Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you tell whole school year your child is autistic?

186 replies

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Queenshandbag · 25/11/2022 22:38

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:10

How exactly would it have been easier to explain “autism” to your child than to explain “impulse control”, or “sound sensitivity” for example?

Was your primary aged daughter an educational psychologist?

Just sharing my personal experience - maybe I didn’t explain myself well.
From the brief times I saw him in the playground at the beginning and end of school, I had no idea what his diagnosis was so explaining his behaviour to my daughter was all guess work and platitudes. I just knew he needed a teaching assistant and was clearly finding starting school difficult as he was lashing out.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:36

Nice concept of SN you have there

Are you suggesting:

  • bad behaviour is non existent in NT children?
  • that there's never any overlap between some bad behaviour exhibited by NT children and behaviours ND children may not be able to control?

Should i literally assume that every child who doesn't behave perfectly has SN? This seems an odd assumption.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 25/11/2022 22:35

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:20

I dont think there is any reason to be more specific though? I know when my kids came home from school complaining that x or y would do this or that I would always explain in generic terms that maybe x or y has additional needs and finds thing you find easy difficult or what ever.

But to do that you need confirmation that they do have additional needs. DC has been hurt a few times in rough play by a child in their class. Child does not have additional needs, they are just quite... free spirited and the parents (friends of friends) impose few/no boundaries at home. I do not and will not excuse other children's unacceptable behaviour to mine, or expect them to accomodate it, unless i know a child genuinely has additional needs.

You don't need to excuse behaviour. You say, aw that shouldn't have happened or whatever, make sure you tell the teacher if it happens again, not everyone knows how to behave, have home lives that teach them how to behave etc. Acknowledge that it shouldn't have happened, teach them what to do if it does and explain that not all kids have the knowledge or the best guides to show them what to do or not do becasue kids aren't generally naughty for no reason.

It was important to me to teach my kids compassion and that life isn't black and white naughty kid/good kid. They are teens now and are really perceptive, they always stop and think and make their mates stop and think too before labelling someone bad or weird or stupid or whatever. There is a difference between excusing behaviour and understanding behaviour.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:33

OP is discussing autism. You seem to be talking about thugs. Not the same at all, old thing.

DC had an autistic child in their class last year. Unfortunately they were struggling a lot and hurt other children. Like a pp, following a school discussion about bullying, my DC was left with the view this autistic child was a bully.

Young children can't distinguish between a child being wired differently and a child who is NT but badly behaved/poorly parented.

Where we live it doesnt seem the norm to be secretive about this. Several parents have openly informed me that their child is autistic/being assessed.

Ericaequites · 25/11/2022 22:30

Keep his diagnosis on a née to know basis, and talk about his needs with parents of his close friends without using the diagnosis. Just say DS has trouble with certain things, and list them. It’s best to keep things confidential, as you can’t unring a bell.

PeppermintyPatty · 25/11/2022 22:26

Also: you need to remember that it’s sensitive personal/medical info that belongs to him and he can’t consent about an announcement right now because he doesn’t have capacity to understand at that age. With my child we’ve said that it’s not something to announce. We’ve been very clear to make sure that he knows it’s not shameful, but that he can only tell people once and so he needs to think about when he is ready to share the information because he won’t be able to control what other people do with it.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:25

Nice concept of SN you have there @MilkyYay

OP is discussing autism. You seem to be talking about thugs. Not the same at all, old thing.

I am not remotely surprised nobody feels inclined to confide in you.

stridesy · 25/11/2022 22:25

No. It was fairly obvious my son was autistic by the fact his 1-1 brought him out plus I’m sure his behaviour as well was a clue. Sen parents I’ve found arnt overly understanding themselves let alone parents whose children don’t have sen needs and are also guilty of excluding certain children from birthday parties ect. I’ve mentioned my sons diagnosis on a 1-1 basis in general conversation with a parent but wouldn’t dream of announcing it to everyone.
Theres at least two sen children in my daughters class. Ironically school did an assembly about bullying unfortunately my 5 year old now thinks one of those children is now a bully. Very tempted to mention it to school that their overall message has got lost somewhere.She also has sen needs as she has a severe speech disorder.

PeppermintyPatty · 25/11/2022 22:24

I think you keep it on a need to know basis but don’t make it a secret. You will find that it slowly percolates through the parent population and your child’s differences will be accepted. If it’s already very obvious they might already know, if it’s not then it will probably become apparent as he gets older. My autistic DS is now 8, and when it comes up or is relevant I do tell other parents. Some are surprised, but maybe mostly because he presents fairly neurotypically most of the time (outside the house), or maybe because diagnosis is hard to get. Others are like well, yeah, duh! I think if he doesn’t yet know himself (and we told our child at about 7.5) then no need to WhatsApp it.

autienotnaughty · 25/11/2022 22:23

We talk about ds being autistic as it's not a secret. He knows he's autistic too. But I wouldn't announce it to all and sundry. Also prepare your self for the fact some parents are dicks regardless of wether they know about ur child's diagnosis.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:22

That you won’t use your imagination about why some children are withdrawn or anxious or hyperactive or lash out?

Of course you can in more extreme circumstances but I'm not going to assume every naughty, aggressive difficult, spoilt or brattish child has additional needs. Hmm

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:20

I dont think there is any reason to be more specific though? I know when my kids came home from school complaining that x or y would do this or that I would always explain in generic terms that maybe x or y has additional needs and finds thing you find easy difficult or what ever.

But to do that you need confirmation that they do have additional needs. DC has been hurt a few times in rough play by a child in their class. Child does not have additional needs, they are just quite... free spirited and the parents (friends of friends) impose few/no boundaries at home. I do not and will not excuse other children's unacceptable behaviour to mine, or expect them to accomodate it, unless i know a child genuinely has additional needs.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:19

Oh @Foolsandtheirmoney don’t go spoiling the fun with your common sense and compassion. These people want their sticky beak tights respected. 😉

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:18

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:15

I find it difficult when expected to accomodate/tolerate behaviour that would be perceived as unacceptable in NT children the same age, when i don't know a child is ND.

Statistically, most children are NT so I'm never going to assume is ND unless I'm told.

I also want to help. I want to avoid triggering difficulties for a child who already struggles with every day life. I want to find ways to minimise their stress. I want to support their parents & offer to help in any way I can. It's very difficult to do this if I don't know that there's a problem.

So i think it really depends on your child's behaviour/profile & how they react to things. If their behaviour is going to be regularly impacting people around them I think its helpful to explain why.

Do you feel the same way about being told a child’s adoption, fostering, care, child protection or abuse background? That you won’t use your imagination about why some children are withdrawn or anxious or hyperactive or lash out? You just insist on your right to judge harshly unless given confidential information to persuade you otherwise?

Wow. There are some truly terrible fellow parents out there.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:15

I find it difficult when expected to accomodate/tolerate behaviour that would be perceived as unacceptable in NT children the same age, when i don't know a child is ND.

Statistically, most children are NT so I'm never going to assume is ND unless I'm told.

I also want to help. I want to avoid triggering difficulties for a child who already struggles with every day life. I want to find ways to minimise their stress. I want to support their parents & offer to help in any way I can. It's very difficult to do this if I don't know that there's a problem.

So i think it really depends on your child's behaviour/profile & how they react to things. If their behaviour is going to be regularly impacting people around them I think its helpful to explain why.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 25/11/2022 22:14

Queenshandbag · 25/11/2022 22:03

I personally think it’s a good idea to be upfront with the other parents. My daughter had a boy in her class all through primary who had a teaching assistant supporting him and needed allowances made for him to cope with a normal classroom. In p1(reception) my daughter often complained that he’d hit her and we raised it with the teacher who went in to a panic and said ‘ I can’t discuss him with you, I can’t discuss him with you.’ Totally fair enough but it would have helped to have been able to explain to our daughter exactly why he found school difficult and was lashing out. We had to talk in really generic terms about how he found school hard and tell her to stay away from him as much as possible because we had no idea what his actual diagnosis was.

I dont think there is any reason to be more specific though? I know when my kids came home from school complaining that x or y would do this or that I would always explain in generic terms that maybe x or y has additional needs and finds thing you find easy difficult or what ever. They never needed am actual name of a condition. I don't even know of those kids has additional needs, I don't think it matters, it's just explaining that everyone copes with things in different ways/not everyone will behave how you want them to etc

WorldLeaderPretend · 25/11/2022 22:14

Yes, it was never a secret about my DS being autistic, but neither did we do a Big Announcement. I always felt for DS to fully accept being autistic it shouldn't be a shameful secret, or a cause to celebrate. It just is, like him wearing glasses and having black hair.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:10

Queenshandbag · 25/11/2022 22:03

I personally think it’s a good idea to be upfront with the other parents. My daughter had a boy in her class all through primary who had a teaching assistant supporting him and needed allowances made for him to cope with a normal classroom. In p1(reception) my daughter often complained that he’d hit her and we raised it with the teacher who went in to a panic and said ‘ I can’t discuss him with you, I can’t discuss him with you.’ Totally fair enough but it would have helped to have been able to explain to our daughter exactly why he found school difficult and was lashing out. We had to talk in really generic terms about how he found school hard and tell her to stay away from him as much as possible because we had no idea what his actual diagnosis was.

How exactly would it have been easier to explain “autism” to your child than to explain “impulse control”, or “sound sensitivity” for example?

Was your primary aged daughter an educational psychologist?

Queenshandbag · 25/11/2022 22:03

I personally think it’s a good idea to be upfront with the other parents. My daughter had a boy in her class all through primary who had a teaching assistant supporting him and needed allowances made for him to cope with a normal classroom. In p1(reception) my daughter often complained that he’d hit her and we raised it with the teacher who went in to a panic and said ‘ I can’t discuss him with you, I can’t discuss him with you.’ Totally fair enough but it would have helped to have been able to explain to our daughter exactly why he found school difficult and was lashing out. We had to talk in really generic terms about how he found school hard and tell her to stay away from him as much as possible because we had no idea what his actual diagnosis was.

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 21:55

@kanaloa you seem to want to take offence to my post.

I am saying the children didnt understand. Putting a name to something helps children understand things more easily. Saying "sometimes people find things hard" doesnt help because thr other kids are thinking "well thats not hard, why cant he behave like us".

The school were allowed to be unsupportive because no one was pushing for a diagnosis. Now hes in year 6 and has struggled socially all the way through school. It wasnt fair and i have no idea what the school and parents were playing at tbh.

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 21:50

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 25/11/2022 21:34

Personally, I don’t understand the secrecy? If people know, then they can understand and relate to issues he might have and make reasonable adjustments?
(but maybe I’m the oddity here?)

Okay. Well from now on I want to know which children in my son’s class have divorced parents. And which children are in the care of the local authority. And which ones are delayed in meeting their goals, and which ones have been victims of abuse, and which ones have suffered bereavement, and which ones are dyslexic. I feel an open disclosure of everything I’m nosy about would help me support those children.

Oh, no… it’s actually not my job or business and I wouldn’t be supporting those children, would I? Unless you are planning on working in the classroom, you really don’t need to know the individual needs of every child - and many of them will have needs of one kind or another.

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 21:47

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 21:29

Yes i agree the children would have began othering him anyway. However, when my son came home from an early age describing meltdowns etc, it wouldve been so much easier if i couldve said "Billy has autism. This means x, y and z and you need to try to realise that he will react in ways you may not always understand."

As it stood, the school did no work about difference or autism or SNs. And then at home, i tried to explain but my son just didnt get it. Maybe if a childs school is better with dealing with SNs its not necessary for parents to know. But i could see the child was floundering and no one seemed to be doing anything about it.

But presumably the school would have been rubbish either way if they were doing no work? And I don’t see how an ‘open disclosure’ to you personally (who had already decided the child was autistic) would have helped. Why is it easier to say ‘he’s autistic’ than to tell your son ‘x child is having a hard time. Sometimes people find things very hard, when that happens we do xyz or we get a teacher.’

Like there’s no reason the magic word ‘autism’ would have suddenly helped your child be understanding - and parents of classmates knowing would make absolutely no difference to the child floundering in an unsupportive school environment. Unless you were all trained in working with autistic children and planning on volunteering your time to support him at the first hint of a disclosure of their private information. Which I doubt.

Whatifiwereareindeer · 25/11/2022 21:42

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 25/11/2022 21:34

Personally, I don’t understand the secrecy? If people know, then they can understand and relate to issues he might have and make reasonable adjustments?
(but maybe I’m the oddity here?)

Because the parents of the children my son doesn’t play with or speak to, often parents I have never spoken to and sometimes have never even seen because for example their child goes to wrap around, don’t need the intimate details of my child’s condition. His actual friends and their parents need to understand more details, random girls in his class he has nothing to do with just need telling by the teacher “x is wearing ear defenders because he doesn’t like the noise in the lunch hall” or “x is sitting on a ball because that’s how he concentrates best, now let’s get back to….” There’s a difference between “secret” and “not shared with thirty odd people, half of whom I don’t know anything about except their child is in my child’s class”.

Poppy160 · 25/11/2022 21:42

Personally I wouldn’t put it on the group chat. Iv told some parents that my son is autistic but only when he’s done something that could be considered rude, like not responding to them or their children, but it’s quite noticeable he has additional needs so they probably already knew.

tickticksnooze · 25/11/2022 21:40

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 25/11/2022 21:34

Personally, I don’t understand the secrecy? If people know, then they can understand and relate to issues he might have and make reasonable adjustments?
(but maybe I’m the oddity here?)

That would first require them to understand autism and how it affects this child.

Most won't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread