Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I talk to my SIL about giving up work?

37 replies

keepyertrapshut · 27/11/2022 18:58

I’m in two minds about how to deal with this situation, so thought I’d come to Mumsnet to see if people would want someone to say something to them in this scenario….

My SIL is unmarried, but with a relatively long term partner. They bought a house together last year (I think the deposit was borrowed mostly from his parents) and had a baby, who is now 18 months. SIL went back to work 3 days a week, and baby has been in childcare for those days since then. However she is ALWAYS ill, not unusual for new babies at nursery! My SIL is almost always the one who has to take days off work with my niece. Her boyfriend works from home in a busy job but not a crazy busy one, and he could definitely take on more of the load.

I held my tongue when SIL went back to work part time and didn’t ask about whether they were paying more into her pension to make up the shortfall etc. as I know it’s none of my business. However now it looks like SIL is going to give up work completely as childcare is too difficult. I’m SO concerned about her doing this when she’s not married to her boyfriend. It feels like she’s making all the sacrifices and there’s no security for her. I like her partner a lot and I trust him, but also I know how things can go wrong in relationships and I worry about what may happen in the future. I also know she does really want to get married and talks about it a lot, and yet he hasn’t proposed and says they’ll get round to it at some point. It all just feels like s massive red flag to me, and I don’t want SIL to end up in a shit situation.

Do I say something? We have a close relationship but it feels so personal to talk about finances in that way, and I also don’t want to sound like I’m accusing her partner of leaving her soon or anything like that. I guess I just want to make sure she’s really thought through all her options before she quits work.

Or should I just butt out and let her make decisions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AdelaideRo · 27/11/2022 21:36

I would definitely raise it (and have with colleagues I've known for a damn site less time than you have known her).

I usually raise it as an "FYI have you thought through the implications of giving up your job as it makes you quite vulnerable in the event of the relationship ending"

I've got a tonne of stories about women taking time out and then basically not being able to get back into workforce at any reasonable level, being screwed over about money etc and of friends who have had real options in the event of divorce because they have maintained their well paid careers.

Kathers92 · 27/11/2022 21:28

On its own I think the childcare thing could be a non-issue. I'm the one who would always take the time off as my husband earns about 5x what I do and is self employed and it is much harder for him to leave work. However I can see the point about financial risk from other points of view in a way it's easier for me to take the risk as I am married

mumyes · 27/11/2022 21:08

I would say something.

I have seen this happen to friends, and it is a terrible thing to see someone essentially out of options if their relationship goes wrong. Too often these days divorce screws over women who have up their careers to support their partner's career,

Maintaining your own earning power as a women & mum is vital.

Say something to her, please.

RFPO77 · 27/11/2022 21:03

Would it be better if your DH had a brotherly chat? It's a difficult one but like you I'd struggle not to say something x

PinkPrettyAndPointed · 27/11/2022 20:59

In a friendly FYI way I'd definitely raise it. Why wouldn't you?! Not every knows/thinks about these things and knowledge is power.

Just make sure it's not a lecture, but a bit of shared info.

MATHRD · 27/11/2022 20:53

HotChicolate · 27/11/2022 19:03

Why do you refer to him as her boyfriend and not her partner?

Because that's what he is?

OP, I would say something. Like PP's I have friend who have been screwed over after years of reciting the age-old "it's just a piece of paper"...

drpet49 · 27/11/2022 20:50

Baffled by the responses. i would say something OP. She may not realise how vulnerable she is making herself

bringbacksideburns · 27/11/2022 20:50

You need to step away. Any concerns need to come via her brother not you.

Maybe he can have a chat at some point but you are not her mother and she’s an adult.

Weatherwax13 · 27/11/2022 20:48

If I had a close friend in this situation I'd bring this up in conversation. The fact that she's also your SIL is kind of irrelevant. I think it's pretty normal for women to privately voice concerns to each other isn't it?
You don't need to be heavy handed or overstep.
I don't think it's rude if it's a long-standing friendship as long as you're not being judgemental or bossy. And you don't sound like that in the least.
Women should look out for one another.
Your SIL will shut down the conversation if she doesn't want to discuss it and you'd obviously respect that.

Pollyputthekettleonha · 27/11/2022 20:37

If she brings it up I would talk to her about it as you are close and have known her a long time. If you have a close relationship you should be able to discuss this kind of stuff. As her partner is not really stepping up I think it's good that you are looking out for her. It sounds as bit unlikely that he will be eg. Paying into a private pension for her while she is out of the workforce.

