Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask parents of mixed race children…..

229 replies

SunsetOverTheBeach · 25/11/2022 23:30

….. how do you deal with the upset caused by racist incidents?

My son is in his final year of primary. Over the past few months there have been a couple of incidents were racist comments have been directed at him without any provocation (confirmed by staff at school). Different kids each time.

The school have gone through the necessary formalities (officially logging incidents, informing parents etc).

My question is how do you deal with the distress it causes? As a white person born and raised in the UK this is new terrain for me.

He came home heartbroken today.

OP posts:
IMissVino · 28/11/2022 15:17

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 15:06

Am I really sounding clueless?! I take offence to this. I feel I'm being quite reasonable in explaining my experience and I've used the words of my non-White husband and children who've explained their own experiences. I am aware of covert racism. It's something I've been interested since I was a teen really and a subject I explored repeatedly during my university years whilst studying sociology and psychology. I can send you my dissertation if you're interested! Ha!
I am sensitive to potential racism against my children and husband. I don't think anything I've said has been clueless. To date, I don't believe my children have been aware of any differential treatment against them because of their skin colour. I accept they might have experienced covert racism which they're unaware of. I'm only describing the experience of my family - my Indian DH agrees with this or do you think he's also completely clueless and oblivious? I completely accept it's something that might increase in the future.

Yes, you are sounding COMPLETELY clueless. If multiple POC are telling you so, perhaps ‘taking offence’ is the incorrect reaction. Do you care more about being right or about supporting your children? If the latter, I’d suggest you reevaluate your attitude.

You:

  • Referred to micro aggressions as ‘micro-forms of racism that are subtle’ and cannot provide any more information on them.
  • In describing racism against your husband, described only overt acts.
  • Have stated, multiple times, that your mixed race children have not been on the receiving end of racism.
  • Said: To date, I don't believe my children have been aware of any differential treatment against them because of their skin colour. I accept they might have experienced covert racism which they're unaware of. Which harks back to my previous comments.

It seems highly unlikely, based on the above, that you have done even the most basic reading on covert racism, much less studied it in an academic context. You don’t have the basic understanding of the concept, nor do you have the language.

MN can be a valuable learning resource if you’re willing to take on board what’s said to you. I’ve advised that you read up on this subject. If you choose not to, that’s on you, I suppose.

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 15:06

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 14:45

If you think a detailed account of the diverse and woke environment in which your kids are being raised addresses what’s being said to you, then you are not listening.

They may have experienced some micro-forms of racism that are subtle and not like the overt racism I mentioned before.

Do you know what a micro aggression is? And I’m not talking about a quick Google. Have you, as the white parent of non-white kids, done any labour to inform yourself about the many forms of covert racism and the profound, insidious impact that it has on the life, well-being and even health of minorities? If so, what have you done? As you are sounding fairly clueless right now.

Am I really sounding clueless?! I take offence to this. I feel I'm being quite reasonable in explaining my experience and I've used the words of my non-White husband and children who've explained their own experiences. I am aware of covert racism. It's something I've been interested since I was a teen really and a subject I explored repeatedly during my university years whilst studying sociology and psychology. I can send you my dissertation if you're interested! Ha!
I am sensitive to potential racism against my children and husband. I don't think anything I've said has been clueless. To date, I don't believe my children have been aware of any differential treatment against them because of their skin colour. I accept they might have experienced covert racism which they're unaware of. I'm only describing the experience of my family - my Indian DH agrees with this or do you think he's also completely clueless and oblivious? I completely accept it's something that might increase in the future.

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 14:45

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 14:30

OK, several people have commented that my children must have experienced racism to an extent. Perhaps they have. Of course I can see this is a possibility. They may have experienced some micro-forms of racism that are subtle and not like the overt racism I mentioned before. I completely accept this.
I have spoken to them about racism and they both say they're not aware of any racism against them. I even felt like I shattered my son's innocence by raising the issue because it seemed to blow his mind that anyone would judge someone because of their skin colour. He kept saying "But why mum?" However, I still felt it was important to talk about it because obviously racism exists and is a very negative force in society. I fully accept it's something they'll face.
I truly believe that it hasn't been a big problem to date. I'd say a third of the children in their classes are are brown skinned. We live in an area with a lot of Hindus, Muslims and people of African descent. My children don't stand out for having darker skin. In fact they look more Greek or something than Asian (I don't know if this makes any difference to the racists though). The white children in the class have grown up being surrounded by many brown skinned children since they were babies really - certainly there was always a mix of skin colours from nursery upwards.
The parents of the white children at school I suppose would be described as "woke" (a term I despise) - certainly the sort of parents who would be mortified if their child said anything remotely racist. The sort of parents who'd go to great lengths to prevent it happening again. There's only one class per year in my son's school so I know the families well.
I've even spoken to teachers about racism (asking them if they see any racism at school) and they've said no, that the children are all mixing well and they don't notice any forms of racism. Some of these teachers have brown skin so they're not talking from a place of white privilege.
I do think we've been lucky so far and I've certainly heard of lots of racist bullying in other places so of course it's something I've been concerned about and will be vigilent in the future.

If you think a detailed account of the diverse and woke environment in which your kids are being raised addresses what’s being said to you, then you are not listening.

They may have experienced some micro-forms of racism that are subtle and not like the overt racism I mentioned before.

Do you know what a micro aggression is? And I’m not talking about a quick Google. Have you, as the white parent of non-white kids, done any labour to inform yourself about the many forms of covert racism and the profound, insidious impact that it has on the life, well-being and even health of minorities? If so, what have you done? As you are sounding fairly clueless right now.

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 14:30

sheepdogdelight · 28/11/2022 11:55

Sorry to break it to you, but I don't believe your DC have never experienced a racist incident. They simply haven't told you, quite possibly because it's a series of low level incidents and they can't see the point as they don't see that anything will change.

OK, several people have commented that my children must have experienced racism to an extent. Perhaps they have. Of course I can see this is a possibility. They may have experienced some micro-forms of racism that are subtle and not like the overt racism I mentioned before. I completely accept this.
I have spoken to them about racism and they both say they're not aware of any racism against them. I even felt like I shattered my son's innocence by raising the issue because it seemed to blow his mind that anyone would judge someone because of their skin colour. He kept saying "But why mum?" However, I still felt it was important to talk about it because obviously racism exists and is a very negative force in society. I fully accept it's something they'll face.
I truly believe that it hasn't been a big problem to date. I'd say a third of the children in their classes are are brown skinned. We live in an area with a lot of Hindus, Muslims and people of African descent. My children don't stand out for having darker skin. In fact they look more Greek or something than Asian (I don't know if this makes any difference to the racists though). The white children in the class have grown up being surrounded by many brown skinned children since they were babies really - certainly there was always a mix of skin colours from nursery upwards.
The parents of the white children at school I suppose would be described as "woke" (a term I despise) - certainly the sort of parents who would be mortified if their child said anything remotely racist. The sort of parents who'd go to great lengths to prevent it happening again. There's only one class per year in my son's school so I know the families well.
I've even spoken to teachers about racism (asking them if they see any racism at school) and they've said no, that the children are all mixing well and they don't notice any forms of racism. Some of these teachers have brown skin so they're not talking from a place of white privilege.
I do think we've been lucky so far and I've certainly heard of lots of racist bullying in other places so of course it's something I've been concerned about and will be vigilent in the future.

RedWingBoots · 28/11/2022 13:29

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 13:14

Or they don’t even recognise these incidents as racism yet, as their parents haven’t given them the vocabulary. They just know some stuff isn’t right or doesn’t feel good.

Or, even worse, they do recognise these things as racism, but keep them to themselves as know that they won’t get any support from someone who doesn’t appear to understand micro aggressions.

👏

RedWingBoots · 28/11/2022 13:29

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 00:57

It’s interesting that only the white parents of mixed race kids ever say this. Never the non-white parent, never the grown up mixed race kids themselves.

You should probably ponder why that is.

👏

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 13:14

sheepdogdelight · 28/11/2022 11:55

Sorry to break it to you, but I don't believe your DC have never experienced a racist incident. They simply haven't told you, quite possibly because it's a series of low level incidents and they can't see the point as they don't see that anything will change.

Or they don’t even recognise these incidents as racism yet, as their parents haven’t given them the vocabulary. They just know some stuff isn’t right or doesn’t feel good.

Or, even worse, they do recognise these things as racism, but keep them to themselves as know that they won’t get any support from someone who doesn’t appear to understand micro aggressions.

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 13:10

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 07:43

But my Indian husband would say exactly the same thing. We really aren't aware of any racism against the children.
I've been with DH for 20 years and have seen 3 racist incidents against him in that time. Two cases were people commenting on his colour in a negative way. One case was someone in a van screaming "P*ki" at him. I found each incident shocking and upsetting.
There are quite a few brown skinned children at the school and my children don't stand out at all. I'm not naive - I'm sure the children will experience some racism throughout their lives but up until now I don't believe it's been an issue. I've asked them about it and they said they've never had any trouble. My son was actually shocked by the implication that some people are bothered by skin colour.

