Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute?

217 replies

PopInn · 25/11/2022 16:50

To DSCs main gifts this year?

Pre teen DSCs, been with DH 6 years, married for 4 and now have joint DC too who is 3 just after Christmas.

We do not share finances, I've never wanted to for a variety of reasons, including DSC. He's always been fine with this so we split bills from a joint account and then have what's left in separate accounts.

In the past I have always contributed toward DSCs presents by way of just going and purchasing some myself, this has become less and less as the years have gone on as their tastes are getting more and more expensive to the point now where their main gifts can be hundreds upon hundreds of pounds. Their parents refuse to share any gifts so I'd say they easily get over £1k each spent on them across the two households.

Basically I just don't want to be involved in this anymore, especially now we have our joint child too who's beginning for the first time to begin to understand Christmas and presents (and therefore is getting a bit more spent on them than previous years although absolutely no where near DSCs amount which I appreciate is down to the age gap).

I have spent £25 each on them so far and I'm not planning on spending anything else now. I don't want to spend hundreds of pounds toward their gifts. Imo they are quite spoilt which is of course up to their parents but I don't want to fund it anymore especially with our child needing accounting for and their birthday so soon after. DH leaves it to the last minute a lot so imagine the requests for contribution won't come until at least a couple of weeks.

AIBU to say if he wants to spend £££ that's up to him but he'll need to find the money himself or split it with their mum now?

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 09:21

@Tandora Boundaries are things like "I want to stay living in my own place and have some separation" or "I want to continue going out sometimes when they are here" or "I'm not willing to do childcare/school runs" or "I'm not willing to spend hundreds on their Christmas presents"

Their welfare is not being impacted by any of the above. If a step parent is not willing to talk to their SC with kindness then yes they shouldn't get involved, but pretty much everything else that pertains to how much they "do" for them is not a welfare issue and is a boundary they are perfectly entitled to have.

Tandora · 26/11/2022 09:14

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 09:06

personally I think however people want to organise blending is fine, but what disgusts me so much, on step parenting threads on this forum, is the way that children’s experiences, needs, feelings get cast aside in the name of step parents standing firm on their “boundaries”. I think if you marry someone with children, you commit to recognising that their (the children’s) welfare comes first- Whether that involves taking a parental role or not . All children deserve that. If you are not prepared to take that stance, you shouldn’t involve yourself in a family with children.

There are very few instances where a SC's welfare would be impacted by a step parent having boundaries over what they are willing to do.

How much their step parent personally contributes to the hundreds of pounds spent on them at Christmas certainly has zero impact on their welfare.

Totally disagree with your first paragraph.

Agree with second. I voted OP was NBU. (Apart from calling her DSC spoiled which I thought was U).

B1993 · 26/11/2022 09:12

@HandbagsnGladrags, That's fine. I'm not going to try and convince you otherwise as is perfectly ok to have different opinions, especially about such divisive topics 🤷🏻‍♀️ I'm pleased you have accepted there's a more polite way of doing so though and have realised you don't have to be quite so nasty and toxic about such matters 👍🏻

Tandora · 26/11/2022 09:11

harriethoyle · 26/11/2022 08:55

Exactly @PopInn . Came on to reply in precisely these terms. It's facile to suggest children aren't hugely influenced by their parents attitude towards step-parents (and ex spouses).

No one suggested that children aren’t influenced their parents, but if the issue is your DSC wouldn’t like you to be too involved with them, then say that. In your pp you center their mother’s perspective - suggesting it was absurd to think you could take on a parenting role , because your DSCs’ mother wouldn’t like it. It just smacked of the vibe that I always get from these forums where the adults involved think it’s all about their respective needs/ wants/ boundaries. As I said, whatever relationship you have, all that matters in my view is that everyone agrees that the welfare of the kids comes first .

aSofaNearYou · 26/11/2022 09:06

personally I think however people want to organise blending is fine, but what disgusts me so much, on step parenting threads on this forum, is the way that children’s experiences, needs, feelings get cast aside in the name of step parents standing firm on their “boundaries”. I think if you marry someone with children, you commit to recognising that their (the children’s) welfare comes first- Whether that involves taking a parental role or not . All children deserve that. If you are not prepared to take that stance, you shouldn’t involve yourself in a family with children.

There are very few instances where a SC's welfare would be impacted by a step parent having boundaries over what they are willing to do.

How much their step parent personally contributes to the hundreds of pounds spent on them at Christmas certainly has zero impact on their welfare.

HandbagsnGladrags · 26/11/2022 09:05

@B1993 we'll have to agree to disagree then won't we. Because in my opinion, it is bullshit.

chikp · 26/11/2022 09:04

Sometimes in my experience the best thing I can do as a stepparent is NOT parent. I've had so many conversations with them I don't think they'd have had if they'd seen me as a parent.

chikp · 26/11/2022 09:01

Sorry if I missed it but has he said he's expecting you to contribute so much?

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:59

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:52

Whilst this is true I do think it's fair to acknowledge that the way their parents behave can often affect DC and their view of a SP. So it's not just as simple as saying who cares whether their mum doesn't like it. The fact their mum doesn't approve may affect how involved DSC want you to be etc..

Lots of nuances so I rarely think it's as simple as "this is how it should work", perhaps in an ideal world yes but lots of varying reasons why that may not be the case.

Yes this is all true. It’s so much more complicated than I had realised. Mumsnet has definitely opened my mind!

billy1966 · 26/11/2022 08:58

Wise woman keeping your finances separate.

I think you give a token gift as planned and leave the competing parents off to do their own thing.

You wrote you don't think you and your husband could match a similar amout to be spent on your child?

Even more reason for you to step away from this.

Start saving for your child.

Don't entertain your husband in this.

harriethoyle · 26/11/2022 08:55

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:52

Whilst this is true I do think it's fair to acknowledge that the way their parents behave can often affect DC and their view of a SP. So it's not just as simple as saying who cares whether their mum doesn't like it. The fact their mum doesn't approve may affect how involved DSC want you to be etc..

Lots of nuances so I rarely think it's as simple as "this is how it should work", perhaps in an ideal world yes but lots of varying reasons why that may not be the case.

Exactly @PopInn . Came on to reply in precisely these terms. It's facile to suggest children aren't hugely influenced by their parents attitude towards step-parents (and ex spouses).

Whiskyvodka · 26/11/2022 08:55

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:49

How many men contribute equally to their sc?

My dad and my step mom have always treated us all equally regardless of whose child we were.

I think that probably skews my view somewhat because they're bloody wonderful.

That's lovely.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:54

Boysnme · 26/11/2022 08:52

Not sure why you are getting a hard time here. Feels in this example like it’s OPs own child that comes off worse with less spent on then.

OP does your DH spend the same on his child with you as he does on his other DC?

No but I don't necessarily expect him to (yet). A 3 year old doesn't need £500+ spending on them. But if this is what DH expects his children to receive at Christmas, I do expect him to feel the same when DC is older and I'll be questioning why not if it's suddenly then acceptable for our child to get much less at the same age!

OP posts:
B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:52

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:50

@HandbagsnGladrags @harriethoyle whilst I take your point about the mothers’ feelings, and it’s obviously complex, you do understand that parents don’t “own” their children right? Children are people, not possessions, and no one, not even their own parents, gets to dictate what relationships they have with others. That’s toxic.

Whilst this is true I do think it's fair to acknowledge that the way their parents behave can often affect DC and their view of a SP. So it's not just as simple as saying who cares whether their mum doesn't like it. The fact their mum doesn't approve may affect how involved DSC want you to be etc..

Lots of nuances so I rarely think it's as simple as "this is how it should work", perhaps in an ideal world yes but lots of varying reasons why that may not be the case.

OP posts:
Boysnme · 26/11/2022 08:52

Not sure why you are getting a hard time here. Feels in this example like it’s OPs own child that comes off worse with less spent on then.

OP does your DH spend the same on his child with you as he does on his other DC?

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:51

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:49

How many men contribute equally to their sc?

My dad and my step mom have always treated us all equally regardless of whose child we were.

I think that probably skews my view somewhat because they're bloody wonderful.

❤️❤️❤️

rainbowstardrops · 26/11/2022 08:51

*rainbowstardrops
I don't think you are being unreasonable but I do think you need to discuss this now and not leave it until you're closer to Christmas.

I think you both need to determine your budget and then split that three ways. Surely that's the only fair way?

Why should op pay the same for her stepkids as her own child? I agree DH should be contributing equally to his children but absolutely no reason for OP to*

Because they are a blended family and there are three children within that. Surely the budget would come out of the joint account as the presents are just put together and are from the dad, step-mum and half sibling?

It would be like buying the food shop when the SC are going to be there but only paying for everything apart from the SCs food because the dad should pay for it as they're his children. Seems odd to me.

Theoverthinkingqueen · 26/11/2022 08:50

In my opinion when you got with an married your DH you knew he had 2 children so the decision you made regarding the children’s gifts right from the start should stay that way whether you have your own dc together or not.

A friend of mine has been with her partner roughly the same amount you have with your DH and he is the step parent to her DD, from the very start he sets an amount he is willing to spend and gets either 1 big item or a few smaller ones and they label them from him so his DSC knows that the gifts are from him.

I don’t feel you should be included in the “from us pile” if you are not contributing half. I get that gifts get expensive having a DD myself roughly this age but your DC is also going to get to this age and want this stuff which obviously your DH will be contributing half to, he then is technically paying for 3 DC and you are not. In my eyes you married him with the children they should be treat exactly as your own DC is.

I agree with you to an extent that “portable” items shouldn’t be duplicated maybe a discussion with the children (if he can’t with their mother) to ask what they would like that they haven’t already asked their DM for and if they are asking for the same thing they need a good reason as to why is can’t just be took from one house to another.

Tandora · 26/11/2022 08:50

@HandbagsnGladrags @harriethoyle whilst I take your point about the mothers’ feelings, and it’s obviously complex, you do understand that parents don’t “own” their children right? Children are people, not possessions, and no one, not even their own parents, gets to dictate what relationships they have with others. That’s toxic.

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:49

PopInn · 26/11/2022 08:46

Yes it was thanks for responsding Smile

I guess I just think if we then get to go on and spend whatever additional on whichever DC we want then that's not exactly equal either at which point I can't see much difference to what I'm suggesting I guess.

I think the difference, for me at least, is that it's be an agreed budget for all the children. DH wouldn't just be spending £X on DSC and then asking you to put your hand in your pocket. You'd have a set amount that you budget for and if he them wants to be involved in the competition for better presents with his ex, you're not in a position where you're asked to be involved in that too as you already contributed your 'fair' share.

girlmom21 · 26/11/2022 08:49

How many men contribute equally to their sc?

My dad and my step mom have always treated us all equally regardless of whose child we were.

I think that probably skews my view somewhat because they're bloody wonderful.

Loopyloooooo · 26/11/2022 08:48

Over a grand each on presents is absolutely crazy. However it probably should be pointed out that you don't really know how much their Mum spends...could be sales etc

HOWEVER personally I think treating children from the same family unit differently is crap. I could never treat my own child differently to their siblings especially if I lived with them half the time etc. I wouldn't particularly not share finances with my DH either tho soo....

harriethoyle · 26/11/2022 08:47

B1993 · 26/11/2022 08:32

@cookiesbeforepookies, I just don't get the 'they aren't her kids' thing. If she didn't want to take on responsibility of them as a parent, they wouldn't have married. Fair enough, they are a blended family, but I do see her equally as part of the coparent relationship. I think she should be valued as an equal parent, and her value them as equal to her own children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Again, just my opinion.

Hahahahaha. My DSC mother would throw an absolute shitfit if anyone suggested I was an equal parent to her. And rightly so. DSC have two parents and don't need or want a third.

HandbagsnGladrags · 26/11/2022 08:47

There was no name calling or abuse. I was just calling out bullshit.