Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Think That The Chalet School Matron Would Be In Prison Nowadays

996 replies

TheShellBeach · 26/11/2022 21:56

..........................for giving unprescribed sedatives to the girls so frequently.

(lighthearted) (in case a million people tell me that IABU)

The Chalet School Matron was forever doling out sedatives to the girls, without even asking Jack Maynard to prescribe them first.
Shocking stuff. Nowadays, she would be jailed and struck off the NMC Register.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
CorporateBull · 29/11/2022 11:02

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/11/2022 10:29

The sewing is a hangover from the Victorian era, when upper and upper middle class women were expected to be forever sewing - known as 'their work' - ironically, since it was always something decorative (the maids did the grunt work). I think the idea was that it occupied them in a womanly way, so that they didn't have time to be dangerously distracted by reading or Having Ideas.

I'm not sure. Only the very richest people by the 30s had servants who would have done a lot of mending - most people struggled to find domestic staff and they did the real grunt work. Darning/knitting/plain sewing/clothes making were very much household tasks that were done by women across the board, even if you had a 'daily'. Women of my mother's age (90s) were brought up expected to be able to 'turn a needle' to things. Darning socks is the eternal job of Jo as an adult don't forget.

PuttingDownRoots · 29/11/2022 11:01

Didn't they hold a party of the evacuees? So they weren't completely dismissive of them... just kept them well away.

Some of the girls must have had a complete culture shock if they joined the womans forces. Even nursing!

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 29/11/2022 11:00

I'm not sure about all the sewing they have to do though. Wouldn't they have maids to do that for them? I'd have been useless.

I think it's that upper middle class instead of upper class thing. They are teaching the wives of doctors, bankers, missionaries, teachers, vicars etc. Plus future nuns, teachers, housewives etc. And this was in a time especially post war where getting servants was increasingly difficult.

I think plain sewing was getting more of a think amoungst the upper middle class as well. Sewing for missionary boxes and knitting for the poor etc. So even if someone else mended their clothes I think there was an expectation of having the skills themselves.

And of course in the Austrian era the Austrians expected their girls to be good home makers even if they married well.

Although I stand by Joeys early resentment at the idea of having to sit around darning her husbands socks (which she later does 🙄) Although somewhat Ironically as a prolific sock knitter I do darn my husbands socks but always berate myself because my darns aren't practically invisible and Mdlle/matron would not have approved them

lieselotte · 29/11/2022 10:50

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/11/2022 10:29

The sewing is a hangover from the Victorian era, when upper and upper middle class women were expected to be forever sewing - known as 'their work' - ironically, since it was always something decorative (the maids did the grunt work). I think the idea was that it occupied them in a womanly way, so that they didn't have time to be dangerously distracted by reading or Having Ideas.

That makes perfect sense!

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 29/11/2022 10:46

But it’s odder to me that there’s such a gulf between the sympathetic attitude to the impoverished Tiernsee peasants and the deeply snide authorial attitude to the Cockney evacuees in Armishire

I think that there are a few things here.

The impoverished peasants were helped by taking them on as servants or by throwing a play to raise money, help from a distance. The evacuees would be taken into their homes as equals not servants (appreciating that didn't always happen with evacuees).

I think there is a level of respecting hard work too. Peasants were acceptable in Austria because they were seen to work hard, and they were portrayed as clean, church going people. The evacuees are portrayed as ignorant, maybe not so clean and godly and I think maybe the work their parents did pre war was not as valued?

Also the school/Joey valued lower class people if they were intelligent (Reg, Biddy etc) and the evacuees were portrayed as ignorant in places. Perhaps if one had been a prodigal they would have found their way into Joeys house.

It's all that wierd balance, they are snobby but anyone openly snobby is derided.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/11/2022 10:29

lieselotte · 29/11/2022 09:40

One thing I like about the CS, in retrospect, is that it is totally taken for granted that women are autonomous and in charge

I'm not sure about all the sewing they have to do though. Wouldn't they have maids to do that for them? I'd have been useless.

The sewing is a hangover from the Victorian era, when upper and upper middle class women were expected to be forever sewing - known as 'their work' - ironically, since it was always something decorative (the maids did the grunt work). I think the idea was that it occupied them in a womanly way, so that they didn't have time to be dangerously distracted by reading or Having Ideas.

DrunkenBoat · 29/11/2022 09:40

Yes, surely no sane person would ever get out of bed if their first actions involved shaking a leg for Mary-Lou, having a cold bath and humping their mattress in the only correct manner (I mean, how many incorrect ways of humping a mattress are there? Fnar, obviously...)

I think EBD sometimes did weird things with characterisation, like continually telling you that a character is X and Y, but then continually making the character do things that really aren't, or retrofitting them in a way that really isn't borne out when you look back at earlier books.

I do think that for someone who herself was physically endangered by WW2 action and who escaped the Reich, EBD, while depicting her as endlessly hospitable and kind-hearted, risks making Joey look callous and snobbish by having whichever old mistress sends her the Highland Twins say I know you don't want evacuees 'because of the precious Three', despite having three spare bedrooms and the fact that other minor characters in reserved occupations like farming and with presumably far smaller houses and no staff, were required to taken them.

(I mean, I can imagine not wanting to take in extra children if I had triplets, but I also wouldn't be roaming Europe taking in random babies saved from train wrecks or complete strangers whose father got lost in space or whose mother had once known me at school if I had a giant family of my own...)

lieselotte · 29/11/2022 09:40

One thing I like about the CS, in retrospect, is that it is totally taken for granted that women are autonomous and in charge

I'm not sure about all the sewing they have to do though. Wouldn't they have maids to do that for them? I'd have been useless.

lieselotte · 29/11/2022 09:39

Just read the second book as I've not read it before. Can't believe we're two books in and Madge is being married off already!

Lots of casual sexism and racism; boys can use slang (Madge was obsessed with that) but girls can't; Jo's hair was like a character with mad black hair from Noddy and a particular brand of jam; someone else referred to working like a n*er etc

The Frau Berlin thing was interesting - because she was Prussian. It shows the book was written after WW1, because obviously by WW2 we'd realised that certain Austrians were rather more dangerous. But Austrians and Bavarians are lovely and those Prussians rude and xenophobic (which rather fits in with the premise of A Short History of Germany).

Definitely a very interesting product of their time! I've never read any of the ones that were in Switzerland.

Gremlinsateit · 29/11/2022 09:36

MissyB1 · 29/11/2022 09:27

oh she would have seen my leg - just as it kicked her right in the shin 😂

🤣

MissyB1 · 29/11/2022 09:27

TheKeatingFive · 28/11/2022 22:10

Ah yes, checking the drawers. They'd all die if that wasn't seen to.

Which reminds me, the morning routine in the Chalet School was excruciating. Imagine dragging yourself out of bed to 'shake a leg' for Mary Lou?

oh she would have seen my leg - just as it kicked her right in the shin 😂

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 29/11/2022 09:24

CatLoaf · 29/11/2022 00:45

Please please can someone remind me about the pink worm?? It's just at the edge of my brain...

Is that the one that crawls into the engine of a bus and kill the engine? I don't think it can be when they had to sleep in the bus overnight because that was floods, but I can't remember which bus related catastrophe it caused

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/11/2022 08:21

One of the appeals of chalet world and it's Ilk is that it's a world where women have a lot of autonomy. Yes there are always the doctors around and a bit of kowtowing to them, but still, women and girls DO things. Even if it's just put on Christmas plays and dress up fetes

Totally. And they take girls' education seriously, in an era when few people did. And, despite all the dick-pandering to the doctors, almost all important decisions are taken by women.

Is there anything so female-centred for girls today? I doubt it. My DSDs are adults now, but I don't remember any 2000s equivalent when they were younger. There are more kids' books with female heroines now, but it's done very self-consciously. One thing I like about the CS, in retrospect, is that it is totally taken for granted that women are autonomous and in charge.

CorporateBull · 29/11/2022 08:15

There are vague references to old girls in service and war work. The MacDonald twins appear because their sister has to go off to do war things. And there is the digging for victory under the excellent-sounding Miss Everett. But there is definitely an overall lack of getting stuck in.

CowPie · 29/11/2022 08:05

Gremlinsateit · 29/11/2022 01:34

Maybe because EBD was not very enthusiastic about the war and the Guides were a bit proto-military?

I know it’s been said before on Mnet, but I’m still astounded that she had refugee characters with an understanding of what was happening to Jewish people in Europe, but not an ounce of war work.

Yes, it does seem odd that Madge and Joey, who’ve actually escaped the Nazis and know people in concentration camps, aren’t depicted as digging for Victory or doing any of the home front war stuff that was compatible with young children and wouldn’t have taken more than the occasional mention.

But it’s odder to me that there’s such a gulf between the sympathetic attitude to the impoverished Tiernsee peasants and the deeply snide authorial attitude to the Cockney evacuees in Armishire, to the point where even hospitable Joey, who is forever throwing her house open to waifs and strays, adopts two Scottish girls who are actually attending a local boarding school, rather than have any billeted on her.

EHopes · 29/11/2022 05:47

I think she got bored of guides and was relieved when she realised that they could just never start them up again once she moved the school to Switzerland.

Exile is a completely amazing book on n it's way - it was published at the beginning of the war and included a lot of information that many didn't admit to knowing until well after the war was over.

The problem with the war years is that there are the books published out of order that must have taken place during those years (Tom, mystery and Rosalie) which have zero references to anything war related, probably cause by the time they were published no one wanted a reminder. But they leave it all a bit murky for those of us wanting to date the series.

One of the appeals of chalet world and it's Ilk is that it's a world where women have a lot of autonomy. Yes there are always the doctors around and a bit of kowtowing to them, but still, women and girls DO things. Even if it's just put on Christmas plays and dress up fetes.

Gremlinsateit · 29/11/2022 01:34

TheKeatingFive · 28/11/2022 22:17

Maybe Austrian trousers are different? 🤔

And why did she drop the Guides in such a wholesale fashion. I always wondered that. Though I can't say I loved those bits so probably a net benefit for me.

Maybe because EBD was not very enthusiastic about the war and the Guides were a bit proto-military?

I know it’s been said before on Mnet, but I’m still astounded that she had refugee characters with an understanding of what was happening to Jewish people in Europe, but not an ounce of war work.

Gremlinsateit · 29/11/2022 01:26

But Thekla was precisely a Prussian, like Frau Berlin, and therefore a bad hat in EBD world. Nothing at all like a delightful Bavarian with delicious torte.

CowPie · 29/11/2022 00:53

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 29/11/2022 00:43

Ah but she didn't have the delicate stomach of the delicately well bred

Wasn’t Thekla a scion of the Prussian aristocracy, and a cousin of the Von Eschenaus, though? Though it’s odd that cured meat seems to be beyond the pale when the books are forever going on about the superiority of foreign food, and sneering at the Little Englanders who want more for breakfast than rolls and coffee.

CatLoaf · 29/11/2022 00:45

Please please can someone remind me about the pink worm?? It's just at the edge of my brain...

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 29/11/2022 00:43

TheShellBeach · 29/11/2022 00:12

But only Thekla ate it and she wasn't ill.

Ah but she didn't have the delicate stomach of the delicately well bred

ToWhitToWhoo · 29/11/2022 00:36

StitchesInTime · 28/11/2022 22:19

It’s the expectation that everyone has a cold bath in the morning that would do it for me.

There’s a definite implication that someone wanting to wash in warm or even tepid water would be lacking in moral fibre 🙄

And then weren’t they only allocated about 5 minutes each to wash in the mornings?

I can’t help but wonder if body odour was a problem or just considered perfectly normal.

This seems to have been a widespread health fad. The American humorous poet Ogden Nash denounced it rather thoroughly:

Jonathan Jukes is full of health,

And he doesn't care who knows it

Others may exercise by stealth.

But he with a cry of Prosit!

Others put up with coated tongues.

And shoulders narrow and droopy;

Jonathan overinflates his lungs

With a thundering shout of Whoopee!

Jonathan's noise is healthy noise,

Jonathan's joys are healthy joys,

Jonathan shuns the primrose path.

And starts the day with an icy bath.

I might forgive the super-physique

Contained in the Jukes apparel;

The apple glowing in either cheek;

The chest like< an oyster barrel;

The muscles that flow like a morning stream.

The result of applied eugenics;

The rigorous diet, the stern regime

Of arduous calisthenics;

I can pardon most of the healthy joys,

I can pardon most of the healthy noise,

But Heaven itself no pardon hath

For the man who boasts of an icy bath.

If the Missing Links were vigorous chaps

And their manly deeds were myriad.

Must civilization then relapse

Back to the glacial period?

Humanity learns at a fearful price;

Must the lessons all be lost?

Does the locomotive feed on ice?

Is the liner propelled by frost?

One constant truth mankind has found

Through fire and flood and slaughter:

The thing that makes the wheels go round

Is plenty of good hot water.

And therefore, therefore, Jonathan Jukes,

You deserve the harshest of harsh rebukes;

You and your frigid daily bath

Are blocking civilization's path.

You think of yourself as Spartan and spunky?

So, Jonathan, is the old brass monkey.

CowPie · 29/11/2022 00:24

RafaistheKingofClay · 28/11/2022 23:54

As is professor Richardson getting lost in space.

And the pink worm.

TheShellBeach · 29/11/2022 00:12

Timepasse · 28/11/2022 23:24

Think that there was also raw bacon at the Joyce/Thekla midnight feast, that could do it .

But only Thekla ate it and she wasn't ill.

OP posts:
RafaistheKingofClay · 28/11/2022 23:54

CorporateBull · 28/11/2022 22:58

The speedboat scene is up there.

As is professor Richardson getting lost in space.