Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not send Christmas presents this year?

63 replies

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 07:18

MN I need some help.

I've realised this year that my personal boundaries have been virtually non-existent and I've been putting up with various dynamics to keep the peace / not upset anyone / keep friendships. However I think it is too late and lots of people in my life have been walking all over me for a long time so I'm in the process of working out which are the healthy and unhealthy relationships. Cue letting various ones drift.

My AIBU is that for some years I've been friendly with an aunt of mine. My aunt has never had kids but does have a brother who I'm not close to and a father who has dementia and is very unwell who she has cared for for years.

In May I flew up to Scotland to see my aunt, it was the second time I'd gone up to see her and I left my husband on his own with the kids for four days to do so, my aunt asked me to go and spend her birthday with her as she said she didn't have anyone to spend it with. I decided to go, bought the flight tickets, got my aunt a really nice birthday gift, lovely hand bag and other bits, gifts for her father and when there i paid for the two meals we had out. I was generous but I wanted to be. However shortly after I got back, she started messaging me asking me to give a donation for a charity event she was doing that was close to her heart. She ended up sending three separate messages asking me for donation money so I ended up sending the cheque she sent me in June for my birthday for £25 back to her towards the charity event.

AIBU that I feel offended that I felt harassed to give her money when I'd already been generous in my own opinion?

Also given that I made such an effort for my aunt actually going to see her flights, gifts and meals when I was there, and then my birthday cheque returned towards her charity event would it be reasonable to say there won't be Christmas presents this year hope she understands because I put so much into her birthday this year? I am still so upset about it I haven't spoken to her on the phone since the trip just the odd text message.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 13:08

Yes shiny in retrospect I shouldn't have been so generous because I feel its caused problems! Lols. As judge Judy says, no good turn goes unpunished! I wanted to treat my aunt as I felt we were good friends. Maybe I shouldn't have gone so mad. Again lesson learnt.

OP posts:
shinynewapple22 · 27/11/2022 12:31

HotChicolate · 27/11/2022 08:40

The charity thing and the birthday aren’t related you need to separate them in your mind.

This.

I think you made a mistake in spending such a huge amount of money on the birthday visit . You aunt asked if you could visit . Buying her a handbag and then the two meals out was your choice - and to be honest if this was your family budget and your DC have gone without because of this expenditure then you were in the wrong .

How did it come about that you paid for the two meals out when you were visiting ?

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 12:07

Thanks Hot, noted for next time! Will be clearer next time.

OP posts:
HotChicolate · 27/11/2022 12:06

Im sure one clear no would have stopped future requests for the donation.

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 11:28

Asking me once for a donation would have been fine i would have understood that.

OP posts:
Baconking · 27/11/2022 10:47

Your aunt didn't ask you to spend £400 for her birthday, that was your own doing.

If she was doing an event for charity you usually are encouraged to raise a minimum amount so she was probably just trying to reach her goal. She had no reason to suspect you couldn't afford it seeing as you were flashing the cash for her birthday

HotChicolate · 27/11/2022 10:32

Can you not see being generous to your aunt and being generous to a charity are two completely separate things?

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 10:30

£400 was a lot of money for us to spend on something not for our family - dh and kids - if that makes sense. I was surprised by and ended up resenting being asked to donate to charity when I felt I had already v recently been generous. It felt as though I was being used a bit tbh. If I had asked her and she'd said she would wait to see if she had any money left after a family trip I definitely wouldn't have asked again I would have left it.

OP posts:
LikeTearsInRain · 27/11/2022 09:42

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 07:18

MN I need some help.

I've realised this year that my personal boundaries have been virtually non-existent and I've been putting up with various dynamics to keep the peace / not upset anyone / keep friendships. However I think it is too late and lots of people in my life have been walking all over me for a long time so I'm in the process of working out which are the healthy and unhealthy relationships. Cue letting various ones drift.

My AIBU is that for some years I've been friendly with an aunt of mine. My aunt has never had kids but does have a brother who I'm not close to and a father who has dementia and is very unwell who she has cared for for years.

In May I flew up to Scotland to see my aunt, it was the second time I'd gone up to see her and I left my husband on his own with the kids for four days to do so, my aunt asked me to go and spend her birthday with her as she said she didn't have anyone to spend it with. I decided to go, bought the flight tickets, got my aunt a really nice birthday gift, lovely hand bag and other bits, gifts for her father and when there i paid for the two meals we had out. I was generous but I wanted to be. However shortly after I got back, she started messaging me asking me to give a donation for a charity event she was doing that was close to her heart. She ended up sending three separate messages asking me for donation money so I ended up sending the cheque she sent me in June for my birthday for £25 back to her towards the charity event.

AIBU that I feel offended that I felt harassed to give her money when I'd already been generous in my own opinion?

Also given that I made such an effort for my aunt actually going to see her flights, gifts and meals when I was there, and then my birthday cheque returned towards her charity event would it be reasonable to say there won't be Christmas presents this year hope she understands because I put so much into her birthday this year? I am still so upset about it I haven't spoken to her on the phone since the trip just the odd text message.

When first asked for the donation, why not just say you can’t afford it after having the trip and birthday celebrations? I get the impression you probably just ignored the messages about the charity event? Or you could have just offered a token £5/£10 and given the same reasons for why you can’t afford too much. You sound fairly close and her fairly lonely so I suspect she viewed you as one of the few reliable people she could get a donation from for her fundraising. So I think YABU here to basically have gone off her for daring to try and save face and raise a decent amount, by asking one of the closest people to her to support her.

If you don’t want to spend more money on her after the expensive trip just let her know you want to agree a small budget for Christmas this year because of that?

rookiemere · 27/11/2022 09:41

Actually on rereading this, I hope your aunt isn't getting harassed by charity chuggers. I've read somewhere that they can be quite relentless in their harassment, if they feel they can get more money out of a vulnerable person. Asking for a specific amount would buy into that theory as well.

Small presents only if you must I agree, but if she asks for charity money again, than maybe phone her up and make sure she isn't under pressure from someone.

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:38

Thanks everyone for your opinions, very helpful!!

OP posts:
CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:36

Summer fun I have always been generous and sent gifts fo my aunt and uncle and great uncle but haven't spoken to my aunt on my phone since the charity stuff.

Also I'm not made of money! Whatever my aunt thinks. I made the effort to go because she was important to me but I do feel the way she has behaved since wirh rhe charity stuff eg messaging for money while we were aaay has been inappropriate tbh.

I think I'm going to send small gifts for the three of them this year.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 27/11/2022 09:34

She will have believed you visited her because you wanted to spend that time and money on having a lovely trip rather than it being spent solely on her. And yes’m your generosity will have led her to believe you have plenty of money. Add to that a family holiday- more spare cash.

Im not saying this is true but she will have read it that way and it does sound as if you didn’t begrudge any of the expenses until she started asking for money.

She shouldn’t have kept asking but you should have told her straight away that you couldn’t help on this occasion.

So now learn from all of this and communicate with her and tell her money is tight and you won’t be doing gifts this year. If you’ve always had a nice relationship it’s a shame to let this spoil things.

Summerfun54321 · 27/11/2022 09:32

Is your motivation for not sending Christmas presents financial or spiteful? You need to communicate better with your aunt. All of these things were within your control: visiting, the birthday, giving money to charity… It seems a shame to punish your aunt for you not being able to assert yourself or for overspending and feeling resentful.

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:28

I have heard from other family members that she had been also pursuing them for sponsorship, yes so I'm not the only one.

In future a strong no is needed earlier, I will accept that. I've just not had someone keep asking over and over in that way for a donation before. Re the cheque, why would I drive half an hour to thr nearest bank to pay in a cheque to write another one when I could just send that one back? It was for near enough what my aunt was asking for anyway.

OP posts:
curtaindrawn · 27/11/2022 09:19

I would hate being pressured for money but ....

I agree with PP you need to be clear and spell it out, some people genuinely aren't great at reading social signals. It's not always premeditated. If they are genuinely trying to take the piss then being clear and upfront is better at shutting it down. Next time just be honest when she asks. If she persists then you can be annoyed or better still you can say "you've asked me before and I said no so why are you still asking? - the answer is still no" and there won't be any confusion.

I think it's a stretch to think she'll consider what you spent on her birthday in relation to your other spending (if anything she'll probably conclude you must be good for the £20). She's asking for money for charity not for you to pay for another meal so it's not like she is looking to personally benefit.

Does she have lots of friends? Could it be that you are one of the few people she can ask for sponsorship and maybe she won't make that much money without you? She might be more persistent in that case.

Physically sending a cheque back is a bit rude and unnecessary in IMO.

I'd just try and move past it, unless she has form for this. Next time be clearer and blunter when she asks

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:17

Ps it was the relentless asking for money/ telling me I was late to donate / asking twice for a donation when I was away on holiday that made me feel strange.

OP posts:
CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:15

I didn't mind being asked once but being asked multiple times and feeling 'chased' for a donation has been perplexing and painful tbh! I felt as though my aunt was going to keep mentioning the event until I donated. My aunt was very happy to receive the birthday cheque back. Just cane away from the whole situation feeling strange after what had been a nice visit.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 27/11/2022 09:07

Your Daunt thinks you're rolling in it rather than being generous to her.

I'd message and say you aren't doing presents this year and donating to your favourite charity instead.

In future grow a backbone- you aren't obliged to donate to anyone's charity and she was rude to ask multiple times.

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 09:02

Thanks LittleBitAcorn but I've answered your points in my previous few posts.

OP posts:
LittleBitAcorn · 27/11/2022 08:56

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 08:42

HotChicolate it's still my family money though so comes out of our one family pot. So in that way they are linked iyswim.

Where the money cones from doesn't matter, it doesn't link them. One event was for your Aunt (birthday) and the other is for charity, very seperate things.

Sending the cheque back doesn't make a 'point' - it's just rude.

I think you clearly begrudge the birthday expense - in future, don't do things you begrudge doing and don't expect people to read your mind when you say things in code or do things to make a 'point'.

I think you have a distorted view on things, OP. A normal response would have been to just tell her that you couldn't donate and to have thought no more about it.

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 08:56

My aunt asked specifically for £20.

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 27/11/2022 08:55

I do think you're massively over thinking this, sorry. She was just asking for a fiver to do something sponsored for charity. I would have just sent it. Not spat out my dummy returning a birthday cheque. She probably thinks you're never speaking to her again because of it, what a shame because she's family. If you felt that strongly about charity, you could have called her up and said no thanks. I hope you make up, life's too short.

Funkyslippers · 27/11/2022 08:54

Also you didn't need to go out for 2 meals. Her birthday is only 1 day. I bet she loved that! But I wouldn't let someone pay that much for me as well as the cost of flights

CottonEyeJodie · 27/11/2022 08:53

Exhaustedbuthappy22 yes that's what I did after the third time i was asked for a donation I said I gave to my own charity and then I got further messages about her preparing for thr charity event and it sort of felt so awkward after her continuing to ask for donations that my aunt was still referring to the charity event that's when I decided to send the cheque back.

I've been working on my boundaries and realise I have to trust my intuition more. The situation felt off and as though I was being badly thought of / judged for being mean! It's difficult to explain.

OP posts: