Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there hypocrisy of constant criticism of Qatar (World Cup)?

110 replies

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 26/11/2022 14:30

I was speaking with my friends, and we all noticed how much outrage is given to Qatar compared to other countries. Yes, Qatar has some awful laws and things going in their country but so do a lot of countries. There was little outrage given to Russia World Cup 2018 and the Olympics in China but when it comes to Qatar a lot of people are virtue signalling. For example, singers like Dua Lipa saying they are not going to perform in Qatar because of human rights. But they do concerts in Dubai which have similar laws to Qatar. I think a lot of people need to realize that Qatar own or have influence to a lot of things in London (Shard, Harrods, Savoy hotel, stock exchange etc..)

I was listening to the radio and a caller made an interesting point "what country is 100 percent perfect?" Even in 2026 USA, Mexico and Canada World Cup there are many issues there. USA- Gun issues, Abortion not always being legalised etc... Mexico - lot of drug cartels there. But I bet you they will not get the same outrage as Qatar.

OP posts:
queenofarles · 29/11/2022 14:52

All stadia in Qatar built from scratch, because there is nothing remotely suitable already that could have been improved or a new one built to replace it.. I haven’t seen the new ones , but I remember seeing the one we’re they held the 2006 Asian games in, DS used to train in one of pitches next to it , its big, I think that’s were they Eng vs Iran was held.

MintyFreshOne · 29/11/2022 14:49

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 14:34

It is ok to criticise but ultimately you should take a chance to meet other countries where they are instead of this quasi-colonial, high-handed position where you ignore them and hope they somehow change for the better? Hard to see how that happens

eh?

You want countries to change their ways and hew closer to Western mores before you deign to attend a soccer game in their country, for
example.

It seems counterproductive to me. There are no universal values, you do what you can to influence the rest of the world but unless you go full-on colonialist, you really can’t force change on other countries.

queenofarles · 29/11/2022 14:46

Brefugee

they wouldn't have had to build all the stadia, would they?

Russia built six stadiums for the World Cup 🙄

Have you been there ? I lived there , they have plenty of stadiums , each local club has its own stadium , Barcelona’s current manger Xavi was the manger of one of the local clubs before moving to Barcelona

where do you think all these International teams are training atm? They are training at these clubs .

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 14:43

i see the Qatar Marketing Board have arrived.

The point of awarding the WC to countries, is in part, to help them improve their infrastructure. What is first needed are places where there is a willingness to have new stadia, that will be used for football after the WC has gone. We have all seen that giant bird toilet they built in Brazil - we complained about the circumstances of that stadium long and hard at the time. but whatever

FIFA don't allow more than 2 stadia in any one city for a reason, bit AFAIK there are 4 in and around Doha? All stadia in Qatar built from scratch, because there is nothing remotely suitable already that could have been improved or a new one built to replace it. That is what people like me mean when we say they don't have a tradition of playing football.

And yes, it would have been better spread over a few countries (and with less of the exploitation of workers and the deaths.).

As for the suitability of the weather: football is a winter season sport. It is already too hot for the players in Qatar - but in essence it is no worse than in 94 when it was in the USA so that's not really an argument against the location.

People's photos from the stadia seem to show them having a good time. They seem clean and comfortable and the food seems ok. The alcohol ban for all but the prawn sandwich brigade isn't on though. It only shows the organisers in a bad light as people who won't keep to their contracts, so there is that. I'm generally avoiding all news of the WC and not actually watching though so I'm not sure what the general feeling is among fans there. Have the games all been sold out? I would hope so, but again, that has happened in other places, i think.

Ponderingwindow · 29/11/2022 14:36

The focus on workers and lgbtq does seem somewhat hypocritical.

that doesn’t change the situation with women’s rights. The press and protesters are completely ignoring that problem. The are no armbands protesting women held hostage by a guardianship system. There is no endless loop of press coverage of women being arrested for the crime of being raped.

dubai should not be given a pass. Women there face criminal charges for reporting rape.

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 14:34

It is ok to criticise but ultimately you should take a chance to meet other countries where they are instead of this quasi-colonial, high-handed position where you ignore them and hope they somehow change for the better? Hard to see how that happens

eh?

MintyFreshOne · 29/11/2022 14:27

It's got the most unsuitable climate for football that you can imagine, except for Antarctica

How is the climate unsuitable? The temperatures aren’t blazing hot all year round you know.

There was corruption involved in the vote

True. FIFA and the IOC are both totally corrupt. But what can anyone do about it?

They had build all the stadia, which will be white elephants as soon as the tournament is over

Its actually nice to have the WC in a place where all the fans are gathered in essentially one city. It’s not going to happen again.

That said, it would have been better if it was a joint bid from the GCC that would have included Saudi, Kuwait, UAE, Bahrain, etc

MintyFreshOne · 29/11/2022 14:22

No one likes real, in your face diversity. They like the fake kind, where you have a diversity of skin colour but believe the exact same things.

Otherwise we would just hold these international events in Europe and who should want that?

Tbh having the games in Qatar has changed the country for the better — the international media focused on the worker abuses and many aspects of the Kafala system have changed for the better under this pressure. Hope they are not rescinded once the spotlight is off them …

It is ok to criticise but ultimately you should take a chance to meet other countries where they are instead of this quasi-colonial, high-handed position where you ignore them and hope they somehow change for the better? Hard to see how that happens

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 14:18

we really need to stop this white prejudice towards others , like only white people play football

bollocks. I haven't mentioned anyone's ethnicity. I don't believe they have a culture of football playing in the way they do in, say, Iran or South Africa or Japan. If they had, they wouldn't have had to build all the stadia, would they?

They may get there in the end if it takes off. They certainly sponsor a lot of football and there are teams with Qatari ownership. That isn't a tradition of football in the way it is in other places.

But sure, try to make everyone out to be a racist. Nobody brings race into it until they try to defend the indefensible.

ilovesooty · 29/11/2022 14:14

queenofarles · 29/11/2022 13:17

They have zero tradition of playing football
they rank 50 , higher than South Africa
they won the Asian cup in 2019.
we really need to stop this white prejudice towards others , like only white people play football ,
I’ve seen videos of an Australian reporter trying to spot fake fans just because they are Indians , like no Indians ever watch football 🙄

Where has anyone suggested that only white people play football?

ilovesooty · 29/11/2022 14:12

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 09:08

Are you a football fan?
I ask because responses are different.
I'm a huge football fan, the WC is a great festival of football and i usually watch as many matches as i can.
I watched the event when it was in Russia. At the time it was awarded to Russia and Qatar i joined the voices of complaint and i have never let that up, even during the WC in Russia. I watched only the football, and none of the related events, because at least Russia has a history and tradition of playing the sport.

Qatar? not so much. They have zero tradition of playing football and i am not watching any of it. Their human rights abuses and the environmental impact are things i, my friends and plenty of people on and offline have been talking about since 2012 when the award was made. When it is over? yep, we'll still be talking about it.

What i am rather tired of are people who have never been involved in any discussions on it with me, or football in general, suddenly going "yeah but USA!" etc. So what? All the talk of "hypocricy" and "band wagons" is getting on my tits.

You do you. But stop pretending this isn't a hugely complex issue.

Agreed.

queenofarles · 29/11/2022 13:17

They have zero tradition of playing football
they rank 50 , higher than South Africa
they won the Asian cup in 2019.
we really need to stop this white prejudice towards others , like only white people play football ,
I’ve seen videos of an Australian reporter trying to spot fake fans just because they are Indians , like no Indians ever watch football 🙄

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 09:19

For the avoidance of doubt though: i think it is fine to have the WC at this time of year. I assume it would be the same if it were hosted in Australia. That is fine.

The fact that homosexuality was illegal when the WC was held here? in 1966? Women weren't allowed mortgages either. So? There were huge social changes between then and now. I am irked by the fact that gay football players feel unable to be out. That is something that i find strange given the push for rainbow flags, armbands, laces etc. I believe it is a matter of time. But that is up to individual players.

I'm a bit nonplussed about the whole LGB hing in Qatar. I mean, we know there are gay people around there always have been. Even in 1966 in the UK. There are in Qatar, they have to be careful. I hope things change for them. I don't think flags and armbands will help them much.

I'll be happy if there is a legacy effect of these games in Qatar and football gets to be much more poupular and those stadiums get a lot of use. The deaths of the construction workers will have more meaning then (IYSWIM? they shouldn't have happened)

I'm angry that rich owners, FIFA, UEFA the FA and theDFB are "stealing" football from the fans, even while i do enjoy going to matches (I have a season ticket to a bundesliga club). Our protest? we're going to the non-league matches and it's great. Will continue to do that after the WC has finished.

WarmWinterSun · 29/11/2022 09:18

I don’t think the criticism is hypocritical. I think there was criticism of the World Cup in Russia. I find a lot very troubling about this World Cup. The deaths of migrant workers who built the stadium is extremely alarming. The lack of workers rights, death penalty for homosexuality, control of women, not to mention the terrible carbon footprint… and then there is the outright corruption by Fifa. I don’t think we should be taking part in this.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 09:18

gogohmm · 26/11/2022 14:59

The issue with this World Cup is that it's far more obvious. Qatar is not a football fan nation, the climate is unsuitable and they didn't have any infrastructure so the carbon footprint is huge. Russia for all its faults do play football and do have stadia (never thought I'd defend Russia!) and yes I did criticise Russia but Qatar is a whole another level of unsuitability

Quite. If you have to move the whole fucking tournament by two seasons just to make it viable then the corruption's a bit harder to ignore.

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 09:08

Are you a football fan?
I ask because responses are different.
I'm a huge football fan, the WC is a great festival of football and i usually watch as many matches as i can.
I watched the event when it was in Russia. At the time it was awarded to Russia and Qatar i joined the voices of complaint and i have never let that up, even during the WC in Russia. I watched only the football, and none of the related events, because at least Russia has a history and tradition of playing the sport.

Qatar? not so much. They have zero tradition of playing football and i am not watching any of it. Their human rights abuses and the environmental impact are things i, my friends and plenty of people on and offline have been talking about since 2012 when the award was made. When it is over? yep, we'll still be talking about it.

What i am rather tired of are people who have never been involved in any discussions on it with me, or football in general, suddenly going "yeah but USA!" etc. So what? All the talk of "hypocricy" and "band wagons" is getting on my tits.

You do you. But stop pretending this isn't a hugely complex issue.

Jackofallsorts · 29/11/2022 09:03

Aishah231 · 26/11/2022 14:41

Which country has been involved in more illegal wars and coups than any other? The USA.

I'm with you OP - it's tokenistic virtue signalling hypocritical bollocks!

Really? Are you able to quote a source on this. Given the age of the USA vs other countries such as England I don't believe this to be true.

Ylvamoon · 29/11/2022 08:59

It's simple, it's new and trendy (in a negative way) ... before the World Cup, we didn't care or know much about Qatar.
We choose to ignore a lot or go along with it because of the oil. It will also fade into insignificance again afterwards.

FlamingJingleBells · 29/11/2022 07:01

Posted too soon, it'll be interesting to see how far their bid goes considering what's gone on in the world Cup.

FlamingJingleBells · 29/11/2022 06:59

I'll try to link to the article but the Qataris along with some other partners are considering putting in a bid for Liverpool football club.

TomPinch · 29/11/2022 03:13

Mentalpiece · 27/11/2022 12:13

They were, but suddenly in the last couple of weeks everyone and their dog has jumped on the bandwagon.

Ie, when the tournament started? How coincidental.

queenofarles · 27/11/2022 13:27

readymade they are very smart with their money. if you can ,look up QatarGas CEO interview on Skynews , the man is very well spoken , he pointed out the issues surrounding the energy crisis, how it started where we are and what can be done ,basically , it can’t be solved very quickly , the west has no actual functioning plan B, The interviewer just sheepishly asked why can’t Qatar just open the tap 😵‍💫.

the west is showing a lot of prejudice towards them, how dare a former British protectorate act this way.

Mentalpiece · 27/11/2022 12:13

They were, but suddenly in the last couple of weeks everyone and their dog has jumped on the bandwagon.

readymade · 27/11/2022 11:09

I think the west is jealous of the money Qatar has, and how the region controls the price of oil while the west are paying for it. And also some casual racism towards the arabs

HoldingTheDoor · 27/11/2022 08:59

Concerns were raised long before 2022. www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/25/revealed-qatars-world-cup-slaves Just one example.

Swipe left for the next trending thread