Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not stop DD playing her French Horn just because it annoys my neighbour

319 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:07

Disclaimer: There was no one more unhappy than me when, last year after DD got to pick an instrument to play at school, she picked the bloody French Horn and not something more reasonable 😂 but sometimes life throws us a child with a penchant for annoying instruments

Anyway. 9yo DD plays French horn. I spend a small fortune keeping her in peripatetic 1-2-1 lessons because she’s good. She’s got a concert in the local cathedral next month and is playing 2 Christmas songs as part of a brass group and one solo. She’s bricking it bless her. We live in an end terrace. Her room is the one at the end side of the end (ie furthest away from neighbours) so she practises in there. 30 minutes after school and then an hour on Saturdays and Sundays. Wouldn’t usually practise so much but this concert means a lot to her and she wants to do well

Anyway she was playing at 1pm today for an hour and the neighbour came banging on the door. Said he’s sick of it, it’s every day and disturbing his lie-in! I said sorry but she’s got a concert to practice for it won’t be forever. He then moaned because when we first moved in we asked him to stop playing his music at full blast (Taylor swift mainly, as if life isn’t hard enough). But he was playing it from 5pm-9pm, in his bedroom which shares a wall with my 5yo! Which he has done again tonight.

it can’t be that loud, it can barely be heard from the far room (DS’s). But WIBU to carry on as normal? It’s not unsociable hours, and it’s only for another 2 weeks.

OP posts:
Roundandnour · 27/11/2022 01:00

If it wasn’t loud the neighbour wouldn’t be able to hear it would they?

Roundandnour · 27/11/2022 00:58

Noise abatement orders include loud musical instruments. If a complaint is made the council have a duty of care to investigate, and advise on how to record the noise.

Noise disturbances are any that unreasonably and substantially disturb the use or enjoyment or a home for example.

People assume that noise is only a problem when it’s after a certain time of the day.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:56

Alvinne · 27/11/2022 00:54

Its not his fault the 5yo is in the room next to his. 9pm isn't unsociable.

Of course it’s unsociable when you’re playing full blast music!

OP posts:
thewolfandthesheep · 27/11/2022 00:56

Ignore the neighbour. I had a friend who played it, very difficult, a lot of respect for your daughter here. Play well and prosper ! Timing and length : It's perfectly fine.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:55

cynicbuthappy · 27/11/2022 00:54

I think, as a PP said, that the neighbour is going to have to put up with the practice. A mute is a solution but not for the entirety of the practice, as tone quality is important. It’s a balance when living in terraced housing.
But, please keep encouraging her. I have travelled the world, performed in major venues, and most importantly made life long friendships because I played the horn. It’s definitely the best instrument to play!

Aw that’s so nice to hear! She struggles with confidence a lot but she loves playing the horn because it’s something she knows she good at so really boosts her

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:54

ErrolTheDragon · 27/11/2022 00:52

It sounds like you weren't happy to have Taylor Swift but think your neighbour should just suck it up because he is a grown up.

No... it's 9pm in a room with a party wall with a 5yos bedroom vs 1pm in a room on the other side of the house to his.

Yes exactly, the two aren’t the same.

I get that with living in a terrace you ah e to tolerate other people’s noise a bit but it’s one thing tolerating noise and the other playing loud (shit) music late at night knowing full well it’s disturbing a child on the other side.

OP posts:
MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 27/11/2022 00:54

1pm isn't early and 9pm isn't late.

You both live in a terrace and you're both going to have to learn to live with noise. So shake it off...

Alvinne · 27/11/2022 00:54

Its not his fault the 5yo is in the room next to his. 9pm isn't unsociable.

cynicbuthappy · 27/11/2022 00:54

I think, as a PP said, that the neighbour is going to have to put up with the practice. A mute is a solution but not for the entirety of the practice, as tone quality is important. It’s a balance when living in terraced housing.
But, please keep encouraging her. I have travelled the world, performed in major venues, and most importantly made life long friendships because I played the horn. It’s definitely the best instrument to play!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:53

As I’ve said I’m not sure she’ll be able to practice at school, I’m not sure if they use few the rooms they have already for after school clubs. It’s only another 2 weeks and we will go back to twice weekly practices. We already have all the doors closed and her turning towards the outside wall - like I say I’ve been in DS’s room when she’s played and can barely hear it so there’s no way it’s that noisy for the neighbour

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 27/11/2022 00:52

It sounds like you weren't happy to have Taylor Swift but think your neighbour should just suck it up because he is a grown up.

No... it's 9pm in a room with a party wall with a 5yos bedroom vs 1pm in a room on the other side of the house to his.

prawncocktailwithdill · 27/11/2022 00:51

stuntbubbles · 27/11/2022 00:49

You’ve asked him to compromise and turn down his Taylor Swift, but you’re unwilling to compromise and have her practice at school one or two evenings because it would mean an extra school run?! I’d say you’re looking at another two weeks of Shake It Off on the party wall, at least.

Bring it on, Taytay Envy

stuntbubbles · 27/11/2022 00:49

You’ve asked him to compromise and turn down his Taylor Swift, but you’re unwilling to compromise and have her practice at school one or two evenings because it would mean an extra school run?! I’d say you’re looking at another two weeks of Shake It Off on the party wall, at least.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:49

Roundandnour · 27/11/2022 00:48

IIf had asked a neighbour to be considerate and they carried on well good look to them. If a neighbour asked me to quieten down and I did only for them to start making noise in a regular basis I would and have taken things further using whatever legal means are available.

I don’t think he will manage to get an injunction on a French horn played for a little while in the afternoon by a child

OP posts:
Roundandnour · 27/11/2022 00:48

IIf had asked a neighbour to be considerate and they carried on well good look to them. If a neighbour asked me to quieten down and I did only for them to start making noise in a regular basis I would and have taken things further using whatever legal means are available.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:47

cynicbuthappy · 27/11/2022 00:45

Can she practice at school? I used to stay after school and use the practice rooms.
I’m not excusing the neighbour, but it would by better if she was able to practice stress free.

Probably not every night, that also means doing 2 school runs or hanging around 5 days a week when we have activities and other things booked.

OP posts:
JonahAndTheSnail · 27/11/2022 00:47

It sounds like he's picked up on this to complain about in response to you previously complaining about him playing music. Neither 9pm at night (for him) or 1pm (for you) are considered 'anti-social' hours for noise. However, both would be equally annoying if you don't personally want to listen to it, so it's very much a case of pick your battles or deal with the consequences.

prawncocktailwithdill · 27/11/2022 00:47

Byelaws · 27/11/2022 00:43

It’s noise - the concert, cause or passion is completely irrelevant.

You don’t like noise at 6pm and he doesn’t like noise at 1pm. You deserve each other.

Taylor Swift is noise, a child practicing an instrument is a happy sound of childhood.
Stick them on a screen, right? YABVU

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:46

And there's nothing wrong with normal noise at 9pm

Sonce when was full blast music ‘normal noise’. Especially next to a shared wall.

OP posts:
atomickitty · 27/11/2022 00:46

Brass player here- a mute is a good idea though it does affect how the instrument feels and can also make intonation (making sure you’re not slightly sharp or flat) a bit trickier. Developing intonation is a really important skill that takes years, so honestly if she’s quite a new player I’d say neighbour will have to put up with at least some unmuted playing.

I wonder if DD’s teacher has mutes of their own that she could try out? Teacher might also be able to help her get used to the difference when playing with a mute.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:45

Shouldershoddy · 27/11/2022 00:44

Does your neighbour work at night ?

I don’t think so, he’s always in but I don’t hear him during the day usually

OP posts:
cynicbuthappy · 27/11/2022 00:45

Can she practice at school? I used to stay after school and use the practice rooms.
I’m not excusing the neighbour, but it would by better if she was able to practice stress free.

justanotherthrowawayname · 27/11/2022 00:45

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:38

He played it full blast at night next to a shared wall.

If he’d done it at 1pm and 4pm like DD does I wouldn’t care.

And unless he’s practising for a Taylor Swift record playing competition I don’t think the causes are the same.

I was sympathetic until you wrote that.

The noise your child makes isn't any more worthy than the noise he makes. You're both noisy and annoying other people.

And there's nothing wrong with normal noise at 9pm. Most adults are awake at that time. Your idea of normal hours doesn't trump his idea of normal hours just because you have kids.

Actually, the Taylor Swift would have been less annoying because it would definitely be in tune and not broken up. You know yourself that practising with an instrument doesn't always sound amazing - that's the point of practice! You start and stop and the notes aren't always right.

If you want to be reasonable, you should both have a civilised conversation of when you both think noisy hours/days should be. There's a compromise to be had, e.g. 2pm to 6pm on both sides.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 27/11/2022 00:44

Byelaws · 27/11/2022 00:43

It’s noise - the concert, cause or passion is completely irrelevant.

You don’t like noise at 6pm and he doesn’t like noise at 1pm. You deserve each other.

I don’t like the Taylor Swift at 9pm. 6pm is not a problem.

OP posts:
Shouldershoddy · 27/11/2022 00:44

Does your neighbour work at night ?