Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selfish dsister or shall i suck it up?

36 replies

AnxietyLevelMax · 25/11/2022 22:40

AIBU to feel hurt she doesn’t understand?
Two important facts:
1.My DS(sister) and I are not from UK but live here for 15+ years.
2.Communion in my culture and for my family is extremely (extremely) important.

My nephews are having a communion in May and since all our family is living in different country, DS is planning to have a fancy lunch there for the family, but the mass will take place in UK as they can attend all of the meetings at church here etc etc.

I just found out she is not planning anything here for myself and my family (i am the godmother of one of the boys) and is expecting me to travel back to our country which is about £700 for my family just for the week (wont be able to stay longer due to work). I am already saving for the gifts as it is an expensive occasion and £400 is the minimum i wanted to spend on both boys.

i wont be able to save next year due to increase of our mortgage, childcare, bills, i just managed to pay off our credit card which i dont want to use now. We barely have any savings and starting to struggle at the moment.

i have mentioned all that but its turning into a family drama now and DS just threw in my face how she spent money last year to go back to our country for my son’s christening (she is his godmother) - true, travelling for xmass is expensive but she was planning to go anyway, also wanted to drive there not knowing the covid travel rules in all of the countries between, and ended up having to purchase last minute flight tickets - everyone advised her to purchase months before bc its too risky and too complicated to drive through few countries, when not all of the countries had same covid restrictions. She didnt want to listen.

I was always very generous auntie to her boys and I am very close with them, but really cant spend so much to go there. If i dont go it will turn into family drama which will affect other people and aspects of our family life which is completely different thread.

i am little hurt. Her lack of understanding my situation is putting a pressure on my family and we are already stretched.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
M340 · 27/11/2022 11:22

Mischance · 27/11/2022 11:19

Religion eh? .... a force for peace and harmony? Sad

Yep!

Mischance · 27/11/2022 11:19

Religion eh? .... a force for peace and harmony? Sad

nobodyknowss · 27/11/2022 11:15

What a load of total unnecessary drama, conflict and money. Typically what religion causes ay.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 27/11/2022 11:01

I didn't say you were selfish, I said her expectation of you is the same as your expectation of her was, therefore you're either both selfish or neither selfish. You don't know if she would have behaved differently in purchasing those expensive tickets if there hadn't been that expectation

Cw112 · 27/11/2022 00:50

Can you go for less than a week or just go yourself as godmother rather than bringing your whole family to keep the traveling costs down?

howmanybicycles · 26/11/2022 21:36

Is the gist of this that your sister is choosing to have an after-service celebration for this event in your home country rather than the UK and you're cross that she's not having an additional celebration here because it costs so much to go back home?

I think she wants to be around lots of her family and hopes you can make it there too. Go if you can. Don't if you can't. If you can't go, she can consider whether she wants to do something here too.

In terms of the £400 present - any supportive family would rather you didn't buy that rather than put yourself in debt. However, if you're too tied to tradition to be more flexible, perhaps you can consider buying something at a later date when it's more affordable?

AnxietyLevelMax · 26/11/2022 20:41

@LunaAndHerMoonDragons she was going for christmas anyway. I couldnt do it here as i need both godparents for christening and my child’s godfather is not in uk. As mentioned - she was planning to go for christmas, we knew everyone will be there so we chose to do it on christmas. She spent a lot on flights as she had to book last minute, she wanted to drive with family despite knowing some countries had different travel rules due to covid and it wasnt as straightforward as it used to be before covid.

on the top of that everything turned out upside down last year for us and we got into debt, which she knows about, and she also knows we werent planning to go back to our country in 2023 in the peak time - summer and Christmas.

not sure when was i selfish?

she is using it as an excuse because she had to spend on last minute tickets and it was painful she knows it will be painful for me too but oh well…

thank you previous poster for an idea of going on my own. Its possible, 2 days just myself. Still considering if there is any other option.

the post is not about how much i am planning to spend on gifts. As i said - each country, each family has different traditions and I am not planning to be the one who breaks it against everyone. I was preparing for this for a while so wasnt stressed until now.

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/11/2022 10:17

The whole it doesn't count she traveled because she was going to travel anyway is a pretty flimsy argument. If she's being selfish now you were being selfish then, unless that is you spoke to your sister, made sure she was comfortable with traveling and offered her an at home in the UK celebration if she couldn't make it abroad. If you just expected her to be there you're being very unreasonable to expect her to behave in a more considerent way to you now then you did to her.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/11/2022 10:11

The whole it doesn't count her traveling for your child last year is a pretty flimsy argument. She's no more being selfish then you were then. Did you offer to host a UK celebration for her and her family to

Hesma · 26/11/2022 09:57

i wouldn’t be doing all of that travel! I’d got the the first holy communion mass and then suggest going out for lunch afterwards. I also don’t see why you need to spend so much on gifts? You are turning a beautiful religious sacrament into something that’s all about money. My kids got small but meaningful gifts on FHC. It should be about the sacrament.

RunLolaRun102 · 26/11/2022 09:55

You are their godmother so you go to the church and travel by yourself to the overseas country. Your DP can take care of the kids for a week.

NoSquirrels · 26/11/2022 09:54

Would you be going ‘home’ at any time soon other than for this event?

Brefugee · 26/11/2022 09:54

i kind of get her point though, she travelled for your DC christening but you won't travel for her DC holy communion. She is miffed and i get that.

But you have to do what you have to do. Don't feed the family drama.

Schnooze · 26/11/2022 09:50

“We can’t afford it unless we spend the present money on flights. What do you want us to do?”
”We are not going to get into debt for this, sorry” Repeat repeat.
”come to ours for a celebration after the service”

Dotcheck · 26/11/2022 09:44

Chomolungma · 26/11/2022 09:20

The church is so small that only parents are allowed inside? That can't be right??

OP, I would go to the service in the UK, give presents and go out to lunch with your sister afterwards. Don't go to the overseas celebration if you can't afford it.

⬆️⬆️

HungryandIknowit · 26/11/2022 09:42

Just offer for her and some family to come to yours after the communion in the UK. You don't need to make a big thing of her not organising something in the UK. She doesn't need to make a big deal out of you not being able to afford the larger gathering in your home country.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 26/11/2022 09:35

Nowadays children make their First Holy Communion within a morning mass, with the usual congregation there as well as any family and friends who may want to attend

Not always. In my church most children do the preparation in school and the service is a special one on a Saturday where there are limited spaces. I couldn’t attend the service for my nephew / godson because there was only space for parents, siblings and grandparents.

OP, if you can’t afford the flights then you can’t afford them. There’s nothing you can do about it. Could you take the boys out for a special treat in the UK instead?

AriettyHomily · 26/11/2022 09:26

This is nuts. It's for show not the religious aspect.

Chomolungma · 26/11/2022 09:20

The church is so small that only parents are allowed inside? That can't be right??

OP, I would go to the service in the UK, give presents and go out to lunch with your sister afterwards. Don't go to the overseas celebration if you can't afford it.

winteriscoming2022 · 26/11/2022 09:15

This is ridiculous.
I, my parents, siblings, children and now Grandchildren have made our First Holy Communion. It is not a time for £200 gifts, a token rosary or bible is acceptable but not even expected. Nowadays children make their First Holy Communion within a morning mass, with the usual congregation there as well as any family and friends who may want to attend ( RC or otherwise). There will be as much room as there always is and I've never seen anyone turned away or discouraged in a Catholic church. As the children will have been preparing to receive this sacrament for a year it most certainly will be a time for celebration and I'd expect your sister to have you to lunch here as well as you to be there when the children receive Communion for the first time. All the rest, travelling to your home country and hundreds of pounds spent on gifts is nothing to do with the sacrament

FlamingJingleBells · 26/11/2022 08:10

Skelligsfeathers · 26/11/2022 06:02

It's not a christening, its a first holy communion. Kid will be about 7 or 8

Ahh I shouldn't post in the middle of the night when I can't sleep! Thanks for the correction @Skelligsfeathers however I still stand by the point that the spiritual aspect of the communion has been lost. Its just been turned into a commercial money grabbing exercise to extract expensive gifts from people.

snowshoehare · 26/11/2022 06:16

How significant is a a godparent at a first communion anyway. Surely it's the signal that your job is done now that they are joining the church as an "adult"?

Having said that my Catholic raised mother was truly appalled at the Anglican version of a first communion - it wasn't the big dress up occasion it was in her generation. It was cheap though I'll grant you.

My eldest child's grandmother though has been a constant presence and gave them a generous gift for university expenses. Since he's a little heathen she's never had to turn up for the confirmation.

daretodenim · 26/11/2022 06:15

Is it a private service? What church is so small (presumably DSIS goes to church along with other people in the community) that it can't hold a regular service? I thought these are community events for the church. Something here I'm not understanding - which may just be me missing something!

I think you were considerate doing your event at Christmas when everybody was already going to be together. DSis is requiring you all to do an extra journey.

Is it possible that you go alone for a day or two and then come back rather than all of you going for a week. It's not ideal but at least you'll be there for your nephew and also not bankrupt yourself.

BTW definitely buy at least your ticket now. I've just missed the cheap flight window for one in early Feb and it'll cost £450 with hand luggage only to fly to an EU location!! And given the rise in flight prices plus the cost of living increases everywhere, it may well be that other relatives aren't all able to attend either, if everybody lives in different countries. Driving is maybe cheaper than flying for a family of four, but one plane ticket can be cheaper than that.

Skelligsfeathers · 26/11/2022 06:02

FlamingJingleBells · 26/11/2022 05:43

This doesn't sound right to me. How can a church be so small that it can't accommodate the godparents for christenings? Can the christening even be valid if the godparents can't be present to perform their part of the ceremony?

I think the spiritual aspect of the ceremony has been sidelined by the emphasis on money. It all sounds like an excuse to host lavish parties, show off and put people under financial pressure. The actual spiritual message of welcoming the child into the faith has been lost.

It's not a christening, its a first holy communion. Kid will be about 7 or 8

Skelligsfeathers · 26/11/2022 06:00

The op's sister is saying she is NOT ALLOTED to attend the communion service in the uk! She must attend the event abroad.