EvenMoreFuriousVexation · 27/11/2022 20:23

I think I'd tell her the story of a mythical old friend of yours who you've just heard has been left high and dry by her relationship ending and her having been in a very similar position to SIL ie unmarried and having taken a hit on her career path.

MayThe4th · 27/11/2022 20:22

I would tread carefully and would get your DH to talk to her rather than you getting involved.

She’s his sister, and you’re an in law. If she resents what you’re saying, concludes that you have a problem with her partner and are suggesting that they might split it could cause issues for you with the wider family. At least if your DH mentions it it’s his family, iyswim.

RosesAndHellebores · 27/11/2022 20:13

Ah my apologies re the relationship. Obviously she is your SIL.

I still think you need to back off though.

Calmdown14 · 27/11/2022 20:10

I wouldn't necessarily tell her but would ask questions that might make her think about it in more detail.

What type of job is she giving up? Unless it's a zero hours type contract really easy to step into then I'd be saying 'oh it must be really hard but will you be able to get three days again easily? My fictional friend did this and then really regretted it as she had to go back full time for a whole year before they would let her cut hours'.

'Oh it's good you'll have more time with the baby. Will you be speeding up the wedding plans to give you more protection? My friend x got married after they had a baby as they realised she wouldn't get his pension of death in service benefits if the worst happened.'

Basically pitch it at things that aren't 'your bf might leave you ' as she'll just say 'that won't happen' or think you don't like him

Stationsofthecross · 27/11/2022 19:54

Depends how close you are - I am very close to my sil and will have no issue bringing something like this up to her with no worry of a fallout with my own brother.

keepyertrapshut · 27/11/2022 19:50

I think from these responses I will bring it up if she mentions something about it again. I’ll try not to do it in a heavy, intervention way, just a sort of introducing the idea. Maybe mention she should double check what the process is with NI payments etc. We are close, and I think the potential awkwardness is probably worth it to make sure she’s looking at things clearly. I think my Mum or my sister would do the same for me if I was in that position.

OP posts:
Salvia89 · 27/11/2022 19:40

Absolutely bring it up with her gently. Before joining Mumsnet, it’s probably something I’d have never properly considered in a relationship so although the convo may be a bit awkward, she may have to idea about the potential future problems she is setting the foundations for.

tickticksnooze · 27/11/2022 19:29

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 27/11/2022 19:05

If you have a close relationship, I think it would make sense to have a conversation about it. Not in a judgy way, just “here are a few observations I have - maybe you’ve thought this all through - I debated whether to raise it but I decided I’d do so even though it’s awkward, because I really care about you and will always be in your corner”

I'd be thinking along these lines. You've known her since she's 14, why wouldn't you at least gently sound her out.

What's the point of having close relationships if nobody can ever be arsed to look out for you or bring their concerns to your attention.

It's perfectly possible to have the conversation without telling her what to do or criticising her.

Babyroobs · 27/11/2022 19:24

I don't think you should get involved. To be honest I think anyone would be mad to even give up a part time job in the current costs of living crisis unless he is a high earner.

keepyertrapshut · 27/11/2022 19:21

@PrincessPoodleI’m worried about that, I think. As I said, her partner is a nice person and we get on well with him but he’s clearly been a bit… crap at taking joint (or even just a bit!) responsibility for childcare issues. I don’t want her to suffer just because he’s being a tool and maybe she doesn’t want to admit that to her family?

OP posts:
DuchessOfSausage · 27/11/2022 19:15

Get your DH to speak with her, unless you and DSIL are close.

keepyertrapshut · 27/11/2022 19:14

If it WAS my brother I would have had some very clear words with him months ago that he needs to step up with time off to look after his daughter, and would definitely have brought up to him that he’s putting her in a vulnerable position.

OP posts:
PrincessPoodle · 27/11/2022 19:14

I'd say something next time she mentioned it in a casual way.

On the other hand she might realize that giving up work is her only option because the boyfriend won't do his share and she'll just end up losing her job

getoutof · 27/11/2022 19:13

RosesAndHellebores · 27/11/2022 19:09

You need to butt out.

Ad they aren't married, she isn't your SIL. She's your brother's partner or girlfriend

This is none of your business whatsoever.

It clearly isn't her brother's partner she's talking about

PrincessPoodle · 27/11/2022 19:13

RosesAndHellebores · 27/11/2022 19:09

You need to butt out.

Ad they aren't married, she isn't your SIL. She's your brother's partner or girlfriend

This is none of your business whatsoever.

Why do you think she'd refer to her brother as the woman's boyfriend, and not her brother?

Swipe left for the next trending thread