Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a normal relationship with food?

160 replies

Miajk · 27/11/2022 20:20

And if so, what is your weight like, have you ever dieted? How often do you think about food, do you only eat when hungry and stop when full?

By normal I mean: no counting/tracking, no excluding food groups (unless for allergy or other health reasons), etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AttilaTheUOkHun · 02/12/2022 02:04

amicissimma · 01/12/2022 11:49

I'd say I have a 'normal' relationship with food and always have.

I weigh 9 stone and have done since the 1980s with no conscious control of intake. Since the menopause I find I want less to eat. I chuckle at the posters who talk about 'competitive undereating' when they describe quantities similar to, or greater than, I would eat, want to eat and maintain my weight on.

I don't think about food much and am surprised when people try to engage me in discussions about it, or describe some dish or recipe. I'm just not interested. Obviously I have to choose in the supermarket, but tend to just pick a few things I fancy, put them in the fridge and eat them in date order. I eat when I'm hungry, which roughly co-incides with breakfast, lunch and dinner. If I'm not hungry I don't mind missing a meal. OTOH, I eat what I feel like and don't deny myself anything. My body tends to tell me what it needs - I sometimes get a huge desire for red meat, and have been rejected for blood donation due to anaemia around then.

I do like fruit and veg and easily have 10 portions a day. At least half of my lunch and dinner will be veg, with fruit for 'pudding'. I prefer a lot of vegetables raw to cooked.

I absolutely hate feeling 'stuffed' and find a plateful that is too much quite off-putting. I know I can leave part of it, but I'd rather not be faced with it in the first place.

Sometimes it seems to me that I enjoy food more than some of my larger friends. I've particularly noticed if we're sharing a box of fancy chocolates - I am still licking the remains of my first from my back teeth and enjoying the sensation and taste, while they are on their second or third. I don't want the whole experience of my first disturbed! This is also true of any tasty dishes. The reverse is true - I can open a packet of, say, crisps, have a few and then get fed up with the synthetic flavour and put a clip on to finish them another time.

Growing up we were very hard up and meals tended to be small and rather strange. Potatoes, cheap vegetables and offal featured. We certainly had to clear our plates; although my parents never said, I was aware that they found it hard to put food on the table and heartbreaking if it was rejected. I was often hungry but I survived and don't fear hunger the way I've noticed some people do. My grandmother grew a lot of fruit and vegetables, so when we stayed with her I enjoyed them freshly picked in unlimited quantities. We only had treats occasionally, so they really were treats. If they had the money we would have ice cream for pudding on a Saturday and two squares of chocolate on a Sunday evening. I don't enjoy a big slab of chocolate nowadays like I used to enjoy the Sunday night treat.

Peak Mumsnet

1980sfookup · 01/12/2022 20:56

amicissimma · 01/12/2022 11:49

I'd say I have a 'normal' relationship with food and always have.

I weigh 9 stone and have done since the 1980s with no conscious control of intake. Since the menopause I find I want less to eat. I chuckle at the posters who talk about 'competitive undereating' when they describe quantities similar to, or greater than, I would eat, want to eat and maintain my weight on.

I don't think about food much and am surprised when people try to engage me in discussions about it, or describe some dish or recipe. I'm just not interested. Obviously I have to choose in the supermarket, but tend to just pick a few things I fancy, put them in the fridge and eat them in date order. I eat when I'm hungry, which roughly co-incides with breakfast, lunch and dinner. If I'm not hungry I don't mind missing a meal. OTOH, I eat what I feel like and don't deny myself anything. My body tends to tell me what it needs - I sometimes get a huge desire for red meat, and have been rejected for blood donation due to anaemia around then.

I do like fruit and veg and easily have 10 portions a day. At least half of my lunch and dinner will be veg, with fruit for 'pudding'. I prefer a lot of vegetables raw to cooked.

I absolutely hate feeling 'stuffed' and find a plateful that is too much quite off-putting. I know I can leave part of it, but I'd rather not be faced with it in the first place.

Sometimes it seems to me that I enjoy food more than some of my larger friends. I've particularly noticed if we're sharing a box of fancy chocolates - I am still licking the remains of my first from my back teeth and enjoying the sensation and taste, while they are on their second or third. I don't want the whole experience of my first disturbed! This is also true of any tasty dishes. The reverse is true - I can open a packet of, say, crisps, have a few and then get fed up with the synthetic flavour and put a clip on to finish them another time.

Growing up we were very hard up and meals tended to be small and rather strange. Potatoes, cheap vegetables and offal featured. We certainly had to clear our plates; although my parents never said, I was aware that they found it hard to put food on the table and heartbreaking if it was rejected. I was often hungry but I survived and don't fear hunger the way I've noticed some people do. My grandmother grew a lot of fruit and vegetables, so when we stayed with her I enjoyed them freshly picked in unlimited quantities. We only had treats occasionally, so they really were treats. If they had the money we would have ice cream for pudding on a Saturday and two squares of chocolate on a Sunday evening. I don't enjoy a big slab of chocolate nowadays like I used to enjoy the Sunday night treat.

Im not surprised you don't eat a lot - you're already bursting with snugness.

SomeChickensAreJustTooBig · 01/12/2022 19:52

StarDolphins · 01/12/2022 11:59

I have a normal relationship with food. Never diet, never eat too much (sometimes) & always pretty much same weight unless stressed then I lose a bit. I don’t think about calories/fat etc more just what I want but within my mind wanting to choose healthy(ish) things. I don’t weigh myself but nurse at my pill check saying always the same.

as a teenager, if I ever mentioned anything to do with body, i was swiftly told ‘it doesn’t matter what size,shape you are’ but dieting or food was never mentioned.

The same for me.

StarDolphins · 01/12/2022 11:59

I have a normal relationship with food. Never diet, never eat too much (sometimes) & always pretty much same weight unless stressed then I lose a bit. I don’t think about calories/fat etc more just what I want but within my mind wanting to choose healthy(ish) things. I don’t weigh myself but nurse at my pill check saying always the same.

as a teenager, if I ever mentioned anything to do with body, i was swiftly told ‘it doesn’t matter what size,shape you are’ but dieting or food was never mentioned.

OnlyFannys · 01/12/2022 11:54

LuciferRising · 30/11/2022 15:00

I think it's important to note that a normal relationship with food, for many people, does not mean they eat what they want. Many people still have to make conscious decisions about what they eat but it doesn't rule their life and is not a big deal. Same with exercise. It doesn't always come easy to get out there and do it, it is making the conscious decision to do it.

Totally agree with this, you need to be aware just not obsessive

OnlyFannys · 01/12/2022 11:53

Mine is now but I used to starve myself and yo yo diet. Over covid I really educated myself about food and calories, tdee etc and used a tracker to lose weight. Now I am a healhy weight and because I understand it all much better now I naturally eat within my calories without needing to track as I understand what I need in a day and roughly what that looks like on a plate. I deny myself nothing but my portion sizes are good now and i make healthy choices (like upping my veg and lowering the carb portion on my meals)

amicissimma · 01/12/2022 11:49

I'd say I have a 'normal' relationship with food and always have.

I weigh 9 stone and have done since the 1980s with no conscious control of intake. Since the menopause I find I want less to eat. I chuckle at the posters who talk about 'competitive undereating' when they describe quantities similar to, or greater than, I would eat, want to eat and maintain my weight on.

I don't think about food much and am surprised when people try to engage me in discussions about it, or describe some dish or recipe. I'm just not interested. Obviously I have to choose in the supermarket, but tend to just pick a few things I fancy, put them in the fridge and eat them in date order. I eat when I'm hungry, which roughly co-incides with breakfast, lunch and dinner. If I'm not hungry I don't mind missing a meal. OTOH, I eat what I feel like and don't deny myself anything. My body tends to tell me what it needs - I sometimes get a huge desire for red meat, and have been rejected for blood donation due to anaemia around then.

I do like fruit and veg and easily have 10 portions a day. At least half of my lunch and dinner will be veg, with fruit for 'pudding'. I prefer a lot of vegetables raw to cooked.

I absolutely hate feeling 'stuffed' and find a plateful that is too much quite off-putting. I know I can leave part of it, but I'd rather not be faced with it in the first place.

Sometimes it seems to me that I enjoy food more than some of my larger friends. I've particularly noticed if we're sharing a box of fancy chocolates - I am still licking the remains of my first from my back teeth and enjoying the sensation and taste, while they are on their second or third. I don't want the whole experience of my first disturbed! This is also true of any tasty dishes. The reverse is true - I can open a packet of, say, crisps, have a few and then get fed up with the synthetic flavour and put a clip on to finish them another time.

Growing up we were very hard up and meals tended to be small and rather strange. Potatoes, cheap vegetables and offal featured. We certainly had to clear our plates; although my parents never said, I was aware that they found it hard to put food on the table and heartbreaking if it was rejected. I was often hungry but I survived and don't fear hunger the way I've noticed some people do. My grandmother grew a lot of fruit and vegetables, so when we stayed with her I enjoyed them freshly picked in unlimited quantities. We only had treats occasionally, so they really were treats. If they had the money we would have ice cream for pudding on a Saturday and two squares of chocolate on a Sunday evening. I don't enjoy a big slab of chocolate nowadays like I used to enjoy the Sunday night treat.

CrunchyCarrot · 30/11/2022 22:55

I'd be really interested to know those of you that have a healthy relationship with food and haven't had huge weight fluctuations your whole life- how was food tackled by your parents? I was always brought up to finish a plate or no dessert etc., which is very different to advice given to us parents now

I was brought up by my mother and grandmother (no father on the scene) and my grandmother did all the cooking - she was a good cook, good basic wholesome food. I always loved veg but I was a fussy eater. My grandmother had had terrible food experiences as a young girl brought up in a convent school at the beginning of the 1900s, where she had to finish what was on her plate (and the food was dreadful) even if it was lumps of gristle. She used to tell me stories about it, trying to hide the gristle in her pocket and dumping it in the school playground later! As a result I never had to eat things I didn't like, she was a real softie, although sometimes Mum used to say 'you're ruining that child!' There was no requirement to eat everything in order to get dessert, either. Funnily enough I haven't eaten dessert for a very long time, and don't miss it, but I do have a sweet tooth.

LuciferRising · 30/11/2022 15:00

I think it's important to note that a normal relationship with food, for many people, does not mean they eat what they want. Many people still have to make conscious decisions about what they eat but it doesn't rule their life and is not a big deal. Same with exercise. It doesn't always come easy to get out there and do it, it is making the conscious decision to do it.

Baconand · 30/11/2022 13:23

I don’t remember anything much about childhood eating if I’m honest. I think we were encouraged to try things but never forced. I don’t think we had pudding regularly but don’t remember ever needing to finish plate first.
I think we had a fair amount of choice and what we ate regularly was what we liked. Non stressful!
My parents did choose relatively healthy things though for the 70’s eg we only had wholemeal bread and they rarely fried anything.
I didn’t have fried bacon until I was in my 20’s for example, they always grilled it and their habits stuck with me.
I think meals were a bit of a non event really, I try to downplay it with DD and try to avoid using it as a treat or demonising either.

Miajk · 30/11/2022 12:53

Wow so many responses on this thread thank you all so much for sharing!

Really sad to see so many of us don't have the best relationship with food, but also really interesting to hear from normal eaters.

I wonder how much of it is driven by childhood and how much dieting has influenced these issues...

OP posts:
Heatherbell1978 · 29/11/2022 20:40

Yes I do. I'm 5'5 and fluctuate between 9 and 9.5 stone. I'm a size 8-10. I don't do much exercise aside from walking (I do try to do 10k steps a day) and a weekly yoga class. I'm 44.
But...from the age of 17 to about 23 I had an eating disorder. I counted calories (limited myself to around 1200) and obsessively exercised. Somehow I managed to 'snap out of it' alone. That whole period ruined my university years and put me in a mindset of not wanting to think about food at all so I genuinely eat what I want when I want, let DH cook evening meals and take a bit of a passive approach to anything food related.
It does mean I often eat unhealthy options as I'll forget to eat breakfast then reach for something sugary etc but I prefer that than trying to be too structured with my eating incase I fall into obsessive patterns again

TurtleTriplets · 29/11/2022 20:27

I have a bad relationship with food, I think about it a lot and see it as a treat or something to restrict.

I have a terrible sweet tooth and can eat sharing packs of sweets to myself. Sweeties are my downfall but I don't have any fillings. Strange!!

I either track my calories in an app or just keep a rough note. I have tried many diet pills and LOVE the saxenda pen because that's the only time I don't think about food.

I am 8st 9 and feel fat all the time - even when I was 7st 13 I didn't feel slim.

I eat healthy meals mostly but damn those sweets!

blubberball · 29/11/2022 20:12

My relationship with food is pretty effed up. I definitely binge eat and have cravings. I am over weight. I am trying to count calories and cut back at the moment. I ate all my calories by about 2pm today, and now I'm fantasising about all the food until I can eat again tomorrow. It's pretty crap

Wisteria1979 · 29/11/2022 19:57

Very interesting thread. I’ve always had a reasonably healthy relationship with food and like some others upthread I like veg so that helps. I don’t ban anything but try to apply the plate model of half veg quarter protein quarter carb since an adult. Moderation in anything but I do hoard food. Not for eating but for keeping 😂 I experienced two different households growing up and they were complete opposites. One where you plate yourself but you eat what you take. No pudding midweek and rarely at weekends. One where it was plated up and you finish or sit until bedtime. Still think of that stewed spinach sometimes!!

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 29/11/2022 19:39

*I'd be really interested to know those of you that have a healthy relationship with food and haven't had huge weight fluctuations your whole life- how was food tackled by your parents? I was always brought up to finish a plate or no dessert etc., which is very different to advice given to us parents now
*
Actually I was brought up to finish plate of food but it wasn't a huge plate, and we always had a pudding such as homemade rice pudding or fruit with cream. It was very unprocessed food. I wasn't brought up with a big snacking culture, we were taught it's good to be hungry before dinner. If I was really really hungry between meals it would be a piece of fruit or a small bit of cheese.

This is in the 90s.

FearofQueefing · 29/11/2022 19:35

No. But it's improving. Had a bit of a wake up call recently when got chastised by the doctor for high cholesterol. Realised I needed to change my mentality towards food. Have cut out snacking, am sticking to 3 balanced meals a day. My only vice is a daily can of Diet Coke.

Not being a slave to the scales but, judging by my clothes, I've lost about half a dress size in the past fortnight. So all those additional snacking calories were clearly adding up.

Batsncats · 29/11/2022 18:47

Eh, I feel like its getting closer to normal now, but didn't used to be. I had a pretty bad struggle with anorexia in my early teen years, It wasn't easy but I managed to recover and eat healthily and even have quite a big appetite as an adult, eliminating animal products really helped with this personally but I respect it has the opposite effect for some people. Since I've been pregnant it's been difficult tho, I've totally lost my appetite and I feel like I'm just forcing myself to eat all the time and not enjoying it at all, I'm hoping this will ease off soon tho 😅

Newusername3kidss · 29/11/2022 18:31

Yes I do! Weight fluctuates between 9 and 9.5 stone. I’m a size 10 or 12 (obviously apart from when I’ve been pregnant 3 times). I would say 9.5 is my comfortable weight, can eat what I fancy and exercise lightly. 9 stone is when I’m watching what I eat more and train more. I’ve never “dieted”. I have had periods of eating less rubbish but never cut out food group etc.

I am very active on a daily basis which helps i think and my mum was slim and she ate like a horse! I love food but think I do self regulate without really thinking about it. If I had a massive takeaway one night the next night I would have something pretty healthy

OneTC · 29/11/2022 18:29

At school we had to eat everything or we weren't allowed to leave the table. I suppose you could have really dug your heels in and held out until after break finished but I don't remember anyone doing this. We had a good dinner lady though and the food was mostly fine

At home you had dessert whether you wanted it or not.

OlympicProcrastinator · 29/11/2022 18:24

I'd be really interested to know those of you that have a healthy relationship with food and haven't had huge weight fluctuations your whole life- how was food tackled by your parents? I was always brought up to finish a plate or no dessert etc., which is very different to advice given to us parents now

I grew up in late 70’s early 80’s and the way we ate at home and school was very different to the way children eat today. There were no ready made / processed foods, everything was cooked fresh at meal times. There weren’t really any snacks. Certainly not during the week and definitely no snack time mid morning at school. Maybe a packet of crisps watching Saturday morning telly.

Food just wasn’t as featured in our lives via the media / check outs at shops / diet & cookery programmes etc. There were no famous fad diets / insta body pics etc. Food just happened at meal times and you just got on with the rest of your life if that makes sense.

That was the main approach as I see it anyway.

Moonatics · 29/11/2022 17:51

KatyJ89 · 28/11/2022 19:26

I'd be really interested to know those of you that have a healthy relationship with food and haven't had huge weight fluctuations your whole life- how was food tackled by your parents? I was always brought up to finish a plate or no dessert etc., which is very different to advice given to us parents now.

I too had to clear my plate before getting a pud, sadly my mum was the worst cook in the world ever and I didn't care about pud.
So I rarely cleared my plate, and didn't get much of a sweet tooth.

You would think her cooking would give me some kind of eating disorder, but I had school dinners which were by comparison a la carte. And my gran who could cook, normal, simple but tasty food.

Gwenhwyfar · 29/11/2022 16:17

Who are you to decide what is normal?
I count and track what I eat sometimes, but I still have a normal relationship with food.

OneTC · 29/11/2022 15:42

I think I have a normal relationship with food but I do some counting and make some choices, albeit not many and not very restrictive ones.

I have a very narrow weight goal owing to the sport I do and as I've got older keeping inside that bracket requires a bit more thought.

I do lots of exercise and basically eat what I want when I want, and am often thinking about food. If for whatever reason I can't exercise (injury or too busy/other commitments) for any extended period of time I find that my appetite takes a dive.

I've never ever been a comfort eater. I tend towards having no appetite if I'm unhappy or stressed. I can't eat if I'm not enjoying it

RobertaFirmino · 29/11/2022 15:39

I have no idea if my relationship with food is good or bad. I pretty much eat what I want. Sometimes I eat a lot, other days, I don't have all that much. It all depends on how hungry I am. Sometimes I fancy chicken or fish and veg, at other times I'll want curry or pizza. I am capable of eating a large Dominos or a 100g bar of choc in one sitting if inclined. I don't stick to traditional meal times either, I just eat when I am hungry.

I don't think about food much and don't really find any 'comfort' in it apart from the obvious hunger relief. A 'treat' to me is a cup of coffee and a nice, quiet sit down.

Having said all this, I'm an ex-addict (not food) and have had addictive behaviours 'therapied' out of me. I'm also lanky. I'm fully aware things might be different if I was short/stout and/or hadn't had effective therapy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread