Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why county boundaries change?

54 replies

AutisticLegoLover · 27/11/2022 20:51

It happens to countries too.
I've just been reading the Manchester Evening News and there was an article on a village that used to be in one county and then it's in another. The MEN is atrocious as far as its journalism goes but I'll link it anyway.

It got me thinking about how my mum and nana used to classify themselves and a conversation with my much older sister back in the 80s. My sister considered herself a Mancunian. She was living in Fallowfield at the time but had grown up between Yorkshire and Greater Manchester/Cheshire. Mum disagreed and said she was a Lancasarian (or similar, I was young and can't remember exactly). My sister was born in Yorkshire so I was totally baffled by this as we were living in the midlands at the time. Mum said I too was from Lancashire. My Nana was from Lancashire as was my Grandad and my mum was born in a lam ashore town that's now part of one of the areas of greater Manchester but not referred to as Lancashire now.
Over the years I've wondered about this because Greater Manchester incorporates several counties. I have never considered myself Mancunian and was brought up and now live in a small town in Cheshire on the edge of Derbyshire or also known as High Peak. The nearest big town is not one I identify with either and find myself a bit lost really when it comes to my regional identity.
It's bloody confusing! We were mostly born within 10 miles of each other except for the Yorkshire born siblings. My dad was born in Lincolnshire i think and lived mostly in Yorkshire as a child and young adult but he was definitely a Yorkshireman and I feel quite an affinity with God's own county.

I suspect that if I looked at Greater London history my mind would be blown. To me it's a fairly far off mystery place that is bloody massive and I don't know where London begins or ends. It has zones according to what I've read here.

Inside the Yorkshire that town that woke up in Lancashire 50 years ago www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/uk-news/inside-yorkshire-town-woke-up-25616384?utm_source=app

So basically what are they messing about with changing boundaries and if you are from somewhere that has had its boundaries messed with over the years how the hell do you know how to identify yourself?

OP posts:
Ted27 · 27/11/2022 21:31

@MarkBright

I bet she hasn't 😂
I don't see myself as a Merseysider - I'm a Scouser

MarkBright · 27/11/2022 21:10

My mum has never got over leaving Cheshire for Merseyside 😂

AutisticLegoLover · 27/11/2022 21:04

It totally messes with my head. I like things to stay the same. It must be horrendous for people in countries that change.

OP posts:
Ted27 · 27/11/2022 21:00

I’m from Liverpool, which was in Lancashire when I was born, its now Merseyside.
Boundaries can change for many reasons, shifts in population, growth of cities over time. Sometimes they make sense in terms of provision and location of services,

Some governments are not above changing boundaries for electoral advantage

Swipe left for the next trending thread