Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To steer DS away from rugby?

138 replies

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 19:07

DS is 10 and plays contact rugby for local club.
He loves it and is good-fast, strategic and tackles well.
But he is the smallest in his team and when up against big lads from other teams I worry he will get very hurt. They don’t put them in positions for another couple of years so he can easily be up against someone twice his size and he will go in for the tackle regardless of the size of his opponent.

On the other hand it’s great exercise and the teamwork is incredible. It comes with a good social life (although I also worry about the excessive alcohol culture in a few years time!)

Especially with the sad news stories about Doddie Weir & Rob Burrows and the increase in the chance of neurological issues in rugby players (albeit professional ones not junior club players!). It makes me wonder if I am doing the right thing in encouraging him and whether I should steer him towards concentrating on his other sports.

OP posts:
IntentionalError · 27/11/2022 11:38

This is such a difficult one. The benefits of playing Rugby are immense. It builds fitness, strength, competitiveness, resilience, physical courage, respect & teamwork in a way few other activities can match. The downside is that the risk of concussion, brain & spinal injuries is unacceptably high, and we are only starting to understand how dangerous repeated head trauma really is.

My view is that Rugby faces a choice. It either has to change to take the head & neck out of the contact area, or the game will die as people become more aware of the scale of the risks.

Mischance · 27/11/2022 11:20

I worked with adults with head injury and major disabilities - I would not allow my son anywhere near rugby - ever.

itsalwayscycling · 27/11/2022 11:19

TinySaltLick · 27/11/2022 00:21

14 year olds who weighed 16 stone? I'm extremely welcome to a debate on the subject but exaggerated figures aren't helpful - let's at least have a fact based discussion and not make up numbers to try and skew the situation

Half the current England International team aren't 100kg plus

Maybe exaggerated slightly but not much- I’m taking about the big 16y olds who can be playing against 14y olds here due to the way the age groups are set up here- our young-for-their-school-year boys play 2 years at U16s. Our biggest boys are def well over 80kg and I’ve seen boys who look significantly bigger than them in opposition teams.

NiceTwin · 27/11/2022 05:37

Purely anecdotal here.

Used to work in an all boys school, no football, all rugby.
In 6 years, we had the air ambulance twice, just to training, not a match. Two boys in back braces due to injury, more dislocated collarbone and broken limbs than I can recall.

Same amount of time in a mixed sex school. No rugby, just football. No air ambulances, no back braces, plenty of lower limb/foot fractures though.

RLScott · 27/11/2022 05:25

Steer clear of collision based sports.

Players are getting bigger, faster, more athletic, meaning the hits are bigger and more dangerous. Both rugby codes are in trouble with the concussion issue. Massive massive blokes. There are players now who have necks thicker than their heads.

Rugby concussions on the rise as players increase in size:

www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/health-family/fitness/rugby-concussions-on-the-rise-as-players-increase-in-size-1.3777673

Concussion rates in elite rugby hit highest levels since records began:

www.theguardian.com/sport/2022/jun/21/concussion-rates-in-elite-rugby-hit-highest-levels-since-records-began

On average, every 25 games a rugby player will have a concussion.

When these sports were invented, players were regular sized blokes. Generally speaking they were safe(ish). That’s changed. Neither are safe to play.

Football had an issue way back with heading heavy balls (and often), but the balls are much lighter now (and don’t soak up water which made the balls weigh a tonne like they used to). In the 1960s/70s Geoff Hurst used to spend half an hour just constantly jumping up and heading a ball hanging from a rope. That’s unheard of now as heading is also kept to a minimum in training (banned at youth level).

Football is a skill based sport. The emphasis is playing with the ball (passing, shooting, dribbling), and honing your technique. You won’t come home bruised and battered after a training session, which is the case with the rugby codes.

