Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I didn't have a phone as new mum, but if I had

85 replies

Lookatbaby · 25/11/2022 15:44

I KNOW I would have been distracted and looking at my phone all the time. I know this thread will be seen as controversial, judgemental. I emphasise I would have been a phone addict, but my kids were born before smartphones were a thing. I just feel as if I never see a parent with a young child who isn't looking at their phone.

YANBU: I worry babies and young children are not getting enough interaction.

YABU it's fine.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Abraxan · 03/12/2022 16:40

I remember reading a library book in the park while dd1 had a nap in a pram. When they were tiny I was fully present. Yes it was often bloody boring but so much better for them

Why is reading a book better than looking at a phone?

DD is 20y so I did have a phone when she was small, though not a smart phone that can do what it does now. But at home I did have a laptop/computer the internet, TV, books, and other things I could have got equally distracted by.

A smartphone is distract myself with in those tedious periods of time just sat in a play park whilst they run around playing, ignoring you, would have been fab tbh!

Squamata · 03/12/2022 16:29

Nah. I remember getting very bored by the sight of my mum's crossed legs in the 80s when she was on the landline. Maybe I was in a playpen? Not sure.

Also my dad reading a huge broadsheet newspaper. Or being dragged around shops and on errands. It was boring and now takes less time but it looks like phone scrolling.

Or the children's room at the pub. Dump the kids with a broken set of connect 4 and a pint of lemonade while the adults play the fruit machines and drink lager.

I think parents spend more time with their kids than before, if anything it might be too much.

MajorCarolDanvers · 03/12/2022 16:16

No smartphone with first child.

Very grateful to have one with second child to see me through breastfeeding during the night.

Both children have grown up fine. First child does not seem particularly advantaged by my lack of phone in his early years.

carmenitapink · 03/12/2022 16:11

Lookatbaby · 25/11/2022 15:44

I KNOW I would have been distracted and looking at my phone all the time. I know this thread will be seen as controversial, judgemental. I emphasise I would have been a phone addict, but my kids were born before smartphones were a thing. I just feel as if I never see a parent with a young child who isn't looking at their phone.

YANBU: I worry babies and young children are not getting enough interaction.

YABU it's fine.

That's because most parents try to focus when having one on one time with their child at home

If I'm wheeling the baby round in a pram, then yes that's a decent opportunity to check my phone!

jamoncrumpets · 03/12/2022 16:08

Lookatbaby · 03/12/2022 15:54

I feel as if some posters are being hostile, but that's just my opinion. It's due to hostile comments being aimed at me though, so maybe..... Here again is what I am not doing: judging. I'm worried. And please notice the use of the word parent as I have employed it from the beginning. I know others will have been aware of the issue around young children having relative developmental delay. Nothing like a messy argument though instead of a reasoned discussion, which is what I was hoping for.

Sources please.

Ponypitter · 03/12/2022 16:02

I adored my baby and interacted loads but also read books and looked at my phone when breast feeding.

If I hadn't had a phone I would've read a book all the time!

I'm very introverted and breaks from human interaction are important to me.

Kanaloa · 03/12/2022 15:56

Lookatbaby · 03/12/2022 15:54

I feel as if some posters are being hostile, but that's just my opinion. It's due to hostile comments being aimed at me though, so maybe..... Here again is what I am not doing: judging. I'm worried. And please notice the use of the word parent as I have employed it from the beginning. I know others will have been aware of the issue around young children having relative developmental delay. Nothing like a messy argument though instead of a reasoned discussion, which is what I was hoping for.

Could you further the reasonable discussion by explaining your statement that ‘teachers say reception aged children have no social skills’ and ‘this generation will grow up without empathy?’

Are these just your uninformed assumptions? Or do you have any actual factual basis for them?

Lookatbaby · 03/12/2022 15:54

I feel as if some posters are being hostile, but that's just my opinion. It's due to hostile comments being aimed at me though, so maybe..... Here again is what I am not doing: judging. I'm worried. And please notice the use of the word parent as I have employed it from the beginning. I know others will have been aware of the issue around young children having relative developmental delay. Nothing like a messy argument though instead of a reasoned discussion, which is what I was hoping for.

OP posts:
TenPenceMix · 03/12/2022 11:58

I think I would have been a hell of a lot less lonely and also more clued up.

Kanaloa · 03/12/2022 11:50

Lookatbaby · 03/12/2022 00:55

I'm talking about parents, not mothers.
I'm using my observations, as are others.
I have heard and read reports quoted in the media, I didn't make the teachers findings up.
You, Kanaloa, are just one teacher and you are giving us your experience. That's great.

I imagine we are on the same side when it comes to being concerned about children's lives. I have to say a flurry of hostile remarks is not an appropriate response,and doesn't persuade me I'm wrong.
Concern for the future is not "judging".

AGAIN can I repeat, I am talking about PARENTS. Parents parents parents. Leaving phone in other room now......

As opposed to you, who is just internet random posting vague statements like ‘teachers say kids don’t have social skills.’ No backup, no source, no context.

And nobody is being hostile - just saying that making vague statements and acting like they can justify your belief that an entire generation will grow up without empathy because you saw a mother on her phone makes you look stupid.

Oysterbabe · 03/12/2022 10:26

I think in general society is more child focused than it's ever been. My mum never worried about teaching me stuff, that's the school's job, or playing with me, she had multiple children so they could play with each other. We were largely left to get on with things while she ran the house.
My kids get so, so much more focused attention than I ever had, Sometimes I'll use my phone inbetween, especially when I'm sat in the park or something, they're having a run around and judgy bitches can see a snapshot and think that I'm not paying attention to them.

JennyForeigner · 03/12/2022 10:09

Yeah, we have baby twins and a 3 year old and the only time I get to look at my phone is when the babies are in a pram facing away from me, probably asleep and I've sat down on a bench for a break from wheeling them endlessly around our village.

We are really careful about phones at home, so I try in turn not to be judgemental of others.

softpilllow · 03/12/2022 09:19

I think uninterested parents existed long before mobile phones.

jamoncrumpets · 03/12/2022 09:12

Lookatbaby · 02/12/2022 23:40

Teachers in reception classes talk about children not having the most basic of social skills at age 4.

You made this up or read it on the Daily Mail.

Either way it adds little to nothing to your argument.

My 4yo is bloody brilliant. She's imaginative, inquisitive, chatty, funny, outgoing. I used my phone around her too, can you even imagine!

Ncgirlseriously · 03/12/2022 09:09

My phone changed aren’t to are. Damn phones.

Ncgirlseriously · 03/12/2022 09:08

Ah yes. I remember the day I was feeling really shitty, had zero sleep but still managed to have a good productive morning with my son, got him out to the playground- spent an hour running around with him and playing games- then my phone pinged, my sister was texting to finalise plans for us to all go the aquarium for my birthday, because I had asked for a day out for my son for a gift. Took a minute or two to text her back, while keeping an eye on my son, who was happily amusing himself, only to look up and see an old lady giving me a the stink-eye and tutting because I DARED to look at my phone.

Yes, parents shouldn’t ignore their kids for their phones but let’s not pretend that most times parents are getting judged over nothing because people just LOVE to judge parents, especially mums on their own.

Squiblet · 03/12/2022 08:40

OP, you've come on a site aimed specifically at parents (clue's in the name), the vast majority of whom are reading it on their phones at this very moment, and said, "All these parents on their phones may be harming their children!" Of course you're going to get backlash - what did you expect?

It's like going onto a birdwatching forum and saying that all this skulking around in hides with binoculars is certainly not doing the birds any good.

Lookatbaby · 03/12/2022 00:55

I'm talking about parents, not mothers.
I'm using my observations, as are others.
I have heard and read reports quoted in the media, I didn't make the teachers findings up.
You, Kanaloa, are just one teacher and you are giving us your experience. That's great.

I imagine we are on the same side when it comes to being concerned about children's lives. I have to say a flurry of hostile remarks is not an appropriate response,and doesn't persuade me I'm wrong.
Concern for the future is not "judging".

AGAIN can I repeat, I am talking about PARENTS. Parents parents parents. Leaving phone in other room now......

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 02/12/2022 23:55

I don’t worry about it at all.

Were mothers 100 years ago worried that their kids weren’t getting enough attention while they did the laundry and scrubbed the front steps and all the rest of it? Probably not. Why are women so harshly judged for having any sort of leisure time that the casual onlooker doesn’t think is worthy? Carry around a Dostoyevsky tome and it’s seen as ok, but read that same book on your phone and suddenly people sneer.

I didn’t have a phone when my twins were little because they weren’t really a thing. I mean I had a Nokia type. They were both still severely speech delayed. I guess if they were born now people would assume this was my fault if they saw me on my phone. I had enough residual guilt about that from my difficult pregnancy.

PS sure I think some might be like you describe. But I think most people actually like their own children and want to spend time with them.

Kanaloa · 02/12/2022 23:47

And as for not judging - you’ve literally said ‘this generation will grow up without empathy’ based on a wide and varied study of… some people you’ve seen out and about, who you don’t even know.

Lookatbaby · 02/12/2022 23:46

Here is what I am not saying:
"parents should be shamed as useless and phone addicted."

Here is what I am saying : if this is happening, people might benefit from a simple reminder "look at your baby, talk to it"

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 02/12/2022 23:46

Lookatbaby · 02/12/2022 23:40

Teachers in reception classes talk about children not having the most basic of social skills at age 4.

Okay, well I teach kids that age and find their social skills to be the same as always. A variety of course as some children are more shy or reserved, others more confident and outgoing.

What teachers do you mean? Teachers you know? Teachers in a study you’ve read? Or just ‘well teachers say this.’ Because just randomly throwing out statements with no backing or context doesn’t prove your point.

Lookatbaby · 02/12/2022 23:40

Teachers in reception classes talk about children not having the most basic of social skills at age 4.

OP posts:
Lookatbaby · 02/12/2022 23:35

I still have not judged, I am not going to but there you are, misrepresentation is a common default reaction.
For people who are actually interested in this as an issue, I'm not saying things used to be better, but I don't think young children have ever been as deprived of socialising contact.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 01/12/2022 23:03

Yanbu

I have the same concerns, parents on buses, in cafes, in parks staring at their screen ... yes individually they may be dealing with urgent matter but they won't all be!

As another mum with kids who are older, we read to our kids, did puzzles etc to entertain them, and actually supervised them in the park (I found a 4 year old girl walking alone in the park recently, her mum hadn't realised she had walked off, I walked the girl back to the playground and her mum was still staring at the screen, didn't even thank me).

Yes I judge, kids needs parenting