Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a normal relationship with food?

160 replies

Miajk · 27/11/2022 20:20

And if so, what is your weight like, have you ever dieted? How often do you think about food, do you only eat when hungry and stop when full?

By normal I mean: no counting/tracking, no excluding food groups (unless for allergy or other health reasons), etc.

OP posts:
musttryharder84 · 28/11/2022 15:02

I have a normal relationship with food. I dieted for a little while before my wedding, not because I wanted to be slimmer but because I was between sizes for the wedding dress I wanted, and it was a design that wouldn't have been able to be taken in by enough had I sized up.
My weight puts me at the bottom end of the healthy BMI range.
I eat when I'm hungry and stop as soon as I get full, but I eat whatever I want without worrying.

SuseB · 28/11/2022 14:38

I have a good relationship with food - have been a petite size 8 all my life and never dieted - but have been aware of my metabolism changing as I've got older, and have been interested in food, nutrition and health for a long time so have changed my eating patterns slightly as a result. But I have always enjoyed home cooking, not really loved fast food, and had instinctive portion control - no one around me growing up ever had or gave out huge portions of anything, you had a serving, could maybe have seconds if available, and there might be a serving of pudding - but everything shared among the family as we all ate together most of the time, so no option or expectation for a eg a big slice of cake or ice cream or something. No family culture of snacking particularly - maybe a slice of cake at teatime if people were over, but then pudding after dinner would be fruit, so it balanced out. I am similar with my teens now and hope they will grow up with healthy relationships with food too. My oldest DD is 16 and seems to be doing fine, she recognises that a poor diet makes her feel less well and comes back from sleepovers etc saying she 'needs to eat something nutritious!' She's a healthy weight, eats sensibly most of the time and enjoys her food, as well as indulging in normal teenage treats.

As a teenager I ate a lot more than I do now - had a fast metabolism and would feel faint and sick if I didn't eat fairly regularly - so as a student would have a toastie or cereal or similar in the evening. Now in perimenopause I find I don't need the extra but I also don't fancy it either! If I feel hungry I will usually have something, but I don't mind feeling a bit hungry and often I actually like it because I am anticipating my next meal. In reality however hungry I am I can't manage massive portions. Also if we go out for dinner I am rarely hungry next morning, and if I go out for lunch or have a cafe slice of cake or a scone in the afternoon I might have nothing but soup or even nothing at all for dinner later. That's not me depriving myself, I just don't feel hungry or that I need it. Even things I occasionally crave I often only need a taste of to feel satisfied.

I actively seek out nutritionally dense food and avoid processed foods for the health benefits (eg microbiome) and enjoy eating it - I love full-fat cheese, double cream, butter, eggs, red meat, all vegetables - in fact I think I like pretty much everything with the exception of liver.

Lcb123 · 28/11/2022 14:30

Yes I think I have a healthy relationship with food. Never dieted or calorie counted, and never owned scales. I judge by my clothes and how I feel, and will then make small adjustments such as reducing carbs or less alcohol.
I tend to avoid having 'unhealthy' food in the house which helps, and plan out my meals each day so I don't make hungry decisions.

PeloFondo · 28/11/2022 14:24

When I read about people eating 3 meals a day and snacks I want to cry!
I have one or two meals, no snacks and fast from 6pm - lunchtime the next day and exercise 5 days a week
That's to lose 1lb a week, if that. Most weeks I maintain or lose 0.5lbs

SafeMove · 28/11/2022 14:21

I am a recovered anorexic and bulimic. I have the most normal relationship with food I have ever had in that I know longer view food as entertainment or punishment anymore but I do still consciously think about what I am consuming - I don't snack and I don't eat sugar.

