Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not stop DD playing her French Horn just because it annoys my neighbour

319 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:07

Disclaimer: There was no one more unhappy than me when, last year after DD got to pick an instrument to play at school, she picked the bloody French Horn and not something more reasonable 😂 but sometimes life throws us a child with a penchant for annoying instruments

Anyway. 9yo DD plays French horn. I spend a small fortune keeping her in peripatetic 1-2-1 lessons because she’s good. She’s got a concert in the local cathedral next month and is playing 2 Christmas songs as part of a brass group and one solo. She’s bricking it bless her. We live in an end terrace. Her room is the one at the end side of the end (ie furthest away from neighbours) so she practises in there. 30 minutes after school and then an hour on Saturdays and Sundays. Wouldn’t usually practise so much but this concert means a lot to her and she wants to do well

Anyway she was playing at 1pm today for an hour and the neighbour came banging on the door. Said he’s sick of it, it’s every day and disturbing his lie-in! I said sorry but she’s got a concert to practice for it won’t be forever. He then moaned because when we first moved in we asked him to stop playing his music at full blast (Taylor swift mainly, as if life isn’t hard enough). But he was playing it from 5pm-9pm, in his bedroom which shares a wall with my 5yo! Which he has done again tonight.

it can’t be that loud, it can barely be heard from the far room (DS’s). But WIBU to carry on as normal? It’s not unsociable hours, and it’s only for another 2 weeks.

OP posts:
FourChimneys · 28/11/2022 07:50

If children are not allowed to practice their musical instruments regularly, where will the musicians of the future come from?

It is not possible to reach a professional standard on 20 minutes a couple of times a week.

My friend's DS was doing up to 4 or 5 hours a day in his teens and is now playing with one of the top orchestras in the country. That opportunity should not be denied to everyone but detached house dwellers.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/11/2022 07:33

I don't think you should stop dd from practising at all, and it would be totally unreasonable for him to expect this. Unfortunately, I think you have probably created this problem for yourself by complaining about his music. Playing music until 9pm is not unreasonable in my view, and some level of noise is inevitable in a terraced house - you just have to suck it up/work around it.

araucanadendrophobia · 28/11/2022 07:23

Yes you're being unreasonable, you have to be considerate of your neighbours if you live in a terraced house. If you want to practise musical instruments move to a detached house or find a practise room.

oakleaffy · 28/11/2022 07:23

Probably the only instrument that sounds pleasant when being practiced is Flute.
Have lived in two places where someone far distant played the flute, and the tumbling sounds drifting across the air was lovely
It provokes a deep nostalgia if I hear it now.

Cello is pleasant too- Deep and resonant, but most other instruments can be hard to listen to.

A Mute is a good idea.

Summysoom · 28/11/2022 07:14

FrippEnos · 27/11/2022 17:12

Going to amend that.

He is not the only one at fault here

True. I should have said that. I might have missed this suggestion but has OP asked the neighbour if she can come in to his house to listen? Might be helpful to hear what he’s hearing.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 27/11/2022 23:33

converseandjeans · 27/11/2022 00:19

That said teenagers can't win - at least she is doing something worthwhile.

She is 9. Not a teenager.

notnowB · 27/11/2022 22:42

Your timings are totally reasonable!

Spiderboy · 27/11/2022 22:14

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 09:56

It’s much less annoying when as far away as possible.

Cool so maybe drive DD to a nice remote field for practice

converseandjeans · 27/11/2022 22:02

Well you asked AIBU and most people have tried to suggest ways you can try to minimise the noise. But you seem intent on continuing with the noise anyway 🤷🏻‍♀️

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/11/2022 17:17

I was going to suggest a trumpet mute too!

We have trombone, cello, piano, guitar and clarinet being playing in this house. Thank god we are end of terrace and until now our only joined on neighbour is quite deaf. She’s moving though and I’m bricking it about the new neighbours if I’m honest!

FrippEnos · 27/11/2022 17:12

FrippEnos · 27/11/2022 17:06

Summysoom

As the next door neighbour was quiet when asked until the OP's DD started making noise.
He is not the one at fault here.

Going to amend that.

He is not the only one at fault here

FrippEnos · 27/11/2022 17:06

Summysoom

As the next door neighbour was quiet when asked until the OP's DD started making noise.
He is not the one at fault here.

Summysoom · 27/11/2022 16:51

I wonder why the neighbour can’t use wireless headphones (not expensive these days) to listen to Taylor Swift or whatever. That way he can play it as loud as he chooses, go deaf and won’t hear the French Horn. Also agree that a mute is reasonable for your daughter to use for her practice.
Having lived mid terrace for a few years with members of a band living on one side and Bob Dylan fans on the other, my DH and I mortgaged ourselves to the hilt to be detached for the next house. A wreck but our quiet wreck.
Good luck OP. I think your daughter sounds like a star but it is vital you can reach some kind of compromise with your neighbour.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 27/11/2022 16:42

I started out as YANBU but your replies have made me feel like changing my mind. 😂

stuntbubbles · 27/11/2022 16:25

ohlookout · 27/11/2022 15:49

I never understand the people that post asking if they're being unreasonable, and when they're told that they are, just deny it and argue with everyone. What's the point of posting in the first place?

To entertain me; it’s my favourite kind of thread and why I can’t quit MN.

FlamencoDance · 27/11/2022 16:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster’s request.

ErrolTheDragon · 27/11/2022 15:50

ohlookout · 27/11/2022 15:49

I never understand the people that post asking if they're being unreasonable, and when they're told that they are, just deny it and argue with everyone. What's the point of posting in the first place?

They're not arguing with everyone, some people think the op isn't BU.

ohlookout · 27/11/2022 15:49

I never understand the people that post asking if they're being unreasonable, and when they're told that they are, just deny it and argue with everyone. What's the point of posting in the first place?

Siriusmuggle · 27/11/2022 15:48

I’m only here for the French horn love. My son is a horn player, hoping to become a pro. In lockdown he practiced with all the windows open, thankfully our neighbours liked it!
You could try a practice mute. Could she practice at lunchtime at school a couple of days a week? The world needs horn players- decent ones are in demand.

surreygirl1987 · 27/11/2022 15:46

No... it's 9pm in a room with a party wall with a 5yos bedroom vs 1pm in a room on the other side of the house to his

Oh come on, either way it's unwelcome noise. It's petty for the OP to say 'but it's not the same'.

OP, I'm just glad I don't live next door to either of you (in fact, this is one reason we sacrificed on location to buy a detached house). You are BOTH being unreasonable as you are both making unwelcome noise. Sure, technically he can do nothing about it, and no doubt your daughter will carry on making that noise. He does have a right to dislike it though - I would!

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 27/11/2022 15:34

It's a fine time to practice and I view musical instrument practice differently to recorded music blasting out, because the one is mastering a skill and educational , and the other is just antisocial. BUT, to him it might be very irritating and not see the difference.

Get a mute for her instrument and get her to play in the part of the house which is furthest away from his, with the windows shut and curtains drawn. Perhaps ask him what times would be most convenient. Does he work late nights or shifts in the week? Or is he just up gaming or drinking until 4am? This does make a difference in my opinion but again might not in his.

I say all this not because I think he has a right to dictate but because he might never stop playing his fecking music (and might play it later or louder) if you don't meet him 3/4 of the way to what he wants and this would disrupt you and your children massively.

Is there somewhere else that she can go to practice, such as a Grandparent's house, or before or after school in the music room? She'll feel less stressed and will gain more from the practice if she is relaxed while doing it.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/11/2022 15:31

Have read all of your posts @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet and YANBU. It’s an hour a day at a reasonable time. I genuinely don’t know how anyone can say that’s unreasonable? If he was a shift worker or something then he could ask you if she could practice at a different time. But it’s unreasonable to think she shouldn’t.

BareGrylls · 27/11/2022 15:27

Even if it were a professional concert pianist I wouldn't want to hear it every day. A small child learning a loud annoying instrument would be appalling.

KatherineJaneway · 27/11/2022 15:16

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 10:06

You think I should stop my DD practising all together?

I never said that. I think you need to find somewhere else for her to practice. You asked him to pipe down with his music, he did. He has told you your daughter's playing disturbs him, so now you need to pipe down.

BassoonsandOrgansandPianos · 27/11/2022 15:13

You're perfectly fine! The French Horn is already a difficult instrument as it is - that should be the extent of DD's worries - and that's incredible that she already wants to practice every day! As far as noise goes, changing instruments won't change the amount of noise, and only having DD play softly will harm her playing greatly in the future. I see that people are recommending mutes, and they are a good thing to have - if DD continues with the French Horn (and I hope she does!) -she'll need the mutes anyway. However, the goal of a mute is to change the sound of the instrument, not just make it softer. So DD will need to play just as loudly and softly no matter if it's muted or not. Practice mutes are good for noise reduction though, as that is their primary goal, but I wouldn't recommend her playing with one in all the time because that will mess with her head when she needs to play without it.
Tl;dr: Your neighbor is complaining about something that's not worth being an issue. She should continue to practice every day and as she builds up experience, she should practice for a longer period. Worst comes to worst, you could always ask if she could practice somewhere in the church, in a community center, or with a friend that also plays an instrument!
Best of luck with your AH neighbor though, maybe he should see if he can rent another bubble to live in!