Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have exercised my dog on the kids play park?

281 replies

CattyStark · 26/11/2022 08:51

Across the road from us used to be wasteland/fields home to deer, hares, foxes, rabbits and all other kinds of beautiful animals. However, god forbid any space be left unbuilt on so they flattened it all and built houses around it with a “green space” in the middle. In the middle of the green space is a kids play park - it doesn’t have much stuff in it, no swings or slides etc, just those modern colourful platform things that parks love these days and some stuff on springs. It’s largely just an enclosed (4 foot gated fence green space with benches in it) There are never any kids in it. Plus, it’s on flood land so is always waterlogged.

8am this morning - nobody about, my dog had already had her shit, she’s not a digger so wouldn’t cause any damage … I took her in, closed the gate and let her have a good run around off lead. Kept my eye on her the whole time, made sure nobody was coming in any direction, gave her 10 minutes and then we left.

I used to walk my dog on the field that used to be there and I’m still disappointed that it’s gone … as well as wondering where all the animals went 😞

OP posts:
CupOfCake · 26/11/2022 13:33

Well, seeing as your dog is special, obviously that's fine.

balalake · 26/11/2022 13:48

You may be a responsible dog owner, your dog had done its 'business', so probably no harm on this occasion.

I don't think you should do so again.

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/11/2022 14:00

SkylightSkylight · 26/11/2022 10:03

Better have a word with those foxes & other wildlife then.

Apart from bird poo which is much less disgusting than dog poo there's not enough of any other wildlife for it to be a problem. A couple of foxes and 2 or 3 hedgehogs in the average park is nothing compared to hundreds of dogs using it as a toilet. Cats usually toilet in flower beds or sheltered areas not in the open grass or tarmac. Unfortunately dog shit is a frequent problem in local fenced off play areas. Other types of shit never are. It's bad enough that pavements, footpaths and every other type of public outdoor space is covered in stinking piles of dog shit , can we not just have one place that isn't?

Hobbesmanc · 26/11/2022 14:06

We have loads of open green space in our village. And an enclosed running track. A small minority of dog owners insist on letting their precious pooches into the track field presumably because they can let them off the lead safely.

Great for lazy dog walkers. Not for those who train at the track or the local school.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 14:10

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/11/2022 14:00

Apart from bird poo which is much less disgusting than dog poo there's not enough of any other wildlife for it to be a problem. A couple of foxes and 2 or 3 hedgehogs in the average park is nothing compared to hundreds of dogs using it as a toilet. Cats usually toilet in flower beds or sheltered areas not in the open grass or tarmac. Unfortunately dog shit is a frequent problem in local fenced off play areas. Other types of shit never are. It's bad enough that pavements, footpaths and every other type of public outdoor space is covered in stinking piles of dog shit , can we not just have one place that isn't?

Yep. Last week DD trod in dog poo directly outside the playground gate as well – leaving aside that anyone who doesn’t pick up their dog’s poo is a bastard anyway, what kind of sociopath lets their dog do it literal inches from kids’ spaces? It’s so territorial, like dog owners resent there being this dog-free spot. In fact that’s what I got from the OP: it was really nothing to do with needing an off-lead area and everything to do with marking her territory.

DixonD · 26/11/2022 14:13

CattyStark · 26/11/2022 09:01

Hardly lazy, we’d been walking an hour and a half before we went in it! I took her in on the way home

Well, if you’d been out that long a run in the park was entirely unnecessary.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 14:19

DuckWalkedUpToALemonadeStand · 26/11/2022 13:12

I don't think it's fair to expose everyone else to dogs. Lets stop glorifying dogs and dog ownership, and point out how gross they actually are. People seem brainwashed about dogs. Too much 101 Dalmatians and Paw Patrol.

Does are gross? Have you seen what humans do?

Vomit, urinate, shit, blow their nose on the ground, hawk up phlegm, pick their nose and eat it, leave rubbish behind? And all this in public spaces.

EndlessRain · 26/11/2022 14:21

There was noone there, your dog didn't wee or poo or dig, just ran around. I can see no issue with this.

Do people saying "dirty dog in play park" etc think dogs and foxes abide by the "no dogs" sign?

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 14:23

EndlessRain · 26/11/2022 14:21

There was noone there, your dog didn't wee or poo or dig, just ran around. I can see no issue with this.

Do people saying "dirty dog in play park" etc think dogs and foxes abide by the "no dogs" sign?

There isn’t a “no foxes” sign and foxes are wild animals. Dogs are domesticated and owned and the “No dogs” sign is for their owners. Quite why so many owners think it doesn’t apply to their super-special magical unique fur baby is beyond me.

Travis1 · 26/11/2022 14:23

😂😂This thread is golden. Loving all the pearl clutching sanctimony. @CattyStark id use it, doesn’t sound like it’s even a proper kids park. Let the dog get the use of it. All the better if you set a ‘precedent’ 😂

EndlessRain · 26/11/2022 14:25

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 14:23

There isn’t a “no foxes” sign and foxes are wild animals. Dogs are domesticated and owned and the “No dogs” sign is for their owners. Quite why so many owners think it doesn’t apply to their super-special magical unique fur baby is beyond me.

But a cat or a fox is car more likely to poo in the area than a dog that has already been to the toilet and is being watched. I just have no idea what the negative impact of a dog running a few laps of a play park is, when noone is around. Or is it just it's mere presence that offends you. Odd.

TheKeatingFive · 26/11/2022 14:28

Vomit, urinate, shit, blow their nose on the ground, hawk up phlegm, pick their nose and eat it, leave rubbish behind? And all this in public spaces

Im sure people would have plenty to say about people vomiting, urinating or shitting in a children's play area and none of those things make it okay to take a dog somewhere they are not allowed to be.

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2022 14:34

But a cat or a fox is car more likely to poo in the area than a dog that has already been to the toilet and is being watched. I just have no idea what the negative impact of a dog running a few laps of a play park is, when noone is around. Or is it just it's mere presence that offends you. Odd
I don't think anyone expects play areas to be perfectly clean and never have any animal in. That would be stupid.

It doesn't mean it's right for dog owners to look at a children's play area and use it as an exercise space for their dogs.

But then I'm a dog owner who also gets annoyed at owners who bring their dogs to play areas with their children. It says no dogs so that means no dogs, not no dogs unless you're too lazy to manage life with children and dogs so let your dogs in the play area.

EndlessRain · 26/11/2022 14:37

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2022 14:34

But a cat or a fox is car more likely to poo in the area than a dog that has already been to the toilet and is being watched. I just have no idea what the negative impact of a dog running a few laps of a play park is, when noone is around. Or is it just it's mere presence that offends you. Odd
I don't think anyone expects play areas to be perfectly clean and never have any animal in. That would be stupid.

It doesn't mean it's right for dog owners to look at a children's play area and use it as an exercise space for their dogs.

But then I'm a dog owner who also gets annoyed at owners who bring their dogs to play areas with their children. It says no dogs so that means no dogs, not no dogs unless you're too lazy to manage life with children and dogs so let your dogs in the play area.

I agree, dogs shouldn't be in play areas where there are children. but when they are not doing any damage, and noone else is there, I just can't see the harm. Noone is impacted, noone will know.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 14:38

EndlessRain · 26/11/2022 14:25

But a cat or a fox is car more likely to poo in the area than a dog that has already been to the toilet and is being watched. I just have no idea what the negative impact of a dog running a few laps of a play park is, when noone is around. Or is it just it's mere presence that offends you. Odd.

Once one owner decides it’s OK, it becomes OK. And on these threads it’s always “Oh, no one was around or ever uses it and it was 4am and I live alone on an otherwise uninhabited island and I’d leave straight away if I saw someone coming” – whereas in reality I’ve seen plenty of dogs in playgrounds and it makes my daughter not want to go in, even when it’s totally empty.

There’s literally no need for a dog to be in a dog-free area. And yes, its presence annoys me as someone who has had to retreat from playgrounds at dawn, dusk, millions of different times of day, because there’s a bloody dog in there.

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2022 14:42

I agree, dogs shouldn't be in play areas where there are children. but when they are not doing any damage, and noone else is there, I just can't see the harm.
Noone is impacted, noone will know
It's generally accepted dogs aren't allowed in children's play areas
If owners need a fenced off area to exercise their dog off lead then they need to find one or hire one. If they don't want to do that, they need to train their dog on a long line somewhere appropriate. If they don't want to do that then they need to keep their dog on a lead and out of children's play areas.

Children's play areas are not facilities for lazy dog owners.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 14:42

I’d also say it annoys me when people use children’s play areas for their group disco Zumba or whatever – the group near me do it because they don’t want to tread in poo, so the dogs are driving adults into children’s spaces too – or their PT session with straps tied onto the swings and inappropriate music blasting out. And equally when kids crawl all over the adult exercise spaces! Children’s playground = for children and the adults accompanying them. Adult equipment = for adults. Skate area = for skateboarding etc. tennis courts = for tennis. Park as a whole = for everyone, which oh look, includes dogs. Dogs already have the run of the park, why do they need more?

user1494050295 · 26/11/2022 15:00

Rubyupbeat · 26/11/2022 10:55

Exactly, the only mess in our closed off playground is food wrappers, never dog poop.
How the hell does a dog walking across ground compromise a childs health?

Thank you

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 15:26

But then I'm a dog owner who also gets annoyed at owners who bring their dogs to play areas with their children. It says no dogs so that means no dogs, not no dogs unless you're too lazy to manage life with children and dogs so let your dogs in the play area.

I would have agreed with you up until two years ago. Things have changed so much now, my local parks are crowded, there are less green space and I think, sod it, I don't care anymore. If my council cannot provide enough parks for me and my dogs I'll just go where I can.

luxxlisbon · 26/11/2022 15:37

I think, sod it, I don't care anymore. If my council cannot provide enough parks for me and my dogs I'll just go where I can.

So essentially if you can’t have exactly what you want you’re going to ruin it for everyone else too.

I’m alright Jack.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 15:54

So essentially if you can’t have exactly what you want you’re going to ruin it for everyone else too.

I'm beyond caring. Besides, I'm not ruining anything.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 15:58

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 15:54

So essentially if you can’t have exactly what you want you’re going to ruin it for everyone else too.

I'm beyond caring. Besides, I'm not ruining anything.

What is it you get out of trespassing in the children-only area that you can’t get in the entire rest of the park and countryside and commons and pavements and open spaces and dog-friendly pubs and shops across the UK?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 16:02

What is it you get out of trespassing in the children-only area that you can’t get in the entire rest of the park and countryside and commons and pavements and open spaces and dog-friendly pubs and shops across the UK?

Open spaces are overcrowded, parks too. Dog friendly pubs are fine.

Why should I be confined to the pavements?

I'm done here.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 16:11

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 26/11/2022 16:02

What is it you get out of trespassing in the children-only area that you can’t get in the entire rest of the park and countryside and commons and pavements and open spaces and dog-friendly pubs and shops across the UK?

Open spaces are overcrowded, parks too. Dog friendly pubs are fine.

Why should I be confined to the pavements?

I'm done here.

You don’t think playgrounds get overcrowded when, say for example, they’re entered by people who don’t belong there – like you! With your dog! Get the fuck out of children’s spaces and take your precious pooch into the park: unless it’s the audience for the main stage at Glastonbury there’s plenty of room.

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2022 16:14

I would have agreed with you up until two years ago. Things have changed so much now, my local parks are crowded, there are less green space and I think, sod it, I don't care anymore. If my council cannot provide enough parks for me and my dogs I'll just go where I can
Councils provide spaces for everyone and it's actually good that more people have started valuing open spaces more. The council green spaces were always for everyone, not for you and your dog.

Using children's play areas because you're annoyed the council aren't providing your preferred dog exercising facility is awful