Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To steer DS away from rugby?

138 replies

Oldjumper · 26/11/2022 19:07

DS is 10 and plays contact rugby for local club.
He loves it and is good-fast, strategic and tackles well.
But he is the smallest in his team and when up against big lads from other teams I worry he will get very hurt. They don’t put them in positions for another couple of years so he can easily be up against someone twice his size and he will go in for the tackle regardless of the size of his opponent.

On the other hand it’s great exercise and the teamwork is incredible. It comes with a good social life (although I also worry about the excessive alcohol culture in a few years time!)

Especially with the sad news stories about Doddie Weir & Rob Burrows and the increase in the chance of neurological issues in rugby players (albeit professional ones not junior club players!). It makes me wonder if I am doing the right thing in encouraging him and whether I should steer him towards concentrating on his other sports.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/11/2022 21:01

Gymnastics is a great example of a sport that changed radically at elite level, due to safety concerns (eating disorders/delayed puberty), and is all the better for it. Current elite female gymnasts are so much healthier than their 80s counterparts, who were competing in adult competitions from their early teens. There was a lot of hand-wringing about how raising the minimum age would ruin the sport, but it's never been stronger. Of course, the changes haven't eliminated eating disorders and body pressures, but they have made many girls safer.

There is risk with all sports, but risks can be mitigated. Rugby needs to change. I bet the posters on here, who say that we should accept the risks of the game in its current form, wouldn't dream of driving their DC without a seat-belt on. Yet the risk of a serious injury as a car passenger, even without a seat-belt, is pretty miniscule for any given journey. But we still wear them because it's not worth taking a risk that is easily avoidable. No one has to play rugby. There are plenty of safer sports that offer as much fun and challenge. If the rugby authorities want their game to survive, they need to step up and make it safer.

Comtesse · 28/11/2022 18:17

The injuries can be horrendous. I don’t think I’d be encouraging rugby I have to say.

Petalpup · 28/11/2022 18:07

Changedma · 27/11/2022 18:45

@RLScott I’ve just looked up Steve Thompson. Apparently he says he would not want his son to take up rugby.

Honestly, that would be enough for me. He would know more about it than anyone commenting on here so I’d take his advice.

Also there’s just the fact that we don’t know much about brain injuries / hits to the head causing dementia and other neurological problems years down the line.. how serious the injury has to be, what kind of contact could be considered “safe” etc … things that were considered safe seem no longer to be. The research is moving very fast.

Completely not denying the connection between rugby and CTE etc but what else will we discover is bad?
I did a lot of gymnastics & trampolining-surely all that rotation and motion can’t be great? Diving?-they look like their head smashes the water at quite a pace.

There must be a balance between living a healthy and fulfilling life and doing as much as possible to prevent damage in later life.

peoniesarejustperfect · 27/11/2022 19:30

We've stopped our DS age 12 playing. He stopped last year. There are many sports that he loves playing including football, hockey and cricket as well as athletics.

Someone upthread suggested boys were going to be bullied as their mother wouldn't let them play. My DS has had no trouble and I can't imagine that happening. He's an athletic boy who loves sport, but who just doesn't play rugby.

Also totally agree with the university / rugby comment too!

Changedma · 27/11/2022 18:45

@RLScott I’ve just looked up Steve Thompson. Apparently he says he would not want his son to take up rugby.

Honestly, that would be enough for me. He would know more about it than anyone commenting on here so I’d take his advice.

Also there’s just the fact that we don’t know much about brain injuries / hits to the head causing dementia and other neurological problems years down the line.. how serious the injury has to be, what kind of contact could be considered “safe” etc … things that were considered safe seem no longer to be. The research is moving very fast.

RLScott · 27/11/2022 18:08

The main issue for the rugby codes when it comes to brain injury is they are getting more dangerous to play not less. Football it’s the opposite trend as the balls are much lighter than the rocks they used to have to head, plus they head the ball far less (in training its minuscule in comparison to the heading sessions they used to have).

On average a player will suffer a concussion every 25 games in RU. That soon adds up.

Older players (pre 1995 before the pro era) have had less issue with brain trauma. With their much smaller/slimmer physique their collisions were far less impactful. It’s the bigger younger players where dementia and other brain conditions have been ramped up.

JPR Williams (Welsh player from the 1970s, when players were more regular sized blokes) says his team would get smashed by the Welsh team of today:

www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/rugbyunion/article-2103088/Six-Nations-2012-JPR-Williams--Welsh-giants-smashed-Grand-Slam-heroes.html

Rugby players on average now weigh 14kg more than they did 25 years ago:

www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/rugby-union/six-nations-2020-how-have-players-grown-size-past-25-years-and-who-heaviest-player-tournament-3020300

Steve Thompson, 2003 Rugby Union World Cup winner, can’t remember any of the final. And just in his size, he was huge, which is indicative of the transformation in physique.

The emphasis with the rugby codes is punishment via gym work, downing protein shakes, and building up your body for the collisions. The emphasis in football is enjoying yourself by getting out a ball and kicking it about.

RandomUsernameHere · 27/11/2022 18:00

YANBU
I'm very relieved both my children hate rugby

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 17:43

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 17:21

Thank you for your reasoned response, we didn't get into a pointless ding dong! Me and my husband cry every time we see Rob on TV or are at an event he's attending. He was such an inspirational athlete, with incredible speed, balance and strength - all accompanied by a fantastic attitude and ethos.

It is so sad - he seems like a lovely guy.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 17:41

Mummyme87 · 27/11/2022 17:27

They’ve stopped the heavy scrum training in professional rugby, my boys both do rugby, 4yr old and 8yr old. Coaches said the head gear doesn’t help anything except cauliflower ears.

Yeah, head gear doesn’t help, because the primary cause of injury is usually the head hitting the inside of the skull. Head protectors probably prevent the odd skull fracture, but skull fractures themselves are not usually dangerous - it’s the brain injury that is the concern.

Mummyme87 · 27/11/2022 17:27

They’ve stopped the heavy scrum training in professional rugby, my boys both do rugby, 4yr old and 8yr old. Coaches said the head gear doesn’t help anything except cauliflower ears.

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 17:21

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 17:09

the sport which, especially for league in some areas, fulfils a very important community role for low cost. I'm sure union is the same for other localities also, although being traditionally for the more affluent, may not be the only option or such a lifeline. See also boxing

Agree about both rugby and boxing. Rugby, at least, has the potential to reform and to reduce risk massively - as it did with spinal injury in the 80s/90s. Yes, it will change the game, but it's that or die, as more parents become aware of the potential harms.

Thank you for your reasoned response, we didn't get into a pointless ding dong! Me and my husband cry every time we see Rob on TV or are at an event he's attending. He was such an inspirational athlete, with incredible speed, balance and strength - all accompanied by a fantastic attitude and ethos.

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 17:13

HoldingTheDoor · 27/11/2022 16:58

There were/are a lot of people involved in the NFL who wanted to deny a link between the sport that they loved and CTE, in spite of the evidence, it doesn't mean that the link didn't exist, and those players also seem to be much more likely to develop MND.

That's why I used the Hawking example , although I may not have made my point very well. Very, very few CTE sufferers have no history of brain trauma, while there are plenty of MND sufferers who have never had head trauma. This makes a direct causal link much harder to prove.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 17:09

the sport which, especially for league in some areas, fulfils a very important community role for low cost. I'm sure union is the same for other localities also, although being traditionally for the more affluent, may not be the only option or such a lifeline. See also boxing

Agree about both rugby and boxing. Rugby, at least, has the potential to reform and to reduce risk massively - as it did with spinal injury in the 80s/90s. Yes, it will change the game, but it's that or die, as more parents become aware of the potential harms.

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 17:05

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow I agree, I didn't mean to offend anyone or say there was no danger. I just got prickly when the examples used were Rob and Dodi, both of whom have been hugely supported by their rugby communities and wouldn't want MND to be a reason to discourage anyone's participation. Neither of ours played, beyond school - seeing their dad during and after games (and how he is now) probably put them off, but they are still involved with the sport which, especially for league in some areas, fulfils a very important community role for low cost. I'm sure union is the same for other localities also, although being traditionally for the more affluent, may not be the only option or such a lifeline. See also boxing.

HoldingTheDoor · 27/11/2022 16:58

There were/are a lot of people involved in the NFL who wanted to deny a link between the sport that they loved and CTE, in spite of the evidence, it doesn't mean that the link didn't exist, and those players also seem to be much more likely to develop MND.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 16:55

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 16:48

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow I wasn't saying OP was unreasonable to be concerned and there have definitely been more credible studies about links to other conditions, such as the one you mentioned. My husband certainly is a mechanical wreck after 30 years of being tackled - he also claims he has some better health indicators than other men his age as a result, such as heart and lung efficiency, muscle mass and a huge social network to stave off mental health issues. With regards to MND, he knows Rob and some of his friends and they are all keen not to discourage rugby out of fear of this specific condition.

