Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To report this zoo

64 replies

belimoo · 25/11/2022 21:42

I went to an animal experience today (in the U.K.). It was a birthday present which I thought I'd love and was very much looking forward to.

However, on arrival it immediately felt sad and I felt bad for every animal I saw. The enclosures seemed small and cold and the animals were listless, This was the case throughout the medium sized park.

As part of the experience I saw three types of animals and fed them. Two of these seemed quite happy and engaged but the rest of the animals were buried in wet straw and I couldn't see anything in their lives which might give them any joy or freedom.

I know I was naive and stupid to go there in the first place. The keepers were knowledgeable and genuinely seemed to care about the animals but I don't know how they could ignore the bleak desperation of it all. There was a giant tortoise who kept bashing his shell against the walls in an attempt to get out.

What can/should do I do in this situation? Am I overreacting? Should I try to talk to the RSPCA? I feel I have to do something and can't just leave them there but don't know what is possible or realistic.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FurAndFeathers · 26/11/2022 18:05

Automaticforthepeople · 26/11/2022 10:25

I found this organisation:
wildwelfare.org/report-a-concern/

It provides steps to follow if you are concerned. You can also contact them through an online reporting form.

They work with organisations to help them make changes. Sounds really good.

I don't think that you are overeacting at all. I would feel the same! Don't beat yourself up. You are not stupid. You sound very caring and your visit might result in improvements for these animals.

They are excellent and make a real difference for animal welfare. I’d strongly suggest a donation!

HeckyPeck · 26/11/2022 15:56

TeenDivided · 26/11/2022 12:10

I can't comment on the place the OP went.
Just wondering about the people who have no support for zoos at all under any circumstances.
If a wild population is at the risk of becoming extinct, would you rather that happen than captive breeding programmes and future reintroduction to the wild?
If a species only exists in the wild in one location or on one island with an active volcano, would you rather risk that population dying off in a natural event, or have a 'saviour population' in zoos?

www.durrell.org/conservation/

I agree.

There are many species that only still exist because of conservation projects in zoos.

frozengoose · 26/11/2022 15:09

The rats aren't going to start taking sly chunks out of the animals.
They are there to help themselves to the high quality food that is available.

BloodyAutocarrot · 26/11/2022 15:00

@Brightstarowl I wouldn't worry about rats attacking the animals, it's highly unlikely. With plentiful food available they'd have no reason to try and eat something that'll potentially fight back (I've seen chickens having a go at rats BTW and the rats just scarpered)

Kindofcrunchy · 26/11/2022 13:38

Brightstarowl · 26/11/2022 12:53

Oh no 😭

The rats probably bite the poor animals when they're trying to sleep 😒😓

Poor things.

And you know this for a fact about rats do you? Plentiful food source around them and yet they "probably" chew on the poor zoo animals while they're asleep 🙄 the animals have much worse human-shaped problems, believe me!

BlackberryCat · 26/11/2022 13:20

I'm not trying to be mysterious by not naming it. I just don't want to slate a place when I'm conscious that I'm not an expert on these things and may be reacting emotionally without knowing all the facts.

Yes, but I was thinking if you said where it was, people might be able to give more specific information, like there may be a reason the tortoise is kept like that or there may be another reason it seemed unhappy, like a medical reason or its always grumpy when it's rainy type of thing.

Brightstarowl · 26/11/2022 12:53

Meklk · 26/11/2022 11:00

I was shocked after I visited London's Zoo. Even my 3,5 year old son asked why its so dirty and all animals upset. I couldn't believe it's a zoo in one of the biggest Europe cities.
Poo everywhere, animals so skinny, rats were running around. Never ever.

Oh no 😭

The rats probably bite the poor animals when they're trying to sleep 😒😓

Poor things.

belimoo · 26/11/2022 12:46

BosaNova · 26/11/2022 12:08

Is it possible the tortoise was in small inside enclosure for a reason?
Most zoos have the set up of outside large, inside and quarantine small for obvious practical reasons.
Grasping at straws, bit inside spaces are never glam. They should though have access to outside

There were a few smaller tortoises in there with it so I don't think it was quarantine. There was no access to outside and it didn't seem like a temporary arrangement given the signage and layout. I guess it could be for hibernation though?