I do not have a normal relationship with my body though. I hate it. I have hated it at 6 stone, I have hated it at 11 stone. I think cracking that nut is harder than cracking the food issue. Food isn't the actual problem, it's the way see their bodies in relation to food that is the problem.

theworldhasgoneinsane · 28/11/2022 14:19

Noideaatall · 27/11/2022 22:07

I find this thread a bit strange, because so many people who say, oh yes, I'm totally normal about food, then go on to list what they've eaten today, their heaviest and lightest weight, what they like to eat as a treat and so on. To me that's still an unhealthy interest. I don't think about it at all. I make food when I need to and then I eat it. If I want to eat something I eat it. That's it. No idea how much I weigh, don't have any scales in the house. I am totally baffled by the obsession some people have with everything that they put in their mouth. That's what I think of as normal - food is just not particularly interesting?

I think you're right, obsessing about calories etc isn't healthy. But it isn't always about the food itself, the issue can be so much more than about the food.

I think it's one of those things that can be difficult to understand

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 28/11/2022 14:10

Noideaatall · 27/11/2022 22:07

I find this thread a bit strange, because so many people who say, oh yes, I'm totally normal about food, then go on to list what they've eaten today, their heaviest and lightest weight, what they like to eat as a treat and so on. To me that's still an unhealthy interest. I don't think about it at all. I make food when I need to and then I eat it. If I want to eat something I eat it. That's it. No idea how much I weigh, don't have any scales in the house. I am totally baffled by the obsession some people have with everything that they put in their mouth. That's what I think of as normal - food is just not particularly interesting?

I'm so jealous. I wish I was like that. For me food has never been about nutrition or even pleasure. I don't even know what it's like to feel hunger and I don't eat because of appetite or because it tastes good. I eat because I want to stuff myself.

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 28/11/2022 14:07

wonderstuff · 27/11/2022 20:32

I have never dieted but I have adhd and often struggle with making decisions about food resulting in missing meals sometimes. Or sometimes not eating much because I get bored or distracted.

I do only eat when hungry and stop when full, I hate that feeling when you’ve eaten too much and try to avoid it.

We mostly cook from scratch, will go through phases of a weekly take-away but never more often and not all the time.

I eat small breakfast, cereal/toast/pancake, fairly small lunch, sandwich or school canteen food and standard dinner. Rarely snack. Did put on weight breastfeeding because I was eating a lot of chocolate and cake. I’m 5’3” and about 8st. Was below 7.5st before I had kids.

I have ADHD too and a very disordered relationship with food. When I was younger I went through phases of bulimia and restricting but now mostly I just binge eat. Crazy amounts.

The only time when I had a reasonably healthy relationship with food was for a few years as a teenager after I'd moved country (before the eating disorder raised its ugly head again in the form of bulimia) and later when I was on stimulants after being diagnosed with ADHD.

theworldhasgoneinsane · 28/11/2022 14:04

I am secretly aware that I have disordered eating and have struggled probably for about 10 years on and off. I think it's all about control and I see myself as emotionally strong when I eat very little. A part of me wants to sort it and the other part of me doesn't want to as I'm scared I'll gain weight (which I probably need to). It doesn't interfere too much with my life, it's like a thing I do which is just mine.

I know this is odd but it's just how I think. I do sometimes wonder if anyone else does this!

beastlyslumber · 28/11/2022 08:57

Great question. Not normal at all here. But I'm interested in the answers.

YesILikeItToo · 28/11/2022 08:13

I would say so. The only thing I consider when I’m planning what to eat is variety. I’m pretty interested in food.
I don’t weigh myself. I did go on a diet in my mid-thirties when I was told my blood pressure was too high. I counted calories and lost over 2.5 stone - target weight was 10 stone, but it took a while to stop losing weight after that. I imagine I weigh somewhere in between now.
I think about food a lot, and plan and eat three meals a day. If I come up with a good idea for dinner, it makes my day. I think I stop eating when I’ve eaten my portion, rather than when I’m full. I don’t often feel ‘stuffed’ though.

Everydaywheniwakeup · 28/11/2022 08:03

Sadly no. I'm overweight and have struggled with my weight for ever, although much more so since clothes sizes changed - I used to be mindful of staying in a size 14 but then sizes changed so significantly and to stay in my old 14s was a 2 stone difference to the new 14s. So I went up rather than staying down. I've now got lots of foods I can tolerate so that doesn't help either.

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/11/2022 08:03

I think I have a normal relationship with food - eg. I don't over eat or binge. I have a modest appetite as far as I can see comparing myself to others - I would never eat 3 courses in a restaurant. And I cannot stand the feeling of being too full, it makes me anxious as I'm an emetophobe. I eat two meals a day - lunch and dinner - and the occasional snack. No snacking after dinner, ever. I don't have a sweet tooth so very rarely eat a pudding (maybe some ice cream in the summer) and never cake or biscuits.

I'm about 30lb overweight which makes me obese as am quite short.

Chazx · 28/11/2022 07:48

Never had a normal relationship. Obsessed with food my whole life. Been very underweight at 7 stone 11 and just into overweight BMI at 12 stone. Now a healthy bmi at 10st, wear UK 12-14 and I'm 5 ft 9.

I eat constantly even though not hungry and can continue even if I'm stuffed. Constantly over eat and get distressed about amount of food I eat.
Keeping my weight at 10 stone is a battle but if when I gain weight it goes on mid section first and 10 st is the max weight I can get away with.

Would love to feel normal around food instead of being addicted to food and being able to have food on cupboard with out wanting to gorge.

It could be anything: if no instant junk food like crisps or kids biscuit bars, I will cook pasta and grate cheese. I will eat half a loaf with marmalade, eat a half box of cereal, eat a whole packet of biscuits in one go.

Really unhealthy eating habits and I just can't break them.

walkinwardrobe · 28/11/2022 07:35

This is me. Never dieted ever and I'm in my 40s now. Never counted a single calorie, never purposely chosen a low fat option. Never ever deprived myself of anything I wanted to eat.
Put on 15kg in both pregnancies, and lost it all again, returning both times to previous weight without looking at scales. Also don't own scales so only knew due to being weighed at the doctors for something.
Basically weight is never in my conscious thought, I didn't really realise others thought about it so much until I was an adult.
I don't notice other people's gaining or losing weight unless it's something major, ie obese or seriously underweight, I'd notice then.
The only thing I notice about myself is that I very much dislike feeling too full. It's only happened occasionally, probably when younger and out for a meal ( cultural differences possibly) and I've felt obliged to eat what I didn't want.

RoachTheHorse · 28/11/2022 07:02

Yep. I have never dieted, calorie counted etc.

I'm 5' 6" and just under 9 stone. If clothes get a bit tight I eat a bit less. If not I eat what I want. I'm eating less of my fave things for health reasons and moving more.

I used to be lighter but I had kids so sit a my that weight now.

I don't eat huge portions, often in a day will only have 2 meals. I think compared to friends though I'm not a huge amount different. A lot must be genetics as my dads side of the family are mostly the same.

EverybodyDance · 28/11/2022 07:02

I have a normal relationship with food I think. I like it and I enjoy it. Both eating it and cooking it but it's just 'there'.

My mother was probably the opposite of @CrackingcheeseWallace mother. She had a low focus on food. She just provided meals which we ate at the table,we sometimes had puddings and we somehow didn't.

If we had a biscuit it would be one biscuit and I remember when I was about ten one of my sister's friends being over after school and going to the biscuit tin and opening it up taking a handful of biscuits. I didn't know that was a thing that people did.

I remember not asking for food and my children were the same. But at the same time I suppose we always knew we would be fed.

I always knew that it was ok to be hungry and when my own children would tell me they were hungry I didn't feel,the need to satisfy that immediately. I think I always just took it as information rather than asking for food and I'd just say something like 'good, we are having pasta for dinner'.

Hippywannabe · 28/11/2022 06:46

Terrible relationship and always trying to do better!

CrackingcheeseWallace · 28/11/2022 06:40

I am totally baffled by the obsession some people have with everything that they put in their mouth. That's what I think of as normal - food is just not particularly interesting?

I suffer with this issue...it totally 'baffles' (🙄) me as to why I'm obsessed with food too. Everyone is different with different upbringing/personalities. There will be reasons why people find food 'interesting' given that without it, we'd die.

@Soproudoflionesses I'm the same. My DM showed love via food/snacks throughout my childhood...looking back it was an awful guilt ridden, emotional blackmail roller coaster ride but it wasn't done maliciously. Cleaning my plate with her huge portions was a daily battle plus the eating by the clock. I can relate to that. When a habit is introduced at such an early age, it does feel an impossible feat to change it. 😔

DelilahBucket · 27/11/2022 23:12

Probably not, but I'm aware of it. Growing up I ate absolute rubbish, donuts for breakfast, largely processed food diet as my mum was too poorly to cook. I have lost significant amounts of weight (3-4 stone) twice, once after pregnancy and once after an accident left me barely able to walk for 14 months (lots of takeaways as I couldn't cook). I'm not as slim now as I was pre-pregnancy, but I'm slimmer than in my late teens.
I do weigh myself often and try to keep things in check with exercise. I'm also mindful of type 2 diabetes which my mum has and will not get under control, and it was the cause of death for her mother and aunt.
I weigh 69kg and I'm 5ft4, so about 3 kg overweight. I carry most of my weight on my boobs and thighs and have a slim waist, so I'm not overly concerned, but I do keep an eye on it.

Vargas · 27/11/2022 23:00

Yes, normal relationship with food. I eat 2 meals a day, I'm not hungry until noon. I'm a normal weight, not skinny. My 2 meals are quite substantial but I stop when I've had enough as I hate feeling full. I would say half my friends have issues with food, either starving themselves or bingeing, must be very difficult so I feel lucky. It helps that DH is like me. Neither of us is fussy so that helps too.

Hippylady · 27/11/2022 22:58

Yes but trying to change after being diagnosed with high blood pressure, my diet was awful for ages. I hate fruit but have always eaten loads of veg and salad etc, & cooked from scratch, but then snacked horrendously on top of that. Crisps, cheese, chocolate, wine… I’m 5 foot 7 and currently about 12 stone 9, down from 13 at the start of the month. I can’t diet because I just don’t stick to them, so I’ve just cut out the crap and watched portion size and tried to walk more. Seems to be working! Oh and I bought a nutribullet and now breakfast is a huge smoothie, which I’m actually enjoying now for a lifelong fruit dodger. I’m 53 and my weight is all round my middle. I know I look horrendous but I just stopped caring.

Hawkins001 · 27/11/2022 22:54

I'm trying to eat more healthy e.g. Veg, salads ect, usually my meals are yellow labels mostly, as I get to sample £££ items on a basic budget. Although it does make it a mix as to what I get, some times I buy full priced items. I'm around 17-18 stone, I'm fairly active.

I do get sugar cravens, e.g. For cakes , ect I've stopped buying biscuits as I'm terrible with them, cakes I rarely buy unless they are yellow labels due to prices and too much sugar being bad.

I take multi vitamins daily and overall I try to balance my weight via the excerising I do.

Soproudoflionesses · 27/11/2022 22:53

I struggle knowing when to stop. Think it stems from having to clear my plate as a child. I would never leave food on a plate even if l am stuffed. And sometimes l eat if not hungry just because it's lunchtime or breakfast time etc.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 27/11/2022 22:35

God, that’s a sobering question.

I grew up with an overactive thyroid so I had a tiny appetite but pushed myself to eat past being full sometimes to maintain.

Fast forward a decade or so, my lovely thyroid is now underactive. Unless I eat under 1100 kcal a day I struggle to shift a thimble.

I’ve replaced having food - which was a perfectly acceptable comforter when my thyroid was on my side - and I suppose I’ve shifted to wine.

Coupled with wine is cheese. (Crap - almost like where my username came from!?)

So, in summary, although it’s certainly not crack - I’m not entirely certain it’s all that healthy? I do know I need to push my GP for treatment for my twatting thyroid, though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread