Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently I'm "old fashioned and anti-feminist"

356 replies

MVDC · 27/11/2022 09:28

Because I told my friend who's thinking about TTC that she should seriously consider getting married first, even if it's just a register office job.

Apparently that makes me puritanical and woman shaming. Have directed her to the 4 threads I've read so far this morning where women had kids unmarried and are now getting completely screwed by their partners as the relationship breaks down.

I'm really, really angry. Not so much at my friend as at society who's convinced women that "cool girls don't need marriage" and I'm just... My coffee isn't Irish enough.

OP posts:
Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 10:22

@luxxlisbon mothers have parental responsibility from the moment the kid comes out of them. The husband of the mother also has parental responsibility from this point (regardless of them being the father or not). The father (if not the husband) only has parental responsibility when they are named on the birth certificate or given this responsibility by a court.

in my old life working with sick neonates I would have to ask if dads were married to mums before I could get them to consent to procedures as if unmarried because the baby has not yet been registered (wouldn’t suggest parents got married to fix this tho, just register the birth)

www.gov.uk/parental-rights-responsibilities/who-has-parental-responsibility

in current life as a hcp of adults I get very frustrated when people get very angry when you explain that they may have lived together for 20years and have three kids but they have no legal relationship

getting married - way of telling the state whom you want as your family

(don’t ever actually say it in reality as that would be mean and thoughtless) but can’t be doing with people who get all upset that the health service/government doesn’t magically know who they want to be their significant other if they haven’t married them (was less annoyed before gay marriage was legal obvs) and then complain that there’s not some easy form or process to complete to make this happen - it’s called marriage and it’s pretty cheap to just get the legal bit done

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/11/2022 10:21

Unless she is likely to be the higher earner throughout the relationship then getting married is sensible. There are ways to protect yourself legally outside of marriage or civil partnership but it's a faff. It also carries inheritance tax protection which is why you see a fair number of long-term partners marrying when one of them gets sick.
In my case I am the higher earner, so marriage protects DH especially as he took some time out as a SAHD.

OkOkOkOkOkOk · 27/11/2022 10:19

Isitsixoclockalready · 27/11/2022 10:17

If it's a friend and coming from a good place - I don't see the harm. Sometimes we walk too much on eggshells around others. A good friend will offer advice with the best of intentions. It doesn't need to be accepted but friends should be able to deal with advice in a grown up way.

Fully agree, but sometimes people can be too opinionated when their opinion wasn't asked for

TeapotTitties · 27/11/2022 10:19

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

We're all an accident/illness away from poverty as they say.

It may not benefit you right now, but it's a bit of a gamble with your future.

beachcitygirl · 27/11/2022 10:18

As a pp said. A friend of mine who was "not into a piece of paper" had to sit in a waiting room where her partner of 19 years life and death decisions were being made by his mother (who disliked her)

Horrific.

You were not unreasonable OP

So many people don't give proper consideration to all the ramifications

knittingaddict · 27/11/2022 10:18

For my relative it was the difference between child maintenance versus child maintenance, £125,000 and half a pension.

Obviously if she had been more financially savvy and not with an abusive man, the marriage wouldn't have made such a big difference. Given her inability to make money at anything like the level he did and his financial control, the marriage was the best thing she could possibly have done.

Isitsixoclockalready · 27/11/2022 10:17

OkOkOkOkOkOk · 27/11/2022 09:51

Did your friend ask for your opinion on whether she should get married first?

If it's a friend and coming from a good place - I don't see the harm. Sometimes we walk too much on eggshells around others. A good friend will offer advice with the best of intentions. It doesn't need to be accepted but friends should be able to deal with advice in a grown up way.

Wish44 · 27/11/2022 10:16

Sadly it may be something some women learn the hard way. I was so idealistic and clueless ,didn't marry ex but had 2 children with him , worked pt, put my family money, time and skills into building our home. When he buggered off with a 24 year old he actually smiled when he pointed out we weren't married.

So OP I tell women exactly the same as you... but I do follow it up with the fact that ex now lives with new wife in my wonderful big house and me and kids live in tiny crap house) and that helps to illustrate the point.

multivac · 27/11/2022 10:15

If your child is unwell your partner can't give consent to treatment, it is all on you. I actually know a couple who got married because when their baby was born he was very sick in NICU and the father didn't have parental responsibility.

This is flat out wrong. As long as the father is registered, he has parental responsibility. The only difference marriage makes is in how (or if - sometimes it is important that a father doesn't have pr) the registering happens.

Scaremongering isn't helpful. Or feminist.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 27/11/2022 10:14

I agree with you, but I can also understand that people don't see the protection it gives until things go south, so only see the 'not birthing a bastard' sentiment. I don't agree with that phrase, but I know deep down quite a few people do believe it.

knittingaddict · 27/11/2022 10:13

TreadLight · 27/11/2022 09:40

@MVDC , your position makes perfect sense if you believe women have a right to be reliant on men. Personally, I don't that position. I think women are fully empowered to be self reliant.

And don't forget that a father in a marriage had more parental rights than a father outside a marriage.

What extra rights do they have? I don't know of any.

Nishky32 · 27/11/2022 10:12

jeaux90 · 27/11/2022 09:42

I'm a rad fem.

I've brought my DD13 up on my own. But i focused on my career for years so I'm financially independent.

You are not wrong OP. Having a child outside marriage does not protect her.

The one piece of advice I give young women is to be financially independent.

Isn’t that the advice we should be giving rather than get married!

KettrickenSmiled · 27/11/2022 10:12

luxxlisbon · 27/11/2022 09:43

You’re right, the only two options are that the friend is stupid or that she just be pretending she doesn’t want to get married when actually she desperately does because she’s a woman so of course if she doesn’t want marriage she must just be stupid. Yawn.

& how many thousands of threads have been posted here by desperate women trapped in horrible relationships, dependent on an abusive man, but unable to escape because she's never recovered her career after maternity, he refuses to stump up for childcare fees, she's moved into his house but isn't on the deeds/tenancy?

& how many ditto, where the OP is hanging on for "him to propose" but during that wait, had DC, & is now becoming horribly aware of how precarious her situation is?

These are 2 really, really common situations.
Not sure why you are so aggressively pretending it doesn't happen.

Rewis · 27/11/2022 10:11

I guess it depends if you recommend that in her situstion she would benefit from marriage before having kids. Or if you thibk every woman should be married and not having children out of wedlock. Wether marriage is a good idea afor her depends on her situation and her future plans.

Joyfuljolly · 27/11/2022 10:10

I think if she will be financially struggling etc then yes you are prob right, but I also think that if she is able to pay her way then no she doesn’t need to be married and kids are protected anyway

i Really don’t think it’s your place to advise her on marriage.

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 10:09

@sashh not all of whats in your post is true.

I don’t want to automatically inherit the other half of the property and I certainly don’t want him to automatically inherit mine. Or many of those things. If I do, there’s ways around it.

Lots of people are assuming the OP knows the financial details, but very few know mine. On the surface perhaps I look vulnerable, I have been a divorced single parent, a student for 4 years, and living in a shared ownership house on a rough estate for 5 years. On the outside it might look like my DP has come in and bought us a house when in reality he couldn’t do this without me whereas I could do it without him not my careers up and running.

WineCap · 27/11/2022 10:08

I wouldn't have children unless I was married. My DH and I both earned around the same amount pre-children but I knew that I may end up going part-time during the early years and I didn't want to leave myself vulnerable.

If the woman has equal or less earning power than the man, then I would encourage marriage.

NatalieIsFreezing · 27/11/2022 10:07

m not from the UK but if unmarried mothers are so vulnerable (it’s not the case where I’m from), then shouldn’t the solution be for them to be better protected under the law than for them to have to get married?

Because often it protects the lower earner and caregiver, which isn't always the woman. And as pp have mentioned, there are benefits in not getting married if you want to walk away with no obligations. Obviously that suits a lot of people too.

The expectation is that if you want the aspects of a particular legal process, such as marriage, you would undertake that process, and if you don't, you don't. It's odd to suggest that any couple should be seen as married in the eyes of the law when they haven't chosen that!

Lalliella · 27/11/2022 10:06

If she intends to be a SAHM and/or has less money/assets than him and/or the house is in his name only then you’re right.

However if she’s richer she could lose out. My cousin lost her lovely house through being married to some cocklodging twat who was awarded half of it.

Hoppinggreen · 27/11/2022 10:05

LynLynette · 27/11/2022 09:58

Being married won’t necessarily mean that you don’t get fucked over if your relationship breaks down. Women can come out of divorces badly off.
I’m not from the UK but if unmarried mothers are so vulnerable (it’s not the case where I’m from), then shouldn’t the solution be for them to be better protected under the law than for them to have to get married?
You’re angry at society for convincing women they don’t need to be married? Why aren’t you angry at society for forcing them into marriage because otherwise they will be vulnerable to getting “completely screwed by their partner“ if the relationship ends?

While I agree with you, presumably OP isn’t in a position to reform these laws but she CAN warn her friend that she would probably be better protected legally if she were married

OkOkOkOkOkOk · 27/11/2022 10:05

If your opinion was asked for then she's walked into it. I dont agree with your opinion, each to their own. People can have babies and get married whenever they like.

luxxlisbon · 27/11/2022 10:04

@sashh If your child is unwell your partner can't give consent to treatment, it is all on you. I actually know a couple who got married because when their baby was born he was very sick in NICU and the father didn't have parental responsibility.

Very dangerous and incorrect advice. A FATHER absolutely does have parental responsibility.
Utter horseshit that only mothers can consent to treatment and fathers cannot unless they are married.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 27/11/2022 10:04

@sashh adding only if your partner is life and death ill you may end up sitting in the waiting room while someone else makes the major decisions.

MVDC · 27/11/2022 10:01

OkOkOkOkOkOk · 27/11/2022 09:51

Did your friend ask for your opinion on whether she should get married first?

She said "we're thinking about having a baby soon, what do you think?" And I said I thought she should consider getting married first.

OP posts:
sashh · 27/11/2022 10:01

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

If your partner died you would automatically inherit his share of the property and possibly his pension, and the same for him. Or do you want to pay taxes and others have a claim on your property.

If your child is unwell your partner can't give consent to treatment, it is all on you. I actually know a couple who got married because when their baby was born he was very sick in NICU and the father didn't have parental responsibility.

If you were seriously ill your partner would not automatically be the next of kin.

You can make a power of attorney but it could be challenged. I looked into this because my mother was very much, "life at all costs" and I was terrified of her being in control of my medical care.

You could move money and assets between you without paying tax.