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 26/11/2022 12:10

I can't comment on the place the OP went.
Just wondering about the people who have no support for zoos at all under any circumstances.
If a wild population is at the risk of becoming extinct, would you rather that happen than captive breeding programmes and future reintroduction to the wild?
If a species only exists in the wild in one location or on one island with an active volcano, would you rather risk that population dying off in a natural event, or have a 'saviour population' in zoos?

www.durrell.org/conservation/

BosaNova · 26/11/2022 12:08

Is it possible the tortoise was in small inside enclosure for a reason?
Most zoos have the set up of outside large, inside and quarantine small for obvious practical reasons.
Grasping at straws, bit inside spaces are never glam. They should though have access to outside

JustLyra · 26/11/2022 12:06

There are quite a few dire zoos in the UK because the people who inspect them are from the local council and don’t always have a clue what they are looking for.

Generally if they’re not members of BIAZA or EAZA they’re one to avoid.

Monkey World will take reports of any monkeys or apes in bad conditions, even in zoos or wildlife parks. They’re limited what they can do often because of their own limited space and the fact that standards don’t have to be super high to be legally acceptable.

belimoo · 26/11/2022 12:05

@SheWoreYellow you're right, I didn't and should have in hindsight.

@NiceTwin no, it wasn't but that sounds horrible.

OP posts:
NiceTwin · 26/11/2022 12:02

Was it Blackpool Zoo?
Went once, saw the poor, poor elephant and walked back out again. A truly upsetting experience.

SheWoreYellow · 26/11/2022 12:00

belimoo · 26/11/2022 11:56

Thank you @Otterock I did mean it when I asked whether I was overreacting. I'm not sure that they're doing anything 'wrong' in terms of what the rules are. I can't imagine an animal in a cage in dreary cold November is ever going to look happy, no matter how much space or good nutrition they have. A lot of these animals are from hot countries though, so how are we allowed to keep them here in the cold and rain at all?

I'm not trying to be mysterious by not naming it. I just don't want to slate a place when I'm conscious that I'm not an expert on these things and may be reacting emotionally without knowing all the facts.

It just seems so sad to see large birds in cages where they don't get to properly fly and other animals living on their own with nothing to play with or hunt. That's the nature of zoos though isn't it. That's why I feel a bit stupid posting this.

The worst one to see was the large tortoise, just pacing around the four walls of its small enclosure, bashing its shell against the walls and unable to even see out of the window we were looking in through. Maybe that's just because it should be hibernating at the moment though and it lives somewhere else in summer?

It sounds like you didn’t tell staff what was going on with the tortoise, maybe you should have so they could help if it was in distress, or reassure you about what it was doing.

belimoo · 26/11/2022 11:56

Thank you @Otterock I did mean it when I asked whether I was overreacting. I'm not sure that they're doing anything 'wrong' in terms of what the rules are. I can't imagine an animal in a cage in dreary cold November is ever going to look happy, no matter how much space or good nutrition they have. A lot of these animals are from hot countries though, so how are we allowed to keep them here in the cold and rain at all?

I'm not trying to be mysterious by not naming it. I just don't want to slate a place when I'm conscious that I'm not an expert on these things and may be reacting emotionally without knowing all the facts.

It just seems so sad to see large birds in cages where they don't get to properly fly and other animals living on their own with nothing to play with or hunt. That's the nature of zoos though isn't it. That's why I feel a bit stupid posting this.

The worst one to see was the large tortoise, just pacing around the four walls of its small enclosure, bashing its shell against the walls and unable to even see out of the window we were looking in through. Maybe that's just because it should be hibernating at the moment though and it lives somewhere else in summer?

OP posts:
Skiphopbump · 26/11/2022 11:41

I love the idea of going to the zoo to see animals but generally leave feeling despondent. I felt like that after visiting a zoo in the summer, it certainly didn’t feel like paradise for the animals.

BosaNova · 26/11/2022 11:36

FettleOfKish · 26/11/2022 11:25

Indeed. The Zoo we are members of operates and funds a network of education and breeding centres all over the world, and the majority of animals they keep here at the Zoo are severely endangered and part of the worlds remaining stock to prevent extinction. Unfortunately we're now in a position that we can't just put all Orangutans back into the wild, because they'd be wiped from the face of the earth by humans within a decade.

There are no big animals just for show at our Zoo, no big cats, no elephants, no polar bears, no giraffes or Zebras.

It saddens me that some visitors to our area will see the word 'Zoo' and immediately write it off with no more research. Not all Zoos are the same.

Exactly.
I believe the one my family and many friends have annual tickets to has nearly 9000 square meters space for elephants and hippos. It's massive and really nice project.
It's zoos like this which are worth it. Though even these good ones can still do better! There are always lessons learned.

Otterock · 26/11/2022 11:35

I used to work in a zoo. Please don’t use born free - they do more harm than good.

Don’t bother with the rspca. They have low standards and to be honest- they’re too busy to care.

You can try the local authority as they are the ones who issue the license. However, they are automatically biased in favour of the zoo as it’s a local attraction that brings in money (an issue in itself with zoo licensing).

If the zoo is a member of BIAZA, EAZA or WAZA you can contact them. Wild welfare are also a good organisation to contact.

However, please remember everything you see is a snapshot of that animals day. The weather has been very wet and dreary recently - so that will already make things seem more ‘grim’ and depressing. Bed was wet? Did you see inside the indoor area or other areas of bedding? You might have just seen it before the bed was replaced and cleaned.

Animals inactive? Likely because of the weather. Could be part of their routine that they rest at the time you saw them.

Visitors do get a very narrow view of things, they don’t see everything that goes on behind the scenes or the animals entire day. There are issues with zoos, how some of them are run and certainly the licensing. In all honesty, unless the situation is really bad (like south lakes several years ago), not much is likely to come of it. Please consider everything carefully before you report.

Emmamoo89 · 26/11/2022 11:33

Ilovemycatalot · 25/11/2022 22:44

Let’s be honest no animal can be happy in a zoo. I wouldn’t visit one . What’s good about seeing a depressed animal in a cage. I hate all this crap about conservation as an excuse to keep animals in cages. They are man made artificial environments that effect an animals mental health and behaviour. I hate how humans think they have the right to cage these beautiful animals to make money it’s disgusting.

Not all are bad and if it weren't for zoos most animals would be extinct

BlackberryCat · 26/11/2022 11:31

You can say the name of the zoo, OP. There’s no need to be mysterious. Unless you’ve posted about it on social media and don’t want to be outed.

There are good zoos out there that do good work but there are a lot of shit zoos too, unfortunately.

FettleOfKish · 26/11/2022 11:25

BosaNova · 26/11/2022 09:24

Last yime I went to zoo my ticket paid for upkeep of modern large spaces, return of Horse przewalski to Mongolian wilderness, Gorilla safety programme in Cameroon and preservation efforts for Egyptian vulture in Europe, amongst other things.
The zoo had signs around habitats that if you cannot see the animal because they are hiding in the grass or bushes, tough luck. They are there to breed.

Some zoos are not like the other and concrete zoos don't belong

Indeed. The Zoo we are members of operates and funds a network of education and breeding centres all over the world, and the majority of animals they keep here at the Zoo are severely endangered and part of the worlds remaining stock to prevent extinction. Unfortunately we're now in a position that we can't just put all Orangutans back into the wild, because they'd be wiped from the face of the earth by humans within a decade.

There are no big animals just for show at our Zoo, no big cats, no elephants, no polar bears, no giraffes or Zebras.

It saddens me that some visitors to our area will see the word 'Zoo' and immediately write it off with no more research. Not all Zoos are the same.

Damnautocorrect · 26/11/2022 11:07

Meklk · 26/11/2022 11:00

I was shocked after I visited London's Zoo. Even my 3,5 year old son asked why its so dirty and all animals upset. I couldn't believe it's a zoo in one of the biggest Europe cities.
Poo everywhere, animals so skinny, rats were running around. Never ever.

Rats are there because there’s food and bedding. They cannot poison the rats as it may harm their animals. There are rats at every animal places, farms, zoos etc.

the animals at london and whipsnade aren’t skinny. They have teams of nutritionists and experts who do field work to ensure the animals are fed as close to natural diet as possible - you should see the feed rooms and prep rooms, utterly spotless and well stocked. So much thought and research is done into it, what you think you saw is not what you saw. They are genuinely world leaders in the field.

i can’t comment on dirty the place is, I wasn’t there the day you were.

belimoo · 26/11/2022 11:02

Automaticforthepeople · 26/11/2022 10:25

I found this organisation:
wildwelfare.org/report-a-concern/

It provides steps to follow if you are concerned. You can also contact them through an online reporting form.

They work with organisations to help them make changes. Sounds really good.

I don't think that you are overeacting at all. I would feel the same! Don't beat yourself up. You are not stupid. You sound very caring and your visit might result in improvements for these animals.

Thank you 🙏

And thank you to all the others who have suggested where to report, I will follow them all up.

OP posts:
belimoo · 26/11/2022 11:01

@FurAndFeathers no I don't think there was a small railway.

OP posts:
Meklk · 26/11/2022 11:00

I was shocked after I visited London's Zoo. Even my 3,5 year old son asked why its so dirty and all animals upset. I couldn't believe it's a zoo in one of the biggest Europe cities.
Poo everywhere, animals so skinny, rats were running around. Never ever.