Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you tell whole school year your child is autistic?

186 replies

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Legallypinkish · 26/11/2022 10:58

With our son it was too obvious not to. It was over 20 years ago and there were only two children in the school diagnosed as autistic. We didn’t make an announcement but all the children knew why our son didn’t speak and why he couldn’t answer them and why he didn’t play with them. The other children were amazing with him. He started an SN school in year 3 and is now an adult in his 20’s but a few of the children from back then still keep in touch with me to ask about how he’s doing. If I had a child at the other end of the spectrum I’d leave it up to them to decide.

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 10:57

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 10:50

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire I’m sorry this has been your experience. I’m unable to hide my disability (I’m a wheelchair user, as well as autistic, dyslexic, left handed and a lesbian. Who grew up in a very Christian community. On one hand I’ve developed a very thick skin, but on the other hand I find the vast majority of people are disinterested in any of this, and those that are are usually pleasant.

@Kanaloa no, I don’t think I have a ‘right’ to know anything. It isn’t about rights… I just think open communication is useful. I don’t care what anyone is but everyone in a classroom has an impact one way or another on everyone else so if there are issues knowledge is useful. Eg, when my son bit another boy in class I apologised to his mum and said he is autistic and still puts Eve in his mouth. She understood and it was over with. When the other autistic kid belted my son his mum explained and it was all good. I’ve twice had other mums come up to me in the playground and asked me about how I accessed speech therapy for my son, not an issue. Also had people ask where my son was diagnosed, who did his dyslexia diagnosis etc etc. wheelchair users frequently ask about each others chairs/equipment randomly in the street… people ask me whether I carried my son or my wife did, how he was conceived and all sorts. It isn’t a big deal.

You said it’s ‘perfectly reasonable’ to want to know about other children’s needs in the classroom. That isn’t reasonable - it’s ridiculous.

I’m glad you don’t feel it’s a big deal, but everyone else is entitled to share or not share their private information as suits them, not as suits all the other nosy parents on the WhatsApp group who want to know. Knowledge won’t be useful - the only knowledge you need is how the teacher is protecting and working with YOUR child. If they’re being repeatedly hit or attacked it doesn’t matter that the other child has x issue. It matters what the teacher will do to support your child.

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 26/11/2022 10:56

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 10:50

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire I’m sorry this has been your experience. I’m unable to hide my disability (I’m a wheelchair user, as well as autistic, dyslexic, left handed and a lesbian. Who grew up in a very Christian community. On one hand I’ve developed a very thick skin, but on the other hand I find the vast majority of people are disinterested in any of this, and those that are are usually pleasant.

@Kanaloa no, I don’t think I have a ‘right’ to know anything. It isn’t about rights… I just think open communication is useful. I don’t care what anyone is but everyone in a classroom has an impact one way or another on everyone else so if there are issues knowledge is useful. Eg, when my son bit another boy in class I apologised to his mum and said he is autistic and still puts Eve in his mouth. She understood and it was over with. When the other autistic kid belted my son his mum explained and it was all good. I’ve twice had other mums come up to me in the playground and asked me about how I accessed speech therapy for my son, not an issue. Also had people ask where my son was diagnosed, who did his dyslexia diagnosis etc etc. wheelchair users frequently ask about each others chairs/equipment randomly in the street… people ask me whether I carried my son or my wife did, how he was conceived and all sorts. It isn’t a big deal.

It's good that it's not a big deal to you, but surely you must understand that your experiences and preferences aren't universal? (And neither are mine, I know, so I wanted to offer another viewpoint.)

zingally · 26/11/2022 10:52

I wouldn't do a blanket announcement, no.

I work in a primary school, and reception was my specialism. Children are very, very aware of children who are "different" or a bit quirky. And in my long experience, I've never once encountered a child with differences being treated poorly by their peers. If anything, they are loved on, and sometimes a bit babied (which we do have to be careful of). They all get taken under the wing of the class, and if anything, become its heart. I've observed this in "leafy middle class village" type schools, and schools in the midst of very, very deprived areas.

I would only disclose it to other parents that your child is particularly friendly with. There's no need to make a song and dance. As long as your child is settled and content, just let the children find their own groove. It doesn't really need any parental involvement.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 10:50

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire I’m sorry this has been your experience. I’m unable to hide my disability (I’m a wheelchair user, as well as autistic, dyslexic, left handed and a lesbian. Who grew up in a very Christian community. On one hand I’ve developed a very thick skin, but on the other hand I find the vast majority of people are disinterested in any of this, and those that are are usually pleasant.

@Kanaloa no, I don’t think I have a ‘right’ to know anything. It isn’t about rights… I just think open communication is useful. I don’t care what anyone is but everyone in a classroom has an impact one way or another on everyone else so if there are issues knowledge is useful. Eg, when my son bit another boy in class I apologised to his mum and said he is autistic and still puts Eve in his mouth. She understood and it was over with. When the other autistic kid belted my son his mum explained and it was all good. I’ve twice had other mums come up to me in the playground and asked me about how I accessed speech therapy for my son, not an issue. Also had people ask where my son was diagnosed, who did his dyslexia diagnosis etc etc. wheelchair users frequently ask about each others chairs/equipment randomly in the street… people ask me whether I carried my son or my wife did, how he was conceived and all sorts. It isn’t a big deal.

MargaretThursday · 26/11/2022 10:29

I would say do it on a need to know basis. You can drop it into ordinary conversation if it's relevant.

My dd has a visible disability and some parents recommend going into the school first and talking to the children and explaining it. It normally takes the lines of "she may only have one hand but can do anything you do."

Personally I don't particularly like that-the children come to the same conclusion on their own generally, so they don't need telling and I haven't seen any evidence to suggest that it makes them more tolerant in general to it. It does also draw attention to it as well. That might sound silly, but I remember one of my dd's friends, after she'd known her for a year which included running round in the paddling pool without a lot of clothes on, suddenly turned to her and said "Oh, where's your hand?" DD said "I never had one" and that was the end of the conversation. I think if she'd been made aware of it before they met, she might well have had far more to say on the matter because she would have thought about it and come up with some whacky ideas (know the child well, 😀)

firefly123 · 26/11/2022 10:24

Absolutely not. It is not your diagnosis to share. Wait until your children are old enough to decide. That is what I did with mine although with my son it was much more obvious and people knew thanks to his primary school having no conception of privacy.. .Now they are older my daughter would be very upset if anyone knew. However my son has happily told everyone on his class at secondary school.

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 10:23

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 09:32

@Dacadactyl for what it’s worth I don’t think you have said anything unreasonable. I don’t know why autism should be private anymore than deafness, wearing glasses, or being left handed. I think it’s perfectly reasonable to want to know what is going on in a classroom your children spend 6 odd hours a day in.

Okay, so you want to know everything about every child in the classroom. So you should go down and ask for a list of all the children in foster care, all those on child in need plans, all those who have been homeless or lived in a refuge, all those who have been a victim of domestic abuse or child sexual abuse etc. These things are nothing to be ashamed of, so anybody who demands the information has a right to examine it at their leisure.

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 26/11/2022 10:23

Sorry for typos.

Obviously other autistic opinions are available, the above is just mine.

jamoncrumpets · 26/11/2022 10:20

Hit send too soon, his SEND isn't a secret. I just refuse to nail it to a billboard.

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 26/11/2022 10:19

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 10:08

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire why astounding?

I disagree strongly with your premise that left handedness is in and way comparable to autism, and that we have an absolute right to know things about other people's children. We are not automatically entitled to this information. My autism didn't bother anyone at school because i was a classic female presentation, but I'd have been utterly bullied and judged if it was common knowledge. It would have served no purpose. Surely it has to be case by case, person by person, friend by friend, parent by parent? We are not one homogeneous mass. But I can assure you, being autistic and the judgement that comes with it, is not simply a quirk. In am ideal world, disclosure would be met with a shrug at worst and an offer of help at best. But it's not an ideal world, is it?

jamoncrumpets · 26/11/2022 10:17

I don't know where some people have got that parents who choose not to disclose are ashamed or embarrassed of their children with SEN.

I can only speak for myself but that's categorically not the case.

I just protect my DC's right to privacy. His SEN isn't

The people that need to know, know.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 10:08

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire why astounding?

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 26/11/2022 09:50

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 09:32

@Dacadactyl for what it’s worth I don’t think you have said anything unreasonable. I don’t know why autism should be private anymore than deafness, wearing glasses, or being left handed. I think it’s perfectly reasonable to want to know what is going on in a classroom your children spend 6 odd hours a day in.

Astounding. Jesus wept.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 09:32

@Dacadactyl for what it’s worth I don’t think you have said anything unreasonable. I don’t know why autism should be private anymore than deafness, wearing glasses, or being left handed. I think it’s perfectly reasonable to want to know what is going on in a classroom your children spend 6 odd hours a day in.

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 08:52

Dacadactyl · 26/11/2022 08:19

I'm bowing out of this thread now. This is not the case, nor my intention.

If you feel I am ignorant about SNs then perhaps it is the case.

My point on this thread is that the school (and the boys family, but to a lesser extent because they are not professionals) have had 7 YEARS to educate us and remove some of that ignorance.

But this will be my last post on the matter.

It is the case. You are being incredibly ignorant - so much so that it appears deliberate. It isn’t other people’s job to share their personal information in the name of ‘educating’ adults. And judging by your responses on this thread you’re not really interested in education from people with experience.

curtaindrawn · 26/11/2022 08:25

One parent sent an email informing the class as her son was being disruptive and lashing out- I think most people knew he was autistic but it probably helped some to understand. What didn't work so well was the child (about 6/7) didn't know he was autistic. So it's likely his classmates knew before him! I didn't reveal his diagnosis to my son as it didn't seem right.

I have told some parents of my sons diagnoses but haven't announced it to everyone. I think it helps with understanding and explains a lot (like why he might not join in initially at parties and might need extra supervision). However my sons know they are autistic - we talk about neurodivergence and how everyone is different frequently, we aren't hiding it as there's no shame there. But we equally don't shout about it because we aren't the sort to shout about things anyway!

I'd make sure your child knows they are autistic before you share this information. It can be in an age appropriate way but they should know asap.

XmasElf10 · 26/11/2022 08:25

My niece has ASD and ADHD and my DD has a couple of friends with similar diagnoses. They are all 11/12 now. In my experience diagnosis was explained when I invited the kids out after school. Th various parents were open about their childrens needs and offered to accompany the play date if needed. I love round the corner from my niece and she is here a lot so I’ve never been put off by my DDs friends additional needs and had no issues. I have supervised by niece at a pony party (my sister wasn’t available) as the host was a bit unsure. I just hung around quietly out the way and stepped in once when my niece got a bit too focussed on a much younger child (she likes to help little kids but sometimes it’s a bit too much).

If I was you I’d not tell the whole year. Some will understand, some won’t and not everyone needs to know. Parents cannot make their kids more understanding and compassionate in my experience. If your son’s behaviours bother some classmates the best you can hope for is that they avoid him. He should eventually find his people and they will enjoy him for who he is and then it’s really helpful to give tips to any parents talking him out but in the meantime I’d say keep his diagnosis off the Wattsapp.

georgarina · 26/11/2022 08:21

A parent at DCs' nursery did this - explained over the group whatsapp - and I think it was really helpful because no one then judged him by NT standards (why is he being badly behaved, etc).

But that was a small group and everyone knew each other. Reception is different. I would definitely talk to DS about it, and maybe ask the teacher how to approach it.

DS has two kids with special needs in his class and he told me their brains work differently so they do different stuff, so I'm assuming the teacher explained to them.

Dacadactyl · 26/11/2022 08:19

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 01:11

I think maybe @Dacadactyl is baiting deliberately.

I'm bowing out of this thread now. This is not the case, nor my intention.

If you feel I am ignorant about SNs then perhaps it is the case.

My point on this thread is that the school (and the boys family, but to a lesser extent because they are not professionals) have had 7 YEARS to educate us and remove some of that ignorance.

But this will be my last post on the matter.

Dacadactyl · 26/11/2022 08:15

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 01:09

Do you think those of us with children struggling at school aren’t ‘not resting until they take it seriously?’ Trying to deal with schools and how they deal with SEN doesn’t involve disclosing your child’s private information to every parent in the school to satisfy their curiosity. And it isn’t on parents to ‘make exceptions.’ It’s on schools to make reasonable adjustments - you as a parent of another child do not have the power to make classroom adjustments for children with autism.

I’ll ask again - do you expect every student’s private information, or just the autistic children? I presume you do require a full up to date list of all fostered or adopted children, so that you can explain their possibly difficult behaviour to your child with ‘in the care of the local authority’ to make it ‘easier’ for you? I suppose every child who has been involved in domestic violence should have it reported to you also? Because these can affect behaviour too, so obviously you have a right to be privy to all that information.

If my child is being hurt by another in the class or his education is being disrupted, then yes I expect the school to inform us that there is a reason and how we can help our children at home to understand what often looks like "bad behaviour" (for want of a better phrase) isn't actually, when it comes from certain kids.

There's a girl in my sons class who is adopted and another lad who was looked after for a few years. Their carers were open about it. The school is a community and something that affects one child, can often affect others. I like to think that the school community can be brought to be more inclusive IF people know about it and how to help.

But you feel free to take offence (where none is intended).

It may well be that you think "dacadactyl just dont get it or understand the stuggles of these children who are adopted, have SNs etc" Fair enough, maybe I don't. But my point is that if the school TRIES to be inclusive and educate and inform parents and pupils etc, then maybe these children wouldn't struggle as much.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 08:03

Out of interest- parents (of primary school age children) who generally don’t tell people unless they absolutely have to, because they feel it is not their information to share; do you ever post pictures of your child to social media?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/11/2022 07:51

jamoncrumpets · 26/11/2022 01:14

'Many ND children don't have such an obvious physical presentation, but can exhibit behaviour that is risky. Knowledge, for those children, could therefore prove to be protective.'

So neurodiverse children who don't 'look disabled' should have their private medical information disclosed to all and sundry so that parents like you can guard your children from them?

That's placing the blame with the child and compromising their right to privacy.

It's up to the adults around them to keep them safe, and if necessary keep other children safe around them. If that's not happening then that doesn't mean mum should share a diagnosis on WhatsApp or whatever. That's not the problem. The problem is they're not being adequately supervised.

Nobody is owed medical information about a child, it is given on a need to know basis. I wouldn't say being a bit worried about little Johnny Stranglehands is reason for a medical disclosure. If he had a fit in the playground and an ambulance turned up I would probably tell the paramedics though.

Parents like me? What - ND ones? Physically disabled ones? Ones with ND spouses, siblings, children of their own? Ones who know how protective it can be to disclose a disability or medical condition in employment so when a new boss comes in and starts having a go about 'fake' issues or 'poor attitude', you can point put that you disclosed it at application? Ones who think 'fuck you, I don't have to be ashamed of anything'? Or, as in this instance, ones who know that there's also advantage in telling others of the nature of an invisible disability?

shruggingitoff · 26/11/2022 05:43

@ChristmasisRuined "You mean your child has ASD. Not is.

My DD has ASD and the condition does not define them!"

I have seen different people use this interchangeably. and it seems to be based on personal preference. Some people say ASD is an integral part of who they are and use 'I am autistic' whereas others (seemingly like yourself) prefer to say 'has ASD'.

It seems to come down to personal preference, and I would never correct someone else on this.

Lightowl · 26/11/2022 04:36

Agree that need to know basis is key. Tbh, most parents will fall into one of three camps:

  1. Know child well enough to have realised anyway
  2. Know child and may be interested but probably on a need to know basis
  3. Don’t and won’t know your child and likely won’t be interested anyway

The proportion of people you’d put into each group will depend on your circumstances, but tbh I would explicitly tell everyone in gp 1, make an effort to tell people in gp 2 but without a big announcement, not tell gp 3 without having told 1 and 2 and / or without an explicit reason to. But your child, your choice. Good luck.