Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently I'm "old fashioned and anti-feminist"

356 replies

MVDC · 27/11/2022 09:28

Because I told my friend who's thinking about TTC that she should seriously consider getting married first, even if it's just a register office job.

Apparently that makes me puritanical and woman shaming. Have directed her to the 4 threads I've read so far this morning where women had kids unmarried and are now getting completely screwed by their partners as the relationship breaks down.

I'm really, really angry. Not so much at my friend as at society who's convinced women that "cool girls don't need marriage" and I'm just... My coffee isn't Irish enough.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YukoandHiro · 04/12/2022 08:59

I didnt get married til after DD 1 but I became very insistent about it very quickly after she was born and we were married by the time she was 8 months. Sometimes it's hard to see how disadvantaged you are until you're well into that

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 04/12/2022 00:29

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

Same here! I’m married because we wanted to be, not because it benefits me. I am and always have been the higher earner, the deposit for our home came from my previous property sale, I could pay the mortgage without him. I married him because I love him, not for financial gain or protection.

Ericaequites · 04/12/2022 00:13

@SueVineer it is a lot more complicated than my discussion.still, it’s better to marry Mr. Kind and Tolerable than struggle as a single mother. True lover is rare, but it’s good to settle for a generous person who likes you and will be a decent dad.

MVDC · 03/12/2022 21:58

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 21:39

So her partner does have assets and/or a good salary? If not what’s the point of her getting married?

He does, yes. But even if he didn't, he's not going to be the one giving up his job and becoming completely financially dependent.

OP posts:
SueVineer · 03/12/2022 21:48

Ericaequites · 28/11/2022 03:34

Marriage offers a wife and their children many legal and financial protections. Children who live with both married parents are less likely to have psychological problems, use illegal substances, and commit delinquency. Why wouldn’t you want the best for yourself and your child if the father isn’t a hopeless mess?

i think it might be a bit more complicated than that

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 21:41

MangyInseam · 27/11/2022 20:44

No, OP, you aren't unreasonable. Marriage is basically a kind of contract that, in most cases, offers some protection to the person having the child, or caring for the child, if things go wrong.

People in that situation should look into it and be aware of the advantages and disadvantages for their situation. Though if the other person in the relationship refuses to do it, there isn't much recourse - I suppose that says something about how they see the relationship, though.

No it isn’t. Marriage allows one party to claim the other party’s assets on break up. It has nothing to do with children.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 21:39

MVDC · 27/11/2022 16:26

Now that would have been remarkably tone deaf. She makes NMW and has no assets. Hence why I think she should consider getting married before TTC.

So her partner does have assets and/or a good salary? If not what’s the point of her getting married?

multivac · 03/12/2022 12:28

Just another point for the 'Marriage is the easiest way to protect yourself as a woman!' crew: my friend is divorced. The house was not in her name. Subsequent to the divorce, her former husband has declared himself bankrupt. She's now spending a fortune on solicitors and likely won't see a penny from the house sale, because the bankrupcy trumps the divorce.
Sometimes, doing it the 'complicated' way is worth it.

Blossomtoes · 30/11/2022 15:18

Men never gave a shit really.

Mine cared a lot more than I did. I wouldn’t have bothered. I really don’t see the difference between marriage and civil partnership, the latter seems completely pointless and should have been removed when same sex marriage was legalised. A lot of gay couples in civic partnerships are getting married now.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/11/2022 09:50

I was definitely surprised by the age for civil partnership - average age late 50s, 29% 65 + when I looked up stats but it absolutely makes a lot of sense. Couples viewing it as paperwork probably done at same time as will, power of attorney. It definitely doesn’t carry the baggage of marriage - how could you get remarried, why didn’t you invite us etc. Just a ‘piece of paper’ that potentially makes surviving partners life a lot easier when dealing with govt depts, banks and pension companies etc. Plus potentially saves a lot in tax. You wouldn’t even need to tell adult children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 30/11/2022 08:33

@ZoeCM

Because the percentage of couples who care about the negative connotations of marriage are minuscule

That’s historically true but is changing I think. Historically women pressured men to marry them because it’s what everyone was expected to do for social reasons but benefitted from the protection it gave them. Men never gave a shit really.

Marriage benefitted the majority of women so one could overlook the unpleasant patriarchal connotations because it was a net positive.

As women are more likely to be (proportionately) wealthier or as wealthy as their husbands they don’t need it as much. All the old fashioned rhetoric, the religious overlay and naff culture of marriage and weddings starts to look like even more of a throwback to a bygone age and more women are questioning it.

I for one think this is a good thing. Marriage benefits some women hugely but it remains a patriarchal institution. The quicker we get to a point where most women don’t need it, the better.

ZoeCM · 29/11/2022 21:30

Why do you think civil partnership isn’t more popular for opposite sex couples. I understand that for many marriage carries negative connotations and people don’t want to marry. But we have a mechanism to officially recognise partners but people aren’t using it.

Because the percentage of couples who care about the negative connotations of marriage are minuscule. When straight couples are unmarried, it's almost always because the higher earner (generally the man) doesn't want to risk sharing their assets. Look around MN: how many threads are there about women being pressured into marriage by their partners? Virtually none. How many are there from women wondering why their partner doesn't want to marry them? Truckloads.

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:45

Marriage should be about compatibility, end of. If the man is of the attitude that his role is to be the main earner and the woman's role is to prioritise the children and the home, then that's perfect.

If however both are of the attitude that they are equal all around and everything should be shared, then marriage becomes more of a romantic nature, or both can be happy never to marry.

I was brought up by a single professional woman as was my OH. Both were raised believing that women and men are equal in their role. We married because we like the notion of a legal union, but we are both financially independent. We are compatible and it's working well.

sashh · 29/11/2022 09:36

Dixiechickonhols · 28/11/2022 11:11

The issue is it’s hard to separate the legal from the emotive. I can imagine the threads on here - midwife told me to get married it’s not the 1950s how dare she.
The bereaved unmarried woman in article I linked wanted info given by registrar when unmarried couple register a baby. Again that could be taken as them drumming up business.
My dc had half a phse lesson briefly touching on legal position in yr 10 that’s it.

It depends how it is done, a leaflet that states what may happen if your baby is born ill could include this information along with other information.

Having never been pregnant I don't know what or if anything is discussed about what could happen post birth.

SirMingeALot · 29/11/2022 09:15

Dixiechickonhols · 28/11/2022 13:27

Apparently ‘deadbed’ marriage is up 11% I’d imagine it’s mainly done for tax reasons and to ensure partner left behind has as smooth ride as possible dealing with bureaucracy.
Perhaps high profile examples like Ken Dodd and Alan Rickman are behind increase too.

I can believe it, often the very smart choice in those circumstances. It's a risky option to wait, because you don't necessarily get reasonable advance warning that your end is near. People die suddenly all the time. But for couples who through age or health have good reason to expect to be in that position sooner rather than later, it makes sense.

Rinatinabina · 29/11/2022 08:53

YANBU, seen it much too often on mumsnet women left trapped and vulnerable. Of course there are many women out there who this doesn’t apply to but it affects enough women that it’s important to talk about the consequences.

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 08:42

Marriage can indeed simplify SOME stuff, especially for the lower earner. But it can also cause problems, and it certainly isn't a magic bullet for every woman everywhere. It genuinely is infantilising, not to mention rolling over for the patriarchy, to pretend it's the wise default.

But let's be honest (we've had the stats about later in life marriages after years of cohabiting etc, and CP at 65+): most people don't make any plans for the future or bad things happening, especially if they (as OPs friend does) have no assets and earns NMW. They don't see the point.

I'm a pragmatic feminist. I married when i did because of death in service and other benefits specific to our jobs at the time (both military). It made a lot of things much much easier without us having to think about them at all.

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2022 08:33

Andypandy799 · 29/11/2022 06:35

A very strange view of marriage based on money.

So if a women earns more then don’t get married but if your a sahm then get married? Sounds very grabby to me and misandrist?

But marriage evolved to protect women from the effects of men’s infidelity and fecklessness from a time when it was virtually impossible for women to work. And to guarantee the man’s bloodline.

Neither of these is relavant to me as I am financially independent and not going to have any more children. So while I understand that marriage is a very useful tool for women who are disadvantaged financially I don’t feel the need to respect any of the woo elements of marriage (romance and all that). They were always at best just window dressing on a financial contract.

And I certainly don’t feel any obligation to provide financial protection to an able bodied man.

MVDC · 29/11/2022 08:23

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 07:47

The cowardly op hasn’t returned. What a shock.

Eh, I've posted multiple times, and answered the main questions - opinion is split, I've learnt what I needed to, and I have no interest is engaging with the pile on! Not cowardly, just busy.

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 29/11/2022 08:19

MVDC · 27/11/2022 10:01

She said "we're thinking about having a baby soon, what do you think?" And I said I thought she should consider getting married first.

Well there you have it.
I've always been very practical and see marriage as a legal protection...but if I announced that I was thinking of having a baby to my friend and that was their first reaction rather than "oh my gosh how exciting!" And maybe whether or not they could see me as a mother...yeah I'd be a bit pissed off too....

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 08:07

if your friend is in the weaker financial position now, will have to fund her own maternity leave, may put herself at a financial disadvantage by being a SAHM then you're not wrong she should be married.

However. If she is in the stronger financial position of the two and can easily afford ML and will go back to work (unless independently wealthy) then marriage is not an advantage.

She should make the decision that strengthens her position not weakens it.

NextPrimeMinister · 29/11/2022 07:50

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 07:47

The cowardly op hasn’t returned. What a shock.

Bit mean.

CliantheLang · 29/11/2022 07:48

Sounds very grabby to me and misandrist?

Are men able to have babies, yet?

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 07:47

The cowardly op hasn’t returned. What a shock.

Spambod · 29/11/2022 07:45

HippeePrincess · 27/11/2022 09:31

I’d tell you to fuck off if you said that to me, I put 1/3 of the value of out home as a deposit, I earn more, and I will be going back to work. How would marriage benefit me?

With respect I think you’re being naive. What if you want or need to take more maternity leave, what if your circumstances change dramatically over the next 10 years. You lose your job, become disabled. Your child is disabled.

Swipe left for the next trending thread