Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To steer DS away from rugby?

138 replies

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 19:07

DS is 10 and plays contact rugby for local club.
He loves it and is good-fast, strategic and tackles well.
But he is the smallest in his team and when up against big lads from other teams I worry he will get very hurt. They don’t put them in positions for another couple of years so he can easily be up against someone twice his size and he will go in for the tackle regardless of the size of his opponent.

On the other hand it’s great exercise and the teamwork is incredible. It comes with a good social life (although I also worry about the excessive alcohol culture in a few years time!)

Especially with the sad news stories about Doddie Weir & Rob Burrows and the increase in the chance of neurological issues in rugby players (albeit professional ones not junior club players!). It makes me wonder if I am doing the right thing in encouraging him and whether I should steer him towards concentrating on his other sports.

OP posts:
Byelaws · 26/11/2022 23:46

YANBU. I chose my DSs schooling specifically so they wouldn’t play rugby. It was a key decision factor.

Never regretted it. Both DSs have always been the tallest/biggest in their year group and they would have been put in the scrum. That was a no from me. No way.

I grew up around rugby - bothers and father played to high level. So many injuries. Life’s too long to have to lug around injuries from school rugby. The size of those guys, too.

AndAway · 26/11/2022 23:45

My DS played from 5 until 13 and then stopped. I was so relieved, it can be brutal. The head injury stuff is scary, I saw coaches from his team putting boys who had had a clash of heads back on to play when they were chasing a win.
I wasn't keen on the laddish culture as well. It was fun and good exercise when he was younger and it definitely taught him lots about teamwork and being part of something but the bigger sizes and everything associated with that meant I didn't want him playing in his teenage years.
Thankfully he decided himself to give it up and I was pleased to support his decision.
He has friends still in the team who absolutely love it and im sure will play until u18's at the least. I do worry about what injuries they'll have though, especially the smaller ones.

SiobhanSharpe · 26/11/2022 23:40

I think it's a very different game at senior/professional level. DH played at school and on one occasion they had a match against a not quite professional adult team, who didn't exactly hold back against the teenagers.
It was a very sobering experience for him and he remembers it vividly.

momlette · 26/11/2022 23:39

It’s incredible how quickly Capabilty changes at rugby. The physicality is a huge factor and those that might be ok aged 7-13 may be ok then suddenly find themselves overpowered by bigger players and too small to play safely due to risk of head/ neck injury . Some children become too easy to tackle and due to light weight can be thrown about which adds to safety risk. My point being it may come to a natural conclusion anyway as the physical concerns present themselves due to his small stature. I’ve seen plenty of younger boys be regarded as good players when very young only to get left behind due to size . It is a very worrisome game so I would breathe a sigh of relief if I were you as it only gets more violent, faster and risky as they get older!

SiobhanSharpe · 26/11/2022 23:32

DS shot up early aged about 12 and the games staff at his very sporty school told him to try out for rugby which he did, and loved it immediately. He played throughout school and ended up in the first XV from 16 to 18. He adored playing for the school and DH, who had also played at school, supported him and was very proud.
I found it hard to watch and seldom did. He was injured aged 16, his jaw was broken in a match. (Not a fight - a collision) We took him to A and E and he had an operation, they put a metal plate in and wired his jaw. It was a tough two weeks or so until the wires came out (he likes his food) but he made a full recovery.
He stopped playing when he left school because he found the rugby club at his RG university very cliquey, and hasn't played since.
I will say it was an important, formative experience for him, he learned an immense amount from it -- teamwork and co-operation, discipline, using his strength wisely, and just having lots of fun with his team-mates. But he was injured, quite seriously, and we were lucky it wasn't worse. He wasn't concussed.
This was about 12 years ago and I hope things are better, safety-wise. (The referees at the match were very blasé about his injury when it was obvious his jaw was broken, they actually sent him home instead of calling an ambulance at the pitch.) Other lads in the team had minor injuries over the years too.
So -- it can be wonderful, but there are other considerations. I didn't find the culture too laddish, the staff kept them on a tight leash. DS was known as the sensible one and his team mates always got him to talk to the refs calmly when emotions ran high.
I wouldn't have stopped him once he got into the team especially as DH was so supportive, they really bonded over rugby. But he outgrew it eventually although he still loves the game as a supporter. Just our family's experience.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 26/11/2022 23:28

Mmm. I heard an interview on the radio a few years ago with a Welsh International ex player. I think his Dad had played for Wales as well. He said that he didn't let his teenage son play, and was delighted that his interests were drama and dance. That playing at a senior level was like being in a car crash every week and under no circumstances would he allow his son to play. It has really stuck with me.

LizzieBet14 · 26/11/2022 23:17

League is definitely not a softer/easier option.

handbagsandholidays · 26/11/2022 23:16

YANBU - my son has to play for school and it terrifies me every single game! I know those who love the sport will say I'm being melodramatic but I've seen shoulders being dislocated, bruises and broken bones on the pitch. It's never intentional which makes it somewhat scarier!

Setyoufree · 26/11/2022 23:13

My kids are primary age but I'm happy with them playing (contact) rugby. They enjoy it, and they've made lovely friends. Yes, I probably would panic a bit more about the brain injury stuff if they were looking to go professional but I hardly think playing club rugby once a week is any more likely to end in brain injury than doing anything else. Seen the stats on the number of kids that end up in a&e from the trampoline in their back garden? Yet most people still have one.

Sport is massively important in so many ways. If they have a passion don't discourage them

ArseMenagerie · 26/11/2022 23:05

There is so much evidence about concussion, dementia and MND being higher for rugby players. I read an interesting article with a brain injury specialist who essentially said her child would play rugby over her dead body. I’ll try and find it. No way would my DC play it. Luckily they like football and netball.

LadyRoughDiamond · 26/11/2022 22:56

YANBU. We feel the same way about this and have discouraged our boys from playing. Brain injury and degenerative illness seems to be happening to younger and younger players. The whole thing’s a health and legal timebomb and unless the RFU addresses this I doubt there’s much future for the game.

healthadvice123 · 26/11/2022 22:56

@AllAoutMe not something I have experienced all though lately tickets at twickers are so experience that not so much rugby supporters now
Womens rugby is also pretty big

GigantosaurusRex · 26/11/2022 22:54

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

healthadvice123 · 26/11/2022 22:53

Big size differences definitely
My two were always smallest on pitch but the biggest tacklers, sometimes they would be 5ft 7 stone and another 14 year old 6ft prob 10 stone
They both are a little bigger now late developers, but some of the Players especially professionals are getting artificially big almost
So the tackles and hits must be very hard

toomuchlaundry · 26/11/2022 22:52

Have to admit I was glad my DS was diagnosed with an issue with his leg where he was recommended to not take part in contact sports (but doesn’t impact in any other way) so had to stop playing rugby at about 12yo. He was very slight compared to his peers

AllAoutMe · 26/11/2022 22:51

Based on my experience of attending 3 matches at Twickenham this month it is a highly misogynistic sport

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 22:48

itsalwayscycling · 26/11/2022 22:27

I love rugby and mine play but this really isn't true - there is a huge size differential at U14-U16 level, I've seen 14y olds who weigh 45kg soaking wet playing against 100Kg plus boys. Overall I think rugby has given mine an incredible experience and a very different team feeling to football (which they've played too) but it is always a bit nerve wracking now. They are really lightly built even at 15+ so I'm not sure how long they will keep playing. I wouldn't stop them but I also wouldn't force/encourage them to keep playing if they ever say they no longer love it.

Yes I agree that’s not true. DS is 5 stone and some of the boys are as tall as me (10 stone) and significantly wider!

If he does continue playing into his teens I doubt he’ll be anywhere near a scrum once they start putting them in proper positions.

I won’t allow him to play at school unless I know that the teachers of his team and opponents have proper rugby coaching qualifications.

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 26/11/2022 22:45

My ds 19 and 17 have played rugby from age 5 , head injury is taken a lot more seriously now even from when they started. But is a higher risk sport, mine are old enough to make own choices now so I don't get a say , but its always a worry
They both played football as well and there now and not risk free either
I suppose lots of sports carry a risk , but I totally get why parents worry or don't want their child to play rugby

Willyoujustbequiet · 26/11/2022 22:36

Yanbu, encourage other sports. Its too risky.

Knowing what we know now I cant understand why any parent is ok with it.

LollyPops123 · 26/11/2022 22:30

Also agree that rugby in it's current form is not going to be around for much longer. Not financially viable.
Personally I don't like the culture in some of these rugby clubs either. Not mentioning specific players but I'm sure some of you will know who I mean.

itsalwayscycling · 26/11/2022 22:27

TinySaltLick · 26/11/2022 20:19

Yabu. It is a contact sport - but the injuries are far fewer than compared to football for instance.

Noone really gets significantly bigger than each other until about 17 anyway, so he has a long way to go before having to come up against enormous gym monsters.

Also you are facing the other team so see the tackles coming - it isn't as dangerous as you seem to think

I love rugby and mine play but this really isn't true - there is a huge size differential at U14-U16 level, I've seen 14y olds who weigh 45kg soaking wet playing against 100Kg plus boys. Overall I think rugby has given mine an incredible experience and a very different team feeling to football (which they've played too) but it is always a bit nerve wracking now. They are really lightly built even at 15+ so I'm not sure how long they will keep playing. I wouldn't stop them but I also wouldn't force/encourage them to keep playing if they ever say they no longer love it.

hangsangwitch · 26/11/2022 22:24

My DS suffered a head injury from rugby at age 12 and the after effects of post concussion syndrome nearly killed him. He suffered painful migraines, lethargy, insomnia and depression for almost a year. We ended up at the office of a paediatric neurologist at GOSH, who shared with us that he sees lots of children damaged from rugby.
It was hell for him and all of us that we only resolved in the end with months of expensive private therapies.
I also worked medical welfare at a high school and one day sent SEVEN boys to a&e injured.
Just my opinion I realise, but it is not a sport for children.

Mossstitch · 26/11/2022 22:23

Two boys died playing rugby at my sons' grammar school, one had a prior heart condition and could have died during any sport but the other one simply hit his head on the floor with a tackle. I was so glad none of mine were interested in playing. There are other safer ways to learn/enjoy teamwork.

MissyB1 · 26/11/2022 22:12

My dh played from about the age of 7 until his mid 30s. He only stopped when he tore his cruciate (horrible injury). But in his 50s he has had a hip replacement and and suffers a lot of back pain, both almost certainly caused by the wear and tear and old injuries from rugby.

Im so glad ds prefers football and running.

HRTQueen · 26/11/2022 22:08

YANBU

its such a rough game ds ended up with a broken ankle (this was at school) I refused to let him play anymore which he wasn’t bothered about his school thought he should get back in the pitch. Once they reach high school the boys are such different sizes you have boys at 6ft against boys who haven’t started their growth spurts it’s absolutely ridiculous