Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of mixed race children…..

229 replies

SunsetOverTheBeach · 25/11/2022 23:30

….. how do you deal with the upset caused by racist incidents?

My son is in his final year of primary. Over the past few months there have been a couple of incidents were racist comments have been directed at him without any provocation (confirmed by staff at school). Different kids each time.

The school have gone through the necessary formalities (officially logging incidents, informing parents etc).

My question is how do you deal with the distress it causes? As a white person born and raised in the UK this is new terrain for me.

He came home heartbroken today.

OP posts:
Mumsanetta · 26/11/2022 15:50

@SunsetOverTheBeach you would have been better off using the thread title “To ask white parents of mixed race children…..”.

Mumsanetta · 26/11/2022 15:43

So the white posters dismiss the comments from the mixed/brown/black posters saying that living in a predominantly white area has an impact? If your children ever come to you with a race related problem or share their experiences with you I sincerely hope you do not tell your children that they are being ridiculous or blasé even if you do not agree with what they are saying because ultimately you do not have their lived experience.

It would be more honest to say “I’m sorry if this is my child’s experience but I don’t want to move” than to deny that there is no problem at all.

Mirabai · 26/11/2022 15:42

However we are not moving. It’s actually astounding how blaze people are about it.

Are they blasé or do they have experience of you something don’t and understand its importance?

If anyone is blasé on this thread, perhaps it is a white woman who failed to consider racial issues when relocating her son.

Haffdonga · 26/11/2022 15:41

I am the white parent of 2 mixed race ds living in a predominantly white middle class area. I was a primary teacher and have worked round here as well as in one of the most ethnically diverse areas in London. I think it's not quite as straightforward as some PPs seem to believe - that if you live in a diverse area you'll experience less racism because there are other people like you.
In fact in the diverse schools I worked in, I saw far more antagonism between different ethnic groups among children than in the more mono-cultural schools. By year 6 the children in the diverse schools were very aware which 'group' they belonged to and friendship groups tended to fall along ethnicity lines. There was sometimes overt discrimination by parents e.g. telling their dc they weren't allowed to play with dc from another ethnic group (often due to wars or tension in their countries of origin) and the dc were very aware of who was 'one of us' and who wasn't.
In the schools my ds went to, they were the only ones of their ethnicity and there was only a handful of dc from any ethnic minorities, so in fact there was less of an identifiable 'other' group among the dc. The downside was that perhaps my ds had less of a sense of belonging to their dad's culture and knew less about it. But both ds tell me they didn't experience overt racism at school and when they were little they were very proud of their identity. They felt it made them interesting and special. As young adults they've been shocked to encounter more prejudice in larger cities usually in the form of thoughtless prejudiced comments by random people.
As the white part of my family I know I can't feel what it feels like to experience racism so I can't advise you on how to deal with your poor ds's feelings @SunsetOverTheBeach but I can say from my experience it really isn't as simple as Well you should move to a diverse area, you bad selfish parent . The grass really isn't always greener (or any other colour) in more or less diverse areas and there are upsides and downsides to both.

SunsetOverTheBeach · 26/11/2022 15:03

There has been a lot of discussions about skin colour. Although my son is mixed race his skin colour is very light olive. In summer it naturally goes “golden” and is in line with what a white person who lives in a sunny climate looks like.

He is extremely proud of his heritage. I lived in his father’s home country for many many years. I went there initially as I was fascinated by many aspects of their culture. I speak the language and know quite a bit about their festivals and traditions, He has role models from that country in the world of sport who he keenly follows. He is following their national team in the World Cup and hopes they win. We are also huge fans of food from his father’s country and many other aspects of that culture.

I agree that he needs to be around people from his father’s country and I’ll look into making that happen.

However we are not moving. It’s actually astounding how blaze people are about it. It will not magically solve the issue of racism. My son went to the school nursery from age 3 and is part of a VERY close knit group of friends that are literally our neighbours. He loves living here and is looking forward to going to high school with the same friends he has had since he was 3. I’m not taking that away from him. Aside from these couple of incidents he is thriving! He is extremely confident, healthy and happy.

I am offended by some posters suggestions that he’s living through some sort of hell for the sake of me being close to my family!

OP posts:
MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 14:45

sozzers @RedWingBoots , meant to quote minionsrule

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 14:42

@minionsrule

As @MarmaladeFatkins , who for some reason quoted me, rightly said if you experienced racism during your own schooling then you will look at the reasons why you encountered it and ensure your child isn't put in the sane situation. You will also warn other parents of mixed ethnicity children who ask for advice of what to be aware off. As a white person you won't have this experience.

minionsrule · 26/11/2022 14:12

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 13:26

@minionsrule why should they be ashamed?

The posters saying that will not be white and have suffered racism themselves.

Because sometimes in life you don't always have the means to just move somewhere else on a whim if you have committed to an area before kids.

I live in a predominantly white area but it is generally a great place to raise kids, low crime, lots of outdoor spaces, great schools, its pretty safe and we all love it. My mixed race ds is not miserable because he doesn't have his own people around him, he loves his white mates and gf. Its not a one size fits all.
Are we saying people should now move to diverse areas so their kids fit in or else they are bad parents?
OP hopefully this was a brief incident and it won't continue now the school have handled it

holierthanthou73 · 26/11/2022 14:01

My son never experienced it, still doesn’t.

Garibaldibikky · 26/11/2022 14:00

Keyansier · 25/11/2022 23:54

I'm mixed race and personally could not think about living in the countryside/somewhere so rural. Not meaning to sound at all accusatory when I say this, but did you think about your children and not just about yourself when considering a place to live?

This.

You will never understand the damage this does to a person mentally, emotionally and even physically. You cannot change the school but you can change your circumstances. You have a duty of care to think seriously about moving for secondary so he is in a multicultural environment. Unfortunately having a child with a non-white person comes with an added layer of parenting responsibility. It shouldn't be that way but unfortunately it is. You will need to do your homework.

mummy182822828 · 26/11/2022 13:58

Getting a teacher to read a kid friendly book about racism to a the class so people understand it wrong or get headteacher to talk to the kids

Mirabai · 26/11/2022 13:57

minionsrule · 26/11/2022 13:23

OP I'm white and my DH is Indian, we live in a predominantly white Middle class area.
DS went through the same around Yr 4, reference to his skin colour looking like poo 🙄.
School dealt with it and all we could do was stress to DS that the boys who said it were silly, they were just trying to upset/hurt him and they were using his skin colour because it was something different, like kids who wear glasses, and that he should be proud of his skin. He suffered some awful names from one boy in high school too.
Thankfully he has had really lovely supportive friends who backed him up and had his back.
He's 17 now and it hasn't affected him.
As for some posters pretty much saying its your fault for choosing a non diverse area to live in, I have no words to say how ridiculous that is, they should ashamed 😡

To be fair you can’t always tell. A very old friend of mine is the same racial mix - Indian father white British mother - and he didn’t tell his parents about the extent of the racism experienced at school until he was 30. Children tend to protect their parents.

Shesasuperfreak · 26/11/2022 13:53

Your son is affected you just can't see it.

Mahanii · 26/11/2022 13:50

I'm with everyone else I'm afraid. For me there was no other option but to move area.

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 13:47

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 13:26

@minionsrule why should they be ashamed?

The posters saying that will not be white and have suffered racism themselves.

they are giving their opinion based on first hand experience of exactly what OP is asking about. it can hardly be called 'ridiculous' or shameful can it 🤷🏼‍♀️

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 13:26

@minionsrule why should they be ashamed?

The posters saying that will not be white and have suffered racism themselves.

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 13:25

Opine · 26/11/2022 00:21

@SunsetOverTheBeach my mother was in the same situation you are. Marriage broke down and she wanted to be near family.
Great for her, horrendous for me. She was being selfish. We moved from a massively diverse area into a town that sounds just like where you are.
If you have mixed raced children you absolutely have to factor their race into your parenting.

Where you live is the problem. Whatever you gain by having family close by won’t amount to what your DC loses. I’m sorry but if you chose to have a mixed raced child you have a duty to make sure they are around people like themselves.

You can’t ask for advice about how to deal with racists. They’re racist. You can’t deal with them. You're outnumbered & all the school policies in the world won’t fix it.You just need to get away from them. That’s really the only real solution.

❤

minionsrule · 26/11/2022 13:23

OP I'm white and my DH is Indian, we live in a predominantly white Middle class area.
DS went through the same around Yr 4, reference to his skin colour looking like poo 🙄.
School dealt with it and all we could do was stress to DS that the boys who said it were silly, they were just trying to upset/hurt him and they were using his skin colour because it was something different, like kids who wear glasses, and that he should be proud of his skin. He suffered some awful names from one boy in high school too.
Thankfully he has had really lovely supportive friends who backed him up and had his back.
He's 17 now and it hasn't affected him.
As for some posters pretty much saying its your fault for choosing a non diverse area to live in, I have no words to say how ridiculous that is, they should ashamed 😡

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 13:20

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 13:09

There is literally no area of the UK that has beyond a handful of people from my ex-husbands nationality it in
**
It doesn't matter.

My DD, who is mixed, looks very similar in ethnicity to two girls and two boys she plays with at nursery and CM. They are all completely different ethnicities.

Yes it will matter when they are older but as small children they know there are other children who look like them.
**

yeah, I agree, the nationality isn't as important as just not being the only non-white kid

RedWingBoots · 26/11/2022 13:09

There is literally no area of the UK that has beyond a handful of people from my ex-husbands nationality it in
**
It doesn't matter.

My DD, who is mixed, looks very similar in ethnicity to two girls and two boys she plays with at nursery and CM. They are all completely different ethnicities.

Yes it will matter when they are older but as small children they know there are other children who look like them.
**

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 12:13

'children need to see themselves reflected in the world around them'

i can't remember where the quote is from, but I think it's true

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 12:11

chose to live in a diverse area of the city for this reason. still had some racism, notably by teachers at school but the kids don't feel so alone. they have strength from their peers and have mostly been able to challenge it themselves. any upset, we have comforted in the same way as if they are upset for other reasons but always talk about racism, prejudice, inequality etc as we are quite a politically interested family I suppose

noworklifebalance · 26/11/2022 12:03

It’s all very well telling the child that it’s not their fault and the problem is with the perpetrators but in the end, it’s the child that has to live through it, ensure it, dread school, fight back the tears and battle it.

Lampzade · 26/11/2022 11:54

Do not raise mixed race children in small villages where there is little diversity
My nephew and niece are mixed race. My sister sent them to a school which was very diverse in order to avoid the issues faced by the Op
My nephew and niece are extremely proud of their mixed heritage. They are lovely and confident children

terryschocolateorangee · 26/11/2022 11:49

Moved schools. Not worth the trauma.

Swipe left for the next trending thread