Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you raise your kids to care about money when it comes to future career and lifestyle?

140 replies

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 13:24

I have been thinking about what advice I would like to give my kids regarding future jobs and careers - they are both still quite young. Yes, this comes from a position of privilege but has been spurred on my the current financial situation in the UK.

We currently live in London - I went to Oxford, have a PhD and work in academia. I earn ok but clearly not as much as I could be. All of my uni friends are the same - chose not to go into the city and are now on 60-70k in their 40s. They are all in managerial positions but dont seem as interested in chasing promotions or money at any price. Would rather go part time than hit the next salary mile stone. As far as I can tell - we all love what we do and are mainly in the arts, medicine, academia, publishing, think tanks etc.

By contrast, parents at my kids' school and my siblings are quite different and do tend to place a lot of emphasis on material wealth, the next promotion, competitive parenting - making sure you get the next thing, the bigger house, that promotion, become a partner, hit the next milestone. This also translates into how they raise their kids.

When I was younger - I clearly thought that doing something you love that pays less, getting a nice work life balance was better than going into the 'city' (could be anything else) and focusing primarily on the financial side of things. However, now that I have my own kids - and hit 40s - I am beginning to think that maybe my way is not better and actually chasing money and the next promotion, the nicer house and the next best thing is much smarter.

Is it that the world has change and money matters more or that I can grown up so to speak. How do you raise your kids and what do you tell them?

OP posts:
Changes17 · 25/11/2022 15:31

My kids are at secondary school and have both come home at some point this year (year 7 and year 11) and said STEM careers were the way forward because they pay more. There was even a graph of how much you could expect to get paid depending on which A-levels you do on a recent email home from school (spoiler - it's further maths followed by maths- and definitely sciences - and definitely not humanities). My oldest actively wants to be an engineer and has for quite some time, so all well and good in that regard. My youngest wanted to somehow do both acting and law part-time, but is now beginning to hear the STEM message, which I think is a shame..

What I tend to say to both of them is that they need to find what they love – or at least enjoy – otherwise they'll hate doing it day in day out. I also say they should be prepared to do more than one career during their very long working lives, so there's nothing totally final about their first choice. It's not like my parents/grandparents, who were sticking it out for the final salary pension...

LemonSwan · 25/11/2022 15:27

It’s interesting. I am from a group of peers who were all older siblings from well off backgrounds. Everyone has pursued more lower paid passion type routes where as the younger siblings of our group have all gone for the high paid city route. When instilled ethos has been largely the same.

My parents didn’t mind what I did but fully instilled the effort in - effort out ethos. Even down to my university choice of Long 7 year course + professional accredition and my dad warned that I might find these years more enjoyable if I opted for an easier degree (easy as in just knowledge based work and less physical coursework).

I was also into art and they did suggest that wasn’t a good career path as very unstable. I now look at peers who did pursue this work and are doing well so that might not have been the right suggestion.

I am looking at my son and will teach him the above. I do want him to feel he can do anything and make money. I think the confidence that you can is the most important part. When I look at the kids in the nearby very well elite private school I think no one there is being discouraged from being a writer, artist or cello player.

The one exception to the rule I think will be sports based. I think the competitiveness there and short span on money earning potential is not a good route. It also leaves you open to a huge early/ mid life crisis and loss of direction.

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 25/11/2022 15:26

The main thing is to be hardworking. Lots of my friends kids won't get a job at 16 they want it all paid for. Work ethic is priority the rest follows

CottageEmo · 25/11/2022 15:25

Coming from a family where nobody earns more than NMW, my 40K salary is an enormous amount to them (and me!).

I had a breakdown/burnout in my late teens, didn’t get my degree until I was 36, am now doing a Masters.

Being as I had my DDs in my early 20s, they’re now teens, and I spent years working shit jobs on shit wages, so yes, I do chase every promotion/extra qualification etc.

Eldest DD is in Y11, is 16. Predicted 8s/9s across the board; she’s also bilingual and clunky in a third as ExH very rarely uses the third language. She lives and breathes Physics, CompSci and Maths. I have no idea how well they pay as I’m in BioMed/Micro, I only have one friend who works in Tech and earns triple my salary, I’m not daft enough to think that’s a standard salary though.

It’s very easy to say “I don’t push my kids” when you earn 60K + and everyone around you does, presumably there’s large inheritances to be had too.

When you come from fuck all, will be inheriting fuck all, by some random fluke you’re intelligent and so are your children, it’s normal to push them to strive for more.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/11/2022 15:24

I’m very conscious of this- when most of us (30/40yrs old) were being raised, a basic income could guarantee you a home and food- now it doesn’t. I’m teaching my children to aim high as money gives you choice, and also think before you marry/ join finances with someone. Harsh but reality!

SilverSalver · 25/11/2022 15:24

A bit of both.
They grew up in a financially comfortable environment though we are careful with money and don't live extravagently. Happy to spend a lot on travel but not interested in the latest phone or new cars.
I always stressed that very few people are lucky enough to do a job they love and most people settle for something they don't mind as long as it pays enough.
My DC are in their 20s now.
One in tech who earns a lot but finds it a bit dull and the other is a teacher so not well paid but absolutely loves his job and buzzes with enthusiasm. The first one works from home strictly 9 to 5 and the teacher works 60+ hours a week and never has a day off.
Which one is best? Who knows.
Fortunately neither lives in London and both live in a part of the UK which is cheap to buy a house and close to beautiful countriside.

Balletandbooks · 25/11/2022 15:24

I just realised that my parents literally never advised us to think about salary in our chosen careers. It was all about ‘do whatever you are good at / what interests you’. We werent especially well off, but comfortable I guess - both parents teachers in the mid 90s. We had everything we needed and the future felt positive.

My brother and I are mid-earners, but could have had higher salaries if we’d gone another route. I think if I had children now I would be giving more financially focused advice.

user564576 · 25/11/2022 15:22

@healthadvice123 that's fine, but you need to ask 2 questions, not 1. 1) what do you want to DO for work 2) and what do you want to be able to do outside of work?

If travelling and home ownership are really important to a person, it doesn't matter how much they love that low paying job if it's not providing for the other aspects of their life, they probably still won't be happy overall.

It's a balance, it's not either, or.

ProfYaffle · 25/11/2022 15:22

My eldest DC has just started Uni, youngest is choosing A Levels. We talk about what they enjoy, where their talents are, what will pay well, what their work life balance might look like etc Dh and I can say what we like, these pesky kids will insist on having their own opinions 😁

Faultymain5 · 25/11/2022 15:21

ShirleyPhallus · 25/11/2022 14:09

And… I accept this might be controversial….

But I would always encourage my daughters to have education and career before having children and ensuring they’re financially independent of any partner they have

not sure why this would be controversial. Makes sense given the current climate and you only have to read mumsnet to see why independence is best.

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 15:20

If I had a few million in the bank, yup I'd tell them just do what makes you happy.

But I dont have that privilege. And they will have to be able to earn a living in order to fund their life.

So they need something that pays the bill, I dont want them to have to worry about heating their house, or where their next meal is coming from.

So because I dont have the millions already, I will be encouraging them to work hard at school, and hopefully they will do well.

healthadvice123 · 25/11/2022 15:20

@user564576 but that comes with it , mine know the value of money etc
But if they want to become a binmen on £23000 and takes them longer to but a house , so what
Rather that than stuck in a job they hate and suffering ill health etc
Just said to mine stay home and save and try and get on property ladder , be sensible with what you do earn , live within your means etc
We can't all have top paid jobs , flashy homes and cars
What we can do is use the money we earn wisely
Also my dc get to choose their own deStination its their life's not mine to dictate or have expectations of

PlumPudd · 25/11/2022 15:19

@iojlrjgi9893 I think that trying to answer a “should kids be encouraged to chase their dreams or go for a practical financially more rewarding job?” question by looking through the prism of the situation of you and your Oxford uni peers that had a choice of following your dreams and going into arts / medicine vs those that followed the money and went into the city is a bit of a false dichotomy.

If you’re at Oxford and in a position to get a job in either arts / medicine or the city, then you’re already pretty far removed from the usual experience.

Personally I think kids should be given an empathetic dose of reality, alongside being presented with a range of job options and being told what the prospects of the job will be / what their likelihood of getting into that job is / what the day to day reality of it will be. Being told to live your dreams, that money doesn’t buy happiness and that you anyone can do anything they set their mind too, is usually wrong and damaging imo.

I went to a standard northern state school, and the number of kids who in the meagre career counselling we got said their dream was to be a footballer, dancer, guardian journalist, actor, novelist, movie director, astronaut and got cheered on was staggering. Whereas the two kids that said they wanted to be a gardener and a nurse got the piss ripped out of them. Yeah there will be some kids who beat the odds, but the reality is that most of the aspiring footballers, actors and guardian columnists out there, could probably benefit from being sat down and told how unrealistic that is and / or how unlikely they are to get into that profession without connections and independent means. And steered towards something a bit more realistic that will also allow them a decent work life balance and enough money to be okay.

user564576 · 25/11/2022 15:18

@healthadvice123 see it's your kind of ignorance (don't mean that as harsh as that sounds written down) as to why so many people have limits put on them. You make it sound unattainable without huge sacrifice. I earn well, doing a job I enjoy and have excellent work life balance. I work flexi, I've never missed a school play, sports day, I'm home more than they are. It isn't either/or. It's this kind of black and white thinking that stops people being ambitious and think they can only have time or money.

user1494050295 · 25/11/2022 15:18

I bang on to my daughter the importance of financial independence and education

Hoppinggreen · 25/11/2022 15:17

We try to teach our DC that while money doesn’t bring happiness on its own it certainly helps - and a lot of people who say that money isn’t important actually have plenty so it can come from a place of privilege.
We are quite well off and they go/went to Private school (Secondary only so they did mix with a wider range of kids Pre Y7) but we aren’t in the league of some families there.
Luckily it seems not to matter and to be honest there’s not much they want that they don’t have - they aren’t very materialistic though which helps!
DS does want a career that earns well, although at 13 he’s not sure what yet. DD is hoping to do a degree that doesn’t traditionally lead to a well paid job but it’s something interesting that she feels passionate about.
We give to charity and DD has helped me with the street kitchen a few times and they know how privileged they are but I do think that having money can go either way - it can make you complacent about earning it or make you more determined to

healthadvice123 · 25/11/2022 15:17

@caringcarer this all sounds sensible advice
One if my friends son works in a bar but he is saving for a house and will probably have one before my son who is just at uni and be a few years in paying a mortgage before my son even leaves
This lad is sensible with money although on nmW so will still do ok , there lots of ways to go around things
And the fact the OP thinks £60-70 k isn't a lot shows how out if touch mumsnet is really with most when the average is half that

SynchOrSwim · 25/11/2022 15:15

Only posted half of what I wrote for some reason. Basically they are very into survival skills, growing food, purifying water etc. I don't know if its a big trend or specific to this homeschooling group.

user564576 · 25/11/2022 15:15

All I want is for my kids to be happy

That's how I was raised, but tbh it wasn't very practical and helpful, financial stability is an important part of happiness. I do wish I was challenged a bit by parents to really think through my career choice and what it afforded me outside of work.

healthadvice123 · 25/11/2022 15:13

Also why would anyone encourage their kids to be unhappy , doing a stressful job they don't want or like and then burning out
Also you can have the best paid job in the world and things can still go tits up ,
I think as we are more working class we are more get a job , one you enjoy as its a long time working
And work / life balance is important

SynchOrSwim · 25/11/2022 15:12

caringcarer · 25/11/2022 15:05

@ShirleyPhallus, wow, do you really think the world as we know it will end and we will all need to forage?

I know a few people like this and they all went antivax and removed their kids from school during lockdowns and take them to allp

healthadvice123 · 25/11/2022 15:08

@Autumnalleavestime plenty of people of average wages are happy we are
And i valued time with my kids over money as money can't buy that
We have holidays and plans for once in a lifetime holidays we have to save for , but then we appreciate it all that more
And finishing at set time each days means we have been there for kids and taken them where they needed with ease.
Money often changes people and not always for the better
Plenty of people are happy and without people doing average jobs who would be collecting your bins etc

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 25/11/2022 15:08

I have chosen to not sugar coat life for my son. We don't have a great deal of money, but aren't in debt, however we don't own any assets so materially we are poor. He is very money orientated, so I have told him that life isn't fair and a lot of people in positions of power that earn a lot of money usually get there by who they know as much as how well they did at school, and have emphasised he needs to work harder to be successful.

We also teach the importance of being charitable when you have been successful, and that material wealth doesn't equal happiness, but it does lead to less stress and more options to enjoy life. Just told him the truth really.

It's upto him what he does with that knowledge. I can't push my son too much at home as I don't have time, so hope he manages to find some grit himself.

caringcarer · 25/11/2022 15:05

@ShirleyPhallus, wow, do you really think the world as we know it will end and we will all need to forage?

caringcarer · 25/11/2022 15:03

I taught all my now adult children

  1. to prioritise making decent sized pension payments. Retirement seems so far away but it creeps up on you.
  2. To try to develop themselves as far as they can academically. To stretch their minds. Not to be afraid to return to learning later in life.
  3. To choose an occupation they will be happy in and enjoy because they are likely to be working until they are 70.
  4. To buy a house first and leave having children until you can definately afford them.
  5. Save for a rainy day. Always have 3 months salary stashed away in case you lose your job.
  6. Take out life insurance and critical injury insurance.
  7. To ask for help if you need it. Don't be too proud to ask Mum and Step-Dad for help or advise.