Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently I'm "old fashioned and anti-feminist"

356 replies

MVDC · 27/11/2022 09:28

Because I told my friend who's thinking about TTC that she should seriously consider getting married first, even if it's just a register office job.

Apparently that makes me puritanical and woman shaming. Have directed her to the 4 threads I've read so far this morning where women had kids unmarried and are now getting completely screwed by their partners as the relationship breaks down.

I'm really, really angry. Not so much at my friend as at society who's convinced women that "cool girls don't need marriage" and I'm just... My coffee isn't Irish enough.

OP posts:
JustCakeInDrag · 27/11/2022 13:09

Fizzywaterbubbles · 27/11/2022 13:00

Its fine to have an opinion on whats the safest option for people legally, but I dont blame your friend for getting annoyed. There have been MANY decisions my friends have made that I personally wouldnt have chosen for myself as I can see it not being beneficial in the future. That said, I dont batter them with it or castigate them for it because ITS THEIR LIFE and their choice. I would bin off a friend who constantly told me what I should and shouldnt be doing with my life because they are meant to be my friend, not my mother and that kind of over protective helicoptering would annoy the fck out of me- its infantilising and patronising.

Have you read OP’s update? Friend said ‘we’re thinking of ttc, what do you think?’ OP gave an honest answer. If it’s infantilising to answer the question then it’s equally infantile to ask and then kick off when you don’t like the answer.

Fizzywaterbubbles · 27/11/2022 13:06

Buildingthefuture · 27/11/2022 13:02

Had a very similar conversation with a work friend last week. She’s much younger than me (early 20s) has been with her BF only a year, lives in his house. They are planning on having a baby, she is going to give up work. When I asked had she thought about marriage, she was horrified….apparently that’s far too much of a commitment - but a baby isn’t? When I pointed out that she didn’t have many rights to the property etc if they weren’t married and he decided to leave her, her response was “he’d never do that”. Her mother also thinks it’s a wonderful idea. I despair……

Does your "friend" also "despair" of your life choices? I'm wondering how much leeway you give her to comment on your lifestyle and make criticisms and remarks about how you live your life?

Buildingthefuture · 27/11/2022 13:02

Had a very similar conversation with a work friend last week. She’s much younger than me (early 20s) has been with her BF only a year, lives in his house. They are planning on having a baby, she is going to give up work. When I asked had she thought about marriage, she was horrified….apparently that’s far too much of a commitment - but a baby isn’t? When I pointed out that she didn’t have many rights to the property etc if they weren’t married and he decided to leave her, her response was “he’d never do that”. Her mother also thinks it’s a wonderful idea. I despair……

Fizzywaterbubbles · 27/11/2022 13:00

Its fine to have an opinion on whats the safest option for people legally, but I dont blame your friend for getting annoyed. There have been MANY decisions my friends have made that I personally wouldnt have chosen for myself as I can see it not being beneficial in the future. That said, I dont batter them with it or castigate them for it because ITS THEIR LIFE and their choice. I would bin off a friend who constantly told me what I should and shouldnt be doing with my life because they are meant to be my friend, not my mother and that kind of over protective helicoptering would annoy the fck out of me- its infantilising and patronising.

TurkishClouds · 27/11/2022 12:58

Buteverythingsfine · 27/11/2022 12:31

My husband also had an insurance policy he'd forgotten about and so I only received that from being his married widow. Ditto all those small pensions you forget about when you work in lots of places. Makes it so much easier. The amount of money from those being given automatically was life-changing. you should still change them manually though if you can, as you can distribute pensions/lump sums how you like, so give some to your kids or whatever. Everyone should check all their pensions/life insurance/other insurances to make sure their loved ones are the beneficiaries, and it's easier to make a claim if this hasn't been done if you were married. Wills the same.

As per my previous post, it's not true that 'you can distribute pensions/lump sums how you like'.

For lump sums you can tell the pension trustees how you would like them to be distributed (but they don't have to follow your wishes). Defined benefit pensions in payment (or a percentage) will only continue to be paid to a spouse or civil partner if one exists. If not, they will cease to be paid to anyone on the death of the pensioner.

There are fewer defined benefit pensions available to new joiners so this will not be relevant for younger people.

It's important to understand the implications of marriage on your OWN circumstances

It's important not to just consider your circumstances now but think about when you are 60+ years old. You may not wish to get married when you are younger but it's important to keep this under review as your circumstances change.

A number of PPs have noted the phenomenon of people aged 50+ deciding to marry after many years together.

One thing we only understood about the IHT situation when we spoke to a solicitor to do our wills was that if we allowed each other to continue living in our jointly owned house after the death of the first partner in a non-legal couple, then the whole house becomes part of the estate of the second partner to die and, in our case, subject to IHT. The only option to avoid this was to get married or form a civil partnership.

Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 12:54

if she thinks marriage is anti feminist would she consider a civil partnership?

LeilaRose777 · 27/11/2022 12:54

I think that was good advice. A lot of people in the UK think that there is such a thing as a "common law" legally binding relationship, which is just like being married. There isn't, and if you're not married to the parent of your child, your situation re: maintenance, property, and inheritance is different. If she's much better off than him, I could see the point of not marrying as she would stand to lose more at divorce.
There's nothing anti-feminist about looking out for yourself and your children.

Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 12:51

@SueVineer

you are correct that no one can make medical decisions on behalf of another adult unless they have POA (and everyone should therefore set up a LPA asap - different thread)

BUT

  1. mental health is different and the “nearest relative” has defined legal powers and this cannot be changed by an LPA
  2. in the (brief) period before the birth is registered (or a court order obtained) an unmarried father does not have legal parental responsibility.
  3. healthcare professionals will try and consult with relatives before making any major decisions about unconscious patients without LPAs and really do take these opinions into account . They will consult with unmarried partners if they are aware of who they are but that depends on the relatives “remembering” them. There’s a bit on most DNACPR forms for “discussion with family” - the hospital staff have no idea who your chosen family are other than those you are related to or have made legal ties to
  4. its not just about decision making- If there is room for two people at your dying partners bedside and his evil mother says that’s me and his dad, it’s really a bad time to be trying to prove your not “just some fling” but a life partner - easier proved if you have kids, easier still if your married
  5. In other counties (that people go to on holiday) the NOK has a legal role
  6. not healthcare but the bit that comes after - disputes about funerals sadly are very commonplace, being excluded from your partners funeral must be horrific
TurkishClouds · 27/11/2022 12:42

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 12:10

So you mean iht exemption? I can’t think of any others unless you have an unusual pension scheme that has spousal benefits that don’t go to unmarried partners

Not true. It doesn't need to be an 'unusual' pension scheme.

The vast majority of defined benefit pensions that are being paid out will, when a pensioner dies, continue to pay out a percentage of that pension (often 50%) to their spouse or civil partner for life. This definitely isn't the case for non-civil partners, boyfriends, girlfriends etc.

As a PP pointed out, this is what civil partnerships and then same sex marriage were so important for gay rights.

Also, when someone dies, part of their state pension may be payable to a surviving spouse or civil partner if the survivor doesn't qualify for a full state pension in their own right. This will apply mainly to older women.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 27/11/2022 12:41

@SueVineer - my partner's pension terms changed from "goes to nominated person" (me) to "goes to spouse" with "option to consider pensioner's request" i.e. didn't have to pay out if not married, could avoid it.

So after god know how many years we got married.

I didn't want to get married for political reasons - patriarchal bullshit institution. However, there's civil partnerships now, so the same instances don't apply.

Peoniesandcream · 27/11/2022 12:37

I am only saying my view point from my own circumstances but wouldn't be the same for others. For example a lot of women who reduce their hours/ stay at home after having children and reduce their earning potential and pension would obviously be better off being married. But for me I'm better off without at present.

Onnabugeisha · 27/11/2022 12:36

Blossomtoes · 27/11/2022 12:23

Just to illustrate how things can change. When we got married I was marginally the lowest earner but I had more assets. In the course of our working life our salaries leap frogged each other several times. When I inherited I had the most assets by quite a margin, when he inherited he overtook me.

Marriage benefits us now because both our survivors’ pensions are dependent on marriage/civil partnership and it minimises inheritance tax liability. As a legal contract there have been times in the last 22 years when I would have benefited more and times when he would. Currently - and probably permanently - it’s my turn to benefit most.

Same here. My DH was a SAHD for fifteen years. Marriage protected him and it was only fair that if I had fucked off into the sunset that he should get some of the assets he had supported me getting for the family by his role of caring for our DC, being a DIY god and getting postgraduate degrees. I had dragged him across the world several times by taking jobs abroad, so he didn’t really have the opportunity to work while being a SAHD.

Now I’m a disabled and not working SAHM and he’s the one with the career and higher income.

Our positions have reversed. Marriage/civil partnership is truly about the long term.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 27/11/2022 12:36

If a woman is herself financially secure, and is confident of being so in future, babies or not, that’s one thing.
If she isn’t, and is going to be dependent on the man, especially after a baby, that’s another.

As for marriage in itself, I know personally of one case, and have heard of many more, where the woman would like to get married, but the man keeps saying he doesn’t believe in it, or, ‘It’s just a piece of paper’ - but after 9 or whatever years he’s off with someone else, has miraculously overcome his objections, and is married to her within a year.

RealBecca · 27/11/2022 12:31

You may have hit a sore point.

But...did you really direct her to mumsnet and then start a post about her?????

Buteverythingsfine · 27/11/2022 12:31

My husband also had an insurance policy he'd forgotten about and so I only received that from being his married widow. Ditto all those small pensions you forget about when you work in lots of places. Makes it so much easier. The amount of money from those being given automatically was life-changing. you should still change them manually though if you can, as you can distribute pensions/lump sums how you like, so give some to your kids or whatever. Everyone should check all their pensions/life insurance/other insurances to make sure their loved ones are the beneficiaries, and it's easier to make a claim if this hasn't been done if you were married. Wills the same.

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 12:30

ByTheGrace · 27/11/2022 12:24

I was just about to ask that question?

No one has any legal right to make medical decisions about you without a poa.

Husbands can be abusive too and often are.

JustCakeInDrag · 27/11/2022 12:29

There are lots of very complex issues surrounding marriage and perhaps OP has overstepped but let's be honest: if OP's friend were against marriage for political reasons she would enter a civil partnership, and if marriage is not in her favour due to considerable wealth or other assets she will already have taken professional advice on protecting herself, and in both cases she would simply say so. The simplest, most obvious, and most likely explanation for this specific outburst is that OP has touched a nerve relating to something within her friend's relationship.

Buteverythingsfine · 27/11/2022 12:27

It is much more straightforward for pensions and death benefits as well if you are married. @SignOnTheWindow I'm so sorry your partner died when you were pregnant, that must have been terrible. It sounds like you had thought it through with the will though which is fantastic- you can get most of the same advantages through making wills, making your partner your pension beneficiary, life insurance etc, but it's very hard to cover everything and my guess is that most unmarried couples don't do all this life admin and don't find out til too late. The widow's benefit is only available for married couples I think, which is about £2500 over two years and I'm sorry you didn't receive that.

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 12:26

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/11/2022 12:17

Unlike France , for example, there is no legal obligation in the Uk to leave anything to your spouse. The spouse will inherit automatically only if the deceased dies intestate.

If you wish to leave all your money to the fabled cats home, you can ( although the spouse might be successful in legally challenging such a will).

That’s actually not true in Scotland as there are limited spousal rights on moveable property. I was talking about iht anyway- as I never wanted to leave my money to him anyway it didn’t matter. I wanted it to go to my children

ByTheGrace · 27/11/2022 12:24

RandomMusings7 · 27/11/2022 12:23

What is the definition of partner though? How are medical professionals expected to decide who is an actual life partner and who is simply boyfriend of the season...? Any dude who shows up at the hospital can declare he's your partner, including a casual bf of 3 weeks, an abusive partner you are recently separated from etc

I was just about to ask that question?

Notcontent · 27/11/2022 12:23

It’s actually a really interesting issue. Because there is now no shame in having children before marriage (which is obviously a good thing) people seem to have forgotten that it’s a really huge commitment. Marriage was always seen as a big commitment, and still is, because it is ultimately a very public declaration of commitment, as well as having legal standing. So, in a way, it did stop women being left holding the baby…. Obviously there were still lots of women who were left abandoned by their husbands - but there were not many women intentionally having children with men who very clearly had no intention to commit to them!

Blossomtoes · 27/11/2022 12:23

Just to illustrate how things can change. When we got married I was marginally the lowest earner but I had more assets. In the course of our working life our salaries leap frogged each other several times. When I inherited I had the most assets by quite a margin, when he inherited he overtook me.

Marriage benefits us now because both our survivors’ pensions are dependent on marriage/civil partnership and it minimises inheritance tax liability. As a legal contract there have been times in the last 22 years when I would have benefited more and times when he would. Currently - and probably permanently - it’s my turn to benefit most.

RandomMusings7 · 27/11/2022 12:23

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 12:18

There’s no legal basis for that. In fact nhs policy should treat partners the same as spouses.

What is the definition of partner though? How are medical professionals expected to decide who is an actual life partner and who is simply boyfriend of the season...? Any dude who shows up at the hospital can declare he's your partner, including a casual bf of 3 weeks, an abusive partner you are recently separated from etc

Buteverythingsfine · 27/11/2022 12:23

I think it would have been good to have suggested this, and discussed it, but not told her to do it. I would say 9/10 on this site, and in my friendship groups, it would have benefitted the woman to be married, because of the salary/career sacrifice of even that six months of maternity leave that then seems to send women on the part/time, lower earner trajectory. If you are a high earner or not the primary carer, definitely worth thinking twice, I have one or two friends in this category and I myself would not marry again to secure my assets for my children.

Surely the issue is more how you approached it, telling her what to do, rather than asking her about it, but then people are notoriously prickly about these things, I once suggested to a friend she didn't marry a man she wasn't in love with and she bit my head off!

Notmysolution · 27/11/2022 12:21

You do hear some horror stories of unmarried couples when one dies. One woman in her 60s was kicked out of her home and business after her partner died (they ran the business together -a farm - but everything was in his name). Not married, all went to his kids. They kicked her out. She lost everything. Her partner, her home, her livelihood. Absolutely everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread