Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To steer DS away from rugby?

138 replies

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 19:07

DS is 10 and plays contact rugby for local club.
He loves it and is good-fast, strategic and tackles well.
But he is the smallest in his team and when up against big lads from other teams I worry he will get very hurt. They don’t put them in positions for another couple of years so he can easily be up against someone twice his size and he will go in for the tackle regardless of the size of his opponent.

On the other hand it’s great exercise and the teamwork is incredible. It comes with a good social life (although I also worry about the excessive alcohol culture in a few years time!)

Especially with the sad news stories about Doddie Weir & Rob Burrows and the increase in the chance of neurological issues in rugby players (albeit professional ones not junior club players!). It makes me wonder if I am doing the right thing in encouraging him and whether I should steer him towards concentrating on his other sports.

OP posts:
Simonjt · 26/11/2022 22:07

Rugbys great, I used to be a full time pro, now I’m only part time and semi-pro. My seven year old plays rugby, well, as much as a seven year old can.

I’m on the smaller side for rugby, six foot and a tight head prop, very few injuries, no concussions (not from rugby anyway) and no reduced range of movement in my shoulders.

If he enjoys rugby let him play, he might play for another year, he might for another ten, its important to embrace things you enjoy, but that also doesn’t mean they have to be a permanent fixture in your life.

Beebumble2 · 26/11/2022 21:57

Our DS played Rugby from aged 8 till his final year at Uni. Yes there were injuries, I spent quite a few hours in A&E! But it taught him so much about team work, loyalty and perseverance.

VestaTilley · 26/11/2022 21:56

YANBU. I would steer my DS away from rugby, as I would from boxing. Heading the ball in football is also a big worry.

It’s a shame if DS loves it, but it’s so risky. If my DS really wanted to try it I wouldn’t stop him, but equally we’re not introducing it via Rugby Tots etc. I have considered horse riding in future though, so maybe I’m not weighing up the risks correctly there.

username8888 · 26/11/2022 21:17

Yanbu. DS isn't interested in any sports so I'm quite relieved about it...except swimming. He has fins I'm sure

Remaker · 26/11/2022 21:13

Hbh17 · 26/11/2022 20:00

Please don't wrap up your child in cotton wool - how does that help him? Imagine the bullying he would get because his mummy won't let him play?

My nephews played rugby from being very young, & right thru 6th Form and they loved it. Not only did they keep fit, but they learnt a huge amount about teamwork, respect, and good behaviour. They both actually have had more injuries (some leading to surgery) from soccer. Sometimes people need to be allowed to take risks....

My two kids play 6 sports between them. Rugby isn’t special, there are no skills or qualities you learn that aren’t present in other sports. All sport has risk but the risk for a broken ankle is a bit different to the risk of early onset dementia in your 50s.

Interesting that you say you are in favour of risk-taking but then you think it’s important that kids do what their friends want so they don’t stand out and get teased. Sounds pretty risk-averse to me.

Waterdropsdown · 26/11/2022 21:09

Honestly I don’t know how parents can get their child involved in rugby with all that’s know about the head traumas.

I’m not at all a wrap up in cotton wool parent, would be happy for them to do I think any other (that I know of) sport but in my opinion it’s really not ok to allow a young child to get started on rugby knowing that they might get really into it and the consequences of what may happen if that’s the case. My husband was a rugby player when younger, saw some horrific non head injuries so was on board with our son not participating. He’s younger than secondary school but I’m so against it that I would rather he goes to a non rugby playing secondary school.

I also believe rugby as we know it isn’t going to be around much longer.

gruffalosbrother · 26/11/2022 21:01

YANBU my eldest played for a bit on school and I strongly discouraged it. It’s a horrible sport

ShirleyKnott · 26/11/2022 20:58

One of my sons played rugby to a semi professional level and jacked it in because he didn’t want to be a professional rugby player when I asked why he said they don’t earn enough and also head injury!

so there we are in the in the they make their own minds up

RomainingCalm · 26/11/2022 20:55

It's a hard one. One of DC played rugby from being small until about Y9 and was pretty good. The club was sociable, he made lots of friends and it was very inclusive.

Then as the boys all starting going through puberty there was a massive gap between the biggest and the smallest and he decided he didn't like getting hurt so he gave up. Whilst we loved being part of the club and the team I have to admit that I was relieved when he stopped.

Other DC played hockey so he started playing that instead (had played a bit before when he was younger). Absolutely loved it and went on to play through the different age groups and into the men's teams. Unlike rugby the men seem to keep playing right into their 50s and 60s so I'm hoping that he will have a 'sport for life' and the social life that goes with it.

Obviously there's still the risk of injury, as there is with any sport, but I wouldn't have pushed him to carry on with rugby. It used to be that rugby was a sport for all shapes and sizes but now I think it's predominantly big and heavy players and even with changes to the rules and awareness of concussion etc. the risk of serious head/spinal injuries is increased.

noworklifebalance · 26/11/2022 20:53

tickticksnooze · 26/11/2022 20:42

Have you missed all the research and attention on the long term brain injuries caused by repeated minor blows to the head?

All these people who seemed fine, but were sustaining catastrophic brain injuries that have cut their lives short.

Doesn't matter how quickly you get to A&E after a given injury, it has a cumulative long term effect that we have no means to treat.

And this. MND is in the news a lot - the number of rugby players suffering from this is significantu higher than the normal background population and other sports.

Yes, dementia in footballers who head the ball but the balls are much lighter (no longer made of leather and pig’s bladder) so I wonder the association will reduce with time.

noworklifebalance · 26/11/2022 20:50

Remaker · 26/11/2022 19:55

For me rugby is the double whammy - the risk of head injury causing brain damage and also the risk of life changing spinal injury. We had a spate of schoolboy spinal injuries from rugby in Australia a couple of years ago. One of them is a boy who lives near us who became a quadriplegic at 16. My DS’s school pushes rugby hard for anyone who is remotely sporty but we just told him it’s not an option. He plays football instead.

This. When the scrum collapses…

tickticksnooze · 26/11/2022 20:42

TinySaltLick · 26/11/2022 20:19

Yabu. It is a contact sport - but the injuries are far fewer than compared to football for instance.

Noone really gets significantly bigger than each other until about 17 anyway, so he has a long way to go before having to come up against enormous gym monsters.

Also you are facing the other team so see the tackles coming - it isn't as dangerous as you seem to think

Have you missed all the research and attention on the long term brain injuries caused by repeated minor blows to the head?

All these people who seemed fine, but were sustaining catastrophic brain injuries that have cut their lives short.

Doesn't matter how quickly you get to A&E after a given injury, it has a cumulative long term effect that we have no means to treat.

greenacrylicpaint · 26/11/2022 20:35

yanbu

rugby is great fun but what you describe sounds too risky.

my dc play tag rugby at school. is that an option?

Littlewhitecat · 26/11/2022 20:32

My DS (15) is a very good footballer and is being pressured by team mates and some parents to play rugby as well (DS goes to a grammar school so rugby is big). My dad was a right rugger bugger and used to bang on about rugby being a gentleman's game etc etc. His face and ears were destroyed and the behaviour at the the rugby club was appalling. I've put my foot down and said no because I don't want my beautiful boy brain damaged or mixing with the rugby wankers at the rugby club.

Seashor · 26/11/2022 20:31

I love rugby. It’s a great sport and has a good ethos. My son played for a club and for school as did all of his friends. It’s football I’d have had a problem with his playing.

jtaeapa · 26/11/2022 20:31

Steer him away from it. It is very dangerous. Lots of the kids in our school do it (mine don’t) and I have seen horrible injuries. Concussion. Neck injuries. Paralysis lasting some days/weeks. Broken collar bone.

Verbena87 · 26/11/2022 20:29

Everyone I know who played regularly has now stopped because of the injuries they’ve sustained. All of them have sustained permanent damage (body stuff not brain injuries thankfully, but one has a spine issue that really limits his life)

Endofmytetherfinally · 26/11/2022 20:27

I'd let him play. My brother was the same and chose for himself when he wanted to retire because he was too slight.

I also dated 2 boys with rugby injuries at school. One broke his collarbone and one his ankle but they both loved the sport and were gutted to miss the season.

I dated a guy who played for an adult team. Again wasn't huge but loved it. If he's unlikely to pick another sport and will just game / watch TV/ sit on his phone I'd be even more inclined to encourage him.

Also league is not safer, sure there's no line outs and fewer scrums but there's a much higher average tackle rate unless you're a winger so I'd leave it with union.

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 20:26

Football is definitely not his sport!
He likes cricket but is much better at rugby.
He’d probably like rowing but as pp said his size would probably stop him progressing there too.

I wouldn’t ban him at this stage but currently I feel I do encourage him a lot-prioritising training over days out, always supporting matches and watching matches on tv etc with him. I could scale that back I guess!

or hold my nerve a couple more years and see if he naturally gets put off.

OP posts:
TinySaltLick · 26/11/2022 20:19

Yabu. It is a contact sport - but the injuries are far fewer than compared to football for instance.

Noone really gets significantly bigger than each other until about 17 anyway, so he has a long way to go before having to come up against enormous gym monsters.

Also you are facing the other team so see the tackles coming - it isn't as dangerous as you seem to think

aleC4 · 26/11/2022 20:10

I think YABU to be honest.
My son played rugby from 5-16 and only packed in due to other commitments.
My daughter plays for our local U16 girls team which I manage. Last year she was selected for the county and she's now in the England Rugby development programme.
Rugby is a fantastic sport. Yes there is an injury risk but my daughter was a high level competitive gymnast before taking up rugby and sustained far more injuries and long term I going issues from gymnastics than she's ever had from rugby.
She had a nasty concussion a year ago but the level of understanding and knowledge around that now is excellent and clubs take it very seriously.
Our rugby team and whole club is a fantastic set up. My daughter has made so many friends for life through rugby and our club is a real family affair. If children are coached correctly and taught about the risk of concussion then it is not as dangerous as many people think.
Yes there are injuries but that can happen in any sport.
I know some will disagree but that's my opinion. Far far more positives than negatives in the sport.

katienana · 26/11/2022 20:09

My sons have both started recently. Dh grew up playing and he says the training and matches are very different to when he was young, way more structured and professional. I think the youth players are better protected. Professional rugby players now are absolutely huge and I'm sure that contributes massively to injuries. It's not likely he'll get to that level. If he's at a good club and he enjoys it I'd keep it up, there are so many risks in life and if he turns away from rugby you don't know what negative things he'll get involved in.

Shinyredbicycle · 26/11/2022 20:07

I think the point is that the risk from playing rugby are very different from playing other team sports.

I think if your ds loves it, he loves it and you support him with your heart in your mouth. If he can be persuaded to other things that he loves, all the better to be honest.

Hbh17 · 26/11/2022 20:00

Please don't wrap up your child in cotton wool - how does that help him? Imagine the bullying he would get because his mummy won't let him play?

My nephews played rugby from being very young, & right thru 6th Form and they loved it. Not only did they keep fit, but they learnt a huge amount about teamwork, respect, and good behaviour. They both actually have had more injuries (some leading to surgery) from soccer. Sometimes people need to be allowed to take risks....

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 19:55

GrazingSheep · 26/11/2022 19:44

I think in 10 years time rugby in its current format will be a thing of the past.

It is a different game to even 10 years ago by all accounts (I’ve only really been interested since he started) so you might be right.
His club offer have a touch session for 17+ So maybe things are changing.

OP posts: