Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I didn't have a phone as new mum, but if I had

85 replies

Lookatbaby · 25/11/2022 15:44

I KNOW I would have been distracted and looking at my phone all the time. I know this thread will be seen as controversial, judgemental. I emphasise I would have been a phone addict, but my kids were born before smartphones were a thing. I just feel as if I never see a parent with a young child who isn't looking at their phone.

YANBU: I worry babies and young children are not getting enough interaction.

YABU it's fine.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 28/11/2022 12:33

Lookatbaby · 28/11/2022 12:20

I am not shaming people. I have a concern. I think it is legitimate. I worry about it. I was distracted as a parent, I wanted to read all the time, but my kids needed attention and showed it so I couldn't. I would have been able to go on my phone though as it is easy to focus. My Mum was distracted too, by TV. But I also know there was plenty of eye contact,social interaction. If you are not neglecting your children, then I am not talking about you so no need to be defensive.

I dunno why you are so obsessed with the fact that you would have ignored your kids if you had a phone, and basically thank god you didn’t.
Stalking someone outside a shop for 10 mins really doesn’t give you an indication of their day.
Having a phone doesn’t make you a shit parent, parenting when your kids were young wasn’t automatically better because you only had a house phone.

. I would like to have a rational debate about the culture where we post things but we don't experience them and we accept and like these things from each other without looking at the faces of the children in them to see if they are actually enjoying things.
What does that have to do about phones? Have you never seen all the 80s and 90s pictures of kids crying at Santa and the parents still took a picture of the kid not enjoying something even though they didn’t have a phone then.

Sweetchildofmine19 · 28/11/2022 12:30

I haven’t voted as to be completely honest I am 50/50 on your first post.

I have a 3 and a half year old and a 1 year old. At certain points throughout the day when I am out with them you may catch me looking at my phone. However, as others have said, this is just a snap shot of my day and does not show the hour prior to this running around a park laughing and playing with them, or the half hour morning puzzles we did together, or the story time in the afternoon, or the bath time and bedtime routine or the chats/cuddles/dancing/singing etc that happen every day throughout the day.

However I do agree to an extent that phones are a distraction and there have been times I have picked up my phone to read and reply to a message and had to consciously stop myself from starting to scroll through fb or something. I do think that sometimes it would be better if I just left my phone in another room and looked at it once the kids were in bed.

I don’t agree with your last post about kids today will grow up without empathy just down to people looking at their phones. Yes, of course there may be some instances of this, where some parents do use their phones too much and don’t have enough interaction with their children but I think the vast majority of people will be like myself and the small number of times they spend looking at their phone throughout the day will not have any significant impact on the children.

Lookatbaby · 28/11/2022 12:28

EndlessRain · 28/11/2022 12:15

I remember my parents ignoring me while reading a news paper.... Funny how it's possible to need a break from your kids and zone out once in a while. I guess you never ever experienced that OP and you were always 100% focus on a responsive to your kids? Never doing soemthing else, distracted, in a conversation?

I am actually in agreement phone addiction is a real issue in society. I just don't agree that it should be another stick to beat new mothers. I also don't agree it's necessarily an issue for someone to use their phone on occassion.

I made it clear that I was not using this as a stick for beating anyone. I would like to have a rational debate about the culture where we post things but we don't experience them and we accept and like these things from each other without looking at the faces of the children in them to see if they are actually enjoying things.
The worst thing I have seen is a video on Instagram where a man was holding his baby, looking at his phone and wearing a mask on the side of his head with a picture of a woman, for the baby to look at. The baby was eyeing it and trying to make eye contact, mystified. This was being liked by thousands of people.

OP posts:
Lookatbaby · 28/11/2022 12:20

I am not shaming people. I have a concern. I think it is legitimate. I worry about it. I was distracted as a parent, I wanted to read all the time, but my kids needed attention and showed it so I couldn't. I would have been able to go on my phone though as it is easy to focus. My Mum was distracted too, by TV. But I also know there was plenty of eye contact,social interaction. If you are not neglecting your children, then I am not talking about you so no need to be defensive.

OP posts:
EndlessRain · 28/11/2022 12:15

I remember my parents ignoring me while reading a news paper.... Funny how it's possible to need a break from your kids and zone out once in a while. I guess you never ever experienced that OP and you were always 100% focus on a responsive to your kids? Never doing soemthing else, distracted, in a conversation?

I am actually in agreement phone addiction is a real issue in society. I just don't agree that it should be another stick to beat new mothers. I also don't agree it's necessarily an issue for someone to use their phone on occassion.

Lookatbaby · 28/11/2022 12:12

I saw a mum recently filming her little boy on a postman pat supermarket ride, looking around the shop as she did so, then lift him out and into the buggy, he tried to speak to her, not once was there any eye contact. I worry that this could have been me. I also saw a woman hold up a phone to a baby in a pram who was about 8 months or so. He giggled and threw himself from side to side while she filmed. Then she put the phone away and sat down out of his sight. It seemed as if he was conditioned to provide this footage of a happy baby. At no time in the next ten minutes did she look at him or speak to him. I was waiting outside a shop, so was she, in case this is seen as creepy. I think this generation will grow up without empathy.

OP posts:
Autumflower · 25/11/2022 17:27

I’m so glad I didn’t have a phone when mine were little ,I know for a fact how obsessed I can be checking for messages .

Tiredalwaystired · 25/11/2022 17:26

Can I check how many of the people who think you aren’t being unreasonable had children pre smartphones?

