Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute?

217 replies

PopInn · 25/11/2022 16:50

To DSCs main gifts this year?

Pre teen DSCs, been with DH 6 years, married for 4 and now have joint DC too who is 3 just after Christmas.

We do not share finances, I've never wanted to for a variety of reasons, including DSC. He's always been fine with this so we split bills from a joint account and then have what's left in separate accounts.

In the past I have always contributed toward DSCs presents by way of just going and purchasing some myself, this has become less and less as the years have gone on as their tastes are getting more and more expensive to the point now where their main gifts can be hundreds upon hundreds of pounds. Their parents refuse to share any gifts so I'd say they easily get over £1k each spent on them across the two households.

Basically I just don't want to be involved in this anymore, especially now we have our joint child too who's beginning for the first time to begin to understand Christmas and presents (and therefore is getting a bit more spent on them than previous years although absolutely no where near DSCs amount which I appreciate is down to the age gap).

I have spent £25 each on them so far and I'm not planning on spending anything else now. I don't want to spend hundreds of pounds toward their gifts. Imo they are quite spoilt which is of course up to their parents but I don't want to fund it anymore especially with our child needing accounting for and their birthday so soon after. DH leaves it to the last minute a lot so imagine the requests for contribution won't come until at least a couple of weeks.

AIBU to say if he wants to spend £££ that's up to him but he'll need to find the money himself or split it with their mum now?

OP posts:
ExhaustedFlamingo · 26/11/2022 08:07

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:31

As I say, if their parents want to spend that sort of money on them they can. I just don't want to be involved in paying for it.

Personally I think my DSC are spoilt in that they appear to get whatever they want regardless as to whether their parents can really afford it or afford it easily. My own husband would agree they are a bit spoilt. My own son can be spoilt sometimes. Personally I don't say spoilt as some momentous insult.

I think the issue is describing your SC as "spoilt". It's a very emotive word, and whether you want to admit to it or not, it has strongly negative connotations.

The dictionary definition of spoilt is "harming the character of someone by being too indulgent".

It's an unpleasant description. Some parents like to treat their DC, and I think in the cases of divorce the reasons for this are complex and manifold. It's perfectly possible to provide your child with lots of material items without them becoming "spoilt".

And the use of that word is why it's coming across to some that you're not too keen on you SC, and are disinterested esp now you have a child of your own.

My DP is stepdad to my DC and I'd be really hurt if he said he didn't want to contribute. I know you've wavered slightly on this now, but just overall, I would find your attitude to buying them presents a bit cold. A new iPad or games console can be £300-£400+ - one each of those from each parent and that's a good chunk of the spend gone! Teenagers ARE expensive, even without parents who are trying to outdo each other. I used to love buying my DC gifts when they were young, buying toys for little ones is so much more fun! And by comparison, so much cheaper too!!

I'm not trying to pile on, honestly. I just think that you can and should be part of the overall spending on your SC, and it's something you should talk and agree with DH. I don't actually think the SC and your DC need the same spending on them because there's such a massive age difference and your DC can enjoy lots of toys for a fraction of the price of a single iPad! When your child is a bit older, the spending on SC will reduce I'd imagine when they're 17, 18 etc? And then your DC will have the financial benefit of more money available to spend on them, whether that's savings you set aside, more presents or just a more expensive lifestyle. So I think in the long term it would even out financially.

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:07

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:03

If you previously spent hundreds and now are only spending £50 then yeah, I think you are unreasonable.

You're expecting to fill the gap where you used to contribute plus also pay half towards a joint child, while you pay loads less than you used to for the SC and only half towards your own child. It feels like you want him to be financially much worse off than you. I know you don't share finances but that still feels wrong to me.

He should be "worse off" though if he's spending that much on gifts OP gets no say in. Why should she subsidise this. He's taken the mick for long enough, he should have insisted OP had already been generous enough. This is OP's money and she might want to save it for her own child or her own care home fees.

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:05

Sparkletastic · 25/11/2022 17:39

Jeez those parents need to sort themselves out and start communicating.

Yes.

They need to understand that if they pool their money and both pay for one tablet then they are spending half the amount and the child gets a nice joint present from their parents with the added bonus both parents have more money to spend on them generally

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:03

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:02

Why is it daft to have 2 xboxes say , one at each house

And I've already said I understand some things like games consoles. But no I doubt get why they need two laptops say, or two tablets and so on.

They don't. It's presumably because the parents aren't able to amicably decide that the tablet can go between houses.

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:03

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:00

Whether 1k is reasonable or not is neither here nor there really. It wasn't my question.

My question was whether id be reasonable to stop contributing hundreds of my own money towards it.

If you previously spent hundreds and now are only spending £50 then yeah, I think you are unreasonable.

You're expecting to fill the gap where you used to contribute plus also pay half towards a joint child, while you pay loads less than you used to for the SC and only half towards your own child. It feels like you want him to be financially much worse off than you. I know you don't share finances but that still feels wrong to me.

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:01

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:55

This is what I did every year but also gave him money towards their main expensive gifts. This year I've still bought them something from my spending money, I just don't want to pay anymore towards their main presents.

Absolutely fair enough. Who is questioning it? Yourself? Then stop. Your DH? Then he's a right CF.

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 07:59

*I would set an equal budget that you can afford for each child, say £200 for arguments sake (obviously it could me more or less depending on what you're both comfortable with). You could both contribute 50/50 into the pot and anything extra that your DH wants to spend (on any of the children) is down to him to fund. If you don't need the full £200 on toys for your little one, agree to spend the remaining money on a family day out or put it directly into savings account.

That way the DSC don't feel like your prioritising your joint DC over them but you have clear boundaries/budgets of what your willing to contribute.*

But if she knows he is going to spend a load of money above her contribution on things she doesn't approve of then she is just spending money for the sake of it.

Plus, when a couple with SC doesn't have shared finances it's perfectly normal for the SP to "prioritise their joint DC". If she's not getting any say on how much is being spent on the SC and how they are being brought up as a result, then she is not an equal parent to them and does not need to keep up a pretence that she is when it comes to finances.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:55

chikp · 26/11/2022 07:53

I buy my DSC something out of my "spending" money and DH is free to buy whatever he wants for them out of his "spending" money

This is what I did every year but also gave him money towards their main expensive gifts. This year I've still bought them something from my spending money, I just don't want to pay anymore towards their main presents.

OP posts:
MeanMrMustardSeed · 26/11/2022 07:54

I agree with you, OP. And you are not U to not enter into the madness of the competitively spending parents.

Believeinyou · 26/11/2022 07:54

hardly a hardship to take your ipad between. houses. I have teens who take theirs to grandparents, friends, on holiday etc all the time with 0 issues so some posters being abit ridiculous

yes i agree it's spoilt and really bad from an environmental perspective

i think none of your business if they wanna do that though but is your right to say no not funding it

chikp · 26/11/2022 07:53

I buy my DSC something out of my "spending" money and DH is free to buy whatever he wants for them out of his "spending" money

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:51

B1993 · 26/11/2022 07:50

You presumably don't have the DSC every weekend? You could organise something just for the 3 of you so it is going directly to joint DC.

Sorry I assumed you meant for everyone, including DSC, when you said family day out.

OP posts:
B1993 · 26/11/2022 07:50

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:48

agree to spend the remaining money on a family day out

Is that not just also spending it on DSC though? I'd rather put it in savings in that situation that way it's actually going to our DC.

You presumably don't have the DSC every weekend? You could organise something just for the 3 of you so it is going directly to joint DC.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:48

agree to spend the remaining money on a family day out

Is that not just also spending it on DSC though? I'd rather put it in savings in that situation that way it's actually going to our DC.

OP posts:
B1993 · 26/11/2022 07:47

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:40

Honestly I doubt we'd be able to afford to spend the same on our joint DC as he spends on DSC. Our child is 3 they don't need £500+ spending on them whether that goes in savings or not that just seems crazy.

The only way we could spend equally right now on all 3 kids is to reduce what DSC get which I doubt he'd agree to.

Maybe I didn't explain my thoughts as clearly as I should!

I would set an equal budget that you can afford for each child, say £200 for arguments sake (obviously it could me more or less depending on what you're both comfortable with). You could both contribute 50/50 into the pot and anything extra that your DH wants to spend (on any of the children) is down to him to fund. If you don't need the full £200 on toys for your little one, agree to spend the remaining money on a family day out or put it directly into savings account.

That way the DSC don't feel like your prioritising your joint DC over them but you have clear boundaries/budgets of what your willing to contribute.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:42

Tandora · 26/11/2022 07:35

Hmm Yeh but you did call them spoiled in the OP, and made digs at your DH and ex for their approach so it did kind of sound like that was part of your reasoning/ justification

Because I think they are spoiled. I didn't ask if I was unreasonable for thinking they are spoiled.

OP posts:
SafariRushHour · 26/11/2022 07:41

I agree with you op and think it’s better for a child to have different items in different houses. Helps mix things up a little

Best tell DH that you’ve put x amount in towards gifts and you’re not planning to put any more in and will leave the coordination to him. You’re tightening your belt.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:40

B1993 · 26/11/2022 07:37

I agree that you shouldn't be treating DSC differently to your child.

I think you need to hash something out with DH. Maybe agree on a budget and split it equally between the all of your children. Then, anything in addition to that, he spends himself. I know your joint DC might not need as much as they're a lot younger, so any additional funds can go towards a family day out or into a savings account.

I personally feel like this is an acceptable compromise 🤷🏻‍♀️

Honestly I doubt we'd be able to afford to spend the same on our joint DC as he spends on DSC. Our child is 3 they don't need £500+ spending on them whether that goes in savings or not that just seems crazy.

The only way we could spend equally right now on all 3 kids is to reduce what DSC get which I doubt he'd agree to.

OP posts:
B1993 · 26/11/2022 07:37

PopInn · 25/11/2022 17:21

It's not solely this. As I said in my OP, as the years have gone on and their tastes are getting more expensive, the amount being spent seems crazy to me and I no longer want to be a part of it. That's in addition to the fact that yes I also have my own child to consider now too.

I agree that you shouldn't be treating DSC differently to your child.

I think you need to hash something out with DH. Maybe agree on a budget and split it equally between the all of your children. Then, anything in addition to that, he spends himself. I know your joint DC might not need as much as they're a lot younger, so any additional funds can go towards a family day out or into a savings account.

I personally feel like this is an acceptable compromise 🤷🏻‍♀️

notdaddycool · 26/11/2022 07:36

Nice to get them something, not necessary to spend anything like that much. YANBU

Tandora · 26/11/2022 07:35

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:00

Whether 1k is reasonable or not is neither here nor there really. It wasn't my question.

My question was whether id be reasonable to stop contributing hundreds of my own money towards it.

Hmm Yeh but you did call them spoiled in the OP, and made digs at your DH and ex for their approach so it did kind of sound like that was part of your reasoning/ justification

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:35

I'm not going to go into every example here either but it's not just solely this situation that makes me say that. There is definitely underlying feelings of competition between their mum and dad about never saying no or being the bad one or wanting to get the best gift and so on. Perhaps that isn't uncommon in separated parents, I can definitely understand why it may happen. But yes I do think it can end up leading to spoiling kids.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 07:33

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:25

Plus they then come to expect it

This is a problem we now have. It's a struggle more and more each year to find gifts that the same wow factor / amount of money as the ones from previous years because it's a precedent now. I also think there is a bit of competition between the parents (not solely based on presents but not going into everything here).

When I was a teenager I received a laptop one Christmas, an iPod another, and I think a mobile phone might have been a Christmas present at one point. But these did not set a precedent, they were one off expensive purchases and next year, when I already had that thing, it was back to DVDs and a new hat and scarf. It's absolutely absurd to think if you buy a kid important tech one year, they need similar spent on them every year.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:31

THisbackwithavengeance · 26/11/2022 07:25

I don't agree with married couples not sharing finances as to me, that is literally the point of marriage. But each to their own and given that you don't share finances, I actually agree that you shouldn't have to contribute to the SDCs presents if you don't want to as long as you do give them something nice.

But YABU to say they are spoilt due to gifts costing upto £1k. Things like iPads, laptops, phones etc can easily cost that and some and these are not unreasonable expectations as gifts for older DCs.

I dislike the general consensus on MN to describe DCs that have had a bit spent on them at Xmas as "spoilt". I always remember reading about Tony Blairs's son who went to the White House to do an internship when he left uni. No one ever said he was spoilt or had too much spent on him. But what an opportunity and all because he had had access to a ££££ education and a PM as a dad. But when a kid who lives in a council flat with zero opportunity in life gets an iPad and an expensive bike, people sneer and say he's spoilt. I bet Elton John's and David Beckham's kids get more then a grand spent on them!

As I say, if their parents want to spend that sort of money on them they can. I just don't want to be involved in paying for it.

Personally I think my DSC are spoilt in that they appear to get whatever they want regardless as to whether their parents can really afford it or afford it easily. My own husband would agree they are a bit spoilt. My own son can be spoilt sometimes. Personally I don't say spoilt as some momentous insult.

OP posts:
MilkyYay · 26/11/2022 07:28

It is absurd to spend this much on children, ever!

They are children. They do not need a gaming pc. If they want one as a teenager, that's a good incentive to go get a job to earn the money to buy one. Same for expensive phones.

I genuinely believe that this is why we have entitled young people coming through. They haven't learned that some things you don't get until you work & earn them for yourself, even if you want them. They just get bought whatever they want.

An ipad at each house is a colossal waste.