Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should probably buy our children less this Christmas if we care about their future?

88 replies

verdantverdure · 26/11/2022 17:15

What do you think? Where are you on the spectrum between an all out Christmas as usual with all the consumption of the earth's resources that involves and a Christmas that prioritises the planet we leave our children over a lot of things we could probably cheerfully do without?

YABU Christmas as usual in our house.

YANBU We have thought about it and reined things in a bit.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 26/11/2022 18:42

@wa At 4 years old you can get your DD one doll and she would be happy. I have teenagers, it is very different as they get older.

TheGuv1982 · 26/11/2022 18:40

No change here, but then because the kids are pretty much past the age that they want toys, presents are much more practical- football stuff ect so I wouldn’t see much of it as frivolous.

FridayNightIsWineNight · 26/11/2022 18:39

Me and DH have cut back with one another. I haven't really cut back on the kids however I do buy second hand plastic toys, I refuse to pay for new plastic that gets wasted so always buy second hand. I've also bought second hand clothes due to DS1 liking brands. I try and only buy what I know will get used lots and I like to buy a lot of edibles cause I know they'll be eaten.
Food wise - I'm cutting back. I always buy far too much and I'm not doing it this year.
We've cut back (agreed by all parties) who we buy for.

Athenen0ctua · 26/11/2022 18:34

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:29

But it's just an assumption. You don't have any evidence to each individual's approach to any of their consumption habits. Which is why blanket statements can at times be ineffective

What assumption? Some people don't buy a lot year round, many just don't have the money like us, many make a conscious decision not to. Some don't buy a lot at Christmas but buy all year. Some buy a lot at Christmas but nothing all year. Many different approaches, I was agreeing while saying it's the yearly consumption that matters.

wannadisc0 · 26/11/2022 18:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 26/11/2022 18:33

You sound like a couple I know who bang on about climate change all the time, but also have 4 kids.

Best thing people can do for climate change is to have fewer children.

P.S. I'm not saying that people should have less children, but people who get preachy about climate change and also have multiple kids wind me up tbh.

antelopevalley · 26/11/2022 18:33

OP I care about climate change very much.
But I find people who tend to take your approach have kids who already have lots. So they do not suffer at all if you give them less at Christmas. My children would suffer.

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:29

Athenen0ctua · 26/11/2022 18:27

It can't just be limited to Christmas as people's approaches do differ. There's no difference between buying many new plastic toys (the kind that don't last) through the year or the same amount yearly but only given at Christmas/birthdays.

But it's just an assumption. You don't have any evidence to each individual's approach to any of their consumption habits. Which is why blanket statements can at times be ineffective

SweetSakura · 26/11/2022 18:29

verdantverdure · 26/11/2022 18:17

Perhaps I should have made the YABU/YANBU more contentious?

YABU The hardest, worst, most horrible climate apocalypse the sooner the better for my children please!

YANBU I do what I can to stave it off as long as possible and soften its effects because every little helps.

Plus the more we slow it down the more scope there is to find new solutions

QuestionableMouse · 26/11/2022 18:28

It'll make no difference until the massive companies change their ways. Don't forget that BP invented the idea of a carbon footprint and they're one of the worst polluters out there!

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:28

SweetSakura · 26/11/2022 18:23

Well, I think it's fair to assume that anyone who is still massively over consuming doesn't care about the future of the planet?

And assuming "You don't care about the planet!" smacks of judgement and self-righteousness when you have no way of knowing that.

That's the problem with this site. "If you don't do what I do exactly how I do it, you're wrong, a bad person, and you deserve to be shamed!"

Athenen0ctua · 26/11/2022 18:27

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:21

I'm not a fan of these kinds of threads because it tends to make people feel guilty if their approach to Christmas gifts differs. It's good to be conscious. But even if it isn't meant, it does imply that people who don't follow the OPs lead don't care about their children's future.

It can't just be limited to Christmas as people's approaches do differ. There's no difference between buying many new plastic toys (the kind that don't last) through the year or the same amount yearly but only given at Christmas/birthdays.

TheChosenTwo · 26/11/2022 18:27

@Ramble0n a stick AND a satsuma? Should be one or the other 🤨

OP, worry about what you can control - your own Christmas. I will worry about what I can control - my Christmas. And our Christmas will be the same as previous years, no changes here. Plenty of good food and booze, plenty of presents for the dc (although they’ve never had mountains), we will have a lovely day. As I’m sure you will, however you decide to celebrate. It’s one day.

Fairislefandango · 26/11/2022 18:26

Why are you assuming everyone usually does an 'all-out' Christmas? I've always been astonished by the excess on the MN Christmas present and food threads, as I barely buy a fraction of what many seem to. And that's not even because of the future of the planet or because I couldn't afford more. It's just not how we've ever done things. And plenty of people just can't afford to.

I love Christmas and will be doing exactly the same as usual. No tat. No 'shit we don't need'. No food we won't eat. Not because of any of any moral or environmental panic though - just because why would you buy stuff people don't want? Tbh I find the OTT hand-wringing and virtue-signalling about the abhorrence and disgustingness of Christmas consumption more irritating than the consumption itself!

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:26

SweetSakura · 26/11/2022 18:23

Well, I think it's fair to assume that anyone who is still massively over consuming doesn't care about the future of the planet?

Yeah but how do we know people are massively overconsuming? Why must people resort to hyperbole when it comes to certain issues. It's not black and white. Maybe they're not at all but will feel bad about it. And shame and guilt isn't, IMO the best approach.

Kpo58 · 26/11/2022 18:26

I think that its much better to buy what a person actually would want as a gift, than the mindless toiletries, Poundland tat or other poor quality items. I prefer buying something smaller which is of quality than lots of poor quality stuff that is either not wanted or breaks easily.

It's also a good idea to ignore the lots of items in an expensive advent calendar, first of December boxes and Christmas eve boxes. They are pretty much someone's entire Christmas present on various days before Christmas. What's wrong with waiting for the big day?

Ramble0n · 26/11/2022 18:25

Mine are getting a second hand stick and a satsuma. Bread and jam for Xmas dinner and they will be grateful for that.

SweetSakura · 26/11/2022 18:23

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:21

I'm not a fan of these kinds of threads because it tends to make people feel guilty if their approach to Christmas gifts differs. It's good to be conscious. But even if it isn't meant, it does imply that people who don't follow the OPs lead don't care about their children's future.

Well, I think it's fair to assume that anyone who is still massively over consuming doesn't care about the future of the planet?

MNMH · 26/11/2022 18:21

I'm not a fan of these kinds of threads because it tends to make people feel guilty if their approach to Christmas gifts differs. It's good to be conscious. But even if it isn't meant, it does imply that people who don't follow the OPs lead don't care about their children's future.

stargirl1701 · 26/11/2022 18:18

Christmas as usual here but we have always used the much-hated poem anyway.

verdantverdure · 26/11/2022 18:17

Perhaps I should have made the YABU/YANBU more contentious?

YABU The hardest, worst, most horrible climate apocalypse the sooner the better for my children please!

YANBU I do what I can to stave it off as long as possible and soften its effects because every little helps.

OP posts:
Oysterbabe · 26/11/2022 18:16

Christmas as usual but we don't buy masses and don't buy tat that's binned 5 minutes later.

Pumperthepumper · 26/11/2022 18:13

I don’t think it’s fair to target the kids specifically, although I agree with you in theory. Everyone could do more: get a live tree in a pot. Buy only what you need for Christmas dinner. Shop ethically and don’t buy tat stocking-filler plastic garbage.

Sidking · 26/11/2022 18:11

I also don't think we go overboard in the first place, 2 boys have around 18 presents each plus stockings (3-5 small toys then chocolate, character undies or socks, a bath bomb...)

Sidking · 26/11/2022 18:10

We're carrying on as usual at Christmas but don't buy a lot throughout the year, and birthdays are usually 1-2 bigger/more expensive things whereas Christmas is more smaller/£10-40ish stuff.

I've also bought some things Preloved, they have new onesies for Christmas eve but they're off vinted, as are a few presents