Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you raise your kids to care about money when it comes to future career and lifestyle?

140 replies

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 13:24

I have been thinking about what advice I would like to give my kids regarding future jobs and careers - they are both still quite young. Yes, this comes from a position of privilege but has been spurred on my the current financial situation in the UK.

We currently live in London - I went to Oxford, have a PhD and work in academia. I earn ok but clearly not as much as I could be. All of my uni friends are the same - chose not to go into the city and are now on 60-70k in their 40s. They are all in managerial positions but dont seem as interested in chasing promotions or money at any price. Would rather go part time than hit the next salary mile stone. As far as I can tell - we all love what we do and are mainly in the arts, medicine, academia, publishing, think tanks etc.

By contrast, parents at my kids' school and my siblings are quite different and do tend to place a lot of emphasis on material wealth, the next promotion, competitive parenting - making sure you get the next thing, the bigger house, that promotion, become a partner, hit the next milestone. This also translates into how they raise their kids.

When I was younger - I clearly thought that doing something you love that pays less, getting a nice work life balance was better than going into the 'city' (could be anything else) and focusing primarily on the financial side of things. However, now that I have my own kids - and hit 40s - I am beginning to think that maybe my way is not better and actually chasing money and the next promotion, the nicer house and the next best thing is much smarter.

Is it that the world has change and money matters more or that I can grown up so to speak. How do you raise your kids and what do you tell them?

OP posts:
ghostyslovesheets · 25/11/2022 16:10

AriettyHomily · 25/11/2022 16:00

No offence but that's not careers advice I'd like my children to have.

No offence taken - I am talking about my own children not young people I work with professionally - in my professional life I am always led by their ideas and interests - I never give my own opinion or steer them.

Buildingthefuture · 25/11/2022 16:10

Money doesn’t make you happy, but it does give you choices. So, it depends on what you want and everyone is different. If you want designer things, a big house and a flash car, then you need to earn enough to give you that lifestyle and certain careers just won’t. If you prefer free time over disposal income, aren’t fussed about house/car etc then you can make different choices, although the current cost of living crisis calls that into question. Personally, I stress the importance of independence….if you want it, you earn it. Don’t rely on anyone else, earn enough to support the lifestyle YOU want and try to understand that the choices you make now, even as teenagers, will affect that.

CottageEmo · 25/11/2022 16:07

Notcontent · 25/11/2022 15:52

Yes - this is so important. It is so depressing to read over and over about women who have no qualifications, stuck at home with small children and no money…

I was one of those women, a decade ago. Didn’t help that my ex viewed his job as so important that I didn’t need one/shouldn’t want one/etc (older than me). He absolutely could have afforded to fund me through college/Uni, but he wanted me stuck at home.

The idea was reinforced by not just my working class, in poverty SAHMs in my family, but by the middle class, wealthy SAHMs in his family.

I grew up with zero guidance on careers - what are they? Factory work/retail/hair/beauty is what everyone in my immediate and extended family work in. They didn’t have a clue what to do with my straight A grade self, they didn’t have a clue about A Levels or University and my school didn’t offer any advice or guidance either

Within a year of leaving him, I was on an Access course. The following year, doing my UG. I was still broke as fuck, but I was making progress.

He made a sneery comment last month about how I still don’t earn as much as he does, I simply replied with “Not yet, no”, which infuriated him.

Eldest DD said to me “I think what you’ve done is amazing, and I’m so proud of you. But fuck this. Even if I weren’t a lesbian, there’s not a chance I would be doing life backwards like this.”

fannyfartlet · 25/11/2022 16:03

Depends what they want. Several of my friends have done as you have and settled for lower paying but more satisfying jobs. A handful of my friends went off into the "city" and earn 7 figures but don't seem any happier.

AriettyHomily · 25/11/2022 16:00

ghostyslovesheets · 25/11/2022 15:47

No - I don't focus on money as the key thing

I value education as a route out of poverty and as a force for change but not that money should be the key driver in career choice.

You could get paid £300 an hour to sit in a dark room and press a button every 30 seconds - you'd go mad within a month but be well paid. You could also get paid £15 an hour to do something that makes you feel fulfilled - and you'd do that for years and be happy.

I'm a careers adviser by profession and have always encouraged my 3 to follow what they love and not what pays the most - one is aiming for the Civil Service/government, one for social work/education and who know what the youngest will be passionate about.

I'm on an okay wage but I love my job, I'm passionate about it and I make small differences to kids lives.

No offence but that's not careers advice I'd like my children to have.

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 15:58

@NellyBarney yes, my experience at the moment - is that it's the techies that still love and earn. Honestly, a lot of generic city professionals that am friends with only do it to afford the holidays and keep talking about retiring but havent yet. A lot of the lawyers also dont seem to love it though at their level of seniority do have more flexibility plus a high income than a lot of other jobs.

OP posts:
DarkShade · 25/11/2022 15:57

I don't think you realise how much you all have already prioritised money. Perhaps you don't "work in the city" but 60-70 k is a decent salary. If you also love what you do then what's the problem? Sounds like you've done ok for yourself.

Loads of people work hard at jobs they don't like for half that money. It's all perspective.

NellyBarney · 25/11/2022 15:55

I would like them to know as much as possible about the world of work - what jobs there are, what are different sectors of industry, what they pay, what you have to do to get into a particular career ... but then it is up to them to decide what matters to them and what they would enjoy most. It's not though that jobs in the city (in finance, tech or law) are not fun - for the right person, they will be more enjoyable than a career in academia. I went to Oxford and then went on to do a D.Phil., stayed on for more post doc research, went into non profit afterwards - and now I am a stay at home mum as it didn't pay enough to warrant the hassle and childcare costs, and I can't say I am missing my work much. My dh went to Cambridge, did a PhD, went into tech and finance and still works in the city and loves it, earns 20x what I did but would do it without pay (he did while working at 2 start ups, and is planning another go at another start up). So dd and ds are definitely more inspired by dh then by me (I worked ft until oldest dc was 10), and youngest one is planning already to start up a company with him, so we are telling them they will need maths, science and computer science skills for that and they took up coding clubs etc.

IhearyouClemFandango · 25/11/2022 15:53

We discuss money as being important for security, and to give you choices. There is no emphasis on it as being important for happiness or whatever.

They need to know what different things pay, so they can make choices about the lifestyle they want.

Echobelly · 25/11/2022 15:52

Not really. Oldest wants to be a music therapist, and maybe do some music performance on the side (they are only 14 though). I haven't broached with them the fact that those won't pay much, although I think they're aware. There's a reasonable amount of money in the family and they're likely to inherit something decent, but probably not until they're in middle age.

It's a bridge that's to cross when you come to it, I guess. I certainly wouldn't want to say to my kids that they should only aim for high paying jobs, but when they're getting towards decisions they may affect careers, I would probably make them aware if they're looking at something without much earning potential.

Notcontent · 25/11/2022 15:52

ShirleyPhallus · 25/11/2022 14:09

And… I accept this might be controversial….

But I would always encourage my daughters to have education and career before having children and ensuring they’re financially independent of any partner they have

Yes - this is so important. It is so depressing to read over and over about women who have no qualifications, stuck at home with small children and no money…

TheaBrandt · 25/11/2022 15:50

Shining your post is intriguing- you are encouraging your sons not to have a partner dependent on them but you were a sahm yourself and did well out of your divorce? Not criticising just seems unusual!

bonnielochs · 25/11/2022 15:48

I teach my children to think outside the box. They are both in secondary school and the Careers Advisors throw the usual suspects around as suggestions (trades, admin, art school, medicine, law, social subjects blah blah). I tell my kids that all of the things they enjoy in this world....its someone's job to create that. Don't think small or "obvious", think outsife the box...costume designer for movies, SFX makeup, animator or marketing for video games, nature photographer, sports writer etc. If you enjoy it, why not consider how to make money from it as a career, basically.

I also try to teach them that if you want things, you need to work for it. So, when my kids tell me they want an Audi Q7 and 3 huskies when they're older I say "Cool, you'll need a pretty good job to afford that". They need to realise that they can aim for the stars and want nice things....but they need to back that up with hard work and a high tier role to bankroll it!

ghostyslovesheets · 25/11/2022 15:47

No - I don't focus on money as the key thing

I value education as a route out of poverty and as a force for change but not that money should be the key driver in career choice.

You could get paid £300 an hour to sit in a dark room and press a button every 30 seconds - you'd go mad within a month but be well paid. You could also get paid £15 an hour to do something that makes you feel fulfilled - and you'd do that for years and be happy.

I'm a careers adviser by profession and have always encouraged my 3 to follow what they love and not what pays the most - one is aiming for the Civil Service/government, one for social work/education and who know what the youngest will be passionate about.

I'm on an okay wage but I love my job, I'm passionate about it and I make small differences to kids lives.

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 25/11/2022 15:47

user564576 · 25/11/2022 15:15

All I want is for my kids to be happy

That's how I was raised, but tbh it wasn't very practical and helpful, financial stability is an important part of happiness. I do wish I was challenged a bit by parents to really think through my career choice and what it afforded me outside of work.

I had the same experience. They are great, but they live very simply and are happy, but I think the world has got tougher since they were young and just working a basic job doesn't provide enough to be happy. I wish they pushed me more and offered more guidance rather than leaving me to it, because I have little security in old age. I don't blame them, but I think this would have helped.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/11/2022 15:45

I think the message is different for girls because they have a biological clock- career changes and chasing the arts wasting a few years has a big knock on effect, less so for men

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/11/2022 15:45

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 15:39

I also do wonder whether the happiness versus money is a generational thing. In the 90s, we certainly got told to do what you love and everyone from teachers to doctors to university profs could afford a family home in London. By the time my siblings finished uni in 2010s - I think the message had changed. I only have boys, but they seem to quite enjoy humanities/social sciences though my whole family is in STEM. It made me wonder whether I need to push them more into STEM as that brings more money at the moment

I think you're right.

My generation (born early 70s, middle class family) was raised by parents who had probably the best set of economic circumstances ever known in this country. When my parents were working they could literally take their pick of any career they wanted. If you had a degree you had a golden ticket to anything you wanted to do. My mum didn't even have a degree and still ended up with a pucker job. My parents were obsessed with us finding "interesting" jobs, which was partly a status thing but also I think reflective of the environment at the time.

By the time I was looking for work in the early 90s with a not particularly stellar degree, things were MUCH harder and they are far harder now. It's not enough just to have a degree. You have to be much more focused about what you want if you want to make enough money to support yourself (certainly in the SE).

This will have a massive influence on the careers advice you give girls in particular. I wouldn't push my DD into doing something massively well paid if she hated it, but the bottom line is money is important, particularly for girls. Girls need to be able to support themselves. And I would be careful about supporting her to go into a very precarious career just because it was "creative" or "interesting" at dinner parties.

thecatsthecats · 25/11/2022 15:45

One thing that I think is worth considering is that if you gun for a massive salary - and achieve it - then you can much more easily take the pedal off later.

I earned a big salary quickly (and my friend an even bigger one much more quickly) - now I'm aged 33, mortgage in a good place due to aggressive pay downs. I work PT, am retraining, and looking to take a 3 day role/set up my own business, selling lucrative skills.

I don't think that's the worst plan, though in my case it happened by accident. Use your twenties working hard and playing hard, and ease the pedal off thirties onwards.

forrestgreen · 25/11/2022 15:40

It's part of a package. They knew we needed money to pay bills and if we had more we had more fun.
I steered them into areas they were good at and enjoyed, we talked about how to financially make the most of that, so they could have a house, car etc

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 15:39

I also do wonder whether the happiness versus money is a generational thing. In the 90s, we certainly got told to do what you love and everyone from teachers to doctors to university profs could afford a family home in London. By the time my siblings finished uni in 2010s - I think the message had changed. I only have boys, but they seem to quite enjoy humanities/social sciences though my whole family is in STEM. It made me wonder whether I need to push them more into STEM as that brings more money at the moment

OP posts:
sheepdogdelight · 25/11/2022 15:38

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 15:32

I think it depends on privilege.

If you're rich, then the kids can afford to be an " artist" or "novelist", and it doenst matter if they fail, cos they have the financial security of mum and dad to fall back on.

I'm from working class roots, I have to work hard even if I hate my job. I havent been able to earn enough to protect my kids from that, so I do try and push them to do well in school.

Yes absolutely this.
thinking of someone I know who says "oh I was never career minded and I can't understand why people would work full time when they have children", whilst pursuing her 3 or 4 hours a week "hobby" job.

Cunningly forgetting that her parents bought and furnished her a house and pay for her children to go to private school, thus enabling her family to have a good standard of living on a single salary.

Very easy to not care about money when you are given plenty of it!

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/11/2022 15:35

It slightly depends on whether you have boys or girls tbh.

I was raised with the idea that you prioritise finding something you enjoy and that fits around your life and that is the best route to happiness. My parents pushed me to achieve but they emphasised that ultimately it was more important to have an interesting and rewarding job than one which pays incredibly well. In general I still hew towards this view: I think its very important to enjoy what you do.

The older I get, though the more I realise that the ability to make money is perhaps more important for girls, because I think its incredibly important that girls not be raised to think of making money as an afterthought. And because the default is often that men become the breadwinner in a marriage.

Girls have to be able to support themselves financially to avoid financial abuse and the trap of living off a man. If they choose to take some time off work to raise children and are with a man they trust, so be it, but it should never be the default that you raise girls in the expectation that they will derive their financial support from marriage.

So its easy to say people should place happiness over making money and as a general principle its true. But if that becomes an excuse to take your foot off the pedal and rely on someone else to do the financial heavy lifting its a bit of a slippery slope.

Babymamaroon · 25/11/2022 15:32

Short answer is yes. It's all about creating the building blocks for happiness. In order to earn well, they need to achieve good grades. Good grades will open their options for universities and courses. A good degree will enable a fast start for a career, which in turn will lead to earning more money more quickly. This leads to lower financial stress, more options for fun and sparkle.

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 15:32

I think it depends on privilege.

If you're rich, then the kids can afford to be an " artist" or "novelist", and it doenst matter if they fail, cos they have the financial security of mum and dad to fall back on.

I'm from working class roots, I have to work hard even if I hate my job. I havent been able to earn enough to protect my kids from that, so I do try and push them to do well in school.

Cuddlywuddlies · 25/11/2022 15:31

The advice I’ll give is the same as what my parents told me…
•do something that you have an interest in and that you will enjoy on the most part
•work hard no matter what you do, always do your best but don’t be made a mug of!
•be as independent as you can
•try to make your wage AT LEAST match your age
•save for a rainy day!