FancyFelix · 27/11/2022 04:23

YANBU. I've always steered my children away from rugby as it's just so brutal. Thankfully they have been much more in to football, cricket and running

CockingASnook · 27/11/2022 03:56

No way would I encourage young people to play rugby, knowing what we do today about CTE and other brain injuries. Look at the better understanding we have of concussion now, when previously players would get straight up and run it off. Developing brains are much more vulnerable too. Is he any good at rowing?

GarlandsinGreece · 27/11/2022 03:40

I don’t blame you for pausing to assess. I’m a Brit in the US and my husband and I were in agreement from when our boys were young, that American football would be a no-go. Concussions are fairly commonplace, even among young kids. So my eldest plays football and basketball, and the younger isn’t into team sports at all.

carefulcalculator · 27/11/2022 03:08

GrazingSheep · 26/11/2022 19:44

I think in 10 years time rugby in its current format will be a thing of the past.

I agree, especially for children.

user1494050295 · 27/11/2022 03:05

HundredMilesAnHour · 26/11/2022 19:44

If he's small, he'll just end up as a cox rather than a rower. Fine if that's what he wants but many find it difficult to deal with something outside their control (i.e. their height/size) blocking them from progressing.

Non contact though

4timesthefun · 27/11/2022 02:33

Rugby has been a no for my sons. They are incredibly sporty, and play several other things. We have had plenty of injuries, but there is a real difference between a broken arm from a basketball fall to the serious risks that rugby poses in later life. I find it puzzling the amount of people using their young adult as an example of how wonderful rugby is….. I wonder if they will still view it as positively when their 50 year old son is one of the MANY diagnosed with severe neurological problems as a result of cumulative head trauma. To me, nothing is worth that risk, particularly when there are so many other sports they could play.

oceanskye · 27/11/2022 02:30

We're in New Zealand and when my son played rugby at junior level it was organized by weight as well as age, so to play in an under 11 team you also had to be below a certain weight and would move up to the next age level if not. It was actually the reason my son stopped playing as he was big for his age but didn't want to play with older kids, however it makes sense for safety reasons. I'm happy enough that he had moved to other sports by high school age anyway as I think that's when it gets more serious.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 27/11/2022 02:13

They should be split by size and strength through the tweens and teens and not just by age. I agree with regard to the suggestion to try rugby league, and/or rowing, and what has been said about ambulances, and also with the positives of the sport. You would not be being unreasonable either way.

DrCoconut · 27/11/2022 01:39

My DS is the stereotypical school geek - skinny, the coordination of a newborn gazelle, and can't see more than arm's length away without his glasses. I worry about him being made to play rough sports now he's at secondary school as he's just not cut out for it. He finds all the charging about and flying balls quite intimidating and he's going to end up with his glasses smashed into his face or something. He's a good (though not Olympic material or anything) swimmer though and really enjoys that regularly, with prescription goggles so he can see the pool edge coming! So I'm all in favour of encouraging gentler pursuits but it does I guess depend on the individual what is suitable for them.

Cormoran · 27/11/2022 01:32

With what we know about CTE, I would never allow my kids to play any sport with repetitive hit on the head, even the light ones as a head shot in soccer.
I live in Australia, and the news are filled with ex players getting demented, suicidal or attacking their family in horror filled attack, like locking them in car and setting them on fire.
Watch the movie "concussion" which describes the true story on how CTE was discovered and research it a bit.
It is not about the injury on the fields, broken bones and such , it is about micro trauma, slamming into someone's back.
In the movie, there is a very visual scene, in which the doctor fills up a jar (head) with water and adds an egg (brain) to it. When you shake the jar (head) , the egg (brain) hits the glass (skull) . That's where the injury comes from, not so much from the outside blows as we all assume, the big hit causes a concussion.

In addition to CTE, there is a wide range of other neurodegenerative diseases caused by contact sport
Research published by the Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry found rugby players were at a greater risk of a brain disorder, ranging from just over twice as high for dementia, three times for Parkinson's disease and up to 15 times for motor neurone disease. Even in non professionals : In this respect, it is the first demonstration that high neurodegenerative disease risk is not a phenomenon exclusive to professional athletes.

I read that a single professional game was equivalent to hitting the head against the wall 17 times.

So , have a think and consider another sport.

Angrymum22 · 27/11/2022 01:06

*aren’t

Angrymum22 · 27/11/2022 01:05

Good coaching is essential with rugby.DS has played at school and club from the age of 6. The modern game is so different with rule changes that discourage the types of injuries that were common in the past.
All sports carry an element of risk and head injuries are just as common in football as they are in rugby.
Head gear does not protect them from head injury in fact it can have the opposite effect by encouraging them to go into tackles harder. The scrum caps are to protect the head and ears from soft tissue damage in scrums. If taught well tackling rarely involves the head and poor body position while tackling is penalised in the modern game with a yellow or red card.
They learn to fall and roll and although it looks like a massive fight/pile on there are strict rules regarding how many players can get involved.
It is a bit like organised gang warfare but they all come off the field, shake hands and retire to the clubhouse/school for food and drink.
DS is now 18 and goes nightclubbing and drinking in town. I feel quite relaxed about it since his best mates play front and second row and he plays back row. There are many people who would take them on as a pack. As on the pitch, they are fiercely protective of each other, although DS does admit that he feels extra safe since he can run the fastest.

PuttingDownRoots · 27/11/2022 00:50

DD plays U10s/U11s. There are so many rules protecting them now and shes getting a lot of benefit from it. Due to the awareness of injury possibility, its safer than some other sports

Unfortunately, she's only got 18months left until there won't be any games for her to play on until she's 14/15 die to lack of players on girls rugby (she can only play mixed at Primary school age)

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 00:39

YANBU. Just look at Mike Tindall. Seems like he barely has a braincell rattling around in there.

StClare101 · 27/11/2022 00:37

A family member is a quadriplegic requiring 24/7 care due to a rugby union incident. It was just a normal adult club game when he was 27.

My children will never play this awful sport.

TinySaltLick · 27/11/2022 00:21

itsalwayscycling · 26/11/2022 22:27

I love rugby and mine play but this really isn't true - there is a huge size differential at U14-U16 level, I've seen 14y olds who weigh 45kg soaking wet playing against 100Kg plus boys. Overall I think rugby has given mine an incredible experience and a very different team feeling to football (which they've played too) but it is always a bit nerve wracking now. They are really lightly built even at 15+ so I'm not sure how long they will keep playing. I wouldn't stop them but I also wouldn't force/encourage them to keep playing if they ever say they no longer love it.

14 year olds who weighed 16 stone? I'm extremely welcome to a debate on the subject but exaggerated figures aren't helpful - let's at least have a fact based discussion and not make up numbers to try and skew the situation

Half the current England International team aren't 100kg plus

AndAway · 27/11/2022 00:08

@healthadvice123 yes, absolutely reported it to the club. The coach denied it and that was the end of it. I was so disappointed, they sing from the rooftops that they're all about safety but when it came down to it, they weren't interested. It's a big part of why DS left. He saw his friend being put back on after the clash of heads and knew it was wrong and was horrified the club didn't seem to care.
I have loved rugby, made so many good friends from it and memories to last a lifetime. I've also seen the darker side of it though and ultimately am glad my own DS isn't involved anymore.

bellamountain · 27/11/2022 00:08

At the school I used to work at, rugby injuries were very very commonplace. Some serious injuries were had. I think perhaps try and steer your DS towards football instead, it's more skilful game anyhow.

healthadvice123 · 27/11/2022 00:02

@AndAway and did you report that to the club or rfu ? As that would of been taken very seriously . I would take my son away from a club that did that , also the laddish behaviour what do you mean
Mine have a laugh with mates but their not rude and a lot of the girls who play as it is growing quite big watch the boys and vice versa and its mixed when younger as well

Jenn3112 · 26/11/2022 23:56

DS is 11 and just started rugby. I don't think I will ever enjoy it but he also plays as a goalie in football and I think the risk is just as high there, if not worse, same with riding his bike on the roads locally. You can't refuse to let them do anything risky.