My hypothesis is that it’s quite a high percentage as it’s a perception not the reality. But I’m really interested to see how many with children post smart phone era also think you’re not being unreasonable. It’s difficult to tell from the poll alone.

OhYouSillySod · 25/11/2022 17:15

CatherineNotSoMuch · 25/11/2022 16:48

I didn't have a phone, too old. Im glad I didn't, not because of the distractions but the fact that there is a virtual world right there in your hand just poised to give an opinion on everything. So many new mum's second guess themselves or ask "AIBU" when I was lucky enough just to be able to wing it without being "shamed " for co-sleeping/not having a routine/drinking Pepsi max all day. It's tough enough for them without anyone commenting that they think they're on their phones all day.

100%

audweb · 25/11/2022 17:15

So glad when I had PND I could message people easily while I spent hours breastfeeding. It meant I could find groups to support me online when I was unwell and vulnerable. I could read my kindle on my phone during the long long nights of breastfeeding.

my mum was plenty distracted in the 80’s, not having phones didn’t magically make everyone present and involved.

luxxlisbon · 25/11/2022 17:08

TheaBrandt · 25/11/2022 16:56

Totally with you op. God I am glad mine were born just before smart phones. I remember reading a library book in the park while dd1 had a nap in a pram. When they were tiny I was fully present. Yes it was often bloody boring but so much better for them. I know I would have been totally distracted far more often if I had had a phone.

Are you actually serious? Reading a book isn’t being any more “present” than being on a phone!

OhYouSillySod · 25/11/2022 17:07

PeeJayDay · 25/11/2022 17:04

Oh yeah cause the 80s were full of interactive parenting and "making memories". We never had a weekend at home....oh 🤔🤣

Yeah. That!

OhYouSillySod · 25/11/2022 17:06

Personally I think new mums get bashed enough.. not really any need for a new topic to bash them about.

PeeJayDay · 25/11/2022 17:04

Oh yeah cause the 80s were full of interactive parenting and "making memories". We never had a weekend at home....oh 🤔🤣

Beees · 25/11/2022 17:01

I remember reading a library book in the park while dd1 had a nap in a pram. When they were tiny I was fully present. Yes it was often bloody boring but so much better for them

If they are asleep why is ignoring them whilst reading's a book better for them than doing the same but with a phone?

GetThatHelmetOn · 25/11/2022 17:00

YANBU

Crunchymum · 25/11/2022 16:58

I KNOW I would have been distracted and looking at my phone all the time

So presumably you just ignore your older children @Lookatbaby?

Dinnerdate1 · 25/11/2022 16:58

Don't see the issue. My dad was forever head deep into a newspaper or a book. There's a million and one different things someone could be doing on their phone.

TheaBrandt · 25/11/2022 16:56

Totally with you op. God I am glad mine were born just before smart phones. I remember reading a library book in the park while dd1 had a nap in a pram. When they were tiny I was fully present. Yes it was often bloody boring but so much better for them. I know I would have been totally distracted far more often if I had had a phone.

Kindthoughts · 25/11/2022 16:56

I had my first baby pre eyes-to-phone-age, so I can see what you are saying.

I think it's rare nowadays to see a mum of a baby/ toddler who isn't glued to her phone, but then the toddler is usually sat in their buggy glued to a kids device.

I think as long as they are still being talked to/ read to/ played with/ sang to, it's fine in moderation. It's just about getting the balance right.

I always worried with my first and questioned myself if he was having too much "TV time". That was before devices.

Goldbar · 25/11/2022 16:53

When my mother was young, her mother used to put her in the pram down at the bottom of the garden next to the coal shed and feed her at 4 hourly intervals. According to my late grandmother, that was how people apparently raised babies back then and anything else was 'spoiling' the baby 🙄. To be fair, mothers needed to get on and do stuff without many of the things we take for granted nowadays.

When I was young, my mother had a large wooden playpen in the corner of the kitchen and we'd go in there for large parts of the day while she was doing things.

I'm not sure everything has changed for the worse in terms of how responsive parents are to their young children.

CatherineNotSoMuch · 25/11/2022 16:48

I didn't have a phone, too old. Im glad I didn't, not because of the distractions but the fact that there is a virtual world right there in your hand just poised to give an opinion on everything. So many new mum's second guess themselves or ask "AIBU" when I was lucky enough just to be able to wing it without being "shamed " for co-sleeping/not having a routine/drinking Pepsi max all day. It's tough enough for them without anyone commenting that they think they're on their phones all day.

Coooosd · 25/11/2022 16:48

You were probably doing other things though, reading magazines/newspaper, watching TV etc. Nobody interacts constantly with their children

takealettermsjones · 25/11/2022 16:40

.

I didn't have a phone as new mum, but if I had
babynoname22 · 25/11/2022 16:36

Whilst I sort of agree with you. And I think im addicted a bit to mine (the irony on mumsnet!) whilst I'm 'looking at my phone' I'm

  • doing the food shop
  • sorting the banking
  • booking DS swimming
  • emailing nursery re pjs day
  • sorting the roofer to come fix the leak
  • planning and prepping stuff for Xmas
  • making play dates
  • reaching out to the others on my mums group after being up for the millionth hour in the night and needing support
  • storing the information a child/you/someone else has just told my into the calendar as I can't remember anything anymore

And lots of other associated 'life admin shit' that means I can raise two children. When you look at others you see a snapshot. You don't see the permanence. You wouldn't have seen the above tasks previously as you can't do them 'out' without a phone they would have been done at home. But now women are expected to raise children. Look good. Have a job. Keep a clean house and partner it's still like the 1950s