Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you tell whole school year your child is autistic?

186 replies

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

OP posts:
MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:35

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:31

I'm a little nervous about posting, as the conversation seems to have become quite bad tempered.
For my part, I wish some other parents with ND children in my DS's class had been more open about it when I was struggling to understand and cope with my DS's behaviour. During the wait for and since his diagnosis, we've been very open about it with him, and he has been quite happy to explain it to other children. I realise that not all children will be able to express themselves as easily.
I possibly wouldn't have gone as far as a WhatsApp announcement though. In the end, we were denied the opportunity to talk about his diagnosis with other parents, as he was permanently excluded, and ended up at a different school. But I do think that unless we talk about neurodiversity to people with no experience if it, it retains its stigma.

Didn’t you and parents of ND children naturally gravitate towards each other? I always think it’s a bit like a secret society.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:34

I’m observing (not assuming) the worst about you because you said that if you weren’t informed about the medical needs of a child unrelated to you, you were going to insist on viewing them as “brattish”, badly parented and wilfully naughty

Im sorry you have interpreted my words that way. That is not what is intended.

My intention is to note that far more children are NT than ND and therefore to recognise that for many behaviours, its more likely a child is NT and displaying unacceptable behaviours, than ND. My point being that brattish, aggressive, naughty NT children are imho more common within the population, than ND children at particular age brackets.

Behaviour in schools has deteriorated massively in the last 20 years, and thus I'm perhaps reluctant to embrace a model where we simply widen the scope of behaviour we tolerate from everyone (NT or otherwise).

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:31

I'm a little nervous about posting, as the conversation seems to have become quite bad tempered.
For my part, I wish some other parents with ND children in my DS's class had been more open about it when I was struggling to understand and cope with my DS's behaviour. During the wait for and since his diagnosis, we've been very open about it with him, and he has been quite happy to explain it to other children. I realise that not all children will be able to express themselves as easily.
I possibly wouldn't have gone as far as a WhatsApp announcement though. In the end, we were denied the opportunity to talk about his diagnosis with other parents, as he was permanently excluded, and ended up at a different school. But I do think that unless we talk about neurodiversity to people with no experience if it, it retains its stigma.

Jenn3112 · 25/11/2022 23:27

Don't share on a whole year Whats app group, thats a horrible idea. Tell parents of close friends, and let the school talk to any children who need to know in an age appropriate way. If you tell everyone now you take that choice away from your child in future - the whole community will already know their diagnosis even if they don't want or need them to at a later time.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:26

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:21

A mum on our WhatsApp has just stared sharing general links about adaptations for people with autism and other info around the topic.

This is a good idea.

But honestly. Stop assuming people are going to be judgy and discriminate, why don't you assume people want to know from a place of good intentions. Most people want to accommodate your child's needs and do what they can to help.

Well I’m observing (not assuming) the worst about you because you said that if you weren’t informed about the medical needs of a child unrelated to you, you were going to insist on viewing them as “brattish”, badly parented and wilfully naughty (CBA to scroll up but it was a vicious list along those lines). So you’ve pigeon holed yourself quite willing as what you are.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:24

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:16

Metalla you are quite deliberately and obtusely twisting my words. I really don't understand why.

but list a lot of nasty words to describe D.C. with SN. Reread the post. The whole point is they are words to describe NT children not behaving well out of choice.

I’m really not. You just can’t see the inconsistencies and implications of what you’re asserting.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:23

How is making the magic disclosure of the word “autism” going to be any use to this majority of parents “who know fuck all about autism” then?

Sorry, where have i explicity said a name needs putting to it? I don't. I do think its helpful if you share with parents who's children will have a lot of interaction with yours (most of their class) that they have additional needs or are neurodiverse.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:21

A mum on our WhatsApp has just stared sharing general links about adaptations for people with autism and other info around the topic.

This is a good idea.

But honestly. Stop assuming people are going to be judgy and discriminate, why don't you assume people want to know from a place of good intentions. Most people want to accommodate your child's needs and do what they can to help.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:19

Ok. But then know that with less obvious behaviours it will be much harder for most parents (who know fuck all about autism) to accomodate or tolerate a child's needs.

How is making the magic disclosure of the word “autism” going to be any use to this majority of parents “who know fuck all about autism” then?

Meaningless to “most”.

Grist to the judgemental and ignorant.

Where is the upside in sharing it?

Focus on specifics, behaviours, solutions, empathy etc. Take any subtle steer that’s in offer and maybe also try to be nice to the introverted children whose medical records you haven’t seen either.

FusionChefGeoff · 25/11/2022 23:19

A mum on our WhatsApp has just stared sharing general links about adaptations for people with autism and other info around the topic. So then if I have read between the lines and reckon there's a higher than average chance her child may have autism.

Perhaps you could approach it like that?

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 23:18

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 23:07

I find it offensive because it is offensive. Putting the name ‘autistic’ won’t suddenly make kids understand if they’re incapable of understanding the concept. And you still haven’t come up with any reasonable explanation for why you feel you (a random classmate’s parent) are entitled to know children’s private information to make it ‘easier’ to explain to your child.

Ok thats fine then. Dont share the information if you dont think itd be helpful. Its your decision as the parent.

But my child isnt the one who is struggling at school. I was concerned about someone elses child but apparently that makes me the bad one. Ok then.

If my child was strugglign, you can bet your bottom dollar i wouldnt rest until the school took it seriously. And every parent in his class would know he had been diagnosed and had SN. People are more willing to make allowances for others if they know theres a reason for their behaviour. Thats all im saying.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:16

Metalla you are quite deliberately and obtusely twisting my words. I really don't understand why.

but list a lot of nasty words to describe D.C. with SN. Reread the post. The whole point is they are words to describe NT children not behaving well out of choice.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:14

Neither you nor your child need the diagnosis given to you or confirmed to you.

Ok. But then know that with less obvious behaviours it will be much harder for most parents (who know fuck all about autism) to accomodate or tolerate a child's needs.

Because they could easily be confused in some instances as the wants of a NT child.

Eg Ed needs to sit on that same green spot for carpet time, every day, because that routine is established and enables him to tolerate school. Eva wants to sit on the pink one because its her favourite colour.

Tristan wants to eat only nutella sandwiches every day because he is 5 and mmmm chocolate. Tom cannot tolerate different foods and needs to eat that to meet his calorie requirements.

Not the same and shouldn't be treated the same, but how can other people tell if these are your child's wants or needs & accomodate accordingly?

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 23:12

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:33

OP is discussing autism. You seem to be talking about thugs. Not the same at all, old thing.

DC had an autistic child in their class last year. Unfortunately they were struggling a lot and hurt other children. Like a pp, following a school discussion about bullying, my DC was left with the view this autistic child was a bully.

Young children can't distinguish between a child being wired differently and a child who is NT but badly behaved/poorly parented.

Where we live it doesnt seem the norm to be secretive about this. Several parents have openly informed me that their child is autistic/being assessed.

It doesn’t matter. If a child is a bully or if they are autistic, put the focus on your child. Every child prolifically hurting others will have a reason of some sort. You don’t need to know why x is hurting your child so you can explain it to them. You need to ask the school what will be done to protect your child so they aren’t hurt, regardless of the reasons the other child is lashing out.

And it doesn’t matter whether your child knows the other kid is NT. All they need to know is ‘if anyone hurts you, you must tell a teacher immediately and get help. It’s not ok for you to get hurt, and the teacher can help you and protect you.’

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:11

But thats because that behaviour rarely negatively affects others.

Right. So you claim you want to “help” DC with SN, but list a lot of nasty words to describe D.C. with SN, and when challenged you say you aren’t interested in helping the quiet D.C. suffering silently with SN. So really just want to condemn. Got it. 👍🏻

Whatsleftnow · 25/11/2022 23:07

We wanted ds to know first and make his own decisions but looking back I think we were wrong. We were still seeing it as an explanation of what was wrong with him. But autism is much more integral than that.,

He’s a teen now, and being open about it has been much better for him. He advocates for himself, even challenging his teachers when they’re being unconsciously ableist. Not rudely they’ve assured me.

But we had a rough couple of years where his challenges were escalating at school and at the same time he was grappling with an identity that seemed mostly about the negatives.

If I could have a do over I would have been open and matter of fact from the start, and faced down any prejudice and ignorance.

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 23:07

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 21:55

@kanaloa you seem to want to take offence to my post.

I am saying the children didnt understand. Putting a name to something helps children understand things more easily. Saying "sometimes people find things hard" doesnt help because thr other kids are thinking "well thats not hard, why cant he behave like us".

The school were allowed to be unsupportive because no one was pushing for a diagnosis. Now hes in year 6 and has struggled socially all the way through school. It wasnt fair and i have no idea what the school and parents were playing at tbh.

I find it offensive because it is offensive. Putting the name ‘autistic’ won’t suddenly make kids understand if they’re incapable of understanding the concept. And you still haven’t come up with any reasonable explanation for why you feel you (a random classmate’s parent) are entitled to know children’s private information to make it ‘easier’ to explain to your child.

IncessantNameChanger · 25/11/2022 23:06

You do what is right for you. My youngest has ASD and comes across very in your face. I have two older kids in special schools and personally I'm done explaining why my child can't go into school like her peers, seems in your face, is louder that all the other girls. I'm done with the parents who...

Recoil,
Pity me,
Think it's my parenting,
Think it can't be asd because that's "rainman'
Etc

Mentally exhausting. So many parents won't get it even if I explained.

The parent who DO get, don't need to be told. They already guessed.

So do what ever is best for you and DC. What other parents think is largely irrelevant I have decided. Plus there's ALWAYS someone who asks 'why do you think that?'

I don't think anything. A consultant paediatrician told me.

Even at my sons special school! After that I gave myself permission to give up. I don't owe anyone a explanation or apology for my children's diagnosis.

Plus lots of our parents are so wrapped up in their own busy lives you haven't even crossed that radar.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:06

Interesting then that it was all words like “brattish” and no mention of shy or isolated children with SN

But thats because that behaviour rarely negatively affects others.

My view is its most helpful if you share information where doing so can help mitigate that.

Its the quieter, less obvious behaviours where knowing helps other parents be helpful. There's a child being obsessed in DC class atm. Masks amazingly at school then goes to pieces at home. Knowing about this helps us educate our children and help find ways to make that child's life easier, maybe reduce their need to mask etc, and hopefully improve things for them.

How are we supposed to try and meet needs if we don't know there are any?

autastic · 25/11/2022 23:04

I don't understand, why are the choices tell everyone or not tell him?
Tell him and bring it up if relevant, oh and make sure the school know, not clear in the op if they know or not.
You just tell him from the get go, it's pet fo who he is and not telling him will make him think it is something shameful.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:59

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:45

How exactly would it have been easier to explain “autism” to your child than to explain “impulse control”, or “sound sensitivity” for example

Because there's a difference between a child who simply cannot control an impulse and one who has made a choice not to because they don't expect consequences due to how they have been raised.

I will often explain things to my children as other children making poor choices and there's usually consequences i can point out (yes, tommy hit you and he had to go on the sad side of the wall chart/miss computer time, didnt he).

The conversation is different when the child who is autisitic hurts another child, because the school do not impose the usual consequences because they would exacerabate a situation. The other children simply see no consequences for the child who hurt them and are upset by perceived injustice.

Right so then you can infer from the different treatment (lack of consequences) that the teacher is handling this differently for a reason and talk to your child about “impulse control” or whatever instead of “poor choices”.

Neither you nor your child need the diagnosis given to you or confirmed to you.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 22:56

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:36

Nice concept of SN you have there

Are you suggesting:

  • bad behaviour is non existent in NT children?
  • that there's never any overlap between some bad behaviour exhibited by NT children and behaviours ND children may not be able to control?

Should i literally assume that every child who doesn't behave perfectly has SN? This seems an odd assumption.

No I think you’re perfectly well aware what was nasty about that list of descriptors you reeled off upthread, while saying you wanted to help children with SN. Interesting then that it was all words like “brattish” and no mention of shy or isolated children with SN.

GlipotyPlop · 25/11/2022 22:49

No.

Let him earn his own reputation for who he is - not what people might think of when they hear the word autism.

Some may have had an experience with a violent Autistic person and be afraid for their child's safety. Telling them to steer clear, to refuse to sit next to him.

Other parents may be worried their child will come home flapping and speaking poorly because they're playing/ copying your sons behaviour. They could guide this to mocking tone. Or saying things about him to try and deter them. Or again just tell them to stay away but because he's weird rather than for safety reasons as above. (Just want to make it clear I'm not saying anyone is weird, just possible ways I can envision parents reacting ).

Other children might over hear their parents talking about how autism is over diagnosed and how dramatic you are. Maybe the children will tell your son how silly he and his mummy is.

Others might be concerned their child will loose out on teaching time to deal with your son and prompt their child about whether or not yours was a nuisance and to let them know if he is so they can talk to the teacher.

I hope you can see that sending this text could make life very difficult for your son. I doubt it will have the outcome you want. Even if it works for some, there is no way thsy are not going to tell your DS he is autistic, I imagine you would like to be the one to tell him. Then the children will share their knowledge about autism, which might not make him feel great.

Just chat to the teacher if you feel he needs extra support in a particular area.

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 22:49

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:45

How exactly would it have been easier to explain “autism” to your child than to explain “impulse control”, or “sound sensitivity” for example

Because there's a difference between a child who simply cannot control an impulse and one who has made a choice not to because they don't expect consequences due to how they have been raised.

I will often explain things to my children as other children making poor choices and there's usually consequences i can point out (yes, tommy hit you and he had to go on the sad side of the wall chart/miss computer time, didnt he).

The conversation is different when the child who is autisitic hurts another child, because the school do not impose the usual consequences because they would exacerabate a situation. The other children simply see no consequences for the child who hurt them and are upset by perceived injustice.

This. My son thinks it is massively unfair that the boy in his class has allowances made for him and wonders why he doesnt get in trouble to the same level that he would if he did the same thing.

I have to give some wishy washy answer that doesnt explain it properly and my son ends up none the wiser.

I dont think its fair on anyome.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 22:45

How exactly would it have been easier to explain “autism” to your child than to explain “impulse control”, or “sound sensitivity” for example

Because there's a difference between a child who simply cannot control an impulse and one who has made a choice not to because they don't expect consequences due to how they have been raised.

I will often explain things to my children as other children making poor choices and there's usually consequences i can point out (yes, tommy hit you and he had to go on the sad side of the wall chart/miss computer time, didnt he).

The conversation is different when the child who is autisitic hurts another child, because the school do not impose the usual consequences because they would exacerabate a situation. The other children simply see no consequences for the child who hurt them and are upset by perceived injustice.