Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you raise your kids to care about money when it comes to future career and lifestyle?

140 replies

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 13:24

I have been thinking about what advice I would like to give my kids regarding future jobs and careers - they are both still quite young. Yes, this comes from a position of privilege but has been spurred on my the current financial situation in the UK.

We currently live in London - I went to Oxford, have a PhD and work in academia. I earn ok but clearly not as much as I could be. All of my uni friends are the same - chose not to go into the city and are now on 60-70k in their 40s. They are all in managerial positions but dont seem as interested in chasing promotions or money at any price. Would rather go part time than hit the next salary mile stone. As far as I can tell - we all love what we do and are mainly in the arts, medicine, academia, publishing, think tanks etc.

By contrast, parents at my kids' school and my siblings are quite different and do tend to place a lot of emphasis on material wealth, the next promotion, competitive parenting - making sure you get the next thing, the bigger house, that promotion, become a partner, hit the next milestone. This also translates into how they raise their kids.

When I was younger - I clearly thought that doing something you love that pays less, getting a nice work life balance was better than going into the 'city' (could be anything else) and focusing primarily on the financial side of things. However, now that I have my own kids - and hit 40s - I am beginning to think that maybe my way is not better and actually chasing money and the next promotion, the nicer house and the next best thing is much smarter.

Is it that the world has change and money matters more or that I can grown up so to speak. How do you raise your kids and what do you tell them?

OP posts:
iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 20:01

@JackandVera exactly. the point is that it could be at any level - thats just my story - i had a clear choice one way or the other and am now rethinking whether I would advise my kids to do the same.

Obviously we dont all have to live in London but my whole family is here, my job is here, support network etc. You could say the same thing at any other financial level especially outside London.

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 25/11/2022 20:01

Of course. I talk to ds's about all these things: doing a job you like, that most people have bits of their job they don't like as much, money and promotions, work-life balance. Changing jobs in later life. Why would you not have these conversations?

TheaBrandt · 25/11/2022 19:59

We went to the City made as much money as we could to set ourselves up - then left. Would definitely recommend that approach.

JackandVera · 25/11/2022 19:56

DarkShade · 25/11/2022 15:57

I don't think you realise how much you all have already prioritised money. Perhaps you don't "work in the city" but 60-70 k is a decent salary. If you also love what you do then what's the problem? Sounds like you've done ok for yourself.

Loads of people work hard at jobs they don't like for half that money. It's all perspective.

She hasn't "prioritised money" - she has ended up being well rewarded for a job she loves and which she worked hard for.

JackandVera · 25/11/2022 19:53

I would always say to a young person that nothing is forever. If you get into something that you really don't like then you can find an alternate path. eg one of mine was like this with investment banking - hated it so decided to make a career move fortunately to another lucrative area. He had grown up in a comfortable environment and knew that to do or get the things he grew up with he had to do well at school, Uni etc. Fortunately he has an active and ambitious mind and is now in a well paid job he loves.
Other extended members of our family are not the same - one is working in B and M having given up his Uni after a term. Sadly he is too comfortable in his parents' house but very comfortable in his job which helps with his anxiety. He however can't even afford to move out of his parents' home as he can't afford to on a B and M wage. How can he ever hope to save for a deposit? I would never say to a young person to do a job that they hate for the money but they do have to realise that a decent well paying career brings present and future rewards.

misssunshine4040 · 25/11/2022 18:13

Jizzle · 25/11/2022 13:43

It's not something I will be talking to my kids about, mostly because by the time they are older (currently DD is 4) I fully suspect the world of work as we know it to have collapsed.

With the changes in the World as they are, I expect that due to energy crises, climate change, food networks, the housing market etc to have completely collapsed and people will be fending for themselves as they see fit. I'll be teaching my daughter usable survival skills, foraging, etc to get her through. We are in the process of moving house to a rather remote location to give us the best chance possible, but of course, nothing is guaranteed.

Envy a tad dramatic no?

Hobbi · 25/11/2022 18:06

Only on MN do you find folk who think £60-£70K each isn't much money.

TimBoothseyes · 25/11/2022 17:28

CottageEmo · 25/11/2022 17:24

If you were subject to the insecurity of private rentals, the eye watering price per month, the horrendous hoops to jump through to even get a viewing that stop just short of demanding a blood sample, the inability to get any repairs done without serious risk of a S21, you would want to buy a house.

But I'm not. TBH I've never wanted to buy a house....I would have if that was the only option available to me in order to be able to have a roof over my head but I'm fortunate enough to have been given this home so it's not.

CottageEmo · 25/11/2022 17:24

TimBoothseyes · 25/11/2022 17:20

I suppose it depends on how materialistic a person is. For example, I have all I need which includes 1 t.v which is a non smart 38" (never felt the need for one in any other room but the lounge), a very basic mobile phone (I have a p.c for anything I need to do online), and a second hand reliable car that gets me from A -B. My home is rented from the HA and I have no desire to own my own home (I can hear the collective MN gasp of horror about that from here), and, although I enjoy a weekend away from time to time, I can take or leave holidays. My job pays enough for me to live on, and have some left over I enjoy it and the hours suit me just fine, but progression and/or a career is not for me. I don't need the stress of it when I'm perfectly happy as I am.

If you were subject to the insecurity of private rentals, the eye watering price per month, the horrendous hoops to jump through to even get a viewing that stop just short of demanding a blood sample, the inability to get any repairs done without serious risk of a S21, you would want to buy a house.

TimBoothseyes · 25/11/2022 17:20

I suppose it depends on how materialistic a person is. For example, I have all I need which includes 1 t.v which is a non smart 38" (never felt the need for one in any other room but the lounge), a very basic mobile phone (I have a p.c for anything I need to do online), and a second hand reliable car that gets me from A -B. My home is rented from the HA and I have no desire to own my own home (I can hear the collective MN gasp of horror about that from here), and, although I enjoy a weekend away from time to time, I can take or leave holidays. My job pays enough for me to live on, and have some left over I enjoy it and the hours suit me just fine, but progression and/or a career is not for me. I don't need the stress of it when I'm perfectly happy as I am.

shiningstar2 · 25/11/2022 17:13

Hmm. It's a difficult one. We encourage DD to do her best at school because the bits of paper you accumulate are not of intrinsic value of themselves but they do provide more options in life. We were not money orientated ourselves because we had enough to live on and were very happy in our marriage. We pulled together and shared everything and with that attitude from both of us our money seemed to stretch a lot further than some of our friends with similar incomes.
DD saw this but it was all she knew and kind of took it for granted I think that things would work out in a similar way for her.
She did get the bit about working hard and that you should strive for an income which provided reasonably for a more comfortable life.
I wish I had emphasised more about choosing a life partner and how that impacts on every area of life. Her teaching job paya reasonably (by no means mega bucks) but if she had married a man on a similar income (or any income) she and her family would be relatively comfortable.
As it is, her income is just above UC threshold and her husband has mental health problems and hasn't worked at all for 15 years. Being the sole provider, ,keeping the roof over the families head, the food on the table and the ca on the drive ve, while supporting his mental health and holding down a demanding job with no financial help whatsoever makes for a difficult work life balance
Long post to get around to saying, in her growing up years I wish I had said more about choosing a partner who will pull together with you. In the long run I think that is even more important than looking for the big bucks jobs.

Vookibooki · 25/11/2022 17:06

@user564576 Ive also lived in leaky moldy shitholes, and i now live in a nice warm comfortable 3bed house. I drive a second hand old car. Shop in Lidl. Work for a charity organisation with issues i deeply care about.

I value my higher education, the salary i get and i honestly dont need 'more'. I always tell my dc that they need to choose a career or profession that makes enough money to get them a nice home, transportation and enough food. But that money isnt the be all and end all.

ghostyslovesheets · 25/11/2022 17:01

A house doesn't have to be in London and cost £46746744 though - I often find these threads so focused on being a top earner and having things. I'm perfectly happy in my little semi in the Midlands which I can afford despite my not high earning job - there is a middle ground - having a job that makes you happy and having a modest comfortable life - which is perfectly possible without needing to earn £150k +

Notanotherone6 · 25/11/2022 16:53

I'll tell them to do what make them happy and not to listen to the bullshit that people sometimes post online.

user564576 · 25/11/2022 16:48

@Vookibooki having lived in a few shitholes I promise you my house gives me SO MUCH happiness. Do you really think people living in damp and squalor aren't miserable? Of course there's a ceiling, but I am much happier now in my better paying, more corporate job with nice house than I was in my "hobby" job, small house, no holidays, because my lifestyle makes me happy, and my lifestyle needs funding 🤷‍♀️

PortiasBiscuit · 25/11/2022 16:45

DD is applying to do Fine Art at university, so No!

Vookibooki · 25/11/2022 16:43

No, i would never encourage my kids to get into this mental and literal rat race. There is so much more to life. That house, promotion, status etc is not the real substance that gives you happiness/fullfillment.

bangersandmash2 · 25/11/2022 16:40

Despite your line of enquiry / pondering your post still reads like you think the school parents are wrong and that you sneer at their attitude to money, so it seems unlikely you'll encourage your children to follow in their footsteps!

daretodenim · 25/11/2022 16:39

Parents of DS(11) friend are both in finance and both very money oriented. The friend and his older brother are being pushed hard academically and taught the price, not value, of expensive things. Think driving down the road with a kid in the car who prices every car that passes and judges it based on the price. Nothing is good unless it's expensive.

There's no way this kid could ever choose what he wants to be. No chance of becoming a nurse or paramedic or even a doctor. He's been/being groomed to have a job that pays extremely well. His worth is already inherently being tied to it. I find it heartbreaking, but horses for courses I guess.

And it's true they have an incredible house. Have top notch 4x4s and holidays (plural) that for us would be once in a lifetime things.

But I don't see that they're really happy.

I think it's about getting the balance between having what you need plus enough of what you like, but also having a life outside work.

I also know other millionaires who are penny-pinching and suck the joy out of life by watching spending on most things.

It's not money that makes you happy. It's not the experiences it can buy either. It's a general balance. That can be different for everybody, but once kids are in the picture then overall, you need a bit higher income without ridiculous extra hours at work, and to be happier with materially a bit less.

So I'm encouraging my kids along those lines. Trying to steer them to choosing areas of work that interest them, offer opportunities for advancement and learning. But won't mean sacrificing their lives to the office/work.

And when they point out that the friend has a mahoooooosive TV in his playroom that's bigger than my kids' bedrooms combined, I tell them they can also buy that when they're older, if they work hard at maths and work in finance. It's in their reach, if they want it, it's up to them.

GarlandsinGreece · 25/11/2022 16:36

We are in the extremely fortunate position of being able to buy our two sons houses when they graduate university, thus reducing the pressure on them to get a job that pays $$$ (we live in a high COL area). I want them to be disciplined about their career path, but equally I want them to be passionate about whatever they choose, whether that’s working for a non-profit, running a small business or becoming a portfolio manager.

iojlrjgi9893 · 25/11/2022 16:35

I definitely agree that kids need to know about salaries once you hit mid-level career levels. Lots of entry jobs/graduate scheme pay similar but diverge quite a bit later on. It's quite frustrating that in reality there is sort of a ceiling when it comes to academic jobs. Life is also unpredictable and I guess it seemed like a reasonable career choice years ago.

OP posts:
TimBoothseyes · 25/11/2022 16:32

No. I always told DD that as long as she earns enough for what she needs it's up to her to decide on her "wants" and what is needed to get it.

topcat2014 · 25/11/2022 16:24

Dd is 16 and has her first Saturday job on 9.50 hr. I am keen she understands money needs to be earned. I do give pocket money as well. She will enjoy the boardmasters gig next summer having paid for the tickets as well.

I will be encouraging her to keep away from careers that have an absolute ceiling on earnings.

I did think I was a higher earner until I read this thread, now it seems I am just coasting:)

bobtheveryoldBuilder · 25/11/2022 16:20

I think I have a good answer to this one. I say they should aim for whatever job they want, AS LONG AS they earn enough money to have the life style THEY want. We know penniless artists and super rich business owners, in varying degrees of happiness. If they want their own flat, new iPhones and nice holidays then they better get themselves on the grad scheme in whatever industry they find interesting. If they want to work three days a week and live on the breadline, then they can, it's up to them.

I say that generally all jobs are hard work, .i.e as min wage job stacking shelves is going to be just as hard day to day as a job in the city. Just in a different way. There's no 'easy jobs' so you might as well get well paid for what you do. In the end if a job is 'good' or not is usually all about your manager and not much else.

StuckInTheUpsideDown · 25/11/2022 16:13

I want my children to be cognisant of what different jobs pay and what is involved in them. Enjoyment by itself is fine but unless you come from money that will help prop you up then it is a perfectly sensible thing to take into account when choosing your path in life.

So you want to be a classroom teacher and don’t want to “chase promotion”? That’s great we need plenty of good teacher. And I certainly it wouldn’t tell people to forget teaching and become a hedge fund manager or whatever just because the pay is better. But go into teaching knowing what what it will pay and what that buys you versus other jobs so you can make a conscious decision that it is the right path.

I would also add that whilst you can also get info easily on what graduate jobs pay, it isn’t as immediately obvious what more senior jobs pay. Data is out there, salary surveys for example, but you have to know what the jobs are and where to look. And as you’ll have seen on 100k threads there are loads of jobs, particularly in the city/higher end financial services that pay very well that were never on the radar as a traditional professional and people who don’t work in those industries would have no idea exists.