Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a normal relationship with food?

160 replies

Miajk · 27/11/2022 20:20

And if so, what is your weight like, have you ever dieted? How often do you think about food, do you only eat when hungry and stop when full?

By normal I mean: no counting/tracking, no excluding food groups (unless for allergy or other health reasons), etc.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 27/11/2022 21:23

I have a fairly normal relationship with food and this was brought home to me because for a fairly brief period, following the breakdown of my marriage, I flirted with having an eating disorder.

I didn't deliberately starve myself but I ate almost nothing during the "acute" period of my marriage collapsing and when things began to stabilise but I was still very depressed and low I got a weird kick out of the weight loss I had inadvertently undergone and the strange feeling of control it gave me. For about two years I ate less thn £1,000 calories a day, not in a deliberate way but in a kind of "this is working, let's go with it" way.

Since then my life has stabilised, I'm in a happy relationship and feel pretty good about life and my eating has returned to normal (ie eat what I like, no calorie counting, basically not really thinking about food intake, aside from how it tastes and its nutritional value) I now look back on that period with a sense of bemusement. It was an aberration and very odd because it gave me a window on what it was like to have an eating disorder, something I'd never previously experienced before.

I've been lucky enough never to have issues with food, never to count calories or worry about food intake and never really understood why people would impose these sorts of privations on themselves. And hopefully I never will again. Going through it myself was an eye-opener. It was a pretty grim period of my life but the only positive which it did bring to me was a sense of control. I had no control over my moods, the behaviour of my ex husband or my boss, but I could control my weight and the one thing I had going for me was that I was really really thin and (and this makes me really uncomfortable in retrospec) some of my friends envied me.

it made me realise that being thin and being aware of your weight, something I'd never bothered with before, goes with hideous self-esteem issues and lack of confidence and I never want to be in that place again. Give me slightly overweight over calorie and portion counting any day.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 27/11/2022 21:22

I think I'd fit the description you're giving.

My BMI is 24 but I think I look a healthy size. I don't calorie count. I eat lunch and dinner, for breakfast usually have a coffee and eat for the first time around 11 - some days I'm hungry and I eat toast or cereal.

For lunch I normally have a big salad (ha mn classic) with chickpeas, spinach, feta, courgette, tomato etc. Dinner might be salmon and rice, noodles, usually a protein and 2-3 veg and a carb. Might have a little bit of chocolate (3/4 squares) and a satsuma for after, or a few jelly sweets. I don't tend to snack but I do get calories from lattes I drink.

BananaPie · 27/11/2022 21:21

Normal I think.

I eat what I want but stop when I am full. I feel full quite quickly.

I am less hungry if I have been less active.

I have been a size 8 my entire adult life apart from when pregnant. Never put on weight.

FlyingPandas · 27/11/2022 21:21

Batterseabunny · 27/11/2022 20:37

I think I do. I really enjoy food and the ritual of it - cooking, the social side etc and I also enjoy ‘healthy’ foods as much as treats. By that I mean that I eat salad and veg by choice every day because I genuinely enjoy it, not because I know I should. I very rarely weigh myself but I’ve been roughly the same size of clothes from 20 until now (40s) apart from a year after each pregnancy. I feel very lucky as I know lots of my friends experience a lot of guilt and shame around food and are often limiting what they eat.

I think I’d say similar to the above. I grew up with a mother who was always dieting - lots of comments along the lines of ‘Ooh I can’t eat this, shouldn’t eat that, that’s naughty, this is fattening, don’t buy those because I like them, and I mustn’t eat them, I’m going to go back to Weightwatchers/try the F Plan diet/try slimming world, gosh I’m fat, oh I shouldn’t eat that, I’m a glutton, a glutton, I’m a big fat pig, oh gosh what can I eat, what can I eat, what can I eat?’

That was the soundtrack to my childhood and I often say to my DM that she is very lucky that DSis and I did not end up with severe eating disorders as a result.

However, by some miracle I think both DSis and I have a reasonably sensible attitude to food. We both eat a variety of foods and enjoy the healthy stuff as well as the treats. i could not tell you what my weight was but I’m 5ft 7 and a size 12 at 50, having had three full term babies. I was somewhere between a 10 and 12 at 30 before having DC. I refuse to obsess over, track or limit what I eat and the only time I restricted my food/drink intake was when pregnant (ie to avoid alcohol and any foods you are not supposed to eat when pregnant). I eat what I feel like eating and have never felt guilty about it.

Orangio · 27/11/2022 21:20

I don't think I have food issues. I love cooking and love veg and love exercise. I also love baking and cake. I would say I tend to eat 3 meals and 2 snacks a day. I could easily binge eat every day (particularly cake) because it's really tempting! Every day I resist temptation probably ten times, and cave one time. I resist because I really really like being a healthy weight and I want that more than I want to binge, so I only do it occasionally. (By binge I mean maybe a 100g bar of chocolate in a sitting, or equivalent). I don't feel guilt when I overeat. I just accept it - I made the choice to eat more than I needed so why feel guilty? I know I'm going to do it again in the future, and at the same time I know I'll eat well mostly, so overall it's fine.
I tend to eat a diet where I put on weight very slowly (maybe four to six pounds a year) and then once a year I tone it down on the cake and lose the extra chub.
I have pcos, so do find it more difficult to lose weight/maintain than if I didn't have it. But you just have to eat for the body you have.

poormanspombears · 27/11/2022 21:16

I have a horrible relationship with food.

My stepmother was abusive towards me and food was often used as a weapon. She used to force me to finish my plate and would often hold my nose until I opened my mouth and she would force feed me then clamp my mouth closed until I finished it.

When my mum finally got custody of me again, I used to steal chocolate bars and eat them in my room. I remember holding my hands over pockets filled with breakaways and kitkats so my parents wouldn't hear the rustling and I would go and practically inhale them.

I rarely try anything new and I barely eat fruit or veg. If anyone tries to encourage me it's like a voice in my head shouts 'NO! They're forcing you to eat something' and I will point blank refuse and my mouth closes.
I couldn't tell you how much I weigh because I daren't check.

Slimming world works for a time and then it all goes back on.
I'm the biggest I've ever been and I'm miserable but just can't seem to get into the mindset to try and change.

snowbellsxox · 27/11/2022 21:13

Normal now, had an ED as a teen

doodleygirl · 27/11/2022 21:11

I think I have a pretty normal relationship with food. Im a pretty healthy eater, not really into sweet stuff, but Im happy to eat cake, sweets and other sweet items but I will only have a small amount. Ive never really eaten a whole pack of biscuits or a family pack of mars bars. I do love cheese and crisps they would be my downfall but I dont buy a lot. My now adult DD is the same , I assume its because we didnt buy a lot of sweet foods.

I have IBS like the earlier poster and can bloat very quickly if I eat the wrong foods. I also love running and boxing so I am careful, if I bloat up I cant exercise as it hurts too much.

Miajk · 27/11/2022 21:08

Swissnotswiss · 27/11/2022 20:54

I don't know if this is relevant (and I know some people will heartily disagree!) but I do eat all my meals at a table and never watch tv while eating unless I am on my own. We spend a lot of time as a family around the table. I think it helps foster a good relationship with food.

I love this. I've been working on my relationship with food and eating mindfully, slowly, and without distractions has been a big part of it.

Struggling with some comfort eating lately though 😭

OP posts:
Tubbyinthehottub · 27/11/2022 21:06

I eat a lot. I've never been on a diet. I eat three meals a day plus snacks. Chocolate every night, biscuits/cake every day, wine a couple of times a week. I never think I shouldn't be eating something, it just all evens out. There was a thread on here the other day about lunch where someone said they only eat a cheese and ham toastie at the weekend as it's too calorific and my mind was blown a bit. If I wanted that for lunch, I'd have it. Despite username, I'm not overweight. I do exercise, less now than when I was younger and I suppose I have put a few, maybe half a dozen pounds on since late 30s/40s. But I can't see my habits changing or me becoming really fat.

Moonatics · 27/11/2022 21:05

Had a couple of years of not eating much at all, it was a control issue in me and trying to right my life then. Obviously unsuccessful. Other than that I have never dieted, I've only ever eaten 2 meals a day, I dont own scales so only weighed at drs once a year or so.
Except for the two years as an anorexic, I'm generally between 10 and 11 stone, I'm 5ft 6, I love food but if I eat too much crap, I crave the good stuff.
My two meals are a decent size, forget breakfast, cant bear to eat on a morning
Brunch and dinner is all I need. Rarely want snacks.

The only time I thought about food all the time was my two years of not eating, I was obsessed with what I was eating next.

JennyForeigner · 27/11/2022 21:03

Yeah, I think so. It all came together for me when I figured out that fighting my body just makes things worse. I'm vegetarian, enjoy food that is naturally pretty healthy and drink wine - provided I don't keep all the snacks around I mostly seem to cycle back to the same size in the summer and then put on a bit over Christmas.

I'm a bit heavier than I like to be atm but had twins not too long ago. When I get back to cooking well again it will either go or it won't, and I'll figure out how to feel good at my new regular size.

Laurdo · 27/11/2022 20:55

My relationship with food is definitely better than it used to be. I had disordered eating as a teen. Used to starve myself, would only eat a tin of beans each day, had certain foods I would fear. I would weight myself daily and never felt skinny enough even at a size 8. I've fluctuated between a UK 6 and 12.

I've done slimming world, atkins diet, slim fast, chemical diet, calorie counted, diet pills.

I'm 35 now. I don't diet or track calories, however after years of doing so I do have a fairly good idea of calorie content of food. I'm a sensible, healthy eater and I do stop when I'm full, eat when I'm hungry. I rarely weigh myself now.

I'm currently a size 6-8 and the happiest I've been with my body. This is mostly down to weight resistance training. My PT asked what my goals were and I said I didn't want to lose any weight. That was a big thing for me. I allow myself to enjoy food now without feeling guilty.

MissTiggywinkles · 27/11/2022 20:55

I have a healthy relationship with food I think, I love food! I’m probably half a stone heavier than I’d like but I don’t let it bother me. I’d much rather be slightly overweight and enjoy food than stress about half a stone. My BMI is about 25 I think so just over the healthy range. I’m 5’7 and 11 stone.
I’ve always been really active though. I cycle everywhere and am training for a marathon so the half a stone should come off soon.
I always believe you have to be either very active/fit and eat what you want, or constantly on a diet if you don’t like exercise. It’s one or the other IMO.

Buzzinwithbez · 27/11/2022 20:55

Yes I do.
I do loose intermittent fasting in that I only eat once I'm properly hungry the next day. I do this for health reasons.
I used to be able to eat absolutely anything and never gain weight but since being peri menopausal that's not the case.
I tend to eat lots of fat and protein and go easy on the carbs, but I'm not dogmatic. I had Indian takeaway last night with all the naan bread etc and tomorrow I'll be having baked camembert for lunch with a friend.
I'm 60kg and 5ft 4 - a comfy size 10

Whiskyvodka · 27/11/2022 20:54

I ate normally as a teen.
I'm in my 60's now and since I was in my early 20's I have suffered frequent stomach cramps over the years, not period related.
I have stress related heartburn and eat less when upset.
Subsequently i am a grazer and at meal times eat very small portions.
I'm 5'4" and weigh 7st 12lbs which is low for me.
I was 8st 9lbs last year.
I wear size 10 clothes.

Swissnotswiss · 27/11/2022 20:54

I don't know if this is relevant (and I know some people will heartily disagree!) but I do eat all my meals at a table and never watch tv while eating unless I am on my own. We spend a lot of time as a family around the table. I think it helps foster a good relationship with food.

Swissnotswiss · 27/11/2022 20:48

Yes, I think so. Outside of pregnancy, I've always been fairly slim although I've noticed that approaching menopause that might not continue. I don't diet. Ever. It scares me to try as everyone I know who diets ends up yoyoing. I love food but I never crave it - that is I never crave a lot of it. I can never manage a starter, main and pudding, for example. My mum's the same.

mrsmalcolmreynolds · 27/11/2022 20:47

Reasonably so I think. I've never cut anything out completely and don't count/track although I do pay more attention in a fairly general way to what calories I'm taking in now.