In the nicest way possible, have you sought to educate yourself on this topic? It would appear (from your comments) that you are only recognising abuse and overt racism. Have you done any reading on covert racism? Micro aggressions? Racial profiling?

Like most non-white people, nobody has ever screamed at me from a bus or ‘commented on my colour in a negative way’, but I’ve been a victim of racism. Meghan Markle, Rishi Sunak and Kwasi Kwarteng, three of the most privileged human beings in the country have been victims of racism. If you think it’s somehow skipped your son, I’d strongly suggest you seek to inform yourself.

Your son won’t recognise it now, because he’s a child and you haven’t taught him how. He’ll figure it out when he’s an adult, as we all do. And, to a greater or lesser extent (depending on your relationship), will blame you for not supporting him. If you doubt this, there’s rather a lot of resources (from academic writing, to autobiographical novels to YouTube, so pick what you’re into) created by adult mixed race kids lamenting the attitudes of their parents - but specifically white mothers - to this very thing.

Ted27 · 28/11/2022 13:10

@sheepdogdelight

I also think its possible that younger children don’t recognise the micro - agression level of racism
Two examples, my son is adopted. In the early days he was often asked were he was from, we would say Xshire, they would say but where are you really from. He was 8, it went over his head. Piece of school homework, write about a famous Victorian, the class was about 80% black/Asian kids. All the examples they were given were white. He was just cross as he had no interest in the Victorians, white or black

sheepdogdelight · 28/11/2022 11:55

SallyWD · 27/11/2022 22:35

My children are mixed race aged 12 and 10. I can honestly say we've never had a single racist incident. We do live in a diverse city and also a nice area where everyone seems to be educated and well mannered (apologies if that sounds horribly snobbish).
If it ever did happen I think I'd have a long chat with my children about racism in general, about how it's usually down to ignorance. I'd really emphasise the fact that it's nothing to do with my children but a problem with the person being racist.

Sorry to break it to you, but I don't believe your DC have never experienced a racist incident. They simply haven't told you, quite possibly because it's a series of low level incidents and they can't see the point as they don't see that anything will change.

Kabalagala · 28/11/2022 09:20

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 28/11/2022 08:55

I see racism against my husband on an almost daily basis.... It's not someone screaming the n word at him in the street but it's security guards following him around, if he goes into a fancy shop he is dismissed by staff, he is always being asked to justify why he is somewhere, at work it is never assumed he is the manager, he has been stopped and searched three times on his lunch break from work... I could go on.

And what I can say is, as a blonde white woman, not a single thing like this has ever happened to me.

Modern racism is a series of micro aggression that are hard to report.

Yes. Exactly this.
The catalyst for us moving was my little boy being seen, then actively ignored in a line at his school summer fair.
It's so so subtle if you're not looking for it.

FiveMins · 28/11/2022 09:01

pinkpotatoez · 25/11/2022 23:49

Weird thing to be thankful about 😂 I'm not sure if you meant it that way

We live in a very diverse area in the North. One of the reasons we moved here was because it was so diverse. We love the fact the kids have friends from all different backgrounds and cultures. Are we weird too?

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 28/11/2022 08:55

I see racism against my husband on an almost daily basis.... It's not someone screaming the n word at him in the street but it's security guards following him around, if he goes into a fancy shop he is dismissed by staff, he is always being asked to justify why he is somewhere, at work it is never assumed he is the manager, he has been stopped and searched three times on his lunch break from work... I could go on.

And what I can say is, as a blonde white woman, not a single thing like this has ever happened to me.

Modern racism is a series of micro aggression that are hard to report.

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 08:02

MarmaladeFatkins · 28/11/2022 06:37

I know I am being rude again, but I just don't believe that any Black or Brown person the UK has never encountered any racism. added to which, ime the middle class areas are usually by far the worst for racism. polite racism, but racism non the less

Well like I said, I've seen racism against my husband 3 times. He grew up in a southern European country and said he experienced much more racism there. I'm not saying there's not a problem here in the UK. There absolutely is and I've seen racism against him and other brown people on numerous occasions. He, himself, says he's hasn't experienced MUCH racism here. Maybe he's oblivious. He works at a university in a very diverse team with people from all over the world so I don't think he'd be picked on for being different. The times I've seen racism against him were from random strangers in the street. His colour has never held him back professionally - he's risen in his chosen profession and is often head hunted. I find that encouraging.

SallyWD · 28/11/2022 07:43

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 00:57

It’s interesting that only the white parents of mixed race kids ever say this. Never the non-white parent, never the grown up mixed race kids themselves.

You should probably ponder why that is.

But my Indian husband would say exactly the same thing. We really aren't aware of any racism against the children.
I've been with DH for 20 years and have seen 3 racist incidents against him in that time. Two cases were people commenting on his colour in a negative way. One case was someone in a van screaming "P*ki" at him. I found each incident shocking and upsetting.
There are quite a few brown skinned children at the school and my children don't stand out at all. I'm not naive - I'm sure the children will experience some racism throughout their lives but up until now I don't believe it's been an issue. I've asked them about it and they said they've never had any trouble. My son was actually shocked by the implication that some people are bothered by skin colour.

PinkFrogss · 28/11/2022 06:46

@username8888 interesting choice of numbers for your username.

MarmaladeFatkins · 28/11/2022 06:37

SallyWD · 27/11/2022 22:35

My children are mixed race aged 12 and 10. I can honestly say we've never had a single racist incident. We do live in a diverse city and also a nice area where everyone seems to be educated and well mannered (apologies if that sounds horribly snobbish).
If it ever did happen I think I'd have a long chat with my children about racism in general, about how it's usually down to ignorance. I'd really emphasise the fact that it's nothing to do with my children but a problem with the person being racist.

I know I am being rude again, but I just don't believe that any Black or Brown person the UK has never encountered any racism. added to which, ime the middle class areas are usually by far the worst for racism. polite racism, but racism non the less

Rummikub · 28/11/2022 01:01

I remembered my dc saying how they didn’t like to go into the town centre with their white grandparents as they would get stared at. It wasn’t a very diverse area. I imagine the lookers were confused. But it made my dc feel offered.

IMissVino · 28/11/2022 00:57

SallyWD · 27/11/2022 22:35

My children are mixed race aged 12 and 10. I can honestly say we've never had a single racist incident. We do live in a diverse city and also a nice area where everyone seems to be educated and well mannered (apologies if that sounds horribly snobbish).
If it ever did happen I think I'd have a long chat with my children about racism in general, about how it's usually down to ignorance. I'd really emphasise the fact that it's nothing to do with my children but a problem with the person being racist.

It’s interesting that only the white parents of mixed race kids ever say this. Never the non-white parent, never the grown up mixed race kids themselves.

You should probably ponder why that is.

SallyWD · 27/11/2022 22:35

My children are mixed race aged 12 and 10. I can honestly say we've never had a single racist incident. We do live in a diverse city and also a nice area where everyone seems to be educated and well mannered (apologies if that sounds horribly snobbish).
If it ever did happen I think I'd have a long chat with my children about racism in general, about how it's usually down to ignorance. I'd really emphasise the fact that it's nothing to do with my children but a problem with the person being racist.

MarmaladeFatkins · 27/11/2022 22:20

@username8888 are you the parent of a MR child?

Lampzade · 27/11/2022 22:03

MarmaladeFatkins · 26/11/2022 15:55

it's not about experiencing 'less racism' it's about not being the ONLY child having to deal with it, in amongst a completely white peer group. it's about not being the only Black person that all your friends and their families know, watching you to prove or disprove the stereotypes they all know. it's about not having all your class mates trying to touch your hair. it's about having peers that you can relate to and who understand your experiences. it's about being proud and not trying to hide parts of yourself. it's about being able to have conversations and arguments about race, racism, ethnicity, nationality without people getting uncomfortable/defensive and trying to shut it down by moaning about 'the race card' and 'chips in shoulders'

@MarmaladeFatkins totally agree

username8888 · 27/11/2022 21:20

@Ted27 You are completely misrepresenting what I said.

I didn't say sweep it under the carpet, but treat it in a more nuanced way.

OP asked opinions.

I am giving my experience.

it may or may not work, but no one has the right to shut down what I say or denigrate my experience, or twist my words, which is what is happening here.

Quite frankly I am being bullied here by certain posters for expressing my opinion.
So well done bullies with your aggressive tone in trying to silence me.
However I learnt to deal with the likes of you at school, so I don't give a flying

Kabalagala · 27/11/2022 20:21

username8888 · 27/11/2022 20:00

@Kabalagala Don't be ridiculous. If the bullying was a daily occurrence then of course not a few weeks. If it was a couple of nasty remarks over the course of a few weeks, then they might just get bored with the lack of reaction. It would also depend on the type of remark.

Those were your words...
I'm ginger, so believe me I had my fair share of shit as a kid. That's one reason why I won't stand for it with my boys.
Kids shouldn't have to learn resilience. There needs to be more consequences for bullies. Any school that does otherwise is complicit.

MarmaladeFatkins · 27/11/2022 20:09

ime in secondary schools, in a diverse school with enough non-white pupils, they often punish racist kids themselves. Its effective