Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute?

217 replies

PopInn · 25/11/2022 16:50

To DSCs main gifts this year?

Pre teen DSCs, been with DH 6 years, married for 4 and now have joint DC too who is 3 just after Christmas.

We do not share finances, I've never wanted to for a variety of reasons, including DSC. He's always been fine with this so we split bills from a joint account and then have what's left in separate accounts.

In the past I have always contributed toward DSCs presents by way of just going and purchasing some myself, this has become less and less as the years have gone on as their tastes are getting more and more expensive to the point now where their main gifts can be hundreds upon hundreds of pounds. Their parents refuse to share any gifts so I'd say they easily get over £1k each spent on them across the two households.

Basically I just don't want to be involved in this anymore, especially now we have our joint child too who's beginning for the first time to begin to understand Christmas and presents (and therefore is getting a bit more spent on them than previous years although absolutely no where near DSCs amount which I appreciate is down to the age gap).

I have spent £25 each on them so far and I'm not planning on spending anything else now. I don't want to spend hundreds of pounds toward their gifts. Imo they are quite spoilt which is of course up to their parents but I don't want to fund it anymore especially with our child needing accounting for and their birthday so soon after. DH leaves it to the last minute a lot so imagine the requests for contribution won't come until at least a couple of weeks.

AIBU to say if he wants to spend £££ that's up to him but he'll need to find the money himself or split it with their mum now?

OP posts:
PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:25

Plus they then come to expect it

This is a problem we now have. It's a struggle more and more each year to find gifts that the same wow factor / amount of money as the ones from previous years because it's a precedent now. I also think there is a bit of competition between the parents (not solely based on presents but not going into everything here).

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 26/11/2022 07:25

I don't agree with married couples not sharing finances as to me, that is literally the point of marriage. But each to their own and given that you don't share finances, I actually agree that you shouldn't have to contribute to the SDCs presents if you don't want to as long as you do give them something nice.

But YABU to say they are spoilt due to gifts costing upto £1k. Things like iPads, laptops, phones etc can easily cost that and some and these are not unreasonable expectations as gifts for older DCs.

I dislike the general consensus on MN to describe DCs that have had a bit spent on them at Xmas as "spoilt". I always remember reading about Tony Blairs's son who went to the White House to do an internship when he left uni. No one ever said he was spoilt or had too much spent on him. But what an opportunity and all because he had had access to a ££££ education and a PM as a dad. But when a kid who lives in a council flat with zero opportunity in life gets an iPad and an expensive bike, people sneer and say he's spoilt. I bet Elton John's and David Beckham's kids get more then a grand spent on them!

TidyDancer · 26/11/2022 07:18

I think you're entirely in the right OP, aside from making it clear now. Don't wait until just before Christmas. I think it's fairer to give your DH the heads up now to say that's what happening this year because of XYZ reasons.

It's clear people have strong opinions because of their own situations but don't be persuaded that you're doing the wrong thing or being mean to your DSCs (because you're not). Every family is different and you need to find a balance that works for you.

Daydreamreve · 26/11/2022 07:09

YANBU

im not sure why children need so much spent on them. Plus they then come to expect it.

the parents need to communicate as well

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:08

How are are his children?

11yo (12 soon) and 13yo

OP posts:
DrMarciaFieldstone · 26/11/2022 07:07

Yanbu.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:04

Newmum0322 · 25/11/2022 18:05

reversed.

“My mum and Dad are divorced, they don’t tend to agree on much but I’m fortunate to have a good relationship with my Dad and his wife, my step mum. They’ve been together for a while now so we see her regularly and I thought we had a good relationship, but since my Step sibling (now 3yo) arrived she seems to be less interested/engaged, I actually think she maybe doesn’t like us very much, maybe thinks we’re a bit spoilt as our parents try to buy our affection…

Anyway, this Christmas she stopped even pretending to make an effort. Our gifts, which are usually signed from both of them, were specifically just from my Dad this year. I feel like we’re being edged out, like we’re not welcome almost. Am I being unreasonable to think she just doesn’t like us anymore, or maybe never did?”

Im not saying that you necessarily feel hostile towards them, but at the very least you have to be mindful that a change in your behaviour towards them will be noticed and it will be felt. If you’re ok with that then go for it, but it would suggest you maybe don’t really care for them as some posters have suggested

This situation is solely about Christmas presents. You've made up that I'm less engaged and interested. We never sign presents anyway so I doubt they'd even know. For example they won't know that I specifically have bought the £25 each gifts. They'll just go in the "from us" pile. It's been that way every year.

OP posts:
PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:02

Why is it daft to have 2 xboxes say , one at each house

And I've already said I understand some things like games consoles. But no I doubt get why they need two laptops say, or two tablets and so on.

OP posts:
PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:01

VladmirsPoutine · 25/11/2022 20:21

What did you think would be the outcome of blending families Confused?

Not sure what you mean?

OP posts:
PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:00

Whether 1k is reasonable or not is neither here nor there really. It wasn't my question.

My question was whether id be reasonable to stop contributing hundreds of my own money towards it.

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 26/11/2022 00:45

Why is it daft to have 2 xboxes say , one at each house.
Moving them About is a bit of a pain and risks them being broke and if only at dads at weekends they only can use it at weekends
£1000 is a lot but does yOur dh and his ex buy them stuff all year
Some people buy laptoos dor school, new mobile and clothes whenever needed others save and give all at xmas
As long as no one is getting into debt with presents then people can spend whatever
I think you may be shocked how much you spend on your dc as they get older

VladmirsPoutine · 25/11/2022 20:21

What did you think would be the outcome of blending families Confused?

NaturalBae · 25/11/2022 20:02

I’m with you OP in regard to not wanting to spend excessive amounts on Christmas gifts.

You should not have agreed to do joint expensive Christmas gifts in the first place. This is the responsibility of their Mum and Dad. They should be communicating and not wasting ridiculous amounts of money buying duplicate expensive gifts.

You should continue to buy your DSC a Christmas gift, but have a normal budget. The same for Birthdays. I don’t get the screwed logic of spending stupid money on gifts just because it’s Christmas. Our kids get decent gifts from us as we’re their parents. Everyone else gets token gifts, minus my Mum, Step Father and Sister who we spend a bit more on. My partner and I have big families. We often buy token Christmas gifts for each other, just so the kids can see us open something from each other. And then we’ll go shopping in the January sales for bargains if we want anything else.

Duplicate expensive tech between households is just crazy and so wasteful. As another pp stated, laptops are portable.

Parents that spend silly money on their DC at Christmas are spoiling their kids. Our DC get one decent Christmas gift each from their Christmas Gift List and then a few cheaper stocking filler type gifts so they grow up to understand the value of money. They also receive several additional gifts from extended family members so receive more than enough. We can afford to spend more on our DC, but we do that throughout the year.

Money or Christmas does not buy you love.

Most people will feel shit when they look at their bank accounts after Christmas and wonder ‘What was it all about!?’

aSofaNearYou · 25/11/2022 20:01

Livelovebehappy · 25/11/2022 18:53

Don’t contribute if you don’t want to. Your choice. But don’t use the reason that after all this time you’ve suddenly come to the conclusion that they’re spoilt and get too much. It’s very clearly down to the fact that you now have your own dc and want to direct your money there instead. IME when step mother has her own child, it changes the whole dynamic of being a step parent, often to the detriment of DSC.

Yeah, noticing that you're spending a fraction of the amount on your own children that you are on someone else's will effectively bring home any festering feelings that too much is being spent on them. It does put things in a new and clearer perspective.

You often hear it said on here that SM's MUST have just suddenly flipped and changed their opinion on SC related issues because they've had their own child. It's rubbish tbh. I experienced no such flip about my DSC when my DC was born, the less positive thoughts I had (such as OPs feeling that they are spoilt at Christmas) were already there - it's perfectly normal for feelings to strengthen over time or for people to run out of patience with something that has always annoyed them after a certain point. It's not always a sudden switch at all or triggered purely by having your own child, as is evidenced by the fact that OP had her DC years ago and has only just become fed up enough with this to make a stand.

Flamingogirl08 · 25/11/2022 19:37

As a step parent myself who treats my step child just the same as I treat my biological child I think YABU

Flamingogirl08 · 25/11/2022 19:32

Testina · 25/11/2022 17:18

I’m going to be in the minority voting yes to unreasonable… my rationale for that is that it was all fine with you until you had your own child. As a stepparent myself, and married to someone who is a stepparent to my child, I think that’s a bit shit of you.

  • not wanting to contribute to stepchildren: YANBU
  • contributing to them only until you have your own child and ditching them: YABU

This

Stillbrokenby2022 · 25/11/2022 19:25

It depends - my children go from school to their Dad’s I wouldn’t want them taking a load of tech to school with them. My OH gives money towards their presents but I don’t rely on it, it’s completely up to him.

Notanotherone6 · 25/11/2022 19:18

Poor kids, having to deal with such pettiness between the adults in their lives.

Autumnalleavestime · 25/11/2022 19:04

You see this quite often with step parents, act all parenty, then when they get the ring and the baby give it, yeah those kids can do one. I think yo8 shouldn’t pay. But I think you should have been honest earlier that you resent it.

mam0918 · 25/11/2022 19:00

Also £25 gift is plenty from a step parent, most years I got nothing from my stepmam and Im in no way upset about it, in fact it never crossed my mind that I was suppose to get something from her (and the year I did it was awkward and age inappropriate).

mam0918 · 25/11/2022 18:55

Testina · 25/11/2022 17:24

My child has an iPad in each house 🤷🏻‍♀️
It’s not “crazy” or “insane”, thank you.

It’s because we both want her to be able to move freely between homes without having to think about where things are, and without having to be packing or carrying anything.
It’s not her fault we’re divorced, and that’s one of the things we can do for it not to impact her. We’re fortunate that we can both afford this.

Its pretty insane... Ipads by their very nature are designed to be portible, its not a bloody desk top PC.

When me and DH lived seperately and the kids went between houses they took their tablet with them with ZERO issues because thats litrally what they are designed for.

Livelovebehappy · 25/11/2022 18:53

Don’t contribute if you don’t want to. Your choice. But don’t use the reason that after all this time you’ve suddenly come to the conclusion that they’re spoilt and get too much. It’s very clearly down to the fact that you now have your own dc and want to direct your money there instead. IME when step mother has her own child, it changes the whole dynamic of being a step parent, often to the detriment of DSC.

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/11/2022 18:28

YANBU. Tell him tonight and if he’s reasonable he’ll say of course he gets it.

When a couple who are still together add a third child budgets often need to be reviewed, that’s normal anyway. And this year of all years a lot of families are cutting luxury spending to the bone. All of ours, my steps and my DC are getting less than last year. We’ll put the heating on all day as a treat and they’ll be grateful for what they get.

aSofaNearYou · 25/11/2022 18:13

Testina · 25/11/2022 17:21

You sound quite judgemental when you say their parents “refuse” to share gifts. Like they’re just being awkward. I think it’s by far the norm that divorced parents do not do joint presents.

I think a majority of parents would share things so they only have one laptop or phone.

Newmum0322 · 25/11/2022 18:05

reversed.

“My mum and Dad are divorced, they don’t tend to agree on much but I’m fortunate to have a good relationship with my Dad and his wife, my step mum. They’ve been together for a while now so we see her regularly and I thought we had a good relationship, but since my Step sibling (now 3yo) arrived she seems to be less interested/engaged, I actually think she maybe doesn’t like us very much, maybe thinks we’re a bit spoilt as our parents try to buy our affection…

Anyway, this Christmas she stopped even pretending to make an effort. Our gifts, which are usually signed from both of them, were specifically just from my Dad this year. I feel like we’re being edged out, like we’re not welcome almost. Am I being unreasonable to think she just doesn’t like us anymore, or maybe never did?”

Im not saying that you necessarily feel hostile towards them, but at the very least you have to be mindful that a change in your behaviour towards them will be noticed and it will be felt. If you’re ok with that then go for it, but it would suggest you maybe don’t really care for them as some posters have suggested