I was a 12 for a long time and then after having DC2 my weight crept up until I was a 14 and definitely overweight although never hugely so (maxed out at 85kg and I'm 5'8"). Not due to massive overeating or anything, just a bit too much on a regular basis.

At 85kg I decided that was enough, and set out to lose weight gradually. Just ate less at each meal, more veggie options very little snacking. Lost 13kg in six months and it has now stayed off (actually a bit more has gone but more gradually) for nearly a year.

5128gap · 27/11/2022 20:46

I have a normal relationship with food AND follow a restrictive diet (vegan whole foods) keeping to around 1600 calories a day. The two for me are not mutually exclusive.
I now think it's 'normal' to eat foods that are good for me, in the quantities I need at my age and size. What wasnt 'normal' was eating to excess, eating foods with little benefit and treating food as a leisure activity, a comfort or a treat, as I did for years. It made me unhappy, harmed my health and made me feel I lacked control.
I'm 5 ' 4" and 8 stone 10.

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 20:45

I don't ever really think about my relationship with food, it's just not really much of a thing for me. I'm certainly not an emotional eater. I'm a slim size 6/ 8 and my weight only fluctuates according to my menstrual cycle, but not by much.

To answer your question about feeling full, I really like the sensation of feeling full however I have a complete inability to eat after that point or I'd feel sick, I understand some people can eat beyond that point but that just seems totally alien to me - my friend is like that and I'm quite envious of how she can just get stuck in!

ThursdayLastWeek · 27/11/2022 20:45

I think I have a pretty healthy relationship with food - I do have a tendency so sometimes eat my emotions though. But part of ‘healthy’ is recognising that I think.

My weight doesn’t fluctuate much.
I put on Lockdown weight because I wasn’t able to move as much as I like and because nice food was often the highlight of my week!

I calorie counted for a while earlier this year to help get rid of it - but generally I’m able to be more active again.

I would recommend anyone on instagram to look for the intuitive eating hashtag.
There are a lot of sensible people on there.

Tisfortired · 27/11/2022 20:44

I think I do in the sense I don’t think about the weight gain aspect of food before I eat it. I am 5’6 and have hovered around a size 12 since my teens, sometimes 10-12 sometimes 12-14 but never really bothered either way.

I eat what I want, but sometimes if I feel like I have been eating rubbish for a couple of days I will crave healthy fresh food and I think my diet naturally balances out in this way.

flowertoday · 27/11/2022 20:42

I had an eating disorder as a teenager. My relationship with food is always in recovery.
However I eat what I want and don't count calories or weigh myself ( last weighed myself about ten years ago. When stressed I lose my appetite and have a tendency to lose rather than gain weight. I dislike large meals / plates of food and am more of a three smaller meals and three or four snacks a day type person.
Because I am aware of my history with food I can become anxious about whether I am normal / have normal eating habits. Then I can talk to the other women I know who are always on a diet, or to one friend who would panic if they put the wrong kind of milk in her latte...
And I try not to worry. Just like other kinds of normal , it may be hard to nail down what is normal re food for people .

Dacadactyl · 27/11/2022 20:41

I eat normally. I can pretty much eat what i want, when I want but I do exercise quite a bit too. However, for at least 4 days out of 7 i only want 3 meals a day and these are all healthy and home cooked. I rarely snack in the week or drink booze.

I know that if i thought "ive eaten too much junk this week", i would 100% cut it out deliberately though. But i tend to self regulate well and not want junk food all that often.

Even if i dont exercise and eat junk, i have only ever got up to 11.5 stone (im 5'7). Im currently 10 st which is 4lbs heavier than id like.

Today i have eaten

A fried egg sandwich
A chicken caesar wrap
A single victoria sponge with lots of cream
Steak and kidney pudding with chips and curry sauce
An irish coffee (double shot of whiskey)

Tomorrow will look different tho!