Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prove my ID after 30 years!

64 replies

Ladyof2022 · 25/11/2022 14:50

I've been with the same GP surgery for over 30 years. Obvs over that time all the GPs and other staff have met me at least once and mostly several times. During that 30 yrs I have not changed my name and for the last 25 years have not changed my address.

I phoned reception last week to request a repeat prescription of a preventative drug I take to avoid stomach ulcers whilst I take OTC painkillers. The receptionist said she will not authorise any more repeats until I prove my identity. I laughed out loud, and told her, I've been with the surgery for 30 years. Nevertheless she insisted. She said I must post or bring my passport or driving licence, but I have neither. In that case, she said, I must come in person and present myself to a receptionist. I asked how that "proved" my identity and she swerved the question and just repeated that they intend to withhold all my repeat prescriptions until I have come in to the surgery. My scripts include Ventolin for asthma.

AIBU for refusing to go along with this utter stupidity of having to "prove" (which I cannot do anyway) who I am after 30 years?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
toomuchlaundry · 26/11/2022 09:23

Money laundering regulations require proof of ID, so solicitors and accountants will normally ask for ID. If you are self employed @Ladyof2022 do you have an accountant?

I needed ID to be a school governor as I needed to have a DBS check done

Wish this country had ID cards would be so much simpler for everyone

justasking111 · 26/11/2022 09:09

Been with our solicitors for 46 years. Had to produce proof of identity yet again when dealing with an issue. I did query it and was told it was government who insisted.

BosaNova · 26/11/2022 09:03

Ladyof2022 · 26/11/2022 01:19

Interesting replies, thanks.

I can see why these bureaucrats get away with this utter nonsense - because people will just knuckle down and comply with anything, just for a quiet life and to be seen as not making a fuss, and being "nice", compliant citizens.

I feel insulted by them treating me like I am a stranger after 30 years.

I think the time for my GP to ask me for my ID was 30 years ago, when I registered and they first started doling out drugs to me.

Back then I had a driving licence, a passport and photo ID for work. Now I have none.

You sre not their mate! You are in effect a stranger😂

Dramatic much. It's totally normal thing to check someone's id and to re id after certain time if needed or when rules change.

"Hkw dare anyone want me to have proper photo id"
"Oh no. how come someone got my xx with just some bank card! Oh no. Fraudulent application, need CIFASAngry"

Id and requirement of showing it on occasion is just so normal outside of uk. This no id is NOT the "good special".

Kazzyhoward · 26/11/2022 08:58

Are GPs still on the list of people who can sign my photo to verify I am who I say I am when applying for photo ID?

They are still on the "approved" list of professions by the passport agency, but in reality, pretty sure I remember a diktat by the NHS a few years ago to say GPs were to be stopped from doing them because it was taking up too much GP/admin time, and that their "recommendation" was that GPs only countersign passports for people they know personally rather than professionally.

Abraxan · 26/11/2022 08:47

Get yourself a passport. It will help with these situations, and there's a bill going through parliament at the moment that will require photographic ID to be allowed to vote (Elections Act 2022).

A provisional driving license is a cheaper option.
It's what dd and her friends all got themselves as soon as they were eligible.

Artygirlghost · 26/11/2022 08:25

Usually when you register at a GP surgery they ask you for proof of address to check that you live within the boundaries that the surgery is happy to cover.

But according to this you actually not need to provide any documents at all:

www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/gps/how-to-register-with-a-gp-surgery/

So stand your ground, refuse to play along and lodge a complaint with your surgery.

They should not be withdrawing your medication in this way. Completely unacceptable.

It looks like the ID check is only linked to online prescription renewal. If you are collecting in person, there is no need for an ID check.

It sounds like the receptionist is getting confused as to when they should be requesting and ID or not...

Wakeywake · 26/11/2022 08:10

You might have been with the surgery for 30 years, but unless you're on their doorstep every week I doubt they'd be able to pick you in an identity parade. I don't know how people live without photo Id, in the past 3 months alone I've needed my passport to prove my right to work in the UK, open an investment account and apply for my kid's bus pass (yes, really, don't start me on that one). Fair enough, 30 years ago ids were not required that much, but the times are changing. You can refuse to change with the times and make your life more difficult, or just accept that you need id and just get it.

WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 26/11/2022 07:46

My GP's practice certainly won't do it (I asked my GP a couple of years ago). Also re provisional driving licence, I just checked now and you need proof of ID to get one, e.g. passport! So if you don't drive you basically need a passport. Birth certificates (no photo) don't count.

Are you sure? My DS got his provisional this year and it was far easier than the passport application we'd abandoned 2.5 years ago (they needed proof of his grandparents marriages, all of whom are divorced as I'm unmarried and don't have a passport)
DVLA accepted his birth certificate and something else. Might have been bank statements. Plus a declaration signed by a professional (we used the Vicar)

Last time I saw anything at the GP surgery about counter signing it said they did it for a fee.

CrunchyCarrot · 26/11/2022 02:57

Are GPs still on the list of people who can sign my photo to verify I am who I say I am when applying for photo ID?

My GP's practice certainly won't do it (I asked my GP a couple of years ago). Also re provisional driving licence, I just checked now and you need proof of ID to get one, e.g. passport! So if you don't drive you basically need a passport. Birth certificates (no photo) don't count.

I am in this situation of not having any proof of ID (my passport elapsed some 20 yrs ago and I've been housebound with disability). My repeat prescriptions go from my GP to my nominated pharmacy who home deliver. I would be in trouble if asked for proof of ID! I don't know anyone who could countersign passport pics as proof of who I am. It's really difficult, more difficult than people may think it is.

Brokendaughter · 26/11/2022 02:15

It's all very well people saying get a provisional licence, but if you read the small print, many of these places say it has to be a FULL driving licence & that a provisional doesn't count.

I am not even allowed a driving licence as I don't see well enough to be allowed to drive, so I cannot pass a test to get a full licence.

There are a lot of people who don't have these photo ids, who opened bank accounts decades ago (when they never even asked for photo id & driving licences didn't have photos on them) who really don't get asked for photo id.

Not all of them have a spare £100 or so to get a passport & not all of them know someone who is on the ever shrinking list of people who are allowed to sign for them.

This photo id policy is intentionally disenfranchising people born in this country & it's creeping in everywhere.

No photo id, no doctor, just means instead of being treated before things gets serious, you can wait until you are a really expensive case in the hospital because they don't demand id when they take you in an ambulance.

It will cost the NHS billions extra in the long term.

They are trying to move towards no photo id, no benefits.
How are people who can't even eat every day supposed to come up with the funds for a passport?

If you make it so people have nothing to lose, prepare to see the crime rates skyrocket.
No money, no hope, no reason not to commit a crime.
The worst that can happen is they'll put you in prison where you'll have a roof over your head & food.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 01:28

Honestly OP pick your battles. I wouldn’t go without my Ventolin in an effort to play King Canute to this data trend.

MetellaInHortoEst · 26/11/2022 01:26

BosaNova · 25/11/2022 17:34

Special for the sake of being special?
Many non UK are baffled

I think it’s a hangover from some muddled notions about being an island nation and escaping various waves of continental despotism and authoritarian control.

All a bit wrongheaded but strongly felt.

Utterly redundant now that most of us are carrying trackers, video doorbells are everywhere, data capture is everywhere and photo ID is widely required.

Ladyof2022 · 26/11/2022 01:19

Interesting replies, thanks.

I can see why these bureaucrats get away with this utter nonsense - because people will just knuckle down and comply with anything, just for a quiet life and to be seen as not making a fuss, and being "nice", compliant citizens.

I feel insulted by them treating me like I am a stranger after 30 years.

I think the time for my GP to ask me for my ID was 30 years ago, when I registered and they first started doling out drugs to me.

Back then I had a driving licence, a passport and photo ID for work. Now I have none.

OP posts:
ichundich · 25/11/2022 22:01

Are you sure? I thought you had to be a UK resident to qualify for NHS care.

alexdgr8 · 25/11/2022 17:54

si how about voting, how will you prove your ID.
best to register for postal vote.
you don't drive, so don't you have a bus pass or similar ? anyway from what you say, they haven't actually demanded photo ID, but for you to appear in person before them.
that's not unreasonable.
they have to make sure drugs are not being misused or intercepted.
in my area, chemists ask for a written note from the patient if someone else unknown is collecting the prescription.
but they deliver to those who cannot get out, for repeats.

Onnabugeisha · 25/11/2022 17:54

ichundich · 25/11/2022 17:49

It's annoying, but I'd rather surgeries do this than than let fraudsters use the NHS for free. Can't you go in with a bank statement or council tax bill?

? All GP surgeries are free to everyone regardless of immigration status.
This isn’t about restricting access to care, this is about ensuring only you access your medical info and accounts.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 25/11/2022 17:53

Apply for a provisional driving license. You don't need a passport to apply and this won't come up again.

ichundich · 25/11/2022 17:49

It's annoying, but I'd rather surgeries do this than than let fraudsters use the NHS for free. Can't you go in with a bank statement or council tax bill?

BosaNova · 25/11/2022 17:47

AnuSTart · 25/11/2022 17:45

This is one way the NHS can avoid health tourism. It has to be done. Suck it up.
My friend has family from all over the EU, who used to routinely come to the UK for dental and medical treatment. It was shitty to be frank and I speak as someone who is a staunch remainer and live in the EU.

Suck it up. Take your ID and accept that being a patient among 10000 (per GP on average) means that no one really knows or cares who the eff you are individually.

😂😂😂 i can absolutely imagine no one who would come to uk for dental treatment or other for that matter. It's rather the other way around and we are actually all trying to go in our respective native countries.
It's even more expensive here!

AnuSTart · 25/11/2022 17:45

This is one way the NHS can avoid health tourism. It has to be done. Suck it up.
My friend has family from all over the EU, who used to routinely come to the UK for dental and medical treatment. It was shitty to be frank and I speak as someone who is a staunch remainer and live in the EU.

Suck it up. Take your ID and accept that being a patient among 10000 (per GP on average) means that no one really knows or cares who the eff you are individually.

KnickerlessParsons · 25/11/2022 17:38

They also took my word for it when I phoned on behalf of DH after an op on his mouth that it was him who muttered a "yes" when they asked if he'd allow them to talk to me.

WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 25/11/2022 17:37

Kazzyhoward · 25/11/2022 17:12

Yes, but that's the case with other professionals such accountants and solicitors, where you have the same merry-go-round.

Ultimately, whoever is "signing off" who you say you are has to satisfy themselves you are who you are and document the evidence.

That's probably another reason why the GP surgery want evidence on record. As if the GP signs an official form to say you are who you are, they may be called upon to provide evidence as to why, and if they've never seen official ID, they'd have difficulty in explaining themselves.

Oh I know. It was just a passing thought that made me giggle. My GP can officially sign that I am who I say I am, only after I've proved to them that I am who I say I am. Which i would do with birth certificate and some kind of bill as proof of address.

But if (as is usually claimed) you have to have photo ID as of ID it wouldn't ever be possible to get photo ID because I'd need photo ID to prove I am who I say I am to get the photo ID that I need to prove I am who I say I am etc.
It's a purely hypothetical thought.

Anyway, I'm not against national ID cards. I never have been. Provided they are free/very cheap. I don't think things should be made compulsory for all and charged for.

KnickerlessParsons · 25/11/2022 17:36

I've had this with our surgery. I pointed out that no one checks my ID when I
•make an appt
•make an appt for someone else
•attend my appt
•take my prescription to the chemist
•collect my prescription from the chemist
•collect DH's prescription
•see a specialist at the hospital
•attend the hospital for a procedure or operation
• when DH goes for his radiotherapy
....and so on ad infinitum.

It shut her up.

BosaNova · 25/11/2022 17:34

FinallyHere · 25/11/2022 17:11

The question for me is why the UK does not routinely issue ID cards ?

so.much.simpler

Special for the sake of being special?
Many non UK are baffled

DogInATent · 25/11/2022 17:32

FinallyHere · 25/11/2022 17:11

The question for me is why the UK does not routinely issue ID cards ?

so.much.simpler

Because pre-2016 the polling suggested that they were comprehensively viewed with suspicion by the public and attempts to introduce them were defeated in parliament.

Now, I think the position may have changed. Many people have had an insight into how difficult it can be to officially prove your legal existence/entitlements when challenged by authority.

Swipe left for the next trending thread