no control over this process and just had to prepare as best I could. It was a three day job, I worked from home the first two days as I don't like having men/people in my flat without me there, they could have completed the work in two days as they worked roughly a half day each day. On the third day I had no choice other than go into my office as I had in person meetings I couldn't get out of. On the third day the contractor arrived alone, previously he had had two other men working with him and two vans. He explained he had put the other two on another job for a man who gives him a lot of work and who he needed to "keep sweet". He had previously told me this last third day was saving "the worst job for last" replacing the kitchen window at first floor level.

The previous two days the other two men had put dust overs over everything and it was still quite dirty afterwards but I accepted here would be some dirt in addition to the significant disruption. They had a Henry hoover they used to clear up afterwards.

As I had gone to work he literally didn't cover a single surface, I have three sets of freestanding shelves as the kitchen has no cupboards space along with wall mounted shelving and a dresser, EVERYTHING for my kitchen is on these shelves, from plates to packets of pasta. EVERYTHING was covered in 100 years worth of dust and dirt from the windows.

When I got home on Wednesday I could see the contractor had used my brand new hoover as it was out in the hallway and full to the brim. I had closed off the living room and bedroom and had stored as much of my kitchen stuff as I could move in my living room. I hid the vacuum in the closed living room as it's a brand new Dyson V10 £329 that was a gift, less than two weeks old. He had gone in to the closed living room and searched for the vacuum, found it and used it on the rubble from the window and broken it. It is full of plaster and rubbish that has gone up into the mechanisms and completely buggered it.

I immediately tried to call him, it went to voicemail, I tried to empty the hoover but could see it was broken, I emailed the estate agent and told them it was broken. The landlord had insisted he visit early the next day to see the windows before he paid the final invoice. I showed him the hoover and cried I was so upset about it, he was quite sympathetic and said he'd sort it. I now haven't heard since Thursday and have spent literally all weekend cleaning my kitchen, removing every item from the shelves and cleaning everything.

I've felt really badly about this, I was really good to the window company, one of them actually thanked me for making them so much tea as he said it doesn't often happen. I even bought them doughnuts on the last day as a thank you, as I am grateful for having new windows even if I didn't ask for them, my flat has been freezing and noisy with original 1906 windows.

It's really affected my mental health. I feel really really upset over having a new hoover and he used it without permission and broke it. I literally never have any nice or new stuff, my boyfriend bought it for me as he knew I struggled with my old hoover, the flat is really hard to keep clean. I'd wanted a hoover like this for years, to have this bloke go into my private space and take it and use it and break it has really profoundly upset me and to have no resolution from my landlord yet feels like they are going to try to duck out of it and I'm the one who loses out and have done nothing to deserve it.

I emailed a formal complaint to the agent, she just called me and said it's completely out of her hands as the landlord used their own contractor.

AIBU to expect my brand new hoover to be replaced?

OP posts:
cookiesbeforepookies · 28/11/2022 16:09

I would also consider these options:

  • taking LL / agency to small claims court
  • withholding cost of vacuum from rent payment, after sending them a letter via registered post
GladAllOver · 28/11/2022 16:04

A Dyson a Hoover. Now am AM confused!

GladAllOver · 28/11/2022 16:03

Why is everyone calling a Hoover a Dyson? Do you call a Ford a Vauxhall?

WombatChocolate · 28/11/2022 15:54

Quite simply, know that this is down to the LL to sort out and you need to communicate firmly and clearly to show you expect this to happen.

Send a picture of the damaged hoover and an email to the agent, who communicates with the LL if you can’t contact them direct, but if you can, copy both in.

State exactly when the hoover was new and the price. If you haven’t got a receipt send a link to one online. Lay out clearly that the workmen has a Henry for the first couple of days and where you put the hoover, hidden away and behind closed doors. State clearly where it was when you returned home and that the builders must have gone into your private space that they didn’t need to enter for the job space to look for it, and used it and broken it.

Quite simply state that as the LL hired the workmen, you expect him to deal with them and decide how to address the issue. Say you are offering him the choice of 2 options - to transfer the money to your Bank Acc or to take an equal reduction on the next rent, and you’d like to know his choice within 48 hours. I would finish by saying that as well as the item being broken, you feel violated by the incident. It’s hard enough to have workmen in your home that you haven’t requested, but it’s totally unacceptable to experience them going into closed off rooms and taking and using your equipment whilst out. State that you hope they will be making that very clear to the workmen and their superiors and considering what more can be done to protect tenants in future.

You dont have to be rude or aggressive. However, you should be firm and assertive.

Take the pics, get a receipt or link to the price and send the email. You will feel empowered and as if you are taking the incident back into your control. And then start to let it go. In all liklihood, the LL will cover the cost as they should.

Anither thing to say to the LL and agent, is that in future you only want workmen organised through the agent. Then, if there is something like this, the agent should be willing to pursue it on your behalf and mediate.

JackTorrance · 28/11/2022 15:38

What shop on the planet would exchange a new Dyson that had been broken clearing up builder's rubble?!

cookiesbeforepookies · 28/11/2022 15:30

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 28/11/2022 10:04

Hoover is less than 2 weeks old so can definitely still be exchanged! 🤦🏻‍♀️What a drama.

I can’t see the shop replacing the vacuum. It’s been abused rather than used.

Crazydoglady1980 · 28/11/2022 14:55

Does the agent manage the tenancy? If they do, they can not come back with saying it is not in their hands as the contract for your housing is with them and they are a third party in this transaction.
Contact them again, I would suggest email so you have a written record, advising that as they are the point of contact for the tenancy they are legally bound to be part of this recourse. Explain what you need and want to happen and that you would be exploring legal options towards themselves, as managers of the tenancy, if the situation is not resolved.
It is then their job to speak with the landlord, as this is who their contract is with and the landlords job to speak with the contractors

Clymene · 28/11/2022 14:38

The contractor went ferreting around in your cupboards, used something of yours without your permission and broke it.

I would email the agent again who will have the landlord's details with the receipt, photographs of the vacuum cleaner and say that you will be deducting the cost of replacement from your rent.

It's up to the landlord to sort it out with the contractor. Not your problem.

BMW6 · 28/11/2022 14:20

OP I had the very similar happen to me years ago. My LL replaced my hoover with brand new and deducted the cost from the contractors final invoice.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 28/11/2022 14:10

jtaeapa · 28/11/2022 10:16

What a scummy contractor. Difficult though - I'm not sure the landlord is responsible - he didn't do this. The contractor is clearly not going to hand over any money for anything.

Of. Course the landlord is responsible. It was his contractors who caused the problem

Sugarplumfairy65 · 28/11/2022 14:03

silverclock222 · 28/11/2022 12:39

Claim it through your insurance and they can reclaim from the glaziers surely?

Don't talk crap

Sugarplumfairy65 · 28/11/2022 14:02

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 28/11/2022 10:03

@Chattycathydoll her landlord was sympathetic and said he will sort it. That was 4 days ago with a weekend in between. He probably called him Friday and waiting for a reply.

yes it’s awful and annoying but to be “really really upset” and “really affected my mental health” over a hoover seems OTT. The hoover probably still has a warranty and OP could exchange it tomorrow!

The warranty would not cover that kind of use. Why should the retailer be out of pocket? The landlord needs to replace it then claim from the window company

MadelineUsher · 28/11/2022 13:21

I hid the vacuum in the closed living room as it's a brand new Dyson V10 £329 that was a gift, less than two weeks old. He had gone in to the closed living room and searched for the vacuum, found it and used it on the rubble from the window and broken it. It is full of plaster and rubbish that has gone up into the mechanisms and completely buggered it.

Good God, I am furious on your behalf. You don't have to apologize for being upset about this or anxious that you won't get a proper response and have your brand new vacuum cleaner replaced. It is a normal response to a very upsetting situation.

Changedma · 28/11/2022 13:17

The landlord doesn't want to pay to replace and obviously the contractor will lie and say he didn't break it. I'm in no mans land with no protection.

It sounded like landlord is sympathetic and on the case though. Presumably you provided photos of it full with rubble. Also doesn’t sound like landlord has paid final instalment to contractor yet so your chance of getting the money is strong as the LL will be sending them the list of deductions from final bill.

It’s reasonable for you to do a bit of cleaning but sounds like they left you to do it all which is also unreasonable and hopefully the LL also witnessed on their inspection.

Blossomtoes · 28/11/2022 12:45

silverclock222 · 28/11/2022 12:39

Claim it through your insurance and they can reclaim from the glaziers surely?

How much would she get after the excess? She needs to be reimbursed the full amount.

silverclock222 · 28/11/2022 12:39

Claim it through your insurance and they can reclaim from the glaziers surely?

DDivaStar · 28/11/2022 12:33

No the guy shouldn't have entered your lounge, used your hoover or broken it.

Your ll sounds reasonable, this is just not at the top of his to do list.

I would email back saying the ll had said he would sort it and could they chase it up or provide contact details for you to ask him.

ditherwood · 28/11/2022 12:22

Thanks all for your kind messages. I've read them all. You're probably quite right, I am overreacting but as another poster said, when you are renting you feel a total lack of agency and completely unimportant. Having men in your home who you didn't employ and don't know, then they take your stuff and destroy it and you have literally NO knowledge that it will be replaced. The agent has said as they didn't recommend or specify the contractor, I have no redress with them. I can't contact the landlord directly as have to go through the agent. The landlord doesn't want to pay to replace and obviously the contractor will lie and say he didn't break it. I'm in no mans land with no protection. And yes it does get you down, and yes, in response to another posters comment, yes I have a lot of other stuff going on and low level anxiety so this has totally tipped me over the edge combined with having to spend all weekend of my limited free time washing dirt off everything in a kitchen I don't own and have no control over who comes in and does what/when.

Thanks everyone though, much appreciate your taking the time to write xx

OP posts:
Calmdown14 · 28/11/2022 11:05

In what way is the hoover broken? You said it is visible so has something cracked?
I would photograph it from every conceivable angle and then empty and clean it. No you shouldn't have to but sometimes it's just worth sorting something than stressing over it.

What you have to establish is are you talking a replacement part or is the whole thing knackered? They contractor is likely to argue the part as to them it will seem like someone trying it on for a brand new expensive hoover.

Rubble is a nightmare for the filters but a good clean does usually sort it.
And while it might not be morally right, I would be tempted to clean it up and exchange it . I've done all sorts of messy jobs with a 10 year old cheap hoover and after a clean it is as good as new. It's only a window so we can't be talking huge bits of masonry. It should be able to cope.

You have a right to be pissed off but there's a point at which it's easier to draw a line and be proactive

MyAutocorrectWishesMeDeaj · 28/11/2022 10:24

Really annoying, but try and think straight. This will get sorted. I'm not sure LL liable though, but you should expect their support.

-Photograph everything.
-Get receipt for hoover.
-Contact LL via email with statement of facts: clear order of what happened/to what/when. Don't exaggerate. You don't need to.
-Get full contact in formation for who they used.
-Email contractor, CC-ing LL. State they did not bring correct equipment and used inappropriate hoover without permission.
-Say you expect full and prompt payment/replacement or you will file small claims case and add on court fees/time taken off work.

If that doesn't work, follow through with court. It's very straightforward, there's no chance you will lose assuming you have evidence in form of photos etc.

But you may not get the resolution as fast as you want, which is annoying, but that's just life.

It is just a hoover. I think you're getting emotional because they were so disrespectful to your home, but try and stay calm when approaching this or you won't seem as serious.

Good luck.

Clymene · 28/11/2022 10:18

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 28/11/2022 10:04

Hoover is less than 2 weeks old so can definitely still be exchanged! 🤦🏻‍♀️What a drama.

That's not how exchanges work.

If you bought a silk dress and wore it to roll down a muddy hill, would you expect to return it and get a new one? Of course not.

This is the same thing.

thebabessavedme · 28/11/2022 10:17

@AllIwantforChristmas22 I think the OP has every right to feel how she does, workmen know the type of tools they need and should bring their own, not nose about and use what is clearly a domestic cleaner for rubble and such, I would imagine that the warrenty will not cover this type of use.

I was seriously pissed off when a guy servicing our boiler filled my bucket up with some sort of sludge and then used one of my tea towels to clean up water that he dripped behind the pipes, not a big deal but surely a plumber/heating engineer would realise that they might need a bucket and cloth (and then expect me to pay him 80 quid and have to clean up old sludge that he left me with and chuck my tea towel away)

jtaeapa · 28/11/2022 10:16

What a scummy contractor. Difficult though - I'm not sure the landlord is responsible - he didn't do this. The contractor is clearly not going to hand over any money for anything.

SirDavidAttenborough · 28/11/2022 10:12

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 28/11/2022 10:04

Hoover is less than 2 weeks old so can definitely still be exchanged! 🤦🏻‍♀️What a drama.

Exchanged by who?

caringcarer · 28/11/2022 10:11

I'd ring LL today and ask what they are doing about your vacuum. Ask if he can deduct the amount from bill for windows. Ask if you can go ahead and replace and deduct from next month's rent. That would be reasonable. Let LL take your vacuum he can probably get it fixed.