People with a disease are often highly invested in denying a link between the disease and an associated behaviour (cognitive dissonance).

And no one knows which individual cases are linked to head injury - anyone who says otherwise is talking bollocks. But the main reason to be wary of rugby at present is not MND or PD anyway, but CTE itself.

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 16:48

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow I wasn't saying OP was unreasonable to be concerned and there have definitely been more credible studies about links to other conditions, such as the one you mentioned. My husband certainly is a mechanical wreck after 30 years of being tackled - he also claims he has some better health indicators than other men his age as a result, such as heart and lung efficiency, muscle mass and a huge social network to stave off mental health issues. With regards to MND, he knows Rob and some of his friends and they are all keen not to discourage rugby out of fear of this specific condition.

Tigofigo · 27/11/2022 16:47

I won't let mine play contact rugby (and when I no longer have a say I'll strongly discourage it). A relative of mine was injured and knocked out playing several times and my DC are small and slight. Luckily they've not shown any interest. YANBU. There are other ways to get cameraderie and team spirit. Also quite a high proportion of the rugger lads at uni were sexist dickheads.

HoldingTheDoor · 27/11/2022 16:46

So if we don't know, why are you so quick to say that it is unrelated in spite of this study, and there will be others in the future? And what was the point of bringing Stephen Hawking into it? No one said that it's exclusively caused by contact sports.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 16:46

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 16:40

And there's been a lot more study into the link between smoking and cancer. The official medical line is that we don't know if anything 'causes' MND.

You don't understand the difference between establishing an association (link) with an illness and understanding the underlying pathology (disease mechanism) that causes the link.

We know that certain behaviours are linked to certain illnesses - smoking and lung cancer, alcohol and liver cancer, infants sleeping on their front and SIDS, etc. In many cases, even decades after the association was first established, we don't understand the exact mechanism by which the disease is caused. That doesn't mean that the link isn't real. If we had waited for the mechanism by which smoking causes lung cancer to be fully understood, we would still not have taken any action to reduce smoking and, worldwide, there would have been millions of preventable premature deaths.

PrettyUpMyPorch · 27/11/2022 16:42

There's a podcast called Head Noise about brain injuries in rugby which is worth listening to

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 16:40

HoldingTheDoor · 27/11/2022 16:34

Stephen Hawking didn't play contact sports.

Confused Non-smokers can still get lung cancer. That doesn't mean that there aren't links between smoking and lung cancer.

And there's been a lot more study into the link between smoking and cancer. The official medical line is that we don't know if anything 'causes' MND.

ninjafoodienovice · 27/11/2022 16:40

My Dnephew has had an horrendous concussion from rugby. Will never play again and had to drop out of university. Currently battling serious depression and insomnia and it's hard to say how long recovery will take.
YANBU in the slightest to take your son out of rugby.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 16:40

Hobbi · 27/11/2022 16:31

@tickticksnooze
Not according to Rob and his medical staff - I have spoken to him about it. One study showed a link. Stephen Hawking didn't play contact sports.

How would they know? No one knows which individual cases are related to head injury. We just know rates are higher in rugby/soccer/NFL players than the general population.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 27/11/2022 16:38

tickticksnooze · 27/11/2022 16:27

It is related. Why are you lying?

It may be related. We know that the incidence of neurological conditions, including MND and Parkinson's Disease, is higher in people who experience repeated head injury. We don't know whether any particular individual's MND or PD is due to head injury.

So we can say with certainty that there is an association between head injury and MND/Parkinson's. We can say that it is highly likely that MND and PD are caused by head injury, though we don't know the exact mechanism yet. We can't yet say whether given individual would have developed MND or PD without playing rugby.

But the data on CTE is pretty horrifying, even without considering MND and PD. CTE can only be diagnosed at post-mortem. One study of American Football players' brains found CTE in 88% of them. CTE is not a small though horrible risk, like spinal injury. It is a natural consequence of repeated head injury - people who don't get it seem to be the exception.

Swipe left for the next trending thread