Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you raise your kids to care about money when it comes to future career and lifestyle?

140 replies

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 13:24

I have been thinking about what advice I would like to give my kids regarding future jobs and careers - they are both still quite young. Yes, this comes from a position of privilege but has been spurred on my the current financial situation in the UK.

We currently live in London - I went to Oxford, have a PhD and work in academia. I earn ok but clearly not as much as I could be. All of my uni friends are the same - chose not to go into the city and are now on 60-70k in their 40s. They are all in managerial positions but dont seem as interested in chasing promotions or money at any price. Would rather go part time than hit the next salary mile stone. As far as I can tell - we all love what we do and are mainly in the arts, medicine, academia, publishing, think tanks etc.

By contrast, parents at my kids' school and my siblings are quite different and do tend to place a lot of emphasis on material wealth, the next promotion, competitive parenting - making sure you get the next thing, the bigger house, that promotion, become a partner, hit the next milestone. This also translates into how they raise their kids.

When I was younger - I clearly thought that doing something you love that pays less, getting a nice work life balance was better than going into the 'city' (could be anything else) and focusing primarily on the financial side of things. However, now that I have my own kids - and hit 40s - I am beginning to think that maybe my way is not better and actually chasing money and the next promotion, the nicer house and the next best thing is much smarter.

Is it that the world has change and money matters more or that I can grown up so to speak. How do you raise your kids and what do you tell them?

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 25/11/2022 15:01

All I want is for my kids to be happy and we encourage always trying your best ar school , college etc and having part time job
They know things cost money etc but ultimately its up to them how they choose to live their life
Ds19 at uni now had gap year to save and work and ds17 at college , and has part time job
Who knows what they will do but as long as they are happy then i think we have done out job

Shiningsilverargent · 25/11/2022 14:58

I am encouraging trying to find a balance between what you enjoy and earning enough for whatever life it is you want to lead. I am also encouraging my boys to not allow a wife/partner to become financially dependent and to be proactive and as equal as possible when it comes to children. Of course, that also includes looking at how they manage potential illness/disability in either themselves or their children and also redundancy. But it's a fine line between tying up every last penny in insurance premiums and actually enjoying life.

I was a SAHM when my ex walked out. I did well out of the divorce, from a financial perspective at least. My ex has never mentally recovered from it - he considers it unfair and has spent the rest of his life avoiding paying maintenance and generally ducking and diving when it comes to work. It has not been a good look on him. I don't usually like using the word 'bitter' but for him, I'll make an exception.

mindutopia · 25/11/2022 14:58

I think this is much more about personality of parents and the culture of their family/social circles than anything to do with 'the times changing' so to speak.

My mum earned well (for someone with no university level qualifications) and worked in a big corporate job. She tried hard to instil in me to choose a career that I loved over money. She hated her job, though she did it for 30 years, because it was well-paid and she was a single parent.

I'm now an academic. I am certainly not wealthy, but I absolutely do earn well above average for the UK. I'm perfectly comfortable. I never pursued any sort of career based on earnings. I knew exactly what I wanted to do from very young, so it was very heart over head, though it's certainly done me well.

Dh started out pursuing a career in a more typically well-earning field (certainly more so than academia). He hated it. After a couple years, he decided to make a complete career change and start a business doing something he loved. It was profitable from the start, but we weren't rolling in it. But he was so much happier. 10 years on, he earns about 5x his previous salary (over £100K a year).

So for both of us, doing something we love has really paid off. We have a lovely big house and are comfortable and pretty much never worry about money (though saying that, we also aren't extravagant, no fancy cars on finance, rarely have a foreign holiday, we mend rather than buy new clothes as much as possible, buy secondhand, etc.). Dc are definitely growing up learning that being happy and doing what you love is more important that money, but also that if you work hard and have the right amount of luck, you can also have both.

That said, I went to a very hothouse sort of school growing up which was very competitive and everyone's mum/dad was a doctor or a solicitor or worked in the City, and a lot of those kids were very stressed. It wasn't a nice environment. I also don't see any evidence that the ones with pushy parents did especially better in life.

Zippedydoo123 · 25/11/2022 14:43

Jizzle · 25/11/2022 13:43

It's not something I will be talking to my kids about, mostly because by the time they are older (currently DD is 4) I fully suspect the world of work as we know it to have collapsed.

With the changes in the World as they are, I expect that due to energy crises, climate change, food networks, the housing market etc to have completely collapsed and people will be fending for themselves as they see fit. I'll be teaching my daughter usable survival skills, foraging, etc to get her through. We are in the process of moving house to a rather remote location to give us the best chance possible, but of course, nothing is guaranteed.

That's an extreme view.

user564576 · 25/11/2022 14:40

Yes. I was brought up with a very practical non-ambitious attitude, working class family, encouraged to do something I enjoyed but not really encouraged to think about the financial aspects or the lifestyle I wanted from life and how to achieve it. Took me until I was 30 to realise I didn't need to be evangelical or coy about money, that successful people aren't and it's not a "dirty" concept to want to do a job you enjoy AND that pays well. So I slightly retraded into a more lucrative area of my sector and doubled my salary. Still very much enjoy my job, but I do get satisfaction and value from the fact it's paid well too.

So when my son said he wanted to join the RAF, I said great, but have suggested he looks at engineering or cyber security elements for better financial stability and options, obviously not forcefully, it's up to him, but I am trying to get him to think about it, to understand that if he wants the lifestyle we have now (or better!) as an adult, he will need to think about the financial prospects for the careers he's considering.

It's a disservice to children to only encourage them to find what they enjoy, that will only get them so far. You can balance it with security too.

sheepdogdelight · 25/11/2022 14:40

DH and I have both chosen work/life balance over chasing top salaries.

But we both earn pretty good-enough salaries which provide the DC with a good standard of living (and they go to a bog standard comprehensive school so are very aware of how lucky they are).

So I wouldn't encourage my DC to chase money. I would however encourage them to chase "enough money". Living in poverty, or watching every penny is not to be recommended

megletthesecond · 25/11/2022 14:39

I want mine to earn enough to own a house and have private health care if needed. Certainly not flash cars and designer clothes level of wealth.
Although they both wished they could have gone to a private school so I said they'd need to find 20k a year on top if they have children.

karmakameleon · 25/11/2022 14:35

I think it’s really important that young people understand their options.

I remember once on a “if you earn more than 100k, what do you do?” thread that someone said that they had no idea that some of these jobs existed or that they paid so much. If she’s known, she’d have had something to aim for in school and wouldn’t be stuck in low paid work.

I don’t particularly want my children to aim for a high earning career that they have no interest in, but I do want them to be aware of their options and the choices that are available to them. They also need to understand that the lifestyle they are used to isn’t particularly cheap

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 25/11/2022 14:34

I encourage mine to give their best in their education and get as much out of it as they can Being well educated means they then have more doors to choose. If they then choose to work in a coffee shop, that's fine so long as they're happy, but they still have all the tools they need should they want more. Setting the foundations is the bit that really matters.

AriettyHomily · 25/11/2022 14:30

I am encouraging mine to be happy in what they choose but also conscious of salary, I don't want them to scrimping on NMW roles. Money doesn't buy happiness but it buys an easier life. So shoot me down.

Cyantist · 25/11/2022 14:28

I think 60-70k is pretty good, even in London. I'd be happy if my children ended up earning that sort of amount.

I think it's important to do a job you enjoy, but I will be upfront with them about the earning potential of certain careers compared to others.

HerRoyalNotness · 25/11/2022 14:27

I encourage mine to choose something they like doing but also to earn enough that they can live rather than just exist. It’s stressful with not enough income and I’d hate to see them struggle and not be able to enjoy meals out with friends for example or a weekend away, let alone not being able to pay their bills on what they earn

MintJulia · 25/11/2022 14:26

My ds, 14, understands the value of money. He knows that to have the kind of life I provide - occasional skiing, spacious detached house, recent but not flashy car, he needs to achieve a certain level.
At the same time he knows it is important to be happy, and he already knows he does not want to live in a city or work in an office.
For now, he will pursue GCSEs that suit estate management or environment science, and likely to do two science plus maths A'Levels.
Then we'll see where he wants to go from there.

dreamingbohemian · 25/11/2022 14:25

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 14:22

@Autumnalleavestime I think thats a very well formulated point of view. Thank you.

@dreamingbohemian I know that 60-70k is not bad. In London, it's just not that much money. In no way do I have to worry about choosing between eating or heating. But I can also see a clear divide between my siblings who can afford three foreign holidays per year, do live in a very nice house in a nice neighbourhood etc.

I also live in London. I still think it's a lot of money, especially if you are both earning around that.

I'm not having a go, I'm just saying that if you encourage your kids to follow the same path as you, they will still have a rather nice life. So I don't think you should worry about it really. It's not like whether you should encourage your kids to be starving artists or something where they could really struggle.

ShirleyPhallus · 25/11/2022 14:25

Jizzle · 25/11/2022 13:43

It's not something I will be talking to my kids about, mostly because by the time they are older (currently DD is 4) I fully suspect the world of work as we know it to have collapsed.

With the changes in the World as they are, I expect that due to energy crises, climate change, food networks, the housing market etc to have completely collapsed and people will be fending for themselves as they see fit. I'll be teaching my daughter usable survival skills, foraging, etc to get her through. We are in the process of moving house to a rather remote location to give us the best chance possible, but of course, nothing is guaranteed.

This is hilarious but I can’t actually tell if you’re joking

Stickmansmum · 25/11/2022 14:23

I’m not teaching that money is everything but I am teaching them the value of money and how hard earned it is. Also that it brings choice and freedom in life. I just want them to be happy but unlike in the old days, people are very aware of each other now, what they have and have not. What jobs even exist! My parents wouldn’t have even come across let alone been in a position to advise anything about the vast majority of the good jobs available in this world. We have all that info at our fingertips so I’m not going to dumb down the world to my kids by teaching them that money isn’t important. And that they can be happy in any job they choose. Because that is not actually how the world works. As millions of people realise way too late.

ShirleyPhallus · 25/11/2022 14:23

Changechangychange · 25/11/2022 14:19

I really hope that isn’t controversial! It’s just good financial sense.

I’d say the same to DS, FWIW (and obviously followed that advice myself).

Well I didn’t want to offend anyone who had children in their early 20s or the very many women who seem to end up very financially depending on their husbands on these boards!

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 14:22

@Autumnalleavestime I think thats a very well formulated point of view. Thank you.

@dreamingbohemian I know that 60-70k is not bad. In London, it's just not that much money. In no way do I have to worry about choosing between eating or heating. But I can also see a clear divide between my siblings who can afford three foreign holidays per year, do live in a very nice house in a nice neighbourhood etc.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 25/11/2022 14:22

money doesn’t buy happiness, but neither does an average wage

Not true

It's perfectly possible to be happy on an average wage (we are)
Living in poverty, not so much, but average wages, sure

Autumnalleavestime · 25/11/2022 14:19

Jizzle · 25/11/2022 13:43

It's not something I will be talking to my kids about, mostly because by the time they are older (currently DD is 4) I fully suspect the world of work as we know it to have collapsed.

With the changes in the World as they are, I expect that due to energy crises, climate change, food networks, the housing market etc to have completely collapsed and people will be fending for themselves as they see fit. I'll be teaching my daughter usable survival skills, foraging, etc to get her through. We are in the process of moving house to a rather remote location to give us the best chance possible, but of course, nothing is guaranteed.

And if you’re wrong, which clearly it’s overwhelmingly likely you are, what skills and work ethic will you encourage?

what chance are you trying to get, survival? Is that why you’re going to live rurally?

Changechangychange · 25/11/2022 14:19

ShirleyPhallus · 25/11/2022 14:09

And… I accept this might be controversial….

But I would always encourage my daughters to have education and career before having children and ensuring they’re financially independent of any partner they have

I really hope that isn’t controversial! It’s just good financial sense.

I’d say the same to DS, FWIW (and obviously followed that advice myself).

dreamingbohemian · 25/11/2022 14:18

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 14:14

I definitely appreciate that I do speak from a position of privilege but thats what made me ponder. Me and my cohort all had a choice to go one way or another and were all smart and ambitious whether we became university professors or went to work in the city. My siblings, for example, got same grades at same uni as me but picked pharma over a university career; another the Big 4 over working for the civil service etc. In my circle - the only who dont chase promotions but get paid a lot are techies.

I think the point was that for a lot of people, you yourself are on the high-earning path.

I'm in academia but make 36K. My husband is on about 20K. So 60-70K for us is a really high salary and I'd be happy if my son ever had a job like this.

Mildura · 25/11/2022 14:18

"Money can't buy you happiness, but it does bring you a more pleasant form of misery!"

As @BumbleNova says, not having money worries is enormously liberating.

Autumnalleavestime · 25/11/2022 14:17

Yes Totally. My view is if I’m going to work I’m going to do something I’m paid v well for and that I enjoy, but ultimately it’s work. And I want paying as much as possible for every single minute I do,

money doesn’t buy happiness, but neither does an average wage. I never understand this work for the love of it and work,life balance, who the fuck really gets that.

there was an advert a few years back, it was a beautiful house, some decking, I think over looking the sea and it said this is your payment for all those conference calls. And I get that, I don’t want to work the exact same hours to be looking round my run down house wondering if I can afford to heat it.

so yeah too right, study hard when young, go for the high paying profession assuming capable and enjoy it, and yes, money is important. Take your vacations in beautiful places, seethe world on those vacations, live somewhere great and don’t be worrying about bills. Not everyone can achieve it, but yes it’s something I encouraged and still do.

Changechangychange · 25/11/2022 14:14

I wouldn’t encourage DS to work in finance/corporate law etc for the money if he had no particular interest in those areas.

I would steer him away from eg zoo work, veterinary nursing etc which are notoriously badly paid, or acting/art which only a tiny number of people are going to be successful at.

I wouldn’t mind if he wanted to doss about for a couple years in a non-career job (DBro was a ski instructor for a couple of years between school and uni), but he’d need to support himself.

Part of what drove DBro back to uni was the realisation he was working hard all summer just to fund working as a snowboard instructor, but if he got a well paying job he could afford to take a couple of ski trips a year and actually enjoy himself on the mountain instead of spending 12 hours a day doing snowplough turns and picking up fallen five year olds.