Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by Thanksgiving in the UK?

260 replies

talomon · 26/11/2022 08:40

Is it me or Thanksgiving is becoming quite widespread in the UK?

I studied in the states and live in central London, so maybe I am exposed to American people more than most, but I still feel many of my Brit and French friends and acquittances have started hosting Thanksgiving and treating it like a major holiday. Ten years ago it was quite obscure.

I mean I get that it's a nice occasion, and the food spread looks nice especially for social media, but still I am not sure I like it.

YANBU = Our culture is becoming to Americanized
YABU = It's a great holiday to celebrate

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QuizzlyBears · 29/11/2022 05:17

I am married to an American - we live in the UK, so celebrated thanksgiving virtually with family in the US over FaceTime this year as we couldn’t all be in the same place. Obviously I’m English but it’s a nice time - good food, no present pressure and taking some time to reflect a bit on what we are thankful for.

Recipe wise - my DP is southern so the dishes have that influence! Sweet potato casserole, corn bread, green bean casserole and deep fried turkey all usually feature.

Ericaequites · 29/11/2022 04:10

Thanksgiving is generally not bigger than Christmas for Americans. Thanksgiving is a big meal; Christmas is a big deal.

There’s a National Day of Mourning held annually at high noon on Thanksgiving by Native Americans in Plymouth not far from the famous Plymouth Rock. Others are welcome to join in the ceremony to mourn the Native American genocide by disease and war. I’ve been several times with my ex husband who lived nearby. We always walked there as penitents should.

TomPinch · 29/11/2022 03:09

RLScott · 27/11/2022 05:51

Literally pmsl @ “I’ve made my point”

You sure have champ!

Had a chuckle at the second sentence too! So your Irish ancestors were wronguns. Apparently the colonisation of NZ was the least bloody and there was greater harmony with the natives (comparatively speaking). NZ also granted universal suffrage before any other nation. Kiwis are great people.

Correct... comparatively speaking. I'm not sure Maori would put it quite the same way! And there was also Australia.

PawPaworPapaya · 28/11/2022 22:02

I've lived in quite a few different countries around the world, and I've still never known a non American or Canadian to host a Thanksgiving celebration.

Sorry for being so insular. I'll get back in my box now.

xogossipgirlxo · 28/11/2022 11:10

I hit YABU, to answer the question, because I like all occasions to feel grateful, and I really like the idea of adopting some elements from this day, but hey ho, it's my opinion. We didn't celebrate, but my husband and I talked about what we are grateful for😂 I celebrate some Polish occasions too, despite living in the UK, even though they're not a thing here. I just like celebrating life.

GrumpyMummy123 · 28/11/2022 11:04

I've not seen anything in shops about Thanksgiving and don't know anyone who has celebrated it. Pretty much passed me by.

Definitely not a 'thing' around my way! Even Halloween is a half hearted take it or leave it.

Perhaps it's only visible where there's a high American population!

EndlessRain · 28/11/2022 11:00

Dotcheck · 27/11/2022 12:44

Sigh

Canadians ‘do’ Boxing Day too!

Loads of countries do a post-Christmas sale. This is not something UK specific.

I don't know anyone who is not american who celebrates thanksgiving. I do however think it should be considered, I liked in America as a child and it was all "we love Christopher Coloumbus" and dressing up as native Indians "gifting" corn to the brave men who had discovered the new world.

SinnerBoy · 28/11/2022 10:50

Thanks, Math!

mathanxiety · 28/11/2022 03:38

Virtual boiled sweet heading your way, SinnerBoy🍭

Mommabear20 · 27/11/2022 21:20

We have a nice dinner together as a family (not necessarily a typical thanksgiving dinner, just nice food eaten together) and we spend the day really being thankful for what we have, but we don't celebrate it in the way Americans do. I think as a holiday, it has no place here in the U.K. but I do like the idea of at least 1 day a year to stop and be grateful for what we have, we're not well off so it's very easy to get caught up in the 'poor us' but some times, but when we actually sit and look, we are so fortunate in what we have, and there's millions that would kill for just a little of what we have.

SinnerBoy · 27/11/2022 21:12

"A boiled sweet prize is yours if you can guess what country my grandparents lived in."

Ireland.

mathanxiety · 27/11/2022 20:57

@RLScott

And what do you mean your family had to move south? My family didn’t. And where south?

Having your home and professional office torched and seeing the local constabulary do nothing to bring the perpetrators to justice will have the effect of focusing your mind on the question of how welcome you are in any given community, how safe your children are to play outdoors, go to school, explore the city you live in, etc.

South to a neighbouring state, of course.

You post here as if the UK is a paragon of civic virtue and religious tolerance, a state that never built the foundations of its economy on the labour of enslaved people in other places. It's not all that.

Even after slavery was ended in the British colonies, the British spinning industry continued to import American cotton, right up to the Civil War, and resuming afterwards. When the Civil War came, the supply of raw cotton from America dwindled, but the city of Liverpool in particular profited from the export of ships and armaments to the Confederacy.

Britain defended its global monopoly on finished cotton by legislating against the importation of Indian cotton and forcing India to open its markets to British produced cotton.

I am interested to know whether you subscribe to the idea that the Civil War was about states' rights or slavery? If the former, be careful of the company you keep.

The legacy of slavery is still embedded, warp and woof, in British society. It generated the capital that was invested in industry, in education, in infrastructure, in the financial sector.

Lougle · 27/11/2022 20:25

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 27/11/2022 15:16

Sounds moreish!

A little shocked by the amount of sugar in the recipes tbh!!

mathanxiety · 27/11/2022 20:11

They're basically celebrating stealing a nation from its indigenous people

@RambamThankyouMam
My grandparents went to primary school in the early years of the 20th century and were taught a little rhyme that they were obliged to recite daily in school. It went like this:

I thank the goodness and the grace

That on my birth have smiled,

And made me in these Christian days,

A happy English child

.........
A boiled sweet prize is yours if you can guess what country my grandparents lived in.

It took wars of independence to dislodge the British from the pink parts of the globe within the last hundred years - that is to say, living memory.

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 27/11/2022 15:43

Who cares! I love celebrations and if there is an excuse to celebrate then why not?

Cornettoninja · 27/11/2022 15:38

Liorae · 27/11/2022 15:15

And how insular your circles are.

Behave. Why are you belittling people for not having every nation represented in their social circle?

Christ this thread is just a snide-fest

Cornettoninja · 27/11/2022 15:36

Dotcheck · 27/11/2022 12:44

Sigh

Canadians ‘do’ Boxing Day too!

Every day’s a school day.

Not sure why you needed a sarky ‘sigh’ though. It’s okay for people not to know things you know? Not everyone is you.🙄

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 27/11/2022 15:22

Onnabugeisha · 26/11/2022 17:33

Anti-Thanksgiving isn’t anti-American.

It is when you don't examine some of the murkier origins of your own country's cultural celebrations and single out the US for criticism. So we might not overtly celebrate colonialism by marking it with a day off work. We celebrate/culturally appropriate plenty else arising out of oppression and genocide, albeit the origins tend to go further back in history.

Still doesn't put us on a superior moral footing, however. The UK is in no position to critizise the US on that score.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 27/11/2022 15:16

Lougle · 26/11/2022 23:10

We had Thanksgiving dinner today for the first time (SIL is American, living in the UK). It was nice to put on a meal for her.

Turkey, stuffing, gravy, corn casserole, pineapple casserole, carrot soufflé, sweet potato casserole, macaroni cheese, green bean casserole, rolls, & mashed potato. Pecan pie and pumpkin pie for pudding.

Sounds moreish!

Liorae · 27/11/2022 15:15

PawPaworPapaya · 27/11/2022 05:07

I don't think I've ever known anyone to host a Thanksgiving celebration, who wasn't American or Canadian, or at least had strong links to America.

Maybe it depends what circles you move in?

And how insular your circles are.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 27/11/2022 15:13

RambamThankyouMam · 26/11/2022 09:48

Even Americans celebrating it gives me a bad taste in my mouth. They're basically celebrating stealing a nation from its indigenous people. Surely in this day and age when you can't even cook a foreign dish without being accused of "cultural appropriation", Thanksgiving ought to be hugely problematic. And yet.

By the same token, Guy Fawkes night might be seen as a deeply problematic celebration of immolating Catholics.

Christmas and Easter are problematic because the Church half-inched them from the pagan celebrations of Yule and Ostara, all the while having persecuted their originators, claimed they are evil devil-worshippers, and executed them for witchcraft.

When you come to think of it a lot of celebrations have dubious origins.

frozengoose · 27/11/2022 14:38

Bayleaf25 · 27/11/2022 08:52

I don’t know anyone who celebrates it???

We have however celebrated Burns Night a couple of times (we’re not Scottish), just because it’s fun and good to have a reason to get together. I don’t see anything wrong with it (hope I’m not offending any Scottish people.

Always happy to share our poet.
The more the merrier.

SinnerBoy · 27/11/2022 12:58

I've an American friend and he doesn't do Thanksgiving. I'm not sure why, I should ask. I've never encountered British people celebrating it.

Dotcheck · 27/11/2022 12:44

Cornettoninja · 26/11/2022 12:41

Btw, that's not American people trying to "indoctrinate" people from other countries into "our" celebrations. We are just living our life. This is all someone else's doing! Seriously, Waitrose?!

exactly this and it’s exactly what happened with Black Friday too. I’m not American but it’s pretty clear to me that shared popular culture has been seized on by various marketing departments.

I wouldn’t expect an American thanksgiving to ever really catch on here tbh. Much like ‘boxing day’ and traditional sales have never really caught on anywhere outside the UK.

Sigh

Canadians ‘do’ Boxing Day too!

IcedPurple · 27/11/2022 11:43

NZ is a British colony. There’s a Union Jack in the corner as a constant reminder.

Don't be daft. NZ is not at all a 'colony' but an independent nation. It could change its flag or have a referendum about having Charles as HoS tomorrow if it wished.