Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you tell whole school year your child is autistic?

186 replies

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Softplayhooray · 26/11/2022 04:01

Both my son's wanted to share their NDs and had the teachers tell the class during homeroom. It was a good move for them. They were older than your child though. I think it's generally a good thing.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/11/2022 03:51

When my DC have had social issues or other struggles with something at school the first thing I do is speak to their teacher. Ask their advice, if they can help. They've always been eager to help my DC.

On an individual level some people will be supportive, a lot probably won't care, and some will use your DS diagnosis as a way to exclude him and blame him. If I know a child needs something specific or struggles with something or will only eat a certain list of foods or will literally race round for the whole of a play date I'll take that into account. My behaviour won't change because they have or don't have a diagnosis. I think a lot of people who would be accepting already will be and the kids that will be mean to him or the parents that will exclude him wont be kinder because they know he's Autistic.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/11/2022 03:02

All my DC are Autistic, I don't see it as something I should share on their behalf, unless absolutely necessary. It's an important part of who they are and they should get to share that if and when they want to. DD pretty much tells everyone, DS1 was the first diagnosed, he didn't tell anyone or really talk about it till his siblings were diagnosed. The other 2 know they're Autistic but they're younger and it really doesn't mean much to them yet. Their teachers and therapists and the school know, sometimes I'd like to talk about it, but its not about me. If I felt it was absolutely necessary maybe, but then it would more be telling specific people not the whole class.

guineapugs · 26/11/2022 02:26

I work with children who have autism, adhd, Down's syndrome, social anxiety, Tourette's, ocd and more... no one has announced any of these diagnosis's on whatsap as a 'big announcement'. Need to know basis surely. All children are different and have their own needs...

jtaeapa · 26/11/2022 02:09

You’d think that it’d benefit him if people knew and gave him a bit of understanding. I thought the same when my ds was little. Unfortunately time has taught me that a child who is inclined to be a bully anyway will seize the information and bully the shit out of your ds. Maybe not at 4yo, but soon. And the bullying will be directly sort of “autistic retard” comments. My ds had this said to him by a child who bullied anyone he identified as different. And then once the child realised what sort of stuff upset my ds, he did these things continually. Some parents will commiserate and say you’re amazing for dealing with him and some will even treat it as though it’s a terminal illness. I suppose they mean well. Only tell people on play dates etc or where necessary and do it 1:1 in a casual way.

parsniiips · 26/11/2022 01:45

My son is autistic, I didn't make a big announcement but I have always let people know on a 1-1 basis for things like parties/playdates etc. Sometimes during chats in the playground when talking about how the kids are doing generally or if something has happened in school.

He's not old enough to understand what it means yet but when he is I will explain it to him and never encourage him to hide it. He is beautiful, kind, funny and thoughtful and he just needs a bit of space and time to process things and some understanding in certain situations. Other children have mostly been lovely and kind and seem to just know that he needs space sometimes or don't bat an eyelid if he has a wobble about something. They know it's just his way and it's fine.

I think it helps for other parents to be aware. I wouldn't want a child to go home and say something negative about my son or his behaviour and have them respond unfairly towards him. I know of a parent who tells her children to stay away from and not play with certain children because of incidents in school.
If parent are aware that he's autistic they can (hopefully) respond in a way that helps their child to understand and learn.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 01:20

I wouldn’t announce it on the WhatsApp group (mostly because I hate class WhatsApp groups!) but it’s common knowledge my son is autistic.

  1. because it is NEVER something to be ashamed of or embarrassed about.
  2. it clues people in to who they are dealing with (in the same way my wife will explain she is deaf- it is just more practical)
  3. to not mention it means obfuscating a lot.

I understand parents worrying about their child being labelled, left out, not invited, teased etc, but I think it’s best to get it out there so the idiots show themselves and you know where you stand (and who to avoid).

Im a dyke in a wheelchair, I have met my fair share of people who dislike/misunderstand/are uncomfortable/talk down/are full on hateful and violent- the answer is never to hide or change who you are so they ‘accept’ you- your Son doesn’t need acceptance from those types of people.

I tell my son some people are dickheads, but that is their issue not yours. (Although maybe don’t say dickheads if he is five!)

jamoncrumpets · 26/11/2022 01:14

'Many ND children don't have such an obvious physical presentation, but can exhibit behaviour that is risky. Knowledge, for those children, could therefore prove to be protective.'

So neurodiverse children who don't 'look disabled' should have their private medical information disclosed to all and sundry so that parents like you can guard your children from them?

That's placing the blame with the child and compromising their right to privacy.

It's up to the adults around them to keep them safe, and if necessary keep other children safe around them. If that's not happening then that doesn't mean mum should share a diagnosis on WhatsApp or whatever. That's not the problem. The problem is they're not being adequately supervised.

Nobody is owed medical information about a child, it is given on a need to know basis. I wouldn't say being a bit worried about little Johnny Stranglehands is reason for a medical disclosure. If he had a fit in the playground and an ambulance turned up I would probably tell the paramedics though.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 01:11

I think maybe @Dacadactyl is baiting deliberately.

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 01:09

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 23:18

Ok thats fine then. Dont share the information if you dont think itd be helpful. Its your decision as the parent.

But my child isnt the one who is struggling at school. I was concerned about someone elses child but apparently that makes me the bad one. Ok then.

If my child was strugglign, you can bet your bottom dollar i wouldnt rest until the school took it seriously. And every parent in his class would know he had been diagnosed and had SN. People are more willing to make allowances for others if they know theres a reason for their behaviour. Thats all im saying.

Do you think those of us with children struggling at school aren’t ‘not resting until they take it seriously?’ Trying to deal with schools and how they deal with SEN doesn’t involve disclosing your child’s private information to every parent in the school to satisfy their curiosity. And it isn’t on parents to ‘make exceptions.’ It’s on schools to make reasonable adjustments - you as a parent of another child do not have the power to make classroom adjustments for children with autism.

I’ll ask again - do you expect every student’s private information, or just the autistic children? I presume you do require a full up to date list of all fostered or adopted children, so that you can explain their possibly difficult behaviour to your child with ‘in the care of the local authority’ to make it ‘easier’ for you? I suppose every child who has been involved in domestic violence should have it reported to you also? Because these can affect behaviour too, so obviously you have a right to be privy to all that information.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/11/2022 00:39

When DD2 was in Year 2, there was a boy in her year who clearly had SEND. One morning, he charged up to her and put his hands around her throat and squeezed, digging his long nails in around her windpipe whilst saying he was going to rip her throat out (I think it was acting out from seeing inappropriate films).

Fortunately, I hadn't left the playground yet, so was able - with a lot of difficulty, as he was nearly five foot tall and about 8 stone to DD's 3 and a half foot/3 and a bit stone and so very, very strong - to force his fingers open and put myself between him and her so he couldn't get to her again when he kept trying, going to kick me for getting in his way. Because I could see the boy had SEND, I was a lot more reasonable about it when speaking to the Head shortly afterwards when I went into the office to say that I felt he needed to be supervised by either his Mum or a member of staff in the morning, as this behaviour didn't just put other children at risk, it put him at risk.

His main protection in this was being visibly different (and luck in not choosing some of the other children whose parents were far more likely to respond with overkill and most likely gone on to an extreme confrontation in the playground that afternoon - she stayed well away from me until the day he left the school, at any rate). DD's response that afternoon was that the Head had come down to see her to check that she was OK and yes, she'd been frightened but she knew he didn't understand what he was doing and was very glad she had been standing next to me when it happened.

Many ND children don't have such an obvious physical presentation, but can exhibit behaviour that is risky. Knowledge, for those children, could therefore prove to be protective.

ChristmasisRuined · 26/11/2022 00:34

My next door neighbours won’t allow their son & daughter to play with my DD because she has ASD (even when she was tiny). It's not behaviour related as my DD has only ever been lovely to them (she's always been supervised by me when playing out, due to her age). They summon their kids in immediately whenever they see them playing with DD. The youngest eventually blurted out that Mum doesn't want them playing with any child with special needs/ASD!!!

Whilst this mindset may not be the norm, people like this do exist and frankly, it's not worth the hurt. Don't broadcast it.

ChristmasisRuined · 26/11/2022 00:29

Abcdefgh1234 · 25/11/2022 21:26

My son is asd. I dont tell every parents in school. I just tell his friends parents. I always open about his conditions. If its not his friend i dont bother to tell.

You mean your child has ASD. Not is.

My DD has ASD and the condition does not define them!

DixonD · 26/11/2022 00:21

There are (were) a few with autism in my daughter’s class and the parents just mentioned it as and when necessary, as I think you should be able to do. My daughter was friends with one of them who was quite severely affected and she knew he needed additional support (she has a cousin with severe autism and I explained it to her in this way) and she accepted him entirely for who he was (I say was because he’s moved to a special school). Kids of 5 years old don’t discriminate.

shruggingitoff · 26/11/2022 00:05

I did not share. It is private information on a need to know basis, as far as I am concerned and no one else's business.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:57

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:56

@MetellaInHortoEst Yes - his new school had an ASD unit, and the staff were so much better with him. The exclusion was overturned, and his old school had a rap over the knuckles. It was quite a ride for us all, but he's in secondary school now, and becoming much better at self-control.

Very glad to hear it.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:56

Generally children don't want to behave badly though.

I think this depends how you define behaviour. In lots of cultures (mine), parenting is fairly strict, children are expected and taught to be quite obedient, to share readily etc.

Young children are quite inherently selfish, and some parents are quite indulgent and allow behaviour others consider spoilt.

DC has a friend who's parents allow them to:

  • jump/climb on furniture
  • choose to eat mainly snacky junk food & be rude when provided with a normal meal like spaghetti bolognese
  • stay up very late/refuse to go to bed
  • disobey adults instructions without any consequences (eg ignoring a request to take a plate to the dishwasher, turn off a tap they've left running, tidy toys theyve left out).
  • tease/be unkind to younger siblings

Their parents don't consider this child's behaviour unacceptable. In my family it is, and children who behave like that don't often get invited for a second playdate.

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:56

@MetellaInHortoEst Yes - his new school had an ASD unit, and the staff were so much better with him. The exclusion was overturned, and his old school had a rap over the knuckles. It was quite a ride for us all, but he's in secondary school now, and becoming much better at self-control.

hollyivysaurus · 25/11/2022 23:55

My son is in reception and is waiting for an ASD assessment, so I totally get this. I don’t think I’d announce it to the whole class, but I’ve told quite a few parents. I’m glad I have as it’s pretty bloody obvious my son is different in the way he jumps around and speaks with little intonation.

Generally people have been supportive, most people have some understanding and have been inclusive. Some of my daughters class parents have known longer and have been so supportive and kind - difficult days are so much easier when you get sympathetic smiles and messages later checking up on you. Personally I’d much rather people know, my MIL was aghast that I’d told people as she thought he’d be labelled, but honestly kids are labelled anyway, I’d rather parents were aware so they can explain things appropriately to their kids. Also I think most people wondered before I told them, but obviously no one will ask. And quite frankly anyone who wouldn’t want to know us because he’s autistic isn’t worth being friendly with anyway IMO!

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 25/11/2022 23:50

I shared a message on the class whatsapp when my child was struggling in nursery anc a few children had pointed him out as 'naughty' to parents or grandparents in the playground. I introduced us as a family and explained my son was being assessed for autism. Several other parents went on to share similar messages about their children and the reaction was totally positive. Comments from kids stopped immediately and parents and kids noticeably made an effort to include us and be supportive/friendly. We are part of a smallish and very supportive and friendly school though.

Starlightstarbright1 · 25/11/2022 23:48

My ds was diagnosed end of year 7.previously diagnosed with adhd..

I left it to him.. tbh the parents that regularly complained about him i doubt would have understood anyway

It is down to him now who he tells.

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:41

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:39

@MetellaInHortoEst Not really, no. I felt extremely isolated. I suspect they did too. I only found out because we met some time later at an autism workshop

That’s a shame. Is his current setting working out?

MetellaInHortoEst · 25/11/2022 23:40

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:34

I’m observing (not assuming) the worst about you because you said that if you weren’t informed about the medical needs of a child unrelated to you, you were going to insist on viewing them as “brattish”, badly parented and wilfully naughty

Im sorry you have interpreted my words that way. That is not what is intended.

My intention is to note that far more children are NT than ND and therefore to recognise that for many behaviours, its more likely a child is NT and displaying unacceptable behaviours, than ND. My point being that brattish, aggressive, naughty NT children are imho more common within the population, than ND children at particular age brackets.

Behaviour in schools has deteriorated massively in the last 20 years, and thus I'm perhaps reluctant to embrace a model where we simply widen the scope of behaviour we tolerate from everyone (NT or otherwise).

If you really didn’t mean that the way it read then fair enough.

I think if you can wrap your head around the fact that neurodiversity is still stigmatised, that choosing how and when to reveal such information is a child’s choice, and teaching staff cannot - by law - sure such information anyway, then you might be closer to understanding why your preferred way is not necessarily what’s best for ND children.

Imagine your child was HIV+, was gay, was epileptic in a time and place that didn’t fully accept or understand such things. It’s their journey, their diagnosis and their decision. These things can’t be arranged for the convenience of other parents.

Jenn3112 · 25/11/2022 23:39

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 23:34

I’m observing (not assuming) the worst about you because you said that if you weren’t informed about the medical needs of a child unrelated to you, you were going to insist on viewing them as “brattish”, badly parented and wilfully naughty

Im sorry you have interpreted my words that way. That is not what is intended.

My intention is to note that far more children are NT than ND and therefore to recognise that for many behaviours, its more likely a child is NT and displaying unacceptable behaviours, than ND. My point being that brattish, aggressive, naughty NT children are imho more common within the population, than ND children at particular age brackets.

Behaviour in schools has deteriorated massively in the last 20 years, and thus I'm perhaps reluctant to embrace a model where we simply widen the scope of behaviour we tolerate from everyone (NT or otherwise).

Generally children don't want to behave badly though. Does it matter whether they have SEN (and realistically there is a huge amount of undiagnosed SEN in schools) or because they are in care or because their parent is drunk all evening and lets them stay up until 1am with no boundaries? All are about unmet needs. A child doesn't experience great fun and happy feelings from trashing a classroom and getting excluded. If you child is being hurt by another child then that is the school's fault and their responsibility to do something to prevent it happening again.

loafintheoven · 25/11/2022 23:39

@MetellaInHortoEst Not really, no. I felt extremely isolated. I suspect they did too. I only found out because we met some time later at an autism workshop