Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you tell whole school year your child is autistic?

186 replies

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

OP posts:
mikado1 · 26/11/2022 15:38

megletthesecond · 26/11/2022 15:30

No.
Need to know basis only.

Some parents will have figured it out already, some would be lovely about it if they are told. But some parents and their children will be horrible.

This view has really surprised me. I can't imagine many, if any, parents, would be like this about it. Perhaps I'm naive but I've only seen understanding for children with SEN.

gogohmm · 26/11/2022 15:37

No, because it's not relevant especially so young - people can be prejudiced

mikado1 · 26/11/2022 15:36

thegreentree · 25/11/2022 20:05

Apologies if I've not quite used the right language around this but... DS attends a mainstream school, he is in reception and has an autism diagnosis.

This is more of a WWYD than an AIBU but DH and I a trying to figure out what would be best for DS...

  • To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

OR

  • To let parents know now so they can hopefully explain to their DC why DS is different? And hopefully act in a more understanding way towards him.

DS is bright but I can see he is struggling socially at school. I'm increasingly starting to feel like it would be good to tell parents (we have an active all year what's app group that I would probably share it on). Just to give everyone some perspective/insight to why DS is a bit different, and to hopefully encourage their kids to be a bit kinder?

I don't know if this is naive. And once disclosed I can't take it back. I would be devastated if DS as he got older hated me for sharing this info about him so widely.

WWYD?

This is the situation with a little boy who's 6 in my dc's class. His mum has told parents incidentally, as and when needed, for example at a drop and go party she let me know and I was very grateful to be aware of his needs. I have since noticed a few comments from my dc about his behaviour and tho I have reminded him we all learn in different ways and he might need a little extra help, I'd prefer to explain properly to my dc but it's not my information to share. So overall, I think it's a good thing that others are aware but.. I think I'd also think your dc himself should know, in an age appropriate way, before others. Not an easy one.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 26/11/2022 15:32

My ds is nt, there's a few boys in his school who I'd infer have asd or are nd from either additional support or comment their parents have made. I don't need to know their diagnosis or anything really. Info I need for play dates is the same as any other child- anything I should know? Whether that be sensitivity to noise, dietery issues or whatever.

However there is one boy who I would consider a bit naughty and I wouldn't be racing to invite him over- from talking to his parents they seem to think his poor behaviour is down to the teacher being over sensitive. but reading this thread I'm wondering if someone had the same behaviour but as a result of asd or adhd or something else would I make more allowances and I think I would. Which I think probably makes me a hypocrite.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:32

Personally some posts to me did seem like they were saying "oh don't tell" ax if it was a shameful secret...I am not going to name posters because I understand context is very different when typed and I know that isn't what people generally mean,

That is a very uncharitable and unempathetic interpretation of what parents have been saying.

I am however not going to apologise for the fact my son should not at all hide the fact he has autism..i

Nor should you. You do whatever works best for your family. But it works both ways.

It’s a choice. It’s complicated. It depends on context and it depends on individual children. So there is no one universal answer.

megletthesecond · 26/11/2022 15:30

No.
Need to know basis only.

Some parents will have figured it out already, some would be lovely about it if they are told. But some parents and their children will be horrible.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:29

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:26

@MetellaInHortoEst I haven't said shout it from the roof top ffs I have shared MY experience with MY child.

You turned up with a very bombastic post repeatedly saying that autism is nothing to be ashamed of. You know the thread is full of autists and parents of autists, if you’ve read it. Where did you see anyone say they were ashamed of it?

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:28

@MetellaInHortoEst I shan't comment any more in regards to you jumping on my own experience without knowing anything about me.

@thegreentree I hope my experience is useful to you. Feel free to pm me.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:27

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:16

@MetellaInHortoEst the child has a diagnosis in the op..,

Yes but he doesn’t seem to know about it or understand it yet (not completely clear which);

To wait until DS is old enough to understand he has ASD, and can choose who he wants to tell?

A child can’t take ownership of something they don’t understand yet. Much less decide how they want the information shared. OFC it’s up to OP whether she wants to do the child-led thing.

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:26

@MetellaInHortoEst I haven't said shout it from the roof top ffs I have shared MY experience with MY child.

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:25

@MetellaInHortoEst I am not at all crass and how dare you say such a thing?!

I am sharing my own experience like the op asked!! You jumped on my comment and patronised me and have no idea of what my actual life is like and the struggles my child faces!!

Personally some posts to me did seem like they were saying "oh don't tell" ax if it was a shameful secret...I am not going to name posters because I understand context is very different when typed and I know that isn't what people generally mean,

I am however not going to apologise for the fact my son should not at all hide the fact he has autism..i

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:24

Just out of interest do you have an autistic child? Because I am living the reality and the ignorance of people assuming my child is neuro-typical and the way he is then subsequently treated is appalling!

Yes I have three. The eldest is in their twenties. They actually had very different preferences and approaches to disclosure as well as different presentations and being diagnosed at different ages. I think being child-led having advised the child of the options carefully works best.

I’d have dug a hole to escape from an undifferentiated banner-waving “autism is nothing to be ashamed of (so shout it from every rooftop)” person like yourself. If you don’t understand that being selective about disclosure isn’t shame, well…

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:20

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:03

@MetellaInHortoEst don't patronise me please..

My child is 6, he had just started year 1 when he got his diagnosis.

Yes children should know that we are all different but they should also know that children and people may present differently because of x,y.z!

It is important to us as a family that people understand my son has an autism diagnosis and what his struggles are and how they can support him!

Why you wouldn't want that I don't know..

Just out of interest do you have an autistic child? Because I am living the reality and the ignorance of people assuming my child is neuro-typical and the way he is then subsequently treated is appalling!

I’m not patronising you. I’m wincing at you bouncing onto thread full of autism-connected parents and artists themselves, to brightly tell us that “autism is nothing to be ashamed of!”

Multiple posters have been at pains to explain why partial disclosures, need to know policy, letting the child take the lead etc were good choices for them or their children and you seem to be crazy dismissing all that caution and consideration as “shame”.

If I couldn’t hear your tambourine type tendencies, i would think you were goading. You sound so crass.

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:20

@Kanaloa but it will help when a child comes home and talks about behaviour/issues...

It is of course up to thr parents but I have shared my personal experience as the mother of an autistic child the similar age to the child in the op and being open has been a positive experience!

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:16

@MetellaInHortoEst the child has a diagnosis in the op..,

Kanaloa · 26/11/2022 15:16

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:03

@MetellaInHortoEst don't patronise me please..

My child is 6, he had just started year 1 when he got his diagnosis.

Yes children should know that we are all different but they should also know that children and people may present differently because of x,y.z!

It is important to us as a family that people understand my son has an autism diagnosis and what his struggles are and how they can support him!

Why you wouldn't want that I don't know..

Just out of interest do you have an autistic child? Because I am living the reality and the ignorance of people assuming my child is neuro-typical and the way he is then subsequently treated is appalling!

I think maybe there’s some crossed wires here. Of course people should know about the diagnosis when they will be supporting your child. The same way it’s important for teaching staff to know about traumatic events, illnesses, difficulties. But every parent in the class will not be supporting your child. Them knowing your child’s business will not get extra support for your child.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 15:15

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:04

Also @MetellaInHortoEst I'm a primary school teacher and SENCO and children in primary school are fully involved in knowing their diagnosis and action plans etc to support them...

I know how it works but you can’t be fully involved in having a diagnosis you haven’t been given yet. Traits are present before dx

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:04

Also @MetellaInHortoEst I'm a primary school teacher and SENCO and children in primary school are fully involved in knowing their diagnosis and action plans etc to support them...

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 15:03

@MetellaInHortoEst don't patronise me please..

My child is 6, he had just started year 1 when he got his diagnosis.

Yes children should know that we are all different but they should also know that children and people may present differently because of x,y.z!

It is important to us as a family that people understand my son has an autism diagnosis and what his struggles are and how they can support him!

Why you wouldn't want that I don't know..

Just out of interest do you have an autistic child? Because I am living the reality and the ignorance of people assuming my child is neuro-typical and the way he is then subsequently treated is appalling!

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 14:56

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 13:12

My son is autistic and we are not ashamed to tell people..I have been very open about his journey and he joined me in thr school I teach in for world autism awareness week to talk about his difficulties and his strengths.

His teacher spoke to the whole class too about my child's autism and how this might affect how he interacts and he understands himself better as a result as do his peers.

Autism is not something to be ashamed of or to hide away!

Nobody is saying it is something to be ashamed of.

The boy in the OP doesn’t even know his own dx yet, though.

It will often be the case in primary that the DC with SN don’t know their dxs, often because they are still under assessment, actually. It isn’t an issue to deal with behaviours without announcing an accompanying dx. DC need to learn that people aren’t all the same.

Anyway, there are lots of things I’m not ashamed of - some I’m positively proud of - that I share selectively.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 26/11/2022 14:28

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 25/11/2022 21:34

Personally, I don’t understand the secrecy? If people know, then they can understand and relate to issues he might have and make reasonable adjustments?
(but maybe I’m the oddity here?)

So you would be happy to share all your private and confidential health information with all and sundry?

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 26/11/2022 14:02

Dacadactyl · 25/11/2022 21:55

@kanaloa you seem to want to take offence to my post.

I am saying the children didnt understand. Putting a name to something helps children understand things more easily. Saying "sometimes people find things hard" doesnt help because thr other kids are thinking "well thats not hard, why cant he behave like us".

The school were allowed to be unsupportive because no one was pushing for a diagnosis. Now hes in year 6 and has struggled socially all the way through school. It wasnt fair and i have no idea what the school and parents were playing at tbh.

The school should have been supporting the child regardless of whether he had a diagnosis or not, support is meant to be based on needs not diagnosis. The school couldn't have mentioned the word Autism to anyone other than the parents they cannot make that diagnosis and they cannot share that diagnosis without express permission.
Not everyone has knowledge and understanding of Autism and there are still plenty of people who believe that Autism doesn't exist. Some people still don't like having kids with SEN in their kids class for various reasons and will complain about it at every opportunity.
Telling the class xxx has Autism will mean absolutely nothing to most younger primary aged kids because most kids have no prior experience of it, but explaining that xxxx cannot cope with something so he does yyyyy instead is an acceptable alternative.

Mammyloveswine · 26/11/2022 13:12

My son is autistic and we are not ashamed to tell people..I have been very open about his journey and he joined me in thr school I teach in for world autism awareness week to talk about his difficulties and his strengths.

His teacher spoke to the whole class too about my child's autism and how this might affect how he interacts and he understands himself better as a result as do his peers.

Autism is not something to be ashamed of or to hide away!

Legallypinkish · 26/11/2022 11:03

zingally · 26/11/2022 10:52

I wouldn't do a blanket announcement, no.

I work in a primary school, and reception was my specialism. Children are very, very aware of children who are "different" or a bit quirky. And in my long experience, I've never once encountered a child with differences being treated poorly by their peers. If anything, they are loved on, and sometimes a bit babied (which we do have to be careful of). They all get taken under the wing of the class, and if anything, become its heart. I've observed this in "leafy middle class village" type schools, and schools in the midst of very, very deprived areas.

I would only disclose it to other parents that your child is particularly friendly with. There's no need to make a song and dance. As long as your child is settled and content, just let the children find their own groove. It doesn't really need any parental involvement.

It made me laugh about some SN children being babies. We had this experience with my son. The girls especially did everything for him even bringing his lunch to him at the table, tidying up his stuff and making sure his clothes were on straight. He had a full time 1:1 who was always trying to explain to them That he needed to do things himself sometimes. I have lovely photos from back them surrounded by kids helping him. Children have always been so lovely with him.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 26/11/2022 11:02

@MarmadukeSpillageEsquire of course. I know my experience is only my experience. I was just answering the op who asked what would people do and I was saying how me/my son deal with it and what works for us in case that was useful to her.

clearly I’m a bit unusual in my opinion.