Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently I'm "old fashioned and anti-feminist"

356 replies

MVDC · 27/11/2022 09:28

Because I told my friend who's thinking about TTC that she should seriously consider getting married first, even if it's just a register office job.

Apparently that makes me puritanical and woman shaming. Have directed her to the 4 threads I've read so far this morning where women had kids unmarried and are now getting completely screwed by their partners as the relationship breaks down.

I'm really, really angry. Not so much at my friend as at society who's convinced women that "cool girls don't need marriage" and I'm just... My coffee isn't Irish enough.

OP posts:
Peoniesandcream · 27/11/2022 10:54

I'm divorced, have a child with my DP we've been together 4 years. I owned a house with ex, got half of it so me and my DP now rent, waiting for house prices to go down. My deposit will be more than his, I also earn more money, we both work full time. Getting married would benefit me how?

Rainraindontgoaway · 27/11/2022 10:51

I'm really, really angry - really, out of all the things you could be angry about you pick this….?

HepzibahGreen · 27/11/2022 10:49

my friends 21 year old has never had a job, shes just had a baby and is now living in his new house that his parents insisted on being in his name only (which is probably what id do)

Bit off topic but...am I reading this right..
You think women should get married to protect themselves before having children, but you approve of the man who is the father of your friend's daughters child keeping the house in his name only?
If my son had got a woman pregnant, and was living with her, I would expect him to be taking car of his family in whatever way he could and I definitely wouldn't want to screw over my own grandchild. But that's very MN , so I am probably in the minority!

NatalieIsFreezing · 27/11/2022 10:47

I have seen devorce fuck far more people than a non married split.

This might be true but these people actively entered into a legal contract. Whereas remaining unmarried is the default so you don't always "actively" choose it unless you've sat down to properly consider the legal situation and have made the choice to remain unmarried IYSWIM.

RedHelenB · 27/11/2022 10:46

Divorce costs. Fair enough to be in the deeds or tenancy but I don't think marriage is always the best way. Keeping your finances in order is more important and making sure you can provide for yourself.

NatalieIsFreezing · 27/11/2022 10:44

getting married - way of telling the state whom you want as your family

Great post from @Qazwsxefv

Would be great of we could move away a bit from the endless narrative of marriage being purely about romance.

This is why gay marriage was such a big issue!

mam0918 · 27/11/2022 10:43

Well you are showing you are all those things though and you're increadibly bloody rude too to stick your nose in other peoples relationships and assume you know their finances..

I have seen devorce fuck far more people than a non married split.

Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 10:42

*unconscious
*parents not partner

urgh phone fingers

Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 10:41

@SueVineer www.rethink.org/advice-and-information/rights-restrictions/mental-health-laws/nearest-relative-under-the-mental-health-act-1983/

well it does in mental health- a big role.

and yes if you are well enough to state whom your next of kin is when admitted to hospital you can say whomever you wish, if your bought in unconsciousness and haven’t changed your GP records since you started your current relationship don't be surprised if they call your parents not your parents (and all decent parents would then call you but not all parents are decent)

Wish44 · 27/11/2022 10:41

@SueVineer but it's not always as simple as that. People's earnings change over a life together. Also a woman might be a high earner but work part time and so have a smaller pension and of course illness happens.

The point of marriage is that if it ends a judge sits down and decides what is fair, especially to the kids. That fairness is often about the person who stayed at home and raised the children while the other earned getting a settlement ( usually the woman, sometimes the man, but that settlement is earned and allows the person without money to house the children.Without that 2 people battle it out on their own and the kids can be forgotten.

username8888 · 27/11/2022 10:40

It's wasn't appropriate to comment on her life choices. I would have carefully approached the subject of the legal protection marriage gives, but you came across as judging her.

strawberriesplease · 27/11/2022 10:40

But if your partner is the lower earner the benefit of any contract is his.

Potentially for this moment but life changes and you never know what's around the corner. Also, it smooths out pension rights and property etc.

If you're a team, having a contract is sensible as you navigate the highs and lows.

stevalnamechanger · 27/11/2022 10:38

For MOST women . Maybe not you . But for the vast majority

stevalnamechanger · 27/11/2022 10:36

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

You clearly need to do more research then smarty pants .

Being married gives you fundamentally more rights

Qazwsxefv · 27/11/2022 10:36

Why don’t unmarried dads have PR from the moment of birth - because legally the state has no idea who the dad is.

There is nothing legally connecting the man and the women (other than some bloke who turns up at the labour ward and claims he’s dad - he could be anyone, if not in a long term relationship mums to be often don’t list anyone in then”dad” bit of the antenatal notes). Can cause Massive massive issues when mum is v unwell post delivery

and at the end of life how on Earth is the state supposed to “just know” who you want by your bedside, to arrange your funeral and get your cash? Clearly there would be outrage if banks just went around handing over the contents of dead peoples bank accounts to any random who walked in off the street and says “can I have all of my dead girlfriends money - she wanted me to have it”.

want to tell the state that your long term partner is your family? Get married. That’s what it is - legally declaring your significant other is family so they have the legal rights and responsibilities of being your family, not a party or a dress or bridesmaids or anything like that

(I am aware that there are ways to replicate all of the above with wills and LPAs and similar and if you wanna do it that way that’s fine as well but the simplest way is always gonna be to get married)

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 10:35

roarfeckingroarr · 27/11/2022 10:23

I won't get married because it would put my higher earning and assets at risk, but that's an informed choice. You are absolutely correct and as a friend you were right to talk to your friend. I imagine she's defensive because she knows you're not wrong.

How do you know ops friend hasn’t made an informed choice?

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 10:34

strawberriesplease · 27/11/2022 10:32

Because marriage is a contract. I'm a high earner, own property and advise all women to have the protection of a marriage if planning a serious commitment.

All the big wedding and over romance is modern bells and whistles

But if your partner is the lower earner the benefit of any contract is his.

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 10:33

beachcitygirl · 27/11/2022 10:18

As a pp said. A friend of mine who was "not into a piece of paper" had to sit in a waiting room where her partner of 19 years life and death decisions were being made by his mother (who disliked her)

Horrific.

You were not unreasonable OP

So many people don't give proper consideration to all the ramifications

Marriage doesn’t give any rights over medical decisions. She could have insisted in being involved. Difficult situation but marriage isn’t the issue here- rather old fashioned ideas of medical staff.

strawberriesplease · 27/11/2022 10:32

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

Because marriage is a contract. I'm a high earner, own property and advise all women to have the protection of a marriage if planning a serious commitment.

All the big wedding and over romance is modern bells and whistles

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 27/11/2022 10:30

strictly speaking you're pandering to patriarchal tradition for personal benefit

And what's wrong with that? if you can't overthrow it then turn it to your advantage.

SueVineer · 27/11/2022 10:29

KettrickenSmiled · 27/11/2022 09:38

Apparently that makes me puritanical and woman shaming.

Maybe you need to accept the sad fact that your friend just isn't very bright OP.

Or maybe she does want to get married really, her partner is prepared to impregnate her but not marry her, & she is deflecting her feelings about that onto you.

Maybe it’s op that isn’t very bright and is instead judge mental and old fashioned. Ops friend doesn’t get to unilaterally choose to get married- if her partner refuses it’s pretty hurtful to bring it up in such a sneery way.

Also perhaps ops friend has a decent job or thinks financially she would be better off unmarried. Or perhaps ops friend is perfectly happy to be unmarried given her circumstances and it’s not for op to sneer about it. Perhaps ops friend and her partner have no significant assets and so marriage wouldn’t make much difference.

the idea that marriage “protects” is a middle class old fashioned mn rubbish. Marriage can be of benefits to the less wealthy partner. If neither party are particularly wealthy or if the woman is the higher earner it’s of no advantage.

There are plenty of threads of married women ending up in poverty after divorce as well as unmarried. Sneering at your friends for their life choices never goes down well.

TruckerBarbie · 27/11/2022 10:27

It's a double edged sword. In most cases marriage is the safer financial choice, but strictly speaking you're pandering to patriarchal tradition for personal benefit.

Whatsleftnow · 27/11/2022 10:26

The marriage act was an absolute shit show that took away the legal protections of unmarried couples and their children, and put women in a position of choosing between giving up their legal personhood or their children having none at all.

Women have clawed back a lot over the centuries with particular gains in the last 50 years. On a practical and individual basis it remains the best way to protect mother and children from the devastating financial gamble of procreating. But it is also a massive social injustice that we don’t afford all mothers and children financial and legal protections from feckless men.

As long as we have a legal system that is predicated on the desire to protect good men (from false allegations, from crime, and from bad women and children) instead of being concerned with the life and welfare of all humans, we can only make piecemeal progress.

Muddying the legal facts with morality and romance was just society wide gaslighting, but unfortunately many people today reject the moral piece without understanding that there’s a nasty, patriarchal bear trap lying in wait.

YANBU op

roarfeckingroarr · 27/11/2022 10:23

I won't get married because it would put my higher earning and assets at risk, but that's an informed choice. You are absolutely correct and as a friend you were right to talk to your friend. I imagine she's defensive because she knows you're not wrong.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 27/11/2022 10:22

I’ll get flamed for this but I agree with you OP. In my experience it’s almost always the man that doesn’t want to agree with it and the woman accepting that and having kids anyway. I personally would not have children with a man who wasn’t willing to put his money where his mouth is and make a legal and financial commitment to me, I think it’s madness. Most women are made vulnerable financially by having kids, not to mention the physical and mental toll on our bodies, I don’t understand why the hell you’d do that for a man that wouldn’t marry you.

Disclaimer: I know sometimes it’s the woman that doesn’t want to get married, but let’s be honest here that it’s a very small minority of cases.