Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a normal relationship with food?

160 replies

Miajk · 27/11/2022 20:20

And if so, what is your weight like, have you ever dieted? How often do you think about food, do you only eat when hungry and stop when full?

By normal I mean: no counting/tracking, no excluding food groups (unless for allergy or other health reasons), etc.

OP posts:
Devoutspoken · 28/11/2022 19:30

We used to eat everything on our plate and always wanted seconds, but as I got older my appetite has decreased, and now often don't finish

KatyJ89 · 28/11/2022 19:26

I'd be really interested to know those of you that have a healthy relationship with food and haven't had huge weight fluctuations your whole life- how was food tackled by your parents? I was always brought up to finish a plate or no dessert etc., which is very different to advice given to us parents now.

ILOVECHEESE79 · 28/11/2022 19:25

Nope.
I was a fat teenager due to binge eating disorder), then became Anorexic in the 6th form.
Anorexia then became Bulimia, which I struggled with 'til I found out I was pregnant when I was 37/38.
Binge eating disorder reared its ugly head again and I ate myself 3 stones heavier.
Now, fat again.

PoppySeedBagelRedux · 28/11/2022 19:21

But I would mention that my slightly-older sister is obese, and ill as a result. We were both slim children- me very skinny because of the fussiness, but both slim. But I was the favourite and mum made her life miserable so she left home as soon as she could and then began to eat. Mums comments made her eat all the more. She loves cooking too and is an excellent cook, but I wish she was as slim and energetic as me, like she was when we were young.

2Rebecca · 28/11/2022 19:20

68kg 171cm late 50s

2Rebecca · 28/11/2022 19:18

Yes normal. Eat when hungry stop when full minimal binging and cravings. I don't count calories but know which foods to eat less of if I want to lose weight. I'm quite busy with a job and lots of hobbies so although I love food and beer wine and cocktails I only think about them when it's time to eat/ drink/ cook

PoppySeedBagelRedux · 28/11/2022 19:15

I think I do. I know I'm lucky compared with some friends.

I am fussy, in the sense that I like only good food: I would refuse to eat bad school food, so often didn't get a play time when I was little. But since I have cooked what I want, I've eaten 3 meals a day, and am now 59 kg, at 5'4", age 62. I still like good food, no matter what it is, and enjoy cooking. I like salads and fruit, and don't like more than a handful of chips at a time, say. I also happily leave food if I'm full, or it's just not that nice.

We only go out for meals occasionally but when we do we go to really good restaurants- not fancy, just good.

I like being slim, partly because I have nice clothes that I want to wear, so do now weigh myself every day. This has made me realise that it's alcohol that puts weight on me. So I cut down.

SomeChickensAreJustTooBig · 28/11/2022 19:09

I have a normal relationship with food. I don’t really snack, I eat pretty much what I want at meals and tend to choose fairly good quality stuff (I don’t eat MacDonalds), I don’t have a sweet tooth and avoid puddings. I drink alcohol moderately and run a couple of times a week, and still wear a size 10 as I did when I was 14. I have had three kids and am 52. My body has obviously aged so I’m not wearing mini skirts etc but I feel fit and have energy. So yes, food presents no problem for me. I have to say though, I’m not that bothered about it; I like nice food but it’s not the be all and end all.

Boating123 · 28/11/2022 19:00

I'm 5f 7 I think. Weigh just under 10 stone. I have a healthy relationship with food. I have always had breakfast, something mid-morning, lunch, afternoon tea and dinner. I often have a hot chocolate before bed and a chocolate with it. I have no desire to eat more, equally I really struggle if I don't get my mid-morning snack e.t.c

I was brought up not to think about 'good' and 'bad food. I believe in the - everything in moderation motto. As soon as you ban something it becomes desirable.
I am so cross my daughter's school has banned chocolate and crisps. It's making an issue out of nothing. It won't solve the obesity problem.

Mentalpiece · 28/11/2022 18:47

I have a normal relationship with food.
I eat what I like when I like and I only eat when I'm hungry.
Some days I eat more than other days.
I've never dieted, tracked ( whatever that is ) counted calories or placed any restrictions.
The only food I dislike is turnip, swede and foods that are too spicy, such as red hot curry, though medium hot is fine.
I'm an average weight.

Walkacrossthesand · 28/11/2022 18:45

I eat to appetite, I have no 'emotional' relationship with food, but I gain 7lb every 6 months if I eat what I like. I managed to stabilise by eating a bit less than I wanted to, but was then diagnosed with type 2 diabetes (asymptomatic).
That gave me the kick up the backside I needed; I went low carb, don't really miss a lot of it (bread, rice, pasta), didn't like cake much anyway, and now I'm in remission.
So, I do 'track' but that's just to keep an eye on carb intake for medical reasons. I regard my relationship with food as pretty normal!

FestiveCrunch · 28/11/2022 18:18

Mothers have a lot to answer for!

Mine was always dieting and jumped on the scales several times a day, while over feeding us kids.

I am now naturally greedy and don't have a good relationship with food.

For all of my life I've been overweight (between one and three stone). I've only managed to change this in the last few years by fasting every week and doing lots of exercise (around 10 hours a week).

I eat twice a day, but big meals and then have fruit for pudding. At the weekends I enjoy wine, chocolate and take always.

I'm now early sixties and my BMI is 24.

Odoreida · 28/11/2022 17:59

I love food, love cooking and creating amazing healthy things but my relationship with it is disordered. I binge eat (not junk food but it's still bingeing), take opportunities to eat alone rather than with others, and also binge exercise to deal with it. I just about maintain a healthy weight (highest healthy BMI for my height). It's just about under control but honestly I would love to have therapy and deal with it somehow.

fastcarsnarrowstreets · 28/11/2022 16:54

I have a good, but complicated, relationship I think.

Generally: I love food, just for what it is - how things taste, how they make you feel; I really take proper pleasure in it. I eat pretty well - 2 meals per day plus sometimes snacks plus lots of water/etc. Over time I've learned how food makes me feel, physiologically - so, no carbs meals at lunchtime because I'll fall asleep an hour later; too many sweets make me feel nausous. I tend towards proteins and veggies and some fats, though definitely more in love with pasta and potatoes during winter.

I do have an incredibly sweet tooth which I try to temper - if I have sweets or cake in the house I will hoover them down; it's definitely close to sugar addiction so I keep an eye on it. I buy nice and expensive cheeses, pork pies, etc to wean me off the sugar habit, so I get a treat if I want it but in a much smaller portion (that is, I'd never eat as much cheese as I would cake).

That said: my relationship with food in early life was a fcking mess. My mother is one of those who under-eats, serves up miniscule portions of food, will eke out the last tiniest amounts of food/eat food that is completely out of date, weight-shames me (together with its evil sibling - 'are you exercising at the moment?'), thinks that processed and fast food are the devil. Deeply embarrassing big family Christmases when mum - having shooed everyone out of the kitchen - would serve up about half the amount of food needed for a regular meal, let alone for a big festive bash.

So when I left home, I ate everything and it took me years to undo that. When I'm sad, my first instinct is to binge the processed food - tins of ravioli, packets of Mr Kiplings - that would never be allowed in my parents' house; though I keep those urges in check these days. When I stay with my parents now I always take an extra bag of food, hidden in our bedroom, to last the stay. Even though I mostly don't over-eat, I do over-buy - lots of panic about possibly running out of food at home; and when I host for people, I always over-cater.

Someone asked earlier 'why get so hung up on food?', and I think it's because food has so much meaning and emotion associated with it. I am so wary of the whole 'we only have home-made food in our house!' thing as a proxy for eating well and healthily because you know what? My mum also only served up home-made food, cooked from scratch, and it barely touched the sides.

Lennon80 · 28/11/2022 16:33

Yes totally healthy - eat what I want when I want. Don’t over eat or under eat. Never been overweight though … naturally slim and would need to massively over eat to be otherwise. I’m so grateful as I can see my kids are the same with food. I also try to encourage healthy eating but I do let them have treats and cake as I love cake myself!

fussychica · 28/11/2022 16:30

Yes I would say so. I've only ever done one extreme diet many moons ago but more recently have tried 5:2 which worked quite well. I've never excluded any food group.
I'm in my 60s now and definitely heavier than I used to be pre menopause despite exercising regularly and not over eating. I definitely can't eat as much as I like or as much as I used to without putting on weight. I'm a 12-14 and ok with that though I could do with losing about half a stone but I find that very difficult to do these days.

xogossipgirlxo · 28/11/2022 16:18

Fuck no. When I moved out of my parents house over a decade ago, my way of eating evolved to something completely different. My body changed. I look good now. Every time I go to see my mum and dad, I panic (!), because I know what sort of food they're going to serve- the one that makes me fat, bloated and gives me heartburn. TBH, I blame my mother, because my sister has fucked up relationship with food too. She feels guilty every time she eats something unhealthy, because my mum (despite serving all the sugar and trans fats), was always the first one to ask "Are you sure you want to eat this biscuit?" 😡

BrilliantGreenFlamingo · 28/11/2022 16:16

I do. Never dieted and always been a healthy weight. I don’t own scales or even think about my weight or calories. I love food but only think about it while I’m eating. Don’t really want snacks. I eat a few packets of crisps a week but no other snacks.

it must be so hard for people to have food take up a lot of their mental energy.

The advert above this post is for Pringles

cushioncovers · 28/11/2022 16:16

No sadly I'm obsessed with food. It's the first thing I think of when I wake up and one of the last things I think about at night. I'm obese and love food. I'm an ex smoker and am on several medications of which one of the side effects is an increase in appetite.

Notmysolution · 28/11/2022 16:12

Oh and I have a healthy bmi too.

Notmysolution · 28/11/2022 16:12

Yes I do. Eat when full, stop when sated. Don’t have restrictions or attribute morality to food ( no ‘good’ or ‘bad foods’.)

I had to train myself to do this though when overcoming disorder eating.

i have succeeded though and for over 20 years now I have had a normal, relaxed attitude to food.

CaptaNoctem · 28/11/2022 16:04

As far as I know yes.

I've never consciously dieted and eat what I like when I like and my dress size has remained a consistent 10/12 all my adult life.

I've never had a big appetite and I find full plates of food quite off putting which means I am full pretty quickly. I took quite a lot of flak on here recently when I said that I would only want to eat 2 fish fingers as part of a meal but that really is enough for me along with the infamous salad and vegetables. I may have some crisps later though with a glass of wine.

Like a PP if I have cake or something in the afternoon or have a proper meal for lunch I will often not be hungry in the evening and settle for a slice of toast or that other hated Mumsnet quantity - a half tin of soup!

Alconleigh · 28/11/2022 15:16

I think I have a fairly healthy relationship with food. Grew up with a mother who cooked from scratch and we always ate round a table. I have a weakness for crisps and chips and could eat them everyday but I don't because they're not good for me. Like good food but not a foodie. As I've got older (now mid forties) am much more interested in giving my body what it needs. I'm often hungry as I have a quick metabolism but my weight has stayed within about half a stone ever since I was a teenager; I am 5 foot 2 and generally weigh from 7 and 3/4 stones to 8 stone at my heaviest. I have never dieted. I am an ectomorphic body shape, so all skinny limbs. No arse, not much boobs either. If I do put weight on, it's straight to stomach and face. Like a bloke 😒.

fancyacuppatea · 28/11/2022 15:10

Oh, and now...food is something I just end up having to have every couple of days to stop me falling over.

fancyacuppatea · 28/11/2022 15:07

No.
Fed on Chocolate (kit kat, penguins etc) or crisps (monster much, wotsits etc) for breakfast then a pasty or sausage rolls for lunch, stodgy or greasy tea as a child. Fish n Chips twice a week.
Was a size 14 at 14...never been that thin (!) since.
My only way of losing weight it to not eat at all.