Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute?

217 replies

PopInn · 25/11/2022 16:50

To DSCs main gifts this year?

Pre teen DSCs, been with DH 6 years, married for 4 and now have joint DC too who is 3 just after Christmas.

We do not share finances, I've never wanted to for a variety of reasons, including DSC. He's always been fine with this so we split bills from a joint account and then have what's left in separate accounts.

In the past I have always contributed toward DSCs presents by way of just going and purchasing some myself, this has become less and less as the years have gone on as their tastes are getting more and more expensive to the point now where their main gifts can be hundreds upon hundreds of pounds. Their parents refuse to share any gifts so I'd say they easily get over £1k each spent on them across the two households.

Basically I just don't want to be involved in this anymore, especially now we have our joint child too who's beginning for the first time to begin to understand Christmas and presents (and therefore is getting a bit more spent on them than previous years although absolutely no where near DSCs amount which I appreciate is down to the age gap).

I have spent £25 each on them so far and I'm not planning on spending anything else now. I don't want to spend hundreds of pounds toward their gifts. Imo they are quite spoilt which is of course up to their parents but I don't want to fund it anymore especially with our child needing accounting for and their birthday so soon after. DH leaves it to the last minute a lot so imagine the requests for contribution won't come until at least a couple of weeks.

AIBU to say if he wants to spend £££ that's up to him but he'll need to find the money himself or split it with their mum now?

OP posts:
Whiskyvodka · 26/11/2022 08:46

Pp's saying you should treat sdc equally as a sm.
How many men contribute equally to their sc?
Most men don't even treat their own dc with new wife equal to their first dc.

It's always the women who have to give all the time.
OP your dc is also your dh's dc and do not let him skip out of contributing properly to his 3rd dc.
His dc by his ex are not yours so you're not under any obligation although a contribution would be the right thing with sdc you are presumably close to.
I think the sc are old enough to tell their dp's what they would like for Christmas to avoid duplication.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:46

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:43

@PopInn

So for example, our 3yos presents come to roughly £100 I'd say. £50 from me, £50 from DH.

I've also then contributed £50 toward DSC too so that's equal is it not?

Then as you say, DH is free to spend whatever extra on top he wants to and I am free to do the same for our DC?

Sorry, I missed this before and assume it was a question for me?

If you're agreed a budget of £100 per child and contribute half each, I think it's fair 🤷🏻‍♀️ I'd make it clear to DH that I think the amount he's gifting is excessive, so if he wants to go beyond the budget for any of his children, he can do so out of his own pocket. Just like you can, if you see something extra for any of the kids.

Yes it was thanks for responsding Smile

I guess I just think if we then get to go on and spend whatever additional on whichever DC we want then that's not exactly equal either at which point I can't see much difference to what I'm suggesting I guess.

OP posts:
B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow! You're right, this sight can be crazy.... some people on here can be downright awful. Name calling and abuse is not ok. Can you not be an adult and just agree to disagree without personally attacking?

harriethoyle · 26/11/2022 08:44

rainbowstardrops · 26/11/2022 08:22

I don't think you are being unreasonable but I do think you need to discuss this now and not leave it until you're closer to Christmas.

I think you both need to determine your budget and then split that three ways. Surely that's the only fair way?

Why should op pay the same for her stepkids as her own child? I agree DH should be contributing equally to his children but absolutely no reason for OP to

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:43

@PopInn

So for example, our 3yos presents come to roughly £100 I'd say. £50 from me, £50 from DH.

I've also then contributed £50 toward DSC too so that's equal is it not?

Then as you say, DH is free to spend whatever extra on top he wants to and I am free to do the same for our DC?

Sorry, I missed this before and assume it was a question for me?

If you're agreed a budget of £100 per child and contribute half each, I think it's fair 🤷🏻‍♀️ I'd make it clear to DH that I think the amount he's gifting is excessive, so if he wants to go beyond the budget for any of his children, he can do so out of his own pocket. Just like you can, if you see something extra for any of the kids.

HandbagsnGladrags · 26/11/2022 08:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:42

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:33

That isn't how a lot of "blended" families work

I guess it’s all about context and no two families are the same. I definitely used to have the idealistic view that if you marry someone with children, you treat them as your own, but mumsnet has really opened my eyes on this point.
personally I think however people want to organise blending is fine, but what disgusts me so much, on step parenting threads on this forum, is the way that children’s experiences, needs, feelings get cast aside in the name of step parents standing firm on their “boundaries”. I think if you marry someone with children, you commit to recognising that their (the children’s) welfare comes first- Whether that involves taking a parental role or not . All children deserve that. If you are not prepared to take that stance, you shouldn’t involve yourself in a family with children.

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 08:41

@ExhaustedFlamingo OP has said many times that they have high expectations of gifts without having any appreciation of whether their parents can afford it. It is not unreasonable to think that that constitutes being spoilt, even if it is down to never being educated on the value of money.

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:38

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:34

I appreciate this may be the ideal but I think it only works if the parents do actually value you equally as a parent to their DC which I imagine a lot won't.

I don't think it's Ideal. The dsc have no need for me to be a third parent. They will be overparented if I tried. They need their own parents who are both equal and step up to all their parenting needs.

NoSquirrels · 26/11/2022 08:36

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:18

So for example, our 3yos presents come to roughly £100 I'd say. £50 from me, £50 from DH.

I've also then contributed £50 toward DSC too so that's equal is it not?

Then as you say, DH is free to spend whatever extra on top he wants to and I am free to do the same for our DC?

This is perfectly sensible and totally fair.

The only (potential) issue is that if your DH has an expectation that you’ll actually contribute more like hundreds per DSC rather than £50 per child, then it is slightly late to have reset the goalposts, but better to discuss it now anyway. Things change, budgets get squeezed and the older your joint child gets the more it will matter to have a fair system.

HandbagsnGladrags · 26/11/2022 08:35

Testina · 25/11/2022 17:26

And you don’t think it’s “a bit daft” for a child who has to split their lives between two homes, through no fault of their own, to have to plan and pack and carry and sometimes be inconvenienced without their computer - all for the sake of the cost of a second which the parents are happy to afford?

My stepson brings his laptop between homes. He's not traumatised by it.

OP you're being completely reasonable. Step parent hating coming out loud and clear on this thread.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 26/11/2022 08:34

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 08:16

*I think the issue is describing your SC as "spoilt". It's a very emotive word, and whether you want to admit to it or not, it has strongly negative connotations.

The dictionary definition of spoilt is "harming the character of someone by being too indulgent".

It's an unpleasant description. Some parents like to treat their DC, and I think in the cases of divorce the reasons for this are complex and manifold. It's perfectly possible to provide your child with lots of material items without them becoming "spoilt".*

But OP knows these children, and she feels that it IS having a negative affect on them. Why is that so hard for some people to stomach? Honestly this thread is maddening.

She's never described any negative effect on the SC, only that she disagrees with the level of spend and the fact that DH and the ex aren't willing to share. Nowhere has she said that the SC are bratty, ungrateful or grabby. OP hasn't been negative at all about the SC and has actually hinted that they get on well with no issues.

OP also said in the post that I replied to - where you took this comment from - that she doesn't view the word spoilt as being particularly negative - hence my response explaining why so many had viewed it as negative. Quoting half the post without showing the history of what I was replying to really doesn't reflect the full context. Maddening indeed.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:34

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:32

@cookiesbeforepookies, I just don't get the 'they aren't her kids' thing. If she didn't want to take on responsibility of them as a parent, they wouldn't have married. Fair enough, they are a blended family, but I do see her equally as part of the coparent relationship. I think she should be valued as an equal parent, and her value them as equal to her own children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Again, just my opinion.

I appreciate this may be the ideal but I think it only works if the parents do actually value you equally as a parent to their DC which I imagine a lot won't.

OP posts:
chikp · 26/11/2022 08:33

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:32

@cookiesbeforepookies, I just don't get the 'they aren't her kids' thing. If she didn't want to take on responsibility of them as a parent, they wouldn't have married. Fair enough, they are a blended family, but I do see her equally as part of the coparent relationship. I think she should be valued as an equal parent, and her value them as equal to her own children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Again, just my opinion.

That isn't how a lot of "blended" families work

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:32

@cookiesbeforepookies, I just don't get the 'they aren't her kids' thing. If she didn't want to take on responsibility of them as a parent, they wouldn't have married. Fair enough, they are a blended family, but I do see her equally as part of the coparent relationship. I think she should be valued as an equal parent, and her value them as equal to her own children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Again, just my opinion.

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:32

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 08:22

@girlmom21 I can sort of see your point about pay day and forewarning but I guess it depends on the financial position of the person in question, if she knows he can't afford to buy their presents without her contribution at this point then it would have been best to tell him earlier, but that's not a given, he might be able to afford it.

It still doesn't detract from the fact it should be perfectly acceptable for her to not spend this much on them.

I do agree she shouldn't be spending hundred of pounds of her own money on someone else's children

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:31

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:28

@aSofaNearYou

I've got MUCH better things to do that explain myself to you, a complete stranger... 🙄🙈🤣

However, OP said that they spilt all joint bills. When they got married, those kids became hers and I see that as a joint expenditure. Therefore, in my eyes, a compromise would be to agree a budget (I've already told OP that this should be amount to she s comfortable with too) and contribute equally.

They absolutely did not "become hers".

If I tried to treat my DSC as if they were my children I'd rightfully get an earful from everyone. It's only when it boils down to the money that step parents are expected to treat the kids like they are their own. If I rocked up to parents evening I'd be rightfully asked what the fuck I was doing by the ex.

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 08:30

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:28

@aSofaNearYou

I've got MUCH better things to do that explain myself to you, a complete stranger... 🙄🙈🤣

However, OP said that they spilt all joint bills. When they got married, those kids became hers and I see that as a joint expenditure. Therefore, in my eyes, a compromise would be to agree a budget (I've already told OP that this should be amount to she s comfortable with too) and contribute equally.

So if those kids became hers, if is fair enough for her to put her foot down about how much is being spent on them and say she feels in her parental wisdom that it is making them spoilt and they need to cut down, right?

cookiesbeforepookies · 26/11/2022 08:30

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:29

I'm honestly not tearing you apart, I apologise if I've come across that way!

Genuinely though, if in your example, DH (and I, I assume) can then go on to spend whatever we want on our DC in addition to whatever we've budgeted and split 3 ways, how is that much different? Surely that still equals unequal spending?

You’ve nothing to apologise for. The people who expect step-mums to fund their step-kids are always weirdly sensitive.

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:30

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:20

He likely will. We've always done it like this. As I said, I'll just put the £25 gifts I've already bought in the "us" pile. They won't even know those were bought by me and not their dad.

Then no problem whatsoever

chikp · 26/11/2022 08:29

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:18

So for example, our 3yos presents come to roughly £100 I'd say. £50 from me, £50 from DH.

I've also then contributed £50 toward DSC too so that's equal is it not?

Then as you say, DH is free to spend whatever extra on top he wants to and I am free to do the same for our DC?

Yes you should be. Go on a spree and spend £1000 on your DC.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:29

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:25

@rainbowstardrops:
I think you both need to determine your budget and then split that three ways. Surely that's the only fair way?

Right?! I've been torn apart for saying to create a joint budget for kids and split it!! Seems like some MN's take the view that it's their way or the high way snd don't understand the idea of compromise 😬

I'm honestly not tearing you apart, I apologise if I've come across that way!

Genuinely though, if in your example, DH (and I, I assume) can then go on to spend whatever we want on our DC in addition to whatever we've budgeted and split 3 ways, how is that much different? Surely that still equals unequal spending?

OP posts:
cookiesbeforepookies · 26/11/2022 08:29

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:25

@rainbowstardrops:
I think you both need to determine your budget and then split that three ways. Surely that's the only fair way?

Right?! I've been torn apart for saying to create a joint budget for kids and split it!! Seems like some MN's take the view that it's their way or the high way snd don't understand the idea of compromise 😬

Where have yiu been ‘torn apart’?

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:28

@aSofaNearYou

I've got MUCH better things to do that explain myself to you, a complete stranger... 🙄🙈🤣

However, OP said that they spilt all joint bills. When they got married, those kids became hers and I see that as a joint expenditure. Therefore, in my eyes, a compromise would be to agree a budget (I've already told OP that this should be amount to she s comfortable with too) and contribute equally.

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:27

PopInn · 26/11/2022 07:42

Because I think they are spoiled. I didn't ask if I was unreasonable for thinking they are spoiled.

Yes but by pointing that out you implied it was relevant context to your AIBU, so it makes sense that people are considering it in their evaluation/ response .