Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Think That The Chalet School Matron Would Be In Prison Nowadays

996 replies

TheShellBeach · 26/11/2022 21:56

..........................for giving unprescribed sedatives to the girls so frequently.

(lighthearted) (in case a million people tell me that IABU)

The Chalet School Matron was forever doling out sedatives to the girls, without even asking Jack Maynard to prescribe them first.
Shocking stuff. Nowadays, she would be jailed and struck off the NMC Register.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EmmaAgain22 · 28/11/2022 19:27

ormaybenot · 28/11/2022 18:43

I never read these as a kid but as an adult I bought one with two stories in one book at a charity shop as I collect those types of books, and really enjoyed the two stories, so I bought the whole lot via eBay and I just couldn't get into them, they were so dreary. I was so disappointed. I donated them to a charity shop.

My favourite boarding school books are Dorita Fairlie Bruce's Dimsie stories. I've got all of those (I think) and still think they're brilliant.

I didn't read more because I found them a bit dreary, but the good ones were good, so to speak. I really need some easy reads now so very glad I found this thread. I remember being very bored by one about twins, one about shocks - where actually nothing happened - and I didn't read any early ones so was a bit confused.

then there was someone fainting at an Easter play, which just seemed very WTAF to a child reading it hoping for fun school stories!

But I have a feeling I'll appreciate them more as an adult.

Flooper · 28/11/2022 19:21

MissyB1 · 28/11/2022 19:10

And why does EBD make negative comments about the physical appearance or demeanour of lower class girls /women?
Joan Baker has to always be “big Joan Baker” why big? Is she tall?
Servants apparently can only “stomp” not just walk normally.

Enid Blyton was the same. The daughters of the nouveau riche were common and pushy, their mothers dressed too showily and their fathers were loud and gauche.

CowPie · 28/11/2022 19:14

MissyB1 · 28/11/2022 19:10

And why does EBD make negative comments about the physical appearance or demeanour of lower class girls /women?
Joan Baker has to always be “big Joan Baker” why big? Is she tall?
Servants apparently can only “stomp” not just walk normally.

I think ‘big’ meant ‘bosomy’ or ‘with a showy hourglass figure that filled out her sophisticated red dress and was nothing like the dainty girlish forms of which EBD actually approved’.

Flooper · 28/11/2022 19:14

ormaybenot · 28/11/2022 18:43

I never read these as a kid but as an adult I bought one with two stories in one book at a charity shop as I collect those types of books, and really enjoyed the two stories, so I bought the whole lot via eBay and I just couldn't get into them, they were so dreary. I was so disappointed. I donated them to a charity shop.

My favourite boarding school books are Dorita Fairlie Bruce's Dimsie stories. I've got all of those (I think) and still think they're brilliant.

Oh I love the Dimsie books. I must give them a re-read. I love that she became a herbalist rather than a teacher or just a wife.

MissyB1 · 28/11/2022 19:10

And why does EBD make negative comments about the physical appearance or demeanour of lower class girls /women?
Joan Baker has to always be “big Joan Baker” why big? Is she tall?
Servants apparently can only “stomp” not just walk normally.

CowPie · 28/11/2022 19:04

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 28/11/2022 18:50

I'd describe them (others may differ) as an acquired taste, @ormaybenot . You have to learn to appreciate the amazing detail and extent of the CS universe, but also the utter bonkersness of it, to enjoy the books properly.

Definitely an acquired taste. Part of that taste involves finding it amusing, as well as/rather than obnoxious, that there are endless descriptions of ‘dainty’ dormitories, unfunny Middles’ pranks, and trilingual is, Joey’s ‘golden’ voice, earphones, fecundity and look-at-me girlishness into her 40s, the insufferable Mary-Lou quoting ‘I will lift my eyes up to the hills’, and blow-by-blow accounts of Christmas plays performed with deep devotion.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 28/11/2022 18:50

I'd describe them (others may differ) as an acquired taste, @ormaybenot . You have to learn to appreciate the amazing detail and extent of the CS universe, but also the utter bonkersness of it, to enjoy the books properly.

ormaybenot · 28/11/2022 18:43

I never read these as a kid but as an adult I bought one with two stories in one book at a charity shop as I collect those types of books, and really enjoyed the two stories, so I bought the whole lot via eBay and I just couldn't get into them, they were so dreary. I was so disappointed. I donated them to a charity shop.

My favourite boarding school books are Dorita Fairlie Bruce's Dimsie stories. I've got all of those (I think) and still think they're brilliant.

Featheryboa · 28/11/2022 18:15

Yes! I do remember now

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 28/11/2022 18:03

Featheryboa · 28/11/2022 17:51

The Malory Towers outdoor sea pool would definitely be a health and safety hazard.
And there was the boyish girl called Tom (iirc
) who rode to school on her horse. Invisioning the modern day version clopping down the M5.

Bill, that was - short for Wilhelmina!

Flooper · 28/11/2022 17:54

feckless brazen hussy Joan Whatsit, who bullies, swears, doesn’t wash, wears makeup and ‘ungirlish’ dresses, has a perm AND eats fish and chips on the street with boys!

Oh Joan!

CowPie · 28/11/2022 17:52

TheKeatingFive · 28/11/2022 17:23

EBD was much more comfortable with the upper middle classes than actual aristos. Though she had a bit more of a thing for continental titled / landed types, particularly in the Tyrol days.

She was deeply insecure about her own class status, clearly — probably not surprisingly, given her wobbly ‘just-about-respectable lower-middle-class’ and the absconded-but-still-local father. It explains her very careful distinction between respectable working-class Rosamund Lilley who loses her accent and fits right in at the CS after a patronising little lecture from Joey about Adam and Eve being WC, and feckless brazen hussy Joan Whatsit, who bullies, swears, doesn’t wash, wears makeup and ‘ungirlish’ dresses, has a perm AND eats fish and chips on the street with boys!

All her working-class good girls (well, two — Rosamund and Biddy O’Ryan! Are there any others, excluding servants, who are either stolid devoted handmaids or skittish, superstitious sillies?) are the daughters of ladies’ maids who learned their ‘dainty’ manners from their employers. All her bad working-class girls (Joan, Elma Conroy, that glue factory heiress who gets booted) are ‘cheaply sophisticated’, interested in boys, and the money that pays the CS fees is from a non-U source like the pools or glue or knick-knack shops.

Featheryboa · 28/11/2022 17:51

The Malory Towers outdoor sea pool would definitely be a health and safety hazard.
And there was the boyish girl called Tom (iirc
) who rode to school on her horse. Invisioning the modern day version clopping down the M5.

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 28/11/2022 17:49

TheKeatingFive · 28/11/2022 17:23

EBD was much more comfortable with the upper middle classes than actual aristos. Though she had a bit more of a thing for continental titled / landed types, particularly in the Tyrol days.

I think that's why Madge drifted off in rhe books, EBD gave her a title and then didn't really know what to do with her other than have her drift round opening fetes etc. She is definitely better with the working women

Zitouna · 28/11/2022 17:40

Oops that was re the book where Mike makes joey faint and she asks why someone didn’t whip him!

Zitouna · 28/11/2022 17:39

Not read the full thread so might have been spotted already, but it’s Joey and Co In Tirol. Mike runs off a ridge or something, and the shock makes Joey faint (6 weeks after giving birth to the second set of twins,). They go on holiday to Tirol for her to recover. NO IDEA why I remember this!

TheKeatingFive · 28/11/2022 17:23

EBD was much more comfortable with the upper middle classes than actual aristos. Though she had a bit more of a thing for continental titled / landed types, particularly in the Tyrol days.

CatLoaf · 28/11/2022 17:03

Haha, the Mitfords would definitely be expelled from the Chalet School. Apart from Pam, maybe.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/11/2022 16:29

Is anyone reminded of the Mitfords while reading EBD?

Well, the CS is a lot less glamorous, and I'm not sure that the Robin would have withstood a day's hunting, followed by the Hons' Cupboard, but they definitely have posh folk with poor impulse control in common 😀

EmmaAgain22 · 28/11/2022 16:15

Talia99 · 28/11/2022 16:11

The thing is, the two ‘types’ of offences don’t make sense in one character. Blackmail takes cold calculation and planning, the type of assault described was an loss of control (still GBH with intent in my opinion - flinging a heavy object at someone’s head is never going to be anything else - but the intent is immediate not planned). Most criminals aren’t both.

I haven't read anything with blackmail but can't see why people wouldn't do both.

having a temper doesn't mean you can't carefully calmly do other things.

Is anyone reminded of the Mitfords while reading EBD?

Talia99 · 28/11/2022 16:11

The thing is, the two ‘types’ of offences don’t make sense in one character. Blackmail takes cold calculation and planning, the type of assault described was an loss of control (still GBH with intent in my opinion - flinging a heavy object at someone’s head is never going to be anything else - but the intent is immediate not planned). Most criminals aren’t both.

StitchesInTime · 28/11/2022 15:54

I do remember Margot causing a girl a head injury and it being treated as if it was something that happens in anger and was seen as forgiveable.

The big problem with that attitude is Margot’s age at the time. I can’t remember the precise book it’s in, but it’s one of the late ones where Margot’s almost at the point of leaving school. So she’s around 17 or 18?
Old enough for such a failure to control one’s temper to be treated very seriously in most schools.

Of course, she gets away with it because her mum is St Joey. It’s difficult to imagine such an outcome if it had been Betty throwing the bookend at Margot’s head.

EmmaAgain22 · 28/11/2022 15:32

This thread jogged my memory

my older sister didn't approve when I read these books but I was too young to really understand why. Now I know!

I am slowly reading the first one, but don't remember any kids being whipped etc in the few books I read. I do remember Margot causing a girl a head injury and it being treated as if it was something that happens in anger and was seen as forgiveable.

MissyB1 · 28/11/2022 15:15

CorporateBull · 28/11/2022 07:18

Yes I have flight of a Chalet girl, it’s certainly very different, I enjoyed it (and it explains what happened to Elsaveta), but saying that I can’t imagine reading it again.

Talia99 · 28/11/2022 14:19

Even for the times EBD had incredibly strange ideas as to what a good parent (or a good person for that matter) looked like. She may have been a teacher but I assume she was a very bad one based on her complete lack of understanding of children and belief that comments like the above were just fine and even necessary to properly punish the child. See also rampant bullying of Eustacia and by Margot, Jack Lambert etc. Margot committed multiple serious criminal offences (blackmail, GBH with intent) and wasn’t even expelled far less prosecuted.