Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister charging me?

303 replies

Arewerrallydoingthisnow · 26/11/2022 22:37

I genuinely can’t work out if I’m being unreasonable. We have v little cash at the moment - nursery fees, mortgage increases, I’m working 2 jobs, kids at state schools etc - much like a lot of the population. Sister does not work. Her husbands family are RICH. So in fact not only does she not work, but he doesn’t either. They live off family money, have 2 kids in private school (paid for), a big house mortgage free, and expenses / cars etc paid for by family money.
i have been trying to sort some stuff in my house on a shoestring recently and after having redecorated our living room myself in evenings between kids and jobs etc I asked if she would have any time to bring over her carpet cleaner and help me move everything back as husband at work during days. She said yes great - came and helped and cleaned the carpets for us with her machine and spent some hours helping me sort everything out again. Note again neither she nor her husband work and both kids in school during the day. I was very grateful and asked her husband what she liked at the moment to buy her a gift to say thank you. To cut a long story short she then called and said she would invoice me for hours she’d spent helping and that when she got help in it was around £15/hr so she thought that was reasonable.
i was shocked as I cannot afford that for a start and would never ever have asked if I knew it came with a cost attached, but moreover I’m devastated about the reflection on our relationship that help is boiled down to a transactional cost. And with no prior warning at all. Aibu? Should I expect to pay?

OP posts:
AllyCatTown · 27/11/2022 11:41

That’s mad to have paid but I sort of get your reasoning. How do you see the relationship going forward?

MinnieGirl · 27/11/2022 11:40

You’ve paid her, so there is no perceived debt in her side…..
But I would be heartbroken, especially if you usually get on fine.
I would leave it for a week, and then send her a message. Some thing in the lines of:
I am so upset and heartbroken that my own sister would choose to invoice me when I asked for a hand. Knowing we are on the breadline. Knowing we could not afford to hire a machine never mind pay out for services. Yet you chose to ignore that and ask for payment. You are my sister. I will always love you, but due to your greed our relationship will never be the same. Please take some time to reflect on the consequences of your greedy actions, and also know that we will be eating less this week as we had to pay you for your “services”.

Toomanysleepycats · 27/11/2022 11:37

A few years ago my single brother asked for help cleaning before a move out.

I took my steam cleaner and carpet washer and spent about six hours working really hard. I was totally exhausted by the time I got home.

I did not charge him. It never crossed my mind to think he owed me anything other than a thankyou.

I was just pleased that when he moved out the LL said it was cleaner than when he had moved in, and they hadn’t noticed that my heavy duty steam cleaner had sandblasted some of the paint of the skirtings boards!

cookiesbeforepookies · 27/11/2022 11:28

I would seriously reassess my relationship with her.

Don’t ask for a thing from now on and don’t do her any favours. No childcare, no meals, no chores, no nothing.

Just keep it formal and polite.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 27/11/2022 11:27

Why the hell did you take this from savings? Cut her off

ErinAndTonic · 27/11/2022 11:18

I can't believe you paid her -

I mean I can understand why you did to just move on and out and end to it. But how cheeky is she!

I agree money is irrelevant and I often help friends/family and if I planned to charge for something a) I'd mention it upfront and b) it would be because I was particularly skilled at it! Most people would just offer up a takeaway or a token thank you item.

She's a giant tit.

xJ0y · 27/11/2022 11:17

That is so odd. You either help your sibling or you say no I can't. You don't help and then Charge them!!
I'd ask her if he is financially abusing her?

Mirabai · 27/11/2022 11:11

It’s a terrible shame you paid her OP and so much.

Leaving the family angle aside for which she is a terrible human being - it’s totally unprofessional to charge for services you have not quoted for beforehand, let alone not having notified there would be a charge.

So even if she were a professional carpet cleaner and this was her bread and butter she was still in the wrong.

cherish123 · 27/11/2022 10:55

Definitely bill her for lunch and itemise it.

Changechangychange · 27/11/2022 10:54

Morph22010 · 27/11/2022 09:02

You can be paid cash in hand £1000 a year and it’s not taxable so she’s not doing anything wrong and hmrc wouldn’t be interested

I know that. That is assuming she has no other passive income though, which if her family are wealthy she might (investment properties in her name etc). You also have to declare it, which I bet she doesn’t. And the tax office also doesn’t know whether or not this £100 is the only time she’s charged somebody.

healthadvice123 · 27/11/2022 10:35

@daisychain01 mates rates applies to someone who runs a business
Its a carpet cleaner she borrowed , The OP sister does not run a business
You seem to be getting that confused with things
My dh was. Self employed builder if he did building work for family they would expect to pay , if he picked them up from train station or helped carry some furniture he wouldn't bill them
£15 per hr is what a lot of companies would charge , ones who have overheads and insurance
She also sat and had lunch which she seems to of invoiced for

Goldpaw · 27/11/2022 10:33

Arewerrallydoingthisnow · 26/11/2022 23:57

We paid up - took it out of savings. I figured either she does need the money in which case if this is a cry for help - then I’d be helping her.
if it’s not a cry for help - and to be clear I do not think it is, they have a lot of luxury extras which she buys herself just for her, so I think she has fair control of money - well if it’s just her being a terrible person then I don’t want to ever feel like I owe her any favours or in debt to her and move on with a totally changed view of our relationship.

Oh well, she saw you coming!

Helpmephrasethis · 27/11/2022 10:32

Please text her and tell her that there is a problem with the carpet she cleaned and you need her insurance

Helpmephrasethis · 27/11/2022 10:32

I can’t believe you paid her

i would have lent you my carpet cleaner for free

Iwantamarshmallowman · 27/11/2022 10:29

Op I'm so sorry. This must he very painfull. My sister used to pull some funny things like this sometimes. Turns out our abusive mother was playing us off against each other and telling us both wicked lies about the other.
what's the relationship with your sister usually like?
Personally I would pull away now, go low contact and if she asks what's wrong I would tell her how hurt you are.

Purplecatshopaholic · 27/11/2022 10:28

I can’t believe you paid her! That’s on you. Although this relationship won’t be the same now either way I guess.

Zilla1 · 27/11/2022 10:27

Might make any Christmas and birthday presents for respective families/children and social meals interesting the the future. Good luck, OP.

healthadvice123 · 27/11/2022 10:26

@daisychain01 your bil situation is not the same as he runs a business so if you asked for solar panels you would be asking for him to do his job
The OP sister does not run a business , has no insurance or public liability and OP asked to borrow a carpet cleaner , I mean I would lend my neighbour my carpet cleaner
And they cleaned together a normal favour families do
£15 per hr OP could of hired someone

Notmysolution · 27/11/2022 10:22

moreover I’m devastated about the reflection on our relationship that help is boiled down to a transactional cost

Its this isn't it? Tell her this.

Helpmephrasethis · 27/11/2022 10:22

JennyMule · 26/11/2022 22:47

"Dear DSis,
I have now had time to reflect on our discussion, during which you told me that you would be invoicing me for your time/labour." Please note that I will not be making any payment; had I intended to engage a paid for service I would have obtained 3 quotations from professional carpet cleaning companies. Had you wished to bid for the work I would have been happy to allow you to quote, and to agree a price before the job began.
I regret any misunderstanding regarding the basis on which you were helping me - ie for free, because you are my sister, and with no payment being offered or requested beforehand. I wish you the very best with your new carpet cleaning venture and would be more than happy to let all the family and our friends know that you are open for business."

This is what I would send.

what a cow.

you don’t bill someone after

PenelopeTitsDrop3121 · 27/11/2022 10:18

whowhatwerewhy · 27/11/2022 10:16

I would message her , hi I've discovered a problem with the carpet you cleaned, let me know how I claim off you ( presumably as a business you have liability insurance).

Brilliant 😊

PenelopeTitsDrop3121 · 27/11/2022 10:17

Arewerrallydoingthisnow · 27/11/2022 00:03

It was a full day!! So about £105!! She was here for the full day to be fair - but we had lunch etc as part of that!

Who bought lunch? If you did,I'd be asking for the money back for that.

JennyJenny8675309 · 27/11/2022 10:16

JennyMule · 26/11/2022 22:47

"Dear DSis,
I have now had time to reflect on our discussion, during which you told me that you would be invoicing me for your time/labour." Please note that I will not be making any payment; had I intended to engage a paid for service I would have obtained 3 quotations from professional carpet cleaning companies. Had you wished to bid for the work I would have been happy to allow you to quote, and to agree a price before the job began.
I regret any misunderstanding regarding the basis on which you were helping me - ie for free, because you are my sister, and with no payment being offered or requested beforehand. I wish you the very best with your new carpet cleaning venture and would be more than happy to let all the family and our friends know that you are open for business."

Haha. Obviously don’t do this, but the thought of it is brilliantly passive-aggressive.

whowhatwerewhy · 27/11/2022 10:16

I would message her , hi I've discovered a problem with the carpet you cleaned, let me know how I claim off you ( presumably as a business you have liability insurance).

PenelopeTitsDrop3121 · 27/11/2022 10:13

"Sorry but I can't afford that. Can do 50p a week". Hopefully she would then realise how much of a cow she is and will feel extremely guilty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread