Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad that the Down Syndrome abortion appeal was defeated

904 replies

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 12:30

A woman with DS has twice tried and failed to get the courts to outlaw abortion beyond 24 weeks for foetuses with DS. Under current legislation for England, Wales and Scotland, there is a 24-week time limit for abortion, unless "there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped", which includes Down's syndrome.
I read that she has is being supported by some religious group.

I’m glad that the appeal was lost. This is a personal decision that every woman has the choice and the right to make. What Heidi Crowter et al are doing, is fighting to remove that choice from women. AIBU?

OP posts:
BloodAndFire · 27/11/2022 20:05

The doctors were found to be at fault in multiple ways:

The Health Service Executive (HSE) and Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) conducted an investigation. Both criticized the team for not diagnosing the sepsis soon enough and for not using already-standard screening tools for detecting and managing maternal sepsis, and for poor keeping of medical records, poor communication at shift changes, and failure to notify staff with needed expertise, and criticized the administration of the hospital for the poor system in which the team failed. They made recommendations about training and policies for the hospital locally along with a number of national recommendations, including the creation of a laboratory system to coordinate a national response to emerging microbial threats.The HSE also recommended changes to the legal situation and training of doctors about the law.

The law in force at the time stated that the act of abortion, where there was no immediate physiological threat to the woman's life to continue the pregnancy, was a criminal offence punishable by life imprisonment. Following a ruling of the Supreme Court of Ireland in 1992 – now known in Ireland as the X case – terminations are allowed under certain circumstances, where "a pregnant woman's life is at risk because of pregnancy, including the risk of suicide".[14] However at the time of Halappanavar's death, there was legal uncertainty regarding the precise circumstances in which this exception to preserve the life of the mother would apply in practice, as the matter had not yet been enacted in legislation.

the jury returned a verdict of medical misadventure.

The doctors and nurses were poorly trained. They did not communicate properly.

Earlier, the consultant obstetrician who treated Mrs Halappanavar has told the inquest there was a "systems failure" in the care that was given to her.
Dr Katherine Astbury said Mrs Halappanavar's clinical signs were not checked every four hours after her membranes ruptured, which was a breach of hospital policy.
She told the inquest that when Mrs Halappanavar requested a termination from her on the morning of 23 October, she outlined the legal position to her.
She said that Mrs Halappanavar had told her she was finding it very upsetting and difficult given that the ultimate outcome would be that her baby would not survive.
Dr Astbury told her "in this country it is not legal to terminate a pregnancy on the grounds of poor prognosis for a foetus".
She said it was her view that Mrs Halappanavar was emotionally disturbed, but not physically unwell.
She told Mr Halappanavar's barrister, Eugene Gleeson, that she felt at the time the prospect of viability for the foetus was poor as opposed to being non-existent.
The phrase "inevitable miscarriage" had been recorded in medical notes by a colleague of Dr Astbury on 22 October.
Dr Astbury told Mr Gleeson that "the law in Ireland does not permit termination even if there is no prospect of viability".
She said this was her understanding based on the X Case judgment and Medical Council guidelines.
Dr Astbury told Mr Gleeson it did not occur to her to consult her colleagues about the legal position.

The doctor was not in a terrible position of thinking she would be imprisoned for 20 years. Rather 'it did not occur to her to ask'.

And the midwife:

The midwife manager on St Monica's Ward at Galway University Hospital has confirmed that she told Savita Halappanavar that a termination could not be carried out because Ireland was a "Catholic country".

The malpractice here was not a case of good doctors and nurses hamstrung by terrible laws, but religious bigotry, probably with a good dose of racism, and shitty medical practice.

BloodAndFire · 27/11/2022 19:59

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 19:25

In the USA right now in Red States doctors are refusing to perform abortions for women even when the foetus isn’t viable and the life of the mother will be at risk, so those women are having to spend thousands of dollars flying to Blue States to get an abortion. That is absolutely not the Doctors fault and as much as you want to martyr yourself and act like you would perform an abortion in those circumstances and risk 20 years in prison for murder it’s easy for you to say that because you aren’t in that position. The risk of life to mother can be hard to prove and these psychotic archaic Laws are the problem.

Yes, it is easy for me to say it in my position.

I also don't accept that the HCPs are blameless in this situation. They knew they could intervene and save her life. They didn't. They let her die slowly and painfully while she and her husband begged them to help.

It is not 'absolutely not the doctors' fault'. When did someone in Ireland last spend 20 years in prison due to performing an abortion to save a woman's life? How did that go in court?

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 19:25

In the USA right now in Red States doctors are refusing to perform abortions for women even when the foetus isn’t viable and the life of the mother will be at risk, so those women are having to spend thousands of dollars flying to Blue States to get an abortion. That is absolutely not the Doctors fault and as much as you want to martyr yourself and act like you would perform an abortion in those circumstances and risk 20 years in prison for murder it’s easy for you to say that because you aren’t in that position. The risk of life to mother can be hard to prove and these psychotic archaic Laws are the problem.

BloodAndFire · 27/11/2022 19:18

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 19:15

“Going to court” oh you mean risk 20+ years in prison? Very easy for you sat behind a keyboard. It’s the Laws that are the problem.

The laws are a problem, yes.

The doctors who decided they would rather let a woman die an agonising, certain death, rather than face the prospect of explaining why they did it in court, are also a problem.

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 19:18

It has nothing to do with religion it’s just largely insecure losers desperate to control women. It’s also in the Bible that eating shellfish is a sin but they ignore that conveniently.

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 19:15

BloodAndFire · 27/11/2022 16:10

Yes, best to let her die to avoid having to go to court to explain why they saved her life. Cowards rather than zealots then. Not sure that's any more admirable.

“Going to court” oh you mean risk 20+ years in prison? Very easy for you sat behind a keyboard. It’s the Laws that are the problem.

whumpthereitis · 27/11/2022 19:08

‘Thou shalt not kill’, says god, who then, like a twelve year old who has just discovered Grand Theft Auto, proceeds to go on a murder rampage across two testaments AND the side quests.

Asking the Abrahamic god to determine the value of life is like going to Henry VIII for marital advice. There’s probably better options out there.

whynotwhatknot · 27/11/2022 19:01

I agree op im sorry she feels this way but the way some religious groups have jumped on this to help her case makes me sick

everyone has their reasons not to carry on to term and thats the way it shold stay

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:53

My fault - I asked a question. Next time I'll PM.

I've apologised upthread and tried to move it back on topic.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/11/2022 18:53

A) I don't know - I cannot read the end of God. None of us can

So then no one should be quoting the bible saying god tells us not to kill. Thats my point. Its hypocritical to use what is said in the bible when even god himself does not adhere to it. Which is why religion has absolutely no place in laws (which I know you agree on, I mean the posters who use it as a reason why abortion should be banned)

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 27/11/2022 18:51

How has this been derailed into bible class?

How arrogant do you have to be to think that the rules of your special book should apply to people who aren't in the special book club.

If people want to live their lives based on the writings of goat herders from the middle east a billion years ago then go ahead, but what the fuck are you thinking trying to suggest that I or anyone else should care about their opinions on my uterus and the contents thereof? Unbelievable.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:51

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/11/2022 18:50

Religion should never come into laws.

Agree

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:50

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/11/2022 18:46

Why does god kill people then? Seems to me he's pretty happy for it to happen when it suits him

A) I don't know - I cannot read the end of God. None of us can

B) We are de-railing this thread and turning it into a theological debate which is unfair on the OP

A new thread should be started if you want to discuss these matters - but I can't promise to be on it, because (A) ⬆

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/11/2022 18:50

pointythings · 27/11/2022 18:48

@OldFan the God thing needs to be kept out of abortion law (and all law) in any case. Laws should be secular. I do not want the religious to impose laws grounded in their beliefs on me as an atheist. Keep your rosaries off my ovaries, as they used to say.

Religion should never come into laws.

SnotRag22 · 27/11/2022 18:49

pointythings · 27/11/2022 18:48

@OldFan the God thing needs to be kept out of abortion law (and all law) in any case. Laws should be secular. I do not want the religious to impose laws grounded in their beliefs on me as an atheist. Keep your rosaries off my ovaries, as they used to say.

Absolutely!! For want of a better word, preach!

pointythings · 27/11/2022 18:48

@OldFan the God thing needs to be kept out of abortion law (and all law) in any case. Laws should be secular. I do not want the religious to impose laws grounded in their beliefs on me as an atheist. Keep your rosaries off my ovaries, as they used to say.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/11/2022 18:46

OldFan · 27/11/2022 17:57

not only does the bible not explicitly condemn abortion, it also gives instructions on how to carry one out

@Endwalker Where is that in the bible please?

We're commanded in the Bible not to kill people and abortion is killing someone. It's about as bad as it gets.

Why does god kill people then? Seems to me he's pretty happy for it to happen when it suits him

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:46

Thank goodness for safe medical abortions.

You are so right @pointythings.

Stopping abortion doesn't stop abortion.

It stops SAFE abortion.

Desperate woman will take risks, and those risks will often have dreadful outcomes. We don''t ever want to go back to those awful days.

SnotRag22 · 27/11/2022 18:44

OldFan · 27/11/2022 18:27

@Emotionalsupportviper @SnotRag22 Numbers 5:11 - It says she will have a swelling of the womb and her thigh will fall away, so no, not about abortion. Just some random ritual of the old law to curse someone if they'd commited adultery. www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers%205%3A11-31&version=ESV

Exodus 21:22 I can't tell what's going on there but the blokes are fined, so it's not seen as a good thing www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Exodus%2021&version=ESV

Genesis 2:7 isn't talking about the creation of the average person, it's about how God created Adam. And it's God that does the breathing into him that starts his life, not Adam.

You're never going to agree with me. You think I'm a murderer. I said previously in here that it took a long time for me not to think of myself as a murderer. And to not feel abandoned by God.

I choose to believe that God was with me, and I have been upheld by my church community during the most harrowing and traumatic time of my life.

I'll pray for you too.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:44

SnotRag22 · 27/11/2022 18:28

Absolutely. And thank you to you too. I have the opportunity to train as an ALM next year. I don't know that I'm in right place currently but if not next year then definitely the year after. I'll keep you in my prayers ❤️

Oh - you will LOVE it Snotty! I wish I could do it again so that I could take all of the modules I had to miss (some were compulsory eg OT studies) others we had to choose between two or three modules, so when I chose Ethics, I missed out on summat else (can't remember now what it was - Liturgy, possibly).

I'll hold you in my prayers, too.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:38

pointythings · 27/11/2022 18:27

@Emotionalsupportviper looking at where hyssop grows naturally, it is likely that it would have been available in the Middle East.

Its use is dangerous, of course. Thank goodness for safe medical abortions.

Oh - sorry. I wasn't clear - yes, hyssop grows int he ME, it was tansy I was wondering about.

Genesis 2:7 isn't talking about the creation of the average person, it's about how God created Adam. And it's God that does the breathing into him that starts his life, not Adam.

God breathes life into every one of us @OldFan . And our every breath is an expression of God - our first gasping intake of breath ("Yah") draws God's life force into our body; the last breath we release ("Weh") releases that force back to God.

Together they speak God's Holy Name ("Yahweh"). You can believe it or not, obviously. I think it's one of the most beautiful things ever. (But then, I would, wouldn't I? 😉_

TimBoothseyes · 27/11/2022 18:34

Trianglesquarerectangle · 27/11/2022 18:21

@pointythings No I am saying to those on the thread who say that abortion should be available for any reason should equally recognise that others may not understand the reasons given for said abortion.

I also made the point for those that saying that people shouldn't view a late abotion as a "change of mind" that it is down to a change of mind, whether or not circumstance contributed to that change of mind, and that they should just own it.

Mine wasn't down to a change of mind. My decision was reached after getting all the facts. I didn't think "I'll go ahead with the pregnancy" when I was told at 20 weeks something was wrong and then change my mind at 26 weeks. Those 6 weeks were spent with neo-natal consultants and various other people to help me understand what going through with the pregnancy and birth would mean.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 27/11/2022 18:29

@pointythings at no point did I say that but you do you

SnotRag22 · 27/11/2022 18:28

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/11/2022 18:18

Thank you @SnotRag22 - your comment got me thinking and brought back a lot of information that had slipped out of my mind. You know how it is. When you remember (or are reminded of) one snippet of information it pulls up lots of other bits with it.

Absolutely. And thank you to you too. I have the opportunity to train as an ALM next year. I don't know that I'm in right place currently but if not next year then definitely the year after. I'll keep you in my prayers ❤️

pointythings · 27/11/2022 18:27

@Emotionalsupportviper looking at where hyssop grows naturally, it is likely that it would have been available in the Middle East.

Its use is dangerous, of course. Thank goodness for safe